Court U.S.: Judges can reduce crack sentences

( AP ) - The Supreme Court on Monday said judges may impose shorter prison terms for crack cocaine crimes, enhancing judicial discretion to reduce the disparity between sentences for crack and cocaine powder.

By a 7-2 vote, the court said that a 15-year sentence given to Derrick Kimbrough, a black veteran of the 1991 war with Iraq, was acceptable, even though federal sentencing guidelines called for Kimbrough to receive 19 to 22 years.

"In making that determination, the judge may consider the disparity between the guidelines' treatment of crack and powder cocaine offenses," Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said in her majority opinion.

The decision was announced ahead of a vote scheduled for Tuesday by the U.S. Sentencing Commission, which sets the guidelines, that could cut prison time for up to an estimated 19,500 federal inmates convicted of crack crimes.

The Sentencing Commission recently changed the guidelines to reduce the disparity in prison time for the two crimes. New guidelines took effect Nov. 1 after Congress took no action to overturn the change. Tuesday's vote is whether to apply the guidelines retroactively.

In a separate sentencing case that did not involve crack cocaine, the court also said judges have discretion to impose more lenient sentences than federal guidelines recommend.

The cases are the result of a decision three years ago in which the justices ruled that judges need not strictly follow the sentencing guidelines. Instead, appellate courts would review sentences for reasonableness, although the court has since struggled to define what it meant by that term.

The guidelines were established by the Sentencing Commission, at Congress' direction, in the mid-1980s to help produce uniform punishments for similar crimes.

Justice Samuel Alito , who dissented with Justice Clarence Thomas in both cases, said that after Tuesday's decisions, "Sentencing disparities will gradually increase."

Kimbrough's case did not present the justices with the ultimate question of the fairness of the disparity in crack and powder cocaine sentences. Congress wrote the harsher treatment for crack into a law that sets a mandatory minimum five-year prison sentence for trafficking in 5 grams of crack cocaine or 100 times as much cocaine powder. The law also sets maximum terms.

Seventy percent of crack defendants are given the mandatory prison terms.

Kimbrough is among the remaining 30 percent who, under the guidelines, get even more time in prison because they are convicted of trafficking in more than the amount of crack that triggers the minimum sentences.

"A reviewing court could not rationally conclude that it was an abuse of discretion" to cut four years off the guidelines-recommended sentence for Kimbrough, Ginsburg said.

In the other case, the court, also by a 7-2 vote, upheld a sentence of probation for Brian Gall for his role in a conspiracy to sell 10,000 pills of ecstasy. U.S. District Judge Robert Pratt of Des Moines, Iowa, determined that Gall had voluntarily quit selling drugs several years before he was implicated, stopped drinking, graduated from college and built a successful business. The guidelines said Gall should have been sent to prison for 30 to 37 months.

"The sentence imposed by the experienced district judge in this case was reasonable," Justice John Paul Stevens said in his majority opinion.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Stephen Breyer , Anthony Kennedy, Antonin Scalia , David Souter , Ginsburg and Stevens formed the majority in both cases.

German retail sales rise more than expected before partial lockdown
German retail sales rise more than expected before partial lockdown
Eni revises up Azerbaijan’s gas reserve estimates
Eni revises up Azerbaijan’s gas reserve estimates
Albgaz invites bids for maintenance of TAP section in Albania
Albgaz invites bids for maintenance of TAP section in Albania
Loading Bars
Latest
Georgia reports 4,033 new cases of coronavirus
Number of inquiries related to computer security in Azerbaijan drops
New hydrocarbon reserves discovered in Turkmenistan
German Energy Agency supports dev’t of energy-efficient housing refurbishment in Uzbekistan
German retail sales rise more than expected before partial lockdown
Uzbekistan to receive observer status in EAEU
Eni revises up Azerbaijan’s gas reserve estimates
Georgia discloses forecast revenue of Tbilisi Transport Company
Azerbaijan talks major restoration work to be carried out on liberated territories
Turkey says export of local defense products to Iran surges
US decreases exports to Kazakhstan year-on-year
World’s gas reserves slightly up y-o-y
Azerbaijan has potential to preserve qanats in Karabakh - Iranian researcher
Azerbaijani MFA talks information about French MPs' planned trip to Karabakh
Azerbaijan to develop transport sector on territories liberated from Armenian occupation
Prices on Azerbaijani oil change
Kazakhstan taking measures to double agriculture goods export via digitalization
Kazakh KazMunayGas to continue improving sustainable dev't activities
Turkmennebit State Concern puts new productive wells into operation
Azerbaijan can take steps to include its underground water channels into UNESCO list
Turkey's October 2020 car exports to France increase
Azerbaijan's AccessBank looks to regain share in agricultural lending
UAE boosts import of defense industry products from Turkey
Uzbek Agriculture Ministry reveals volume of harvested raw cotton
Iranian currency rates for December 2
Trading in shares of Xiaomi halted pending share sale, bond issue statement
Demand for Turkish cars in Kazakhstan increases
Albgaz invites bids for maintenance of TAP section in Albania
Albania ready to offer full range of gas network maintenance services for TAP
Azerbaijani currency rates for Dec. 2
Fuel demand to recover over 2021-2022, while growth rates to soften
Turkmenistan’s Turkmengas plans to increase productivity of wells
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for December 2
Cargo traffic to/from Azerbaijan via NSTC carried out regularly
Azerbaijani branch of Romanian IT GRUP talks plans for 2021
OPEC+ failure could be highly detrimental for oil prices
SecGen of OIC sends letter to President of Azerbaijan
Gov't spokesman warns against quick decisions on Iran's nuclear program
Kazakh power networks maintenance company to buy construction materials via tender
Japan ruling party weighs up inheritance tax exemption for foreigners
Iran ready to share scientific achievements with friendly countries
Georgia to increase price of natural gas for commercial consumption starting January
Singapore becomes first country to approve sale of lab-grown meat
Turkey, EU cooperation key to fight hate, discrimination in Europe: Comms Director Altun
683 COVID-19 cases among schoolchildren registered in Kyrgyzstan in 3 months
State-owned enterprises in Georgia lose about 130 mln GEL due to pandemic
Eurozone manufacturing sector expands at slower pace
Borrell highlights terrorist nature of Fakhrizadeh assassination
Kazakhstan invites Hungarian companies to jointly hold geological exploration
Bezos' Blue Origin taps former Pentagon, NASA officials for new advisory board
Ford announces 580 mln USD investment in Argentina
Cement price up in Uzbekistan due to decrease in production volumes
House seen backing bill that could block Chinese firms from U.S. securities markets
Lebanon central bank can keep subsidies for only two more months
Nigerian troops kill 5 gunmen, rescue nine hostages
Israeli archaeologists discover 2,000-year-old game dice
Tesla CEO says he is open to friendly deal with rival carmaker
Uzbekistan’s export of furniture products to Italy down
Iran increases exports from Gilan Province
Kazakhstan’s freight transportation operator opens tender to buy spares
FAA issues new first air certificate for Boeing 737 MAX since 2019
Number of Kyrgyzstan’s recoveries from COVID-19 reaches 64,711 with 560 new ones
Georgia to participate in discussion on Black Sea security at NATO Foreign Ministerial
Bahar Azadi gold coin price rising in Iran
Turkey to start COVID-19 vaccination drive after Dec. 11
COVID-related restriction may complicate procedures for car registration in Georgia
Euronews prepares reportage from Azerbaijani Aghdam liberated from occupation (VIDEO)
AP highlights aspects of Armenian Armed Forces withdrawal from districts of Azerbaijan
Israeli airline conducts 1st commercial passenger flight to UAE
Humiliating prisoners of war is not characteristic of Azerbaijani people - State Security Service
Quarantine regime to affect some investment projects of Kazakh national oil company
Equal number of Russian, Turkish personnel to work in center to control ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh
Georgian IT sector to arouse investor interest
Azerbaijani marine infantry personnel return to place of permanent deployment (PHOTO)
Delivery process of logistic support assets for peacekeeping contingent in Azerbaijan continues (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgian economy sees decrease due to COVID-19 lockdown
Return of Lachin district by Azerbaijan has not only important political, but also economic significance - Georgian expert
AP publishes article highlighting political success of Azerbaijan over Karabakh conflict
Foreign trade operations between Azerbaijan and Poland up
Georgia reveals details of Fourth Stage of Anti-Crisis Plan
Azerbaijani Culture Minister gives interview to France 24
Gradual liberalization of wholesale and retail electricity markets defined in Georgia
Import of aluminum by Azerbaijan up
Georgia approves volume of external debt planned for 2021
Development of well-functioning gas hub to diversify Georgia’s gas market
Uzbekistan, Belarus eye signing mutual tourism dev’t agreement
Demand for tobacco products in Azerbaijan may decline amid pandemic crisis
UAE based company to grow cannabis in Uzbekistan’s Syrdarya region
Fiat brand to electrify 60% of its models by end-2021
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry auctions state medium-term bonds
Georgian hazelnut-producing company faces with complex logistics
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on December 2
Number of phishing attacks on Azerbaijani web sites down
European culture to have new dimensions with Lachin's liberation - US expert
Enagas working on 12 projects in hydrogen developments
Spanish Enagas moving towards more sustainable energy model
Azerbaijan's mortgage fund puts up new bond tranche for auction
Georgia names number of beneficiaries of discount cards under agro-diesel promotion program
World Bank helps Georgia to purchase equipment in its fight against coronavirus
Italy decreases crude petroleum oil import from Kazakhstan year-on-year
All news