European Security Architecture May be Maintained Providing Dialogue with Russia

European Security Architecture May be Maintained Providing Dialogue with   Russia

Azerbaijan, Baku, 6 Dec / Trend corr. E.Tariverdiyeva, R.Agayev/ European security architecture may be maintained providing compromises and direct dialogue with Russia.

"In my opinion, there is no need for a new European security architecture providing that NATO maintains a level of direct and honest dialogue with Russia and assumes positions that pave the way for a greater understanding, accommodation and collaboration between the two sides," U.S. expert for security Ioannis Stivachtis said.

The meeting of OSCE fifty Foreign Ministers in Helsinki actively focused on the questions of European security, including Russia's proposal on the new transatlantic security agreement.

This proposal made by the President of Russia Dmitry Medvedev did not find support in OSCE. Medvedev has been insisting on the new agreements on European security for already long, emphasizing that only NATO is insufficient for ensuring the security in Europe.

From the perspective of those Americans and Europeans who see Russia as a threat, then there is no substitution for NATO. It is expected that NATO will continue containing Russia as it contained the Soviet Union during the Cold War, Stivachtis said.

Stivachtis believes there are perspectives that it is the existence of NATO that makes Russia assuming a more threatening diplomatic position. "A new European security architecture which could accommodate Russia and its fears is seen as the solution to the current state of relations between Russia and the Transatlantic Community," Stivachtis, Director for International Studies Program at Virginia Tech, said to Trend via e-mail.

Stivachtis believes there is no need for a new European security architecture providing that NATO maintains a level of direct and honest dialogue with Russia and to pave the way for a greater understanding and collaboration between the two sides.

"But Russia should also reciprocate for otherwise it would signal that it is indeed a threat," he said.

European observers believe Russia indeed plays an important role to provide European security.

As to the Russian President's idea itself, it is already acknowledged in Europe, that the security challenges of the 21st century are broad and demand multilateral responses, European expert for security Kamil Zwolski said.

According to Zwolski, one of the most urgent security challenges for Europe in the foreseeable future will be securing the stable access to the energy resources. "This is also the area where Russia's policy plays the vital role," Kamil Zwolski, a researcher in the field of European Union and international security at the University of Salford, UK, said to Trend via e-mail.

Russian Americanist historian, political scientist Anatoliy Utkin also believes that the dialogue and efforts of both sides are necessary to ensure effective architecture of European security. "Cold War will finish, when there will be created general command with the strategic nuclear forces of Russia and West, or NATO or new organization, which will include Russia and the USA," Director of Centre for International Studies of the Institute of the USA and Canada of the Academy of Sciences of Russia, Anatoly Utkin, told Trend . Russia or USA can not carry out policy of large union in this organization only with their national decision, he said.

However, he said that Russian political elite's distrust on NATO can complicate relations with Russia.

According to Zwolski, The Russian President creates an ambiguous framework for the cooperation with the new US President. "Medvedev on the one hand says: yes, we want to cooperate with the new US Administration. Yet on the other hand he demands that the new President changes the US policy in Europe completely and de facto suggests that the US presence in Europe is not necessary at all," he said.

Undoubtedly there is a necessity for a change in the European structure of security, and the main problem is that the USA builds one-sided security system, not advising with NATO, Russian political scientist Gleb Pavlovsky said.

Being the member of NATO, the USA does not trust this block in the questions of anti-missile security of the country and some allies, the expert said. "This speaks of the high degree of the ineffectiveness of this block, because it seems that for some unknown reasons, the USA can not or does not want to solve this problem inside NATO. But indeed, the block exists exclusively for resolving security questions," the President of the Effective Politics Foundation, Pavlovsky, told Trend .

Have any feedback? Contact our journalist at

Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 36 times
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 36 times
Letter of Azerbaijan's FM on Armenia's illegal activities in occupied Azerbaijani lands published as UN document
Letter of Azerbaijan's FM on Armenia's illegal activities in occupied Azerbaijani lands published as UN document
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 38 times
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 38 times
Loading Bars
Uzbekistan to include goods and services in Unified Electronic Catalog
Kazakhstan's oil & gas company opens tender to buy filter blocks
Azerbaijani Central Bank unveils number of borrowers with restructured loans
Georgia sees increase in COVID-19 cases
Production started at Uzbek gas condensate field
Japan, Uzbekistan to increase tourist flow between countries
Turkmen Ministry of Construction to purchase equipment from Italian company
Kazakhstan, Russia agree to resume mutual flights
Turkmenistan, Ukraine discuss trade, economic cooperation
Iranian currency rates for September 19
Number of coronavirus cases in Uzbekistan pass 50,000
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 36 times
Australia COVID-19 hotspot records fewest cases since June
Turkey summons Greek envoy over expletive headline against Erdoğan
E3 says Iran sanctions relief to continue beyond Sep. 20
Georgia sends armored medical evacuation vehicles to Indonesia
65 new COVID-19 infections reported in Kazakhstan over past day
UN, Kazakhstan intend substantially contribute to environmental resilience (INTERVIEW)
Japan's new PM Suga to meet with Pompeo in October
Chinese mainland reports 14 new imported COVID-19 cases
Brazil's COVID-19 death toll tops 135,000
French finance minister tests positive for COVID-19
Trump says he sees no reason to delay TikTok decision
Eleven more coronavirus patients die in Moscow in past day
Qatar reports 224 new COVID-19 cases, 122,917 in total
Kazakhstan's crude oil exports to India surge in 1H2020
Georgia to acquire 135 000 doses of flu vaccines in October
Istanbul introduces alternate working hours for public servants amid COVID-19 pandemic
Kazakhstan launches programming learning platform
UK PM Johnson says second wave of virus inevitable, new restrictions possible
Israel's daily new COVID-19 death cases hit record high
Iran, Russia stress promoting scientific, technological coop.
Kazakh company looking to establish medical cannabis production
Azerbaijan’s Baku to hold World Cups in three gymnastic disciplines in 2021
Georgia increases export of apples
Data on cargo movement from Albania via Turkish ports revealed
Deputy PM: 'Contract of the Century' - special among grandiose events in Azerbaijan's history
Minister: Azerbaijan - integral part of global energy security system
Spanish capital region orders partial lockdown in some COVID-hit areas
COVID-19 kills 144 more Iranians over past 24 hours
Representatives of Azerbaijani Karabakh community meet with ambassadors of several countries
Azerbaijan on Kazakhstan's list of 'safe' countries in terms of COVID-19 threat
Data on industrial production of Uzbekistan for January through August 2020
Net profit of Georgian insurance companies increases
Azerbaijan preparing proposals to develop hazelnut growth
Central Bank of Azerbaijan announces slow post-COVID economic recovery
Azerbaijan’s mining, IT companies sign tender contract
Georgian finance minister elected chairman of ADB board of governors
Baku Stock Exchange includes AzerGold's bonds in listing
Baku holds video conference entitled "Heritage of Caucasian Albania" (VIDEO)
Clients of Azerbaijan's bankrupt Standard Insurance receive compensations
Georgia continues projects of Winter resort in Gudauri
Turkish cement in great demand in Turkmenistan’s construction markets
Azerbaijani MP: Armenia's draft law on so-called "genocide" aims to deceive world community
Azerbaijani oil prices continue to grow
ENKA Renewables: Namakhvani HPP Cascade project to have substantial impact on property tax
BMB Trade Group develops project for livestock complex in Uzbekistan
U.S. current account deficit surges 52.9% in second quarter
Companies reserving capacity in IGB disclosed
Gold, silver prices in Azerbaijan rebound
Requirements to oil&gas service companies to be revised in Kazakhstan
Turkmenistan working to improve transport, customs systems
Firefighter dies in California wildfire - U.S. Forest Service
IGB to start commercial operations by July 2021
Germany to send observers for Georgia’s parliamentary elections
Iran expected to launch neobanks by 2021
S.Korean, Azerbaijani officials discuss healthcare co-op
Number of gas consumers increased in Turkmenistan’s Lebap region
Rami Levy said mulling withdrawal from Delek Israel deal
Azerbaijani economy ministry: Digitalization - important component of economic dev't
Azerbaijan confirms 135 more COVID-19 recoveries
Baku International Energy Charter Forum to be held online
Azerbaijan's oil pumping through BTC pipeline shrinks
International tourism restrictions to be canceled in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani president congratulates president of Nepal
Sulfur production increases in Kazakhstan in Aug, 2020
Russia to invest in modernization of power generation field of Uzbekistan
Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan in talks on gas exports
Minister: Georgia moving towards period of adaptation
Average daily volume of gas production at Turkmenistan’s Uchaji field revealed
Azerbaijan Deposit Insurance Fund continues compensating depositors of closed banks
Azerbaijan raises propylene production
Georgia sees increase in hazelnuts exports
Pumps producer terminates memorandum with Kazakhstan's largest oil pipeline company
Kazakh coal extracting venture opens tender to buy vehicles
Iran's industrial production increases
French imports of leather goods from Turkey down
Georgia imports more steel from Turkey
Volume of delivered oil at Turkmenbashi Oil Refinery published
Azerbaijan unveils timeframe for commissioning road to highest mountainous village
Central Bank of Azerbaijan lowers interest rate
Azerbaijani ambassador talks Armenia's military provocation against Azerbaijan in popular US radio show
Iran and Pakistan discuss trade between border provinces
PETRONAS's upstream volumes to fall by about 4%
Ryanair cuts October capacity, blames travel restrictions
BMB Trade Group eyes to expand export products of Uzbekistan
“My Bakcell” – the ultimate solution for managing your account
EBRD to back up solar plant construction in Kazakhstan’s Karaganda
Kazakh Ministry of Ecology talks restrictions in industry sector
Georgia reveals volume of exported peaches and nectarines
All news