U.S' intermediary role on Nagorno-Karabakh conflict not to be decisive: experts

U.S' intermediary role on Nagorno-Karabakh conflict not to be decisive: experts

Azerbaijan, Baku, May 6 / Trend , E.Tariverdiyeva/ 

The role of the U.S. mediation in the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict can be successful for Azerbaijan, as well as Washington is less biased to the parties than any other active mediator, but it will not be decisive.

"The US differs from Russia as a mediator in that it is not a neighbouring state, Russia has a long history in the region," British Expert on Caucasus Ziba Norman believes. "Caucasus's entrenched interests there are at the heart of Russia's geopolitical strategy and he US is more detached from the situation."

The Azerbaijani Foreign Minister met with U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on May 5. The meeting focused on some issues of bilateral interest, including speeding up settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, cooperation in Afghanistan and struggle against terrorism, energy security, as well as diversifying energy deliveries to Europe.

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's meetings with the Azerbaijani and Armenian foreign ministers at the White House laid basis of discussions between these countries' presidents, US Assistant Deputy Secretary of State Matthew Bryza believes.

"Today's discussions in Washington has laid basis for constructive discussions to be held between Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Serzh Sargsyan in Prague on May 7. And we hope considerable progress will be reached and differences in basic principles will be reduced in these discussions," Bryza told Trend in a telephone conversation from Washington.

At each meeting, the secretary of state stressed her readiness to do her best which can support efforts as part of the OSCE Minsk Group to provide breakthrough in the Nagorno-Karabakh peace process, Bryza added.

The conflict between the two South Caucasus countries began in 1988 when Armenia made territorial claims against Azerbaijan. Armenian armed forces have occupied 20 percent of Azerbaijan since 1992, including the Nagorno-Karabakh region and 7 surrounding districts. Azerbaijan and Armenia signed a ceasefire agreement in 1994. The co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group - Russia, France, and the U.S. - are currently holding the peace negotiations.

Western experts say U.S. is less biased to the countries in the region than negotiators such as Russia and Turkey who have offered their assistance in the resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict on numerous occasions.

"The meetings of the Foreign Ministers of Azerbaijan and of Armenia with the United States Administration should be seen as part of a broad effort by the international community to sustain the current moment in the Nagorno Karabakh peace negotiations," expert on South Caucasus Licinia Simao said. The U.S. plays a crucial role as one of the Co-Chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, she said.

Simao said the new Obama Administration has shown how far it is willing to go in supporting local developments in the Caucasus (for instance by refraining to openly recognise the Armenian genocide, in order to support Turkish-Armenian dialogue).

"U.S. supports Russia's efforts to bring the Azerbaijani and the Armenian Presidents to an agreement that can allow substantive progress in the future," University of Coimbra fellow Simao wrote to Trend via email.

"U.S. can help compensate each side for the concessions that both will need to make, American expert on South Caucasus Mark Katz said.

He said the main advantage of Washington is that the U.S. has (especially compared to Russia) is that the U.S. is friends with both Azerbaijan and Armenia.

"Russia is much, much closer to Armenia than to Azerbaijan.  Indeed, I believe that Russia does not want the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to be resolved," professor at George Mason University Katz told Trend via email.

Katz said if it happens, Armenia and Azerbaijan will normalize ties and pipelines will run from Azerbaijan through Armenia to Turkey skirting Russia.

"If the conflict is solved, both Armenia and Azerbaijan would become more integrated into the West, and both would have much less need of Russia," Katz said.

Simao said both Armenia and Azerbaijan have close relations with the U.S. and both can influence and be influenced by its policy choice. "It is therefore central to have the US engaged in the peace process," she said.

According to Azerbaijani political scientist Tafik Abbasov, the U.S's role in settlement of Nagorno-Karabakh conflict must appear in support of Russia's efforts.

The OSCE Minsk Group countries are equal right states, but one of them is the first. Russia has more informal right for leadership.

"Russia has powerful levers of pressure on the aggressor, and if the United States take a more flexible position that Moscow would have easily brought a moral duty to curb the aggressor to its logical conclusion, would help significantly," Abbasov, Azerbaijani expert of the analytical group of Lider-TV, told Trend .

Obviously, the U.S. also has its interests in the Caucasus region, which will affect Washington's mediatory efforts.

Nevertheless, the US has very significant interests in the region, not least of which is the need to maintain energy transport links to the West. This is Azerbaijan's trump card, Норманн wrote to Trend via e-mail.

U.S. is lobbying the projects on construction of Transcaspian oil - and pipelines to ensure energy security of Europe. Two U.S. companies- Exxon mobil and Devon are represented in the largest oil project in Azerbaijan, Azeri-Chirag-Guneshli, proven reserves of which is 1 billion tons of light oil.

Turkey needs to maintain good relations with the US, and the US will not wish see a diminishing of its influence in the region, which would be the natural outcome if Azerbaijan felt the need to stop energy supplies via Turkey and opt for alternatives. "The US are thus in a position, by virtue of their own interests, and those of Turkey, to argue most strongly for the border opening and Nagorno-Karabakh settlement to be linked," Norman said.

Although Russia is recognized as a crucial actor in solving the conflicts in the Caucasus, and Moscow has been willing to take up a more conciliatory tone and a pro-active attitude regarding the Karabakh conflict, the U.S. and the Europeans remain crucial partners in bringing about a peaceful solution to this conflict, Simao said.

E.Ostapenko contributed in the article.

Do you have any feedback? Contact our journalist at: [email protected]

"Together we are POWER": ENGINET supports injured children in Ganja city (FOTO)
"Together we are POWER": ENGINET supports injured children in Ganja city (FOTO)
Azercell continues to support medical staff fighting coronavirus
Azercell continues to support medical staff fighting coronavirus
The National Institute for International Education of Korea invites international students for “2021 Global Korea Scholarship
The National Institute for International Education of Korea invites international students for “2021 Global Korea Scholarship
Loading Bars
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for October 31
Uzbekistan’s 9M2020 carpet export down
Georgian CEC reveals voter turnout by 15 p.m.
Weekly review of Azerbaijan's precious metals market
Iran increases value of exports via Kerman Province
17 religious monuments damaged as result of Armenian aggression, including churches - Vusal Gasimli
Azerbaijani president's aide says Armenia shelled civilian districts even during Geneva meetings
Azerbaijani army destroys military equipment, manpower of Armenian Armed Forces (VIDEO)
Armenian Armed Forces continue shelling Azerbaijani settlements - Defense Ministry
Azerbaijan confirms 547 more COVID-19 recoveries
President Ilham Aliyev expresses condolences to President Erdogan
Azerbaijan only restoring its territorial integrity, top official says
UzAuto Motors eyes expanding financing opportunities by issuing Eurobonds
Iran implements new limitations to prevent COVID-19
Georian CEC introduces media with the information about voter turnout for 12:00
Armenia deliberately burns down forests in Shusha - Azerbaijani president's aide
Tehran city council calls for extending lockdown
Uzbekistan int’l consulting organizations to transform large state-owned enterprises
Iran to inject new foreign currency package
VTB Bank (Azerbaijan) completes 9 months with profit
Military conflict in Karabakh drives Armenia to dead end - Russian edition
President Ilham Aliyev expresses condolences to Berna Yilmaz.
Drilling operations in Iran's South Pars gas field to begin soon
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
Russia warns Armenia about ban on import of tomatoes
Azerbaijani oil prices down
Russia responds to Pashinyan's appeal
Inflation coming down in Georgia - Finance Minister
Voting process at Georgian polling stations ongoing in peaceful environment - CEC
Kazakhstan’s KazTransOil opens tender for equipment repair services
Azerbaijani association talks importance of OSAGO insurance in country
Iran’s NICICO boosts its production
More people rescued from rubble in Turkish Izmir
Captured Armenian cleric admits his forced involvement in Karabakh clashes (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani president's aide voices his concern over tortures against old woman
Azerbaijani 'A Audit and Consulting' LLC talks about slowdown in audit services' dev't
Armenia delivering phosphorus cargo to Khojavend creating basis for further provocations - MoD
Long term loans value surges in Kazakhstan year-on-year
Uzbekneftegaz announces tender for turboexpander unit supply
Voting in parliamentary elections in Georgia continues normally - Arzu Nagiyev (PHOTO)
Iran and Russia reach to agreement on construction of thermal power plant
Azerbaijani FM forwards his condolences to Turkish people due to Izmir earthquake
Ukraine reports record daily high new coronavirus cases
Uzbek oil and gas production dep’t announces tender for feasibility studies
Loan portfolio of Azerbaijan AFB Bank grows
Elections proceeding peacefully, no serious violations so far in Georgia - Interior Ministry
President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by German ARD TV channel (PHOTO)
Uzbek-Korean Uz-Kor Gas Chemical to buy radiant tubes via tender
Uzbekistan’s Ministry of Innovative Development to buy light vehicles via tender
South Korean companies invited to enter Turkmen market more actively
Azerbaijani FM, ICRC Director General meet to discuss current situation in Karabakh
Armenia's barbaric crimes tantamount to actions of fascists - Mikhail Zabelin (PHOTO)
Reports about shelling of Shusha by Azerbaijani army - another lie, MoD says
Azerbaijan's largest loans share falls on household sector
Azerbaijan's PM meets Pakistani ambassador
Armenian reports on missile attack on Khankendi by Azerbaijani army - lie, says MoD
Azerbaijan develops website to fight spread of Armenian fake news
Presence of PKK terrorists in ranks of Armenian Armed Forces - fact, says aide to Azerbaijani president
Iran reveals value of fishery products exported from Gilan Province
Turkmen MFA opens tender for supply of technical equipment
October conscription for active military service ends in Azerbaijan
Georgia reports 1,673 new coronavirus cases
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 31
Georgia decreases export to Kazakhstan amid COVID-19
Turkmenistan, Denmark's Haldor Topsoe continue discussions on gasoline plant construction
Azerbaijani-Iranian border outposts reopen after being liberated from Armenian occupation
Some international organizations silent on crimes committed by Armenia - expert
Another earthquake strikes Turkish Izmir Province
Prime Minister of Georgia votes in parliamentary elections
Iran's per capita income declines
Turkmenistan considers opportunities to attract investment to Caspian Sea
Azerbaijani, Georgian experts discuss issues on agenda via teleconference (VIDEO)
Turkmenistan improves transport infrastructure
Iranian currency rates for October 31
Armenian Armed Forces fire at Azerbaijani Aghjabadi district's village
Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili votes at parliamentary elections
Local and international election observer organizations monitor parliamentary elections in Georgia
Parliamentary elections being held with new election system in Georgia
Parliamentary Elections being held in Georgia
Azerbaijani products to be showcased at int’l exhibition in Shanghai
Azerbaijan's income from sales of pharmaceutical products increases
Propylene production grows in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan investing in alternative energy dev't
Azerbaijan denies accusations on use of weapons prohibited by international law
Azerbaijani army fires back at Armenia firing points, which shelled Gubadli - MoD
Latest situation on battlefield on October 31
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry lists Armenian military equipment destroyed
Azerbaijani Tartar, Aghdam, and Aghjabedi districts come under artillery fire
Brazil's COVID-19 cases top 5.5 million with 159,477 deaths
24 dead in Izmir as magnitude 6.6 quake shakes Turkey’s west coast (UPDATE)
U.S. says Iranian hackers behind threatening emails accessed voter data
Israel's COVID-19 cases up by 587, tally reaches 313,701
Trump derides doctors as COVID surges, Biden says Trump 'giving up' on virus
Protesters clash with police over COVID-19 restrictions in Barcelona
U.S. COVID-19 cases surpass 9 mln -- Johns Hopkins University
COVID-19 remains public health emergency of international concern: WHO
Meeting of Jeyhun Bayramov with OSCE MG Co-Chairs and Armenian FM ends
Azerbaijan, Armenia reach new agreements following talks in Geneva
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva offered condolences to relatives and loved ones of those killed as a result of earthquake in Izmir (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani army does not fire at civilians - MoD
All news