Experts: Arab-Iran-Turkey triangle in Middle East is still impossible

Experts: Arab-Iran-Turkey triangle in Middle East is still impossible

Azerbaijan, Baku, March 30 / Trend U.Sadikhova /

Experts believe establishment of the so-called structure of the Arab countries with its close neighbors - Iran and Turkey is impossible until Tehran and the Arab countries will not be restored full relations.

Alliance of Muslim countries is possible if it will be attended by all three parties - the Turkish, Iranian and Arabic, analysts say.  

Arab leaders decided to examine in detail Arab League Secretary General Amr Moussa's proposal to create a structure in the Middle East that will unite the Arab world with its immediate neighbors - Iran and Turkey.

Moussa proposed it after that the Arab countries discussed the establishment of a commission with the participation of the leaders of Libya, Egypt, Qatar, Iraq and Yemen, the Arab League General Secretariat, which will deal with the issue of creating an "Arab Union" like EU. The idea of an "Arab Union" that was initiated by Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh, will be discussed at an extraordinary Arab summit in autumn 2010.

The Arab League's summit in Sirt, took place on the background of the termination of the peace process between Palestinians and Israelis because of Israel's refusal to freeze construction of settlements in the occupied Palestinian territories.

Moussa, who will left his post as Arab League Secretary General in 2011, called on the Arab countries to launch a new dialogue with Iran, with which they are linked geographically and historically, and accept the proposal to establish a tripartite structure with the participation of Arab countries, Tehran and Ankara, except Israel.

Turkish analyst on the Middle East Hilmi Ozev does not preclude the creation of such a structure theory that can pull a lot of nerves to Israel.

"The Arab countries, as well as Turkey and Iran, understand that they will not be able to solve regional issues," Senior Analyst for Middle East Policy at Turkish-Asian Center for Strategic Studies (TASAM) Ozev said. "However, this structure may be real, only if they involve all three parties - the Turkish, Arab and Iranian."

It is important to coordinate efforts of all three parties, which may well exert Israel, to achieve stability in the region, he added.

But Arab analysts see no prospects for creating such an organization in the absence of normal relations among Iran and several Arab countries, notably Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Jordan - the most important U.S. allies in the region.

In addition to Tehran's dispute with the Arab states around the interference in the internal situation in Iraq and Yemen, up to now the Persian Gulf countries have tensions in relations with Iran, Middle East Studies Center Head Javad Mahmoud Al Hamad believes.

"If Iran is able to solve its problems with the Arab countries and is prepared to change its policy towards the Arab world, then it will be possible to speak of dialogue and establishment of such a structure," Al Hamad told Trend over the telephone from Amman. "Turkey, unlike Iran, has taken more steps to get closer to the Arab countries and has succeeded in economic relations."

Iran's differences with several Arab countries were aroused basically, around the policy of the armed Palestinian resistance against Israel and in connection with Iran's accusation in destabilizing the situation in Iraq and Yemen. The Arab Gulf states and Iran also have a territorial dispute over three oil and gas islands in the Hormuz strait, controlled by Iran.

The expert believes, since, Iran's government has not shown willingness to change its policy and interests in the Arab countries, and there is still no understanding between the parties.

Head of the Beirut Center for Strategic Studies Muhammad Noureddine also underprices the chances of creating a structure upon Amr Moussa's initiative, due to the fact that Turkey and the pro-Iranian Arab countries will require Iran's full participation.

"The Arab countries want to form a structure only with Turkey, while excluding Iran. The implementation of this idea is somewhat unrealistic, because Syria and Iraq want to unite not only with Turkey, but also with Iran," Noureddine told Trend over the telephone.

Turkey, which supported Moussa's initiative, may, however, withdraw from participation without Iran, the Arab analyst added.

Meanwhile, Saudi Foreign Minister Saud al-Faisal refused any dialogue with Iran until Tehran's policy will not change.

British analyst of Iranian origin, involved in the study of Iranian-Arab relations, Alirza Nurizade believes that Moussa's proposal is initially unrealistic: even if Syria, Libya and Qatar will support the initiation of a dialogue with Iran and the most Arab countries  will reject it.

"I do not think that it is now an opportune time for the [Arab-Iran] dialogue," head of the Iranian-Arab Center for Strategic Studies Nurizade told Trend over telephone " The Arab countries are concerned about the situation surrounding the Iranian nuclear program, because in both cases - in the case of military attack on Iranian nuclear facilities and Tehran's response or continuation the development of Iran's nuclear program - they may suffer."

Therefore, the Arab countries rely more on Turkey, which, unlike Tehran, does not carry the ideological politics and does not seek to interfere in the internal Arab politics, the expert added.

"The Iranian leaders have ideological, while Turkey has pursued a moderate policy that satisfies the Arab countries. Turkey can play a central role [Middle East], having good ties with the Arab countries and Israel," Nurizade said.

Do you have any feedback? Contact our journalist at [email protected]

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Ports giant DP World expects container volume growth to moderate in Q4
Ports giant DP World expects container volume growth to moderate in Q4
Gadkari bats for green hydrogen; says India needs to reduce oil imports
Gadkari bats for green hydrogen; says India needs to reduce oil imports
Indian Defence Minister invites foreign defence firms to take part in DefExpo 2022
Indian Defence Minister invites foreign defence firms to take part in DefExpo 2022
Loading Bars
Leadership of Turkish Defense University visit Azerbaijani War College of Armed Forces (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan, WB discuss possible co-op in restoration of liberated lands (PHOTO)
Iran not to raise price of energy carriers - PBO
Ports giant DP World expects container volume growth to moderate in Q4
Azerbaijani, Turkish presidents laid foundation stone for Zangazur corridor (PHOTO)
Russian company plans to participate in restoration of Azerbaijan's liberated lands
Kazakhstan offers Hungary to launch Budapest - Almaty - Budapest flight
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Bank of Georgia to support construction of solar power plant
Tehran in need for new small-scale gas stations
Iran`s TEDPIX keeps downward trend
Azerbaijan confirms 2,266 more COVID-19 cases, 1,194 recoveries
Iran unveils details of its gas extraction, consumption and export
Iran begins cargo shipment from northern ports
TAP covers 17% of Greek demand for natural gas
Iran and Russia's trade turnover increases
Gadkari bats for green hydrogen; says India needs to reduce oil imports
Indian Defence Minister invites foreign defence firms to take part in DefExpo 2022
Iran's crude steel production declines
Foreign companies to pay taxes online in Kazakhstan since 2022
European Fund for Southeast Europe provides funding to Georgian TBC Bank
Russia records another 36,466 coronavirus cases
Hungary names areas for further co-op with Kazakhstan
Hungary increases export of goods to Kazakhstan
Uzbekistan forms new investment projects with South Korea
President Ilham Aliyev and President Recep Tayyip Erdogan attend opening ceremony of Fuzuli International Airport (PHOTO)
BSTDB ready to expand cooperation with local financial institutions in Azerbaijan (Exclusive)
Iran shares data on its oil extraction and exports
BSTDB may consider supporting Azerbaijan in issuing green bond (Exclusive)
Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan implementing large transport projects
Six Indian Naval Ships Arrive In Sri Lanka To Boost Defence Cooperation
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan arrives in Azerbaijan. First official welcome ceremony held at Fuzuli International Airport (PHOTO/VIDEO)
High oil prices to improve Azerbaijan’s external balance – BSTDB president (Exclusive)
New steel production plant to appear in Georgia
Azerbaijan repairs civilian properties in Barda destroyed by Armenia (PHOTO)
Iran can extract oil for next hundred years - Iranian Parliament's Research Center
Turkish president's current visit to Azerbaijan is another step towards strengthening bilateral ties - administration
Iran increases aluminum ingots production
Turkey reveals data on car shipments between its Tuzla, Italy's Trieste ports for 9M2021
High probability of oil reaching $100/barrel - Blackrock CEO Fink
Some 30 people died from methanol poisoning in Russia’s Urals
bp’s ACE platform to be launched in coming months
Turkish president leaves for one-day visit to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan publishes data on trade with China
Kazakh National Bank talks reasons for recent base rate increase
bp, SOCAR mull possibilities of increasing Azerbaijan’s gas output (PHOTO)
Indian economy likely to record 9.5 pc growth this fiscal: Reports
Iran to complete transit routes - official
Physical gas flows, nominations at TAP’s interconnections
Kazakhstan’s KMG-Security LLP opens tender to buy diesel fuel
Some forces trying to break stability in region - Secretary of Security Council of Azerbaijan
Georgia releases data on COVID-19 cases for October 26
Uzbekistan takes measures to prevent changes in gas prices
Azerbaijan's International Anti-Terrorism Training Center holds opening ceremony for "National Security" course (PHOTO)
Revanchist forces in Armenia engaged in anti-propaganda campaign against Azerbaijan - State Security Service
SOCAR’s Kulevi Oil Terminal conducts contractor performance evaluation
Azerbaijani oil prices continue to rise
Kazakh president proposed to create interstate border trade zone with Turkmenistan
Reps of SMEs of Russia’s Yaroslav in Azerbaijan in search for potential partners - Russian official
Iran’s Shiraz Petrochemical Company records increase in revenues
UK's Heathrow Airport flags tepid travel recovery until 2026
Iranian currency rates for October 26
Georgia lowers import of Turkish-made leather goods
Majority of foreign investmens in Iran made in industrial, mining and trade sectors
Azerbaijani expert talks danger of new AY.4.2 variant of COVID-19
Value of cement supplies from Turkey to Turkmenistan rises
Law firm advising LUKOIL in acquisition of 15.5% interest in Shah Deniz named
PM Modi to attend ASEAN-India Summit virtually on Oct 28
Iran shares data on agricultural exports from Hamedan Province
Iran, Japan to collaborate in rural cooperatives sector
Apple importer iDigital plans TASE IPO at NIS 1b valuation
Turkey notes growth in cement exports to Uzbekistan
Azerbaijan prolongs program of cooperation with FAO
Oil gains as traders await stocks data, Iran talks
Embassy of Hungary with support of AZAL presents “Treasures of Hungary” photo exhibition (PHOTO)
U.S. Treasury's Yellen raised 'issues of concern' with Chinese Vice Premier Liu -statement
1,353 more COVID-19 cases reported in Kazakhstan
From digital transformation to strategic priorities: Siemens talks work in Uzbekistan (Exclusive)
Chinese Xi congratulates Mirziyoyev on election as Uzbek president
Man shot inside Union Square subway station in New York
Facebook invests billions in metaverse efforts as ad business slows
Egypt not to extend years-long state of emergency: president
Spain's COVID-19 cases top 5 mln
Seven killed, 140 hurt in protests against Sudan military coup
Western ambassadors took a step back, will be more careful: Erdogan
Tesla’s market value tops $1T after Hertz orders 100K cars
6 injured, including officer, in Idaho mall shooting
Saudi Arabia outlines plans under Mideast Green Initiative
British PM tells Putin Russia-UK relationship "is not the one" London wants
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by Italian Rai 1 TV channel on October 26, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev addresses the nation on October 26, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: October 26, 2020
Development of financial technologies in Kyrgyzstan discussed in Bishkek
Georgian PM holds videoconference with Ukrainian, Moldovan counterparts
Modernization of our country, fight against unpleasant situations must reach a completely new level - President Ilham Aliyev
Master plan of Gubadli will probably be submitted in coming months - Azerbaijani president
Africa's COVID-19 cases near 8.5 mln: Africa CDC
For me, biggest reward is joy and pride in the eyes of former IDPs - Azerbaijani president
Second Karabakh war showed our strength and national spirit - President Ilham Aliyev
After 27 years, we ended occupation and drove enemy out of our lands - Azerbaijani president
All news