Interview: President of European Court of Human Rights Notes Necessity Searching Additional Ways of Simplifying Court Procedures

Interview: President of European Court of Human Rights Notes Necessity Searching Additional Ways of Simplifying Court Procedures

Trend's interview with President of the European Court of Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Jean-Paul Costa.

Question: The European Union has recently established an Agency for European Union on major rights. How could the activities of the new establishment affect the work of the European Court of Human Rights?

Answer: Well first of all I should stress that I have never seen efforts undertaken by the European Union in the field of human rights as being in some way in competition with the Council of Europe and its institutions. If we are serious about strengthening human rights protection throughout Europe then we must welcome initiatives that help to achieve this. The efforts of the European Union and the Council of Europe in this sphere are and must be complementary. In this context I am particularly encouraged by the decision at the recent EU summit in Brussels that the new reform treaty will include the obligation for the Union to accede to the European Convention on Human Rights. As to the Fundamental Rights Agency itself, I do not see it having any direct impact on the Court's work, since its role is entirely different. It is not a judicial organ with competence to examine and adjudicate individual complaints against member States. It is more concerned with data collection, research, analysis and awareness-raising and this may help the Court and the Council of Europe (who will have a representative on the Agency's management board) in the wider perspective of enhancing human rights protection generally.

Question: What are your views on the future of the Court and its mission in the general European law, with the consideration of developments ongoing worldwide, including Europe? Will the Court remain loyal to its principles, developed over more than 50 years?

Answer: My view is that the system set up by the European Convention on Human Rights has proved its worth and that no one has yet come up with a better system for international human rights protection. Indeed I would go further and say that the system remains an outstanding model for control mechanisms designed to supervise the implementation of international law. In many ways its mission has become even more important - as the world get smaller the need for effective international justice grows. But also if the challenges do change and the environment within which the system has to operate obviously evolves, the basic premise of the system remains as valid as it was in 1950. That is that the best way to secure a stable and peaceful Europe is the maintenance of democracy and the rule of law through a judicial mechanism of external scrutiny based on the principle of collective enforcement. Will the Court remain loyal to its principles? Well in one sense of course it will remain an independent judicial body, functioning impartially on the basis of the legal framework which defines its competence. Yet the Convention has never been wholly static; it is what we call a living instrument and this dynamic character is necessary to adapt its guarantees to changing society and technology. For example what was understood by private and family life in 1950 bears little resemblance to what is encompassed by this notion in 2007. Thus the Court has interpreted the Convention's provisions quite extensively over the years. However, it does so with caution and it is in my view right that it should do so, within a subsidiary system, having close regard to what is or is not a matter of European consensus in terms of the legal recognition of moral, social and technological development.

Question: At the moment over 90,000 appeals are under the consideration of the European Court of Human Rights. Yet Protocol 14 has not been ratified. Ideas by the Sage Group are not approved fully, as well. What are your views on the future of the European Court of Human Rights?

Answer: I have repeatedly stressed the need for a rapid entry into force of Protocol No. 14 and I continue to urge the Russian Federation, the only Council of Europe State still to ratify the Protocol, to take the necessary steps as soon as possible. At the same time I think it is important that the Council of Europe takes forward the work of the Wise Persons without delay. We must look for additional ways for the Court to streamline its procedures. We have to make sure that the Court is able to devote enough time to producing well-reasoned judgments in respect of the most important cases, particularly those which have the most impact on national legal systems. But in the end it is only through more effective implementation at national level that we will be able to reduce the Court's caseload to a more manageable level. When, as already happens in some Contracting States, national courts are ready to apply the Convention and the Convention case-law themselves, then the Strasbourg Court could become what it is designed to be, a Court of last resort, not instance.

Could you name the post-Soviet country which mostly appeals the Court and what are the major problems in the court system in counties in transition period?

It is no secret that State with the highest volume of incoming applications is the Russian Federation, which accounts for approximately 22% of all the applications pending before the Court. However, in terms of the number of applications per head of population several States have higher rates: for example Slovenia, Czech Republic, Latvia, Romania, Poland, Croatia .... I should also make clear that the number of applications brought against a State is not necessarily an indication of how well human rights are protected there. For one thing many applications will be declared inadmissible; for another the number of applications will often depend on how well known the Convention is generally within the State concerned and specifically within the legal community.

The sort of problem varies from State to State and there are some rather special situations which give rise to particular types of issue. Generally it takes time to adapt a legal system to the proper operation of the rule of law and it also requires adequate financing. Some problems are common to certain States. For instance the non-execution of final judicial decisions is an issue that we encounter in several states. Schemes introduced for the restitution of nationalised property have given rise to problems in some states. Some systems allowed for the quashing of final judgments on an appeal by the Prosecutor General, but this has mostly been resolved. Length of judicial proceedings is also a chronic problem in some States, but we also find this issue in the older democratic States.

Question: Do you plan to visit the South Caucasus countries, including Azerbaijan, in the near future?

Answer: I will be going to Armenia in the autumn and I plan to visit Azerbaijan next May.

Aztelekom develops project to improve quality of services in Azerbaijani districts
Aztelekom develops project to improve quality of services in Azerbaijani districts
Brazil central bank chief says WhatsApp payments service faces further review
Brazil central bank chief says WhatsApp payments service faces further review
Alibaba Cloud announces business expansion in Southeast Asia
Alibaba Cloud announces business expansion in Southeast Asia
Loading Bars
Hungary's parliament adopts 2021 budget
Israel reports 1,008 new COVID-19 cases, 28,055 in total
Russia leading among importers of Azerbaijani fruit, vegetables
Azerbaijan launches pilot project for breeding highly productive species of livestock
TPAO to continue conducting oil, gas exploration in 2 Turkish provinces
TABIB discloses number of infected people in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic
Assistant to Azerbaijani president: List of spheres affected by pandemic to be amended
TABIB: Azerbaijan begins to conduct serologic tests
Georgian National Bank takes measures to support tourism sector
Assistant to Azerbaijani president: Those infected people who leave houses - criminally liable
Turkmen company plans to increase harvest of vegetables
Central Bank of Azerbaijan to hold deposit auction
Five-month cargo shipment volume via Turkish Mersin port disclosed
Turkey bans entrance of Kazakhs as anti-COVID quarantine extended
Fitch estimates Georgia Global Utilities regulated water revenue
Aztelekom develops project to improve quality of services in Azerbaijani districts
Kazakhstan starts exporting locomotives to Moldova
PETRONAS Carigali in Turkmenistan opens tender for purchase of high-speed ship
Azerbaijan records growth in export of its products to Switzerland
Erdogan: Some countries' statements on Hagia Sophia - direct interference in Turkey's internal affairs
Data on maritime cargo transshipment from US via ports of Turkey announced
Plastic cards number grows in Kazakhstan year-on-year
Azerbaijan makes changes to SMS permission system during COVID-19 quarantine
Azerbaijan reveals amount of COVID-19 cases revealed in Baku
Info on cargo shipment from Iran via Turkish ports disclosed
Daimler's Mercedes-Benz to streamline global production network
Georgian citizens traveling to Latvia not be placed under mandatory quarantine
Azerbaijan discloses number of fatal COVID-19 cases
Azerbaijan Hotel Association eyes restoring work in post-pandemic period
Russia's Tatneft opens tender for construction, installation work in Turkmenistan
Iran's export to Kuwait declines
Oil demand won’t get back to pre-crisis growth trend for some years
Azerbaijan confirms 583 new COVID-19 cases
IOM assists Turkmenistan in developing counter-trafficking plan
Azerbaijani Cabinet of Ministers approves resolution on toughening quarantine regime
Revenues of Georgian Vannilla Sky decrease
Transport cooperation between Lithuania, Kazakhstan growing despite COVID-19 pandemic
Kim Jong Un says North Korea prevented coronavirus from making inroads
Azerbaijani president sends letter to US conterpart
Raw milk prices increase in Georgia
CAERC talks current operational balance of Azerbaijan
Georgia building new highways
Azerbaijan, Indonesia to sign energy memorandum
Volume of five-month cargo transshipment from UAE via Turkish ports disclosed
Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan agree on co-op in water resources area
Georgia effectively monitors land borders
Kazakhstan's export to South Korea decreases
WB to support sustainable development of beef production in Kazakhstan
Data on cargo movement from Greece via Turkish ports announced
Turkey's export to D-8 countries drops compared to last year
TANAP Natural Gas Transmission Co. sees increase in current assets
Total assets of Azerbaijan’s Bank BTB grow
Thailand's main airport offers rapid coronavirus test for international arrivals
Azerbaijan supports entrepreneurs’ existing loan portfolio
Revenues of TANAP Company up
Azerbaijani, Russian experts highlight economic perspectives of North-South strategy
Macron names Jean Castex as prime minister in government overhaul
Volume of cargo shipment from China via Turkish ports revealed
Industrial production surges in Azerbaijan
Uber widens taxi app to Japan's Tokyo but ride-sharing still barred
Large harvest of potatoes, onions expected in Turkmenistan
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for July 3
Serbia's capital declares state of emergency over rising COVID-19 cases
Air France unions braced for job cut talks
OECD: COVID-19 limiting inflow of investments into Turkmenistan
Kazakhstan Railways to buy accumulators via tender
Iran to address debt payment issue of productive units
Shell evacuating its staff from Kazakhstan's Kashagan field
Georgia expects rich harvest of wheat, barley
UK-based ITI Capital eyes expanding its product lines in Kazakhstan
EU Delegation to Azerbaijan outlines deliverables for next months
Kazakh Gas Refinery extends tender for pipeline inspection
Azerbaijani gas will add to EU-Azerbaijan bilateral trade – Jankauskas
Caspian Legal Center expanding its services for Azerbaijan's oil, gas sector
New French PM to be named within hours - Macron's office
Prices for Azerbaijani oil continue to rise
India to scrutinize power supply parts imports from China
German Ambassador praises Georgia’s efforts to combat COVID-19
Geostat reveals inflation rates in Georgia in June 2020
French PM Philippe resigns as Macron readies reshuffle
Azerbaijan, Ukraine highly appreciate cooperation at int'l organizations (PHOTO)
Precious metal prices drop in Azerbaijan on July 3
Uzbek students to be able to study at Turkish military universities
Ayan Aliyeva, CEO of A-Level Education Group: “The Foundation program is a 100% guarantee of admission to a range of leading universities around the world”
UNEC employee wins the Special Prize of the International Festival (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan-Iran trade turnover down
Air France unions braced for job cut talks
Georgia reports 4 new COVID-19 cases
OECD looks to help Turkmenistan simplify creation of businesses
Liquified gas imports to Georgia increase
Number of German companies operating in Kazakhstan increases
Mortgage lending through state line increases in Azerbaijan
Huseyn Abdullayev, who scored the maximum number of points at the final exams: ‘My biggest dream is to enter Baku Higher Oil School’
England to relax quarantine rules for around 50 countries
Azerbaijani currency rates for July 3
Nissan's China sales grew 4.5% in June
CPC oil handling down month-on-month at its Marine Terminal
Details of five-month cargo shipment via Turkish Rize port announced
Azerbaijani State Oil Fund's forecast for oil, gas sales in 2020 revealed
Azerbaijan's Central Bank ramps up its currency reserves
All news