Global recession from West to East

By Pr.Kamran Dadkhah, Senior Economist - Trend:

There seems to be pessimism in the air regarding the economic prospects of the West and by extension the world. In its recent report, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) revised downward its estimates of growth for many countries. It lowered the overall growth rate forecast of the Euro Zone for 2013 and 2014 each by 0.5 per cent. For the entire OECD, the forecast has been lowered by 0.6 per cent for 2013 and 0.2 per cent for 2014.

We hear the same pessimism from economists and experts. In his talk at a conference honoring Stanley Fischer at the International Monetary Fund, Larry Summers noted that in order to achieve full employment, the interest rate has to be at a "natural level". However at present, he contended, that rate is negative. But the Federal Reserve cannot possibly set the nominal interest rate below zero. Similar sentiment was shown by two Nobel laureates, Joseph Stiglitz and Paul Krugman, in a recent interview with the BBC.

Needless to say, we are living in a globalized world and if the United States and the Euro Zone experience economic stagnation, it will affect other countries around the world. Many economies including China, South Korea, and Japan would be affected by the sluggish demand for their exports. Similarly, many developing countries have to rely on export promotion at the first stage of economic growth.

New round of recessions more complicated than ever

So, we might ask, what is happening? According to official data and expert pronouncements, the recessions in the United States and Europe are over.

According to the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), which dates business cycles in the United States, the recent recession that started in December 2007, ended in June 2009. According to Eurostat, the recession in Europe started in the second quarter of 2008 and ended in the third quarter of 2009. But then another recession started in the fourth quarter of 2011. This later recession came to an end in the second quarter of 2013 when both German and French economies posted growth.

Thus, as far as Europe is concerned, there has been a double-dip recession and many fear that if fundamental changes are not adapted, then there could be another recession. It is true that the United States has not experienced a double-dip recession, but the recovery has been anaemic. The average annual growth rate of the economy since the end of the recession has been slightly more than 2.2 per cent. In comparison, during the last recovery, that is from November 2001 to December 2007 the average annual rate of growth was more than 2.8 per cent. If we go further back the contrast is stronger. During the recovery period from March 1991 to March 2001 the average annual growth rate was more than 3.6 per cent.

The employment data is also not encouraging. The unemployment rate is still above 7 per cent. But more importantly, the labor force participation rate has fallen and many have claimed disability.

Another possible recession

Of course, not all news is bad. The stock market has recovered and recently there has been a strong showing in the housing market.

But overall the feeling in the United States and around the world is that there may be another recession. More importantly, many believe that there will be long term stagnation; slow growth and high unemployment in the West, which will be transmitted to emerging markets.

The basic diagnosis is that the European and American economies are beset by fundamental problems, which can only be fixed by structural changes. Different economists have a variety of ideas about these structural problems. For instance, Stiglitz believes that a main problem is the increasing income inequality. As mentioned before, Summers points to the fact the natural rate of interest (the rate that is consistent with full employment) is now negative. Some also claim that the natural rate of unemployment now is far above 4 per cent-5 per cent that it used to be.

U.S. policy

The policy followed so far by the U.S. Federal Reserve has been to keep the interest rate low and buy financial assets to inject liquidity into the market (quantitative easing or QE). But this is demand side stimulus. It has been in effect since the start of recession and has not been as effective as advertised.

Some have noted that this policy has only benefited rich investors and large banks. On the other hand, median income of households (in constant 2012 prices) that had reached $55,627 in 2007 went down to $51,017 in 2012. On February 1, 2014 Janet Yellen will become the first chairwoman of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. It is expected that she will continue the same policy. John Taylor, a prominent economist from Stanford University notes that such low interest rates reduce banks incentive to extend loans and assume credit risk.

What Summers, Stiglitz, Krugman, and some other economists suggest are also demand based policies. For instance, Stiglitz believes that if the low income people get more money they will spend all of it, while the rich would not do the same.

But if we agree that we need a structural change, then stimulating demand or even redistribution of income by taxing the rich and increasing welfare payments will not succeed. The structural changes should be aimed at removing barriers to investment and innovation. Recoveries and booms in the economy will happen when there is innovation. Indeed this is essence of Schumpeter's theory of business cycles. Barriers to investment should be removed and innovation and competition encouraged. These were the essence of policies followed by President Kennedy, who reduced tax rates and President Regan, and Margaret Thatcher.

Towards the East

In Europe, welfare programs should be reined in. Furthermore, the European Union was not meant to stop at monetary unification. It is time to take further steps. Finally, countries like Greece have to seriously address corruption. If people can live off welfare or through graft and embezzlement, why would they think about working?

But what about countries such as China, Korea and others which rely on exports? Particularly China needs to shift a good deal of its reliance on exports to domestic demand. There are many who have everything and there are more people who have not shared the fruits of economic growth. Here again there is a need for structural change to shift to domestic consumption and also opening work and investment opportunities for those left behind.

Oil and gas producing countries need not worry in the short run. But in the long run, the energy map of the world will be changing. The United States and other countries are using innovative technologies to get more oil and gas from untapped sources. The warning for oil and gas producing countries is: "diversify while there is time."

Finally, developing countries have no choice but to rely on export promotion if they want to break out of a cycle of poverty and underdevelopment. Their markets at the beginning are too small to solely rely on domestic demand. Therefore, long term stagnation in developed countries is bad news for developing countries.

So if the United States and Europe experience another recession, long term stagnation, or even slow growth, it is bad news for the rest of the world. So let us hope that these countries opt for fundamental changes in their economies and stimulate supply.


Kamran M. Dadkhah is Associate Professor in the Department of Economics at Northeastern University, Boston, where his areas of interest are econometrics, macroeconomics, international economics, and Middle Eastern economies. Previous positions have included Senior Economist, Abt Associates, Inc., Cambridge, Mass.; Senior Economist, Development and Investment Bank of Iran; and Director of Planometrics and General Economy Bureau, Plan and Budget Organization of Iran. He is the author of Foundations of Mathematical and Computational Economics, 2nd ed. (Springer 2011) and The Evolution of Macroeconomic Theory and Policy (Springer 2009).

Turkey records more revenue from Jan.2021 car exports to France
Turkey records more revenue from Jan.2021 car exports to France
Turkmenistan to send cargo flight to Turkey
Turkmenistan to send cargo flight to Turkey
Kazakhstan's expenses for importing Turkey-made steel grow in Jan.2021
Kazakhstan's expenses for importing Turkey-made steel grow in Jan.2021
Loading Bars
Turkey records more revenue from Jan.2021 car exports to France
Uzbekistan eyes purchasing helicopters from Airbus
Turkey always next to Azerbaijan - speaker of Turkish Parliament
Volumes of agricultural products export in Turkmenistan’s Lebap region revealed
Annual profit margin of Georgian banks increases
Azerbaijan's export of plastics over Jan. 2021 shows substantial growth
Iranian parliament shares grief of relatives of victims of Khojaly tragedy
Upgrading of Internet equipment in Azerbaijan's Khachmaz district continues - Ministry
Uzbekistan to fund introduction of drip irrigation technology for cotton growing
Europe’s gas trade to decline to 450 bcm by 2050
Kazakh gas producing company opens tender to buy spares for wells repair
Turkmenistan to send cargo flight to Turkey
Kazakhstan boosts mutual trade with Germany amid COVID-19
Ukrainian companies eye creating logistics center in Turkmenistan’s seaport
Chip shortage leads Japan automakers to post 4.5% slump in January global output
Georgia sees decrease in COVID-19 cases
Direct impacts of COVID-19 on gas market to be evident through to 2030
Baku Higher Oil School, Stockholm University to start training cybersecurity specialists
Aston Martin expects better 2021 sales after deep losses
Kazakhstan's expenses for importing Turkey-made steel grow in Jan.2021
IGB can be extended to eastern, northeastern Europe
Iranian president inaugurates Abyek-Varamin Highway
Azerbaijan shares footage from Gubadly district's Yusifbayli village (VIDEO)
Indian citizen Kaushik Barua conferred with Royal Order in Cambodia
India set to manufacture containers to boost exports
GUAM commemorates Azerbaijan's Khojaly Genocide
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan preparing for demarcation of state borders
World's largest cricket stadium renamed as Narendra Modi Stadium
Ukraine receives first Covid-19 vaccine doses
UAE establishes executive office to combat money laundering, terror financing
Reconstruction Work Of 66th School Under Indian Aid Begins In Nepal's Dakshinkali
Senior Officials Of India, France, Australia Discuss Further Cooperation In Indo-Pacific
Gold price in Azerbaijan decreases
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for Feb. 25
ERIELL int’l oilfield services group working on increasing hydrocarbon production in Uzbekistan
Georgian Crystal's refinancing plan carries elevated execution risk
Turkey issues data on ships received at Kocaeli port during Jan. 2021
Azerbaijani oil prices continue to grow
Azerbaijani currency rates for Feb. 25
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on February 27
Pakistan announces opening of flights to Azerbaijan
Iran's Minister of Tourism explains health protocols in coming Nowruz trips
N. Macedonia’s ICT sector may be attractive for Azerbaijani investors – minister
Another Italian municipality officially condemns Khojaly genocide against Azerbaijani civilians
Iran's Rouhani asks US to pave way for talks
Iran cooperates with Germany, Afghanistan to develop renewable energy sector
Iranian gov't, Expediency Council hold another meeting on FATF bills
N. Macedonia names energy, tourism most productive sectors for co-op with Azerbaijan
N.Macedonia, Azerbaijan negotiating on trade agreement
Oil prices hit 13-month highs on tighter supplies, Fed assurance on low rates
Iran and US negotiate only within JCPOA framework
Australian media reforms pass parliament after last-ditch changes
Decrease in bank lending observed in Baku and Azerbaijani districts
Appeals to consulting organizations in Azerbaijan growing dynamically - Azecoconsulting
Azerbaijan Industrial Corporation aiming to restructure portfolio
China becomes Uzbekistan’s main foreign trade partner
Azerbaijan's Central Bank publishes latest data on population's bank deposits
Azerbaijan discloses share of household loans in total lending
Azerbaijani State Migration Service opens tender to buy air transport services
Kazakhstan to reduce VAT for new manufacturing companies
New Turkish ambassadors to Washington, Tokyo officially appointed
Municipal transport to operate on weekends in Georgia
Tariffs on Eurasia trades to go zero: Iranian Official
Number of COVID-19 cases in Kazakhstan surpasses 210,000
Biden to press for $37 billion to boost chip manufacturing amid shortfall
Participation of Azerbaijani SMEs in public procurement to be encouraged
U.S. report on Khashoggi death expected to single out Saudi crown prince
Egypt plans to order 10 mln Sputnik V doses from Russia
Kazakhstan, Poland trade decreases amid COVID-19
Germany grants special approval for first COVID-19 self-test kits
Ford CEO calls on U.S. government to support EV batteries, charging
Swiss logistics giant to partner with Chinese company in vaccine storage and distribution
Japan's cabinet green-lights bill to ratify RCEP trade deal
Kazakhstan increases imports of Sweden-made goods
Kazakh Karachaganak Petroleum Operating paying particular focus to "green" technologies
Kazakhstan's Kcell mobile telecom services provider to de-list its GDRs
Azerbaijan - leader among neighboring countries for index of sustainable development goals
Israel's hi-tech services exports up 19 pct in 2020
Conditions for Int’l cooperation changing - Rouhani
Kazakh airlines eye boosting jet fuel imports
Uzbekistan notes decrease in mining production
COVID-19 greatly affects cargo transportation by vehicles in Azerbaijan's transportation sector
Head of Georgian Governmental Administration quits
Turkey registers more than 9 500 new coronavirus cases
Johnson & Johnson's one-dose vaccine closes in on U.S. approval
Pashinyan shows anti-Russia stance, denigrates 'Iskander' missile fired on Azerbaijan
Azerbaijani FM, European commissioner for Neighborhood and Enlargement discuss situation in region
Azerbaijani FM meets Ukrainian deputy FM (PHOTO)
Visitors show great interest in Azerbaijani products at Gulfood 2021 exhibition (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan discloses amount of investments in economy of Turkic-speaking states
Assistant to Azerbaijani president meets with Ukrainian deputy minister for foreign affairs (PHOTO)
Japan eyes to support development of Georgian agrarian potential
Airlines expanding their activities in Georgia
Georgia reports three cases of UK coronavirus strain
Azerbaijan talks state-supported domestic SME market researches for 2020
Iran's Khatam Al-Anbia Headquarters to begin second phase of Chabahar port development project
Georgia to receive AstraZeneca Vaccine from South Korea and India
Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of technological equipment
Port of Baku records growth in annual turnover despite pandemic
Uzbekneftegaz to accelerate sale of gas stations serving farms
All news