Four exit strategies for OPEC+ deal in 2018

Baku, Azerbaijan, Feb.1

By Leman Zeynalova – Trend:

The status of the OPEC, non-OPEC production cut deal will remain central to the global oil market in 2018, according to the report released by BMI Research, (a Fitch Group company).

As the market continues to rebalance, attention will turn to potential exit strategies for the group, said the report obtained by Trend.

Below BMI Research analysts discuss four main pathways for exiting the deal and the implications of each.

“Our core view and 2018 price forecasts assume that the production cut deal holds in its current form until December. However, we see a significant risk that the deal is exited early, at the OPEC ordinary meeting in June. It is also possible that the deal will collapse in advance of the meeting, or that circumstance will force its extension to 2019, although we assign a low probability weighting to both,” said the analysts.

1. Deal Collapse

Market conditions are strongly bullish. Oil demand growth accelerates in both developed (DM) and emerging (EM) markets, while supply growth disappoints, due to large-scale unplanned outages and delays in the commissioning or ramp-up of greenfield projects.

The combination of accelerating demand growth and soft supply growth drives OECD crude inventories down to their five-year seasonal average in Q1, while Brent crude rallies into the range of $70-$80 per barrel. Rising prices trigger an aggressive response from shale producers in the US and incentivizes cheating amongst OPEC members and Russia (OPEC +1). Compliance worsens substantially month-on-month provoking retaliation from Saudi Arabia and marking a de facto end to the production cut.

'Deal Collapse' is the most bearish of the four scenarios. Prices would be declining from the highest base - plausibly in excess of $80 per barrel. The aggressiveness with which OPEC+1 returned its barrels to market would determine the depth and duration of the decline.

Our demand and supply growth forecasts are, respectively, well-above and -below market consensus and 'Deal Collapse' requires substantially higher consumption and lower production than we currently forecast.

2. June Ending

Global fuels consumption growth accelerates strongly, led by resurgent EM demand. DM growth decelerates, but stays positive overall as building economic momentum offsets the impact of rising fuels prices domestically.

Renewed outages in Libya and Nigeria and aggressive decline rates in parts of Latin America and Asia tighten the market, offsetting a strong recovery in US shale. Soft inventory builds in Q1 and aggressive withdrawals in Q2 pull OECD stocks down to their seasonal norms, lifting prices. A strong demand and pricing environment weakens compliance amongst those countries with the capacity for growth. Uneven compliance levels fray cohesion in the OPEC+1 and Saudi Arabia fails to secure consensus to hold the deal - in its current form - through to December.

Given that the deal is priced in until end-2018, the 'June Ending ' scenario is on balance, bearish for Brent. A lot will hinge on how OPEC manages the exit.

As with the 'Deal Collapse' scenario, declines will happen from a high base ($70-$80 per barrel).

There are relatively few members of the OPEC +1 that have the capacity to substantially raise their output. Spare capacity is dominated by Saudi Arabia, which remains strongly committed to the deal. Russia, Kuwait, Iraq and the UAE hold the bulk of the remainder. With the exception of Iraq, substantial compliance slippage is, in our view, unlikely in these markets. Russia has signaled an intent to extend cooperation with OPEC beyond the cut deal, whilst OPEC policy in Kuwait and the UAE tends to align with that in Saudi Arabia.

3. December Ending

Broad-based economic growth and a continued pick up in global trade support accelerated oil consumption growth. Supply remains relatively comfortable, despite high overall compliance with the OPEC, non-OPEC production cut deal. US shale leads strong growth in non-OPEC supply and prevents the normalization of OECD crude inventories until H218.

This is the most price-neutral of the four scenarios, given that it reflects the consensus expectation of the market. However, as with the 'June Ending' scenario, the form that exit takes will largely decide its impact on price. Historically, the group has been better able to maintain its cohesion in a rising oil price environment and we expect Saudi Arabia to effectively manage the group's exit from the cut in 2019.

4. Deal Extension

Global economic momentum fails, dragging down on demand for fuels; EM growth flattens, while DM consumption falls into decline.

Large greenfield additions and historically low global supply outages tip the market deeper into surplus. Weaker prices restrain production in the US, but low breakevens fuel substantial year-on-year growth in the core of the Permian. High compliance with the production cut deal is insufficient to prevent heavy seasonal builds and soft seasonal draws in OECD stocks across 2018 and, as a result, inventory levels fail to normalize this year.

This is the most bullish of the four scenarios and would likely trigger a significant rally in Brent.

---

Follow the author on Twitter: @Lyaman_Zeyn

Georgia reports 1,673 new coronavirus cases
Georgia reports 1,673 new coronavirus cases
Georgia decreases export to Kazakhstan amid COVID-19
Georgia decreases export to Kazakhstan amid COVID-19
Prime Minister of Georgia votes in parliamentary elections
Prime Minister of Georgia votes in parliamentary elections
Loading Bars
Latest
Uzbek-Korean Uz-Kor Gas Chemical to buy radiant tubes via tender
Uzbekistan’s Ministry of Innovative Development to buy light vehicles via tender
South Korean companies invited to enter Turkmen market more actively
Azerbaijani FM, ICRC Director General meet to discuss current situation in Karabakh
Armenia's barbaric crimes tantamount to actions of fascists - Mikhail Zabelin (PHOTO)
Reports about shelling of Shusha by Azerbaijani army - another lie, MoD says
Azerbaijan's largest loans share falls on household sector
Azerbaijan's PM meets Pakistani ambassador
Armenian reports on missile attack on Khankendi by Azerbaijani army - lie, says MoD
Azerbaijan develops website to fight spread of Armenian fake news
Presence of PKK terrorists in ranks of Armenian Armed Forces - fact, says president's aide
Iran reveals value of fishery products exported from Gilan Province
Turkmen MFA opens tender for supply of technical equipment
October conscription for active military service ends in Azerbaijan
Georgia reports 1,673 new coronavirus cases
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 31
Georgia decreases export to Kazakhstan amid COVID-19
Turkmenistan, Denmark's Haldor Topsoe continue discussions on gasoline plant construction
Azerbaijani-Iranian border outposts reopen after being liberated from Armenian occupation
Some international organizations silent on crimes committed by Armenia - expert
Another earthquake strikes Turkish Izmir Province
Prime Minister of Georgia votes in parliamentary elections
Iran's per capita income declines
Turkmenistan considers opportunities to attract investment to Caspian Sea
Azerbaijani, Georgian experts discuss issues on agenda via teleconference (VIDEO)
Turkmenistan improves transport infrastructure
Iranian currency rates for October 31
Armenian Armed Forces fire at Azerbaijani Aghjabadi district's village
Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili votes at parliamentary elections
Local and international election observer organizations monitor parliamentary elections in Georgia
Parliamentary elections being held with new election system in Georgia
Parliamentary Elections being held in Georgia
Azerbaijani products to be showcased at int’l exhibition in Shanghai
Azerbaijan's income from sales of pharmaceutical products increases
Propylene production grows in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan investing in alternative energy dev't
Azerbaijan denies accusations on use of weapons prohibited by international law
Azerbaijani army fires back at Armenia firing points, which shelled Gubadli - MoD
Latest situation on battlefield on October 31
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry lists Armenian military equipment destroyed
Azerbaijani Tartar, Aghdam, and Aghjabedi districts come under artillery fire
Brazil's COVID-19 cases top 5.5 million with 159,477 deaths
24 dead in Izmir as magnitude 6.6 quake shakes Turkey’s west coast (UPDATE)
U.S. says Iranian hackers behind threatening emails accessed voter data
Israel's COVID-19 cases up by 587, tally reaches 313,701
Trump derides doctors as COVID surges, Biden says Trump 'giving up' on virus
Protesters clash with police over COVID-19 restrictions in Barcelona
U.S. COVID-19 cases surpass 9 mln -- Johns Hopkins University
COVID-19 remains public health emergency of international concern: WHO
Meeting of Jeyhun Bayramov with OSCE MG Co-Chairs and Armenian FM ends
Azerbaijan, Armenia reach new agreements following talks in Geneva
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva offered condolences to relatives and loved ones of those killed as a result of earthquake in Izmir (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani army does not fire at civilians - MoD
Franck Muller founder engaged in illegal gold exploration in occupied territories of Azerbaijan – top official
Priests also fighting in ranks of Armenian Armed Forces (PHOTO)
Business confidence forecast to deteriorate in Georgia
Venture funds to be created in Uzbekistan to finance innovative developments
Trade turnover between Ukraine and Georgia decreases
Roads connecting number of Azerbaijan’s Agsu settlements reconstructed (PHOTO)
All climate resources must be mobilized to tackle global warming, UK Ambassador Laurie Bristow
Banking sector of Azerbaijan looks more stable than predicted - CBA chairman
Azerbaijan destroys another "Osa" anti-aircraft missile system of Armenian troops (VIDEO)
UK's coronavirus reproduction number drops slightly to between 1.1 and 1.3
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs, OSCE MG Co-Chairs holding Karabakh talks in Geneva
Armenia's attack against Barda is crime against humanity perpetrated in widespread manner - Azerbaijani embassy in Canada
Azerbaijani embassy to Canada condemns speeches in House of Commons as they support war crimes
Armenia-inflicted damage on culture in occupied Azerbaijani territories would soon be irreversible - Modern Diplomacy report
Situation at front - under Azerbaijani Armed Forces’ control - Defense Ministry
Fire brigade extinguishes fire in Azerbaijan’s Goranboy due to Armenian Armed Forces’ artillery strikes
I don't know how efficient meetings are going to be now with regard to Armenian leadership - President Aliyev
President Ilham Aliyev's response call for Armenia: Recognize Nagorno-Karabakh
Azerbaijani PM phones Turkish VP regarding recent earthquake
Turkey already engaged in Karabakh settlement, whether Armenia likes it or not - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan destroys Armenian military equipment with precise strikes (VIDEO)
Armenia fires Smerch missile at Alasgarli village of Azerbaijani Tartar region
President Aliyev says Pashinyan lies about Pakistani, Turkish forces fighting for Azerbaijan
President Aliyev talks online footage of armed clashes, Azerbaijan's military potential
If Armenia got sanctions imposed on it as with Iraq, conflict would've been resolved long ago - president
Armenian side has no moral norms, no honor or dignity - President Ilham Aliyev
News about earthquake in Turkey’s Izmir saddens Azerbaijan – FM
Azerbaijan prepares new draft laws in renewable energy field
Central Bank of Azerbaijan reveals forecast for inflation in country
If someone willing to create second Armenian state, let them give away part of their own territory - Azerbaijani president
When three nuclear powers cannot exert pressure on Armenia, this raises questions - President Aliyev
Armenia sending convicts to fight in Karabakh conflict
Azerbaijani Embassy in Turkey opens hot line in connection with earthquake in Izmir
Combining efforts of Turkey and Russia to benefit region - President of Azerbaijan
What's happening now - results of Armenian PM Pashinyan's activity, says Azerbaijani president
President Ilham Aliyev expresses condolences to President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
Missile attacks on Barda by Armenian Armed Forces heavily damage local business entities (PHOTO)
Gold, silver prices in Azerbaijan down
Every human life is priceless, our losses are minimal - Azerbaijani president
If Azerbaijan agrees on political settlement, Armenia must withdraw from Kalbajar, Lachin and part of Aghdam immediately - president
Armenia says one thing to mediators, then does something completely different - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan destroys 2 more 'Smerch' rocket launchers of Armenian troops - MoD (VIDEO)
President Ilham Aliyev talks Armenian troops killed during recent military clashes
Georgian Tegeta motors opens “Toyota center” in Batumi
Armenia refuses to hand over body of 84-year-old Armenian to his family
Uzbekistan increases profitability of its textile exports
Kazakhstan's Nostrum Oil & Gas reveals revenues forecast for 9M2020
All news