Energy as a service (PHOTO)

Energy as a service (PHOTO)

By Chris Cook, for Trend:

As ever at such major energy events, a great deal more heat than light has been generated here at the World Energy Congress (WEC) in Istanbul. I have been attending the WEC as an expert participant in two Round Tables: firstly the influential Bosphorus Energy Club, and secondly, a Round Table convened jointly by the International Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) organization and the Economic Co-operation Organization (ECO) grouping of ten nations.

The tectonic shifts in global energy markets which I have been observing for some time, appear now to be increasingly discussed, but are not quite yet mainstream. The influential Head of Research of the King Abdullah Petroleum Studies and Research Center, David Hobbs was perhaps the clearest in expressing his view that electricity is a service, and not a commodity capable of being transacted for profit.

This reality is not well reflected by electricity market instruments and structures and Scott Foster of UNECE has been advancing a similar analysis for some time. Anyone familiar with my views will know that I have believed (and said) that this market paradigm for electricity is fundamentally misconceived since it was adopted over 20 years ago. My analysis is shared by my colleague Mahmood Khaghani who accepted it at least a dozen years ago in his official role at the Iranian oil ministry.

However, there are some interesting questions to be addressed, such as what would such energy market as a service look like; why would energy market participants wish to adopt it; and what would be the route of Road Map to implementation?

The Fifth Fuel

Discussions during the Bosphorus Energy Club Round Table and afterwards over dinner were artfully and dexterously chaired by Mehmet Ogutcu – the Club's influential and urbane founder. A clear recognition from this private sector gathering emerged that the transformation from a role of energy commodity intermediaries (middlemen) to a role of energy service providers has a very simple financial rationale.

This is that since service providers take neither market risk nor credit risk then their need for finance capital is reduced to that necessary for operating costs. In other words, finance capital is being replaced by (Smart) intellectual capital. In my view what is increasingly being termed the Fifth Fuel – fuel savings – comes about from the use of intellectual capital such as knowledge and know how.

The other crucial attribute of this Fifth Fuel which emerged in discussion during and after the Round Table was that the more expensive that finite resources such as fossil fuels become in dollar and euro terms then the more valuable become fossil fuel savings from the Fifth Fuel.

Energy Charter Treaty & Iran

The ECT/ECO Round Table was focused upon the further development of continuing bilateral discussions between senior officials from Turkey and Iran in relation to the development of the existing energy corridor between the two countries and its extension into ECO physical and financial energy markets.

Since the aim of the ECT organization is to provide the necessary frameworks to promote investment in sustainable and resilient energy infrastructure enabling transition to a low carbon economy, the existence of functioning physical and financial markets is essential.

However, while Turkey has long been a full member of the ECT, and Iran first entered into dialogue with ECT well over a decade ago, this dialogue came to an end with sanctions, and has only recently restarted. The ECT proposes that Iran should – like many other countries - sign the non-binding political declaration which would allow them to take up a form of associate observer status. However, there remains considerable suspicion within Iran in relation to such engagement with any institution identified with Western markets and there is a continuing debate between Iran's Reform and Resistance factions.

Professor Hossein Iranmanesh (an expert in intelligent systems and Director of two Iranian energy research institutes), my colleague Mahmood Khaghani (an expert in regional physical energy markets) and I outlined a proposal for a framework and instruments for a Smart Market which could deliver Energy as a Service.

Smart Markets

The first element of a Smart Market is the use of energy swaps or exchanges of energy flows, and these come in several types. The first is a Category Swap, where raw energy such as oil or gas is converted into energy as a service: examples would be the gas/power swap such as that where Iran supplies gas to Armenia in return for electricity; another variant is Gas by Wire, which is gas powered generation and export of electricity such as that between Turkmenistan and Iran.

More interesting is the Location Swap, where energy delivered into one location is exchanged for energy delivered out of another: Iran's Caspian Oil Swap is one such (but lacked transparency); but it will be seen that the outcome is essentially Energy by Fibre, where energy does not physically flow between locations through cables, pipelines or transport, but is in practice transmitted via the Internet. Finally, there are many possible hybrids such as oil swapped for oil products; and combined Category and Location Swaps.

The Smart Swap

However, perhaps the most important Swap is that of the Fifth Fuel for the value of Carbon Fuel savings. The best example of this, which emerged from my historical research, was that of the great Scottish engineer James Watt from 1778 onward, who refused to sell his steam engines to tin mines in South West UK to pump out water, but instead supplied the use of his pumps in exchange for a third of coal savings.

This Smart Swap of intellectual value for the value of carbon fuel is well described as Pumping as a Service and the outcome was that Watt was incentivised to ensure that his engine was properly maintained and continually improved since to do so increased his income from coal savings.

By way of a modern application of this approach the savings from replacing legacy power generation and pipeline compressors with up to date technology enable a phenomenal return in energy savings as efficiency is increased from 25% to 30% to some 60% in the case of modern gas turbines. However, conventional funding frameworks and instruments face insuperable problems in monetizing these savings. The use of Smart Swaps offer a simple generation as a service mechanism for the funding of the necessary system upgrades where Iran alone has a funding requirement approaching many hundreds of millions of US dollars.

The question is how would those who provide the use of technology access their entitlements and this is where the simple instrument of prepay energy credit instruments come in.

Promises, Promises

An energy credit instrument is simply a promise issued by an energy producer in exchange for value received from an acceptor of his promise. Such a promise is not a debt instrument (since there is no enforceable obligation to deliver money); it is not a derivative (forward) instrument since there is no obligation to deliver energy; and it is not an equity (ownership) instrument over flows of energy.

The energy producer is simply obliged to accept his own promise when presented to him in payment for supply instead of (say) dollars or euros: such a promise represents an energy credit.

Provided there is a robust framework of mutual guarantee, energy producers will be prepared to accept each others' promises and to account among themselves in respect of balances. Such a system - an ECO Energy Clearing Union - requires administration, risk management (to avoid over-issuance), dispute resolution and a suitable regulatory standards of behavior.

Outcomes
This illustration of a possible future networked energy market operating under the principle of resource resilience received a good reception. When combined with the patient explanations in respect of the ECT and the diplomacy of the cosmopolitan and talented Marat Terterov – the Principal Coordinator of the ECT who chaired the meeting – an avenue for accelerated development of the bilateral energy relationship between Turkey and Iran appears to have opened up.

My instinct is that Iran's reservations in relation to the Energy Charter may have been sufficiently addressed that they may now regard signing the political declaration in of the International Energy Charter and assuming Observer status.

In my view, such a smart move could be the catalyst for the creation of a Smart Market, where energy is generated and consumed on the basis of Least Resource Cost economic decisions, rather than conventional Least $ or € Cost decisions.

Next Steps

There appears to be a consensus that work should be undertaken by ECO with ECT and expert assistance to develop the necessary frameworks and instruments, undoubtedly through practical Proof of Concept energy projects, probably in border areas. The possibility of Energy Free Zones on ECO national borders has also been raised.

I believe that the 2016 Istanbul World Energy Congress may come to be seen as an inflection point in market development and possibly even as the beginning of a paradigm shift in energy markets to energy as a service.

Chris Cook is a former director of the International Petroleum Exchange. He is now a strategic market consultant, entrepreneur and a commentator.

Second batch of Sputnik V vaccine expected to be delivered to India by end of the week
Second batch of Sputnik V vaccine expected to be delivered to India by end of the week
Russia reports 9,462 daily COVID-19 cases
Russia reports 9,462 daily COVID-19 cases
Sputnik V approved for use in Republic of Maldives
Sputnik V approved for use in Republic of Maldives
Loading Bars
Latest
Israel's annual inflation up 0.8 pct, highest in nearly 2 years
Chairs of Azerbaijani Parliament, Turkish National Assembly talk issues of mutual interest
COVID-19 kills 202 more Iranians over past 24 hours
Lithuania gifts 15,000 Covid-19 vaccines to Georgia
Turkey to gradually relax COVID-19 measures, normalcy in June
President Tokayev receives Finnish Minister for Development Cooperation and Foreign Trade
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva made another post from Karabakh (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Germany's COVID-19 incidence rate drops below 100 for first time in two months
Georgia updates environmental targets with support from EU4Climate project
Azerbaijani FM, high-ranked EU official discuss Armenian-Azerbaijani border situation
Extra costs to air fares for PCR testing almost double flight cost - IATA
SOCAR to supply Rosneft’s oil products to Baltic states, Ukraine, Poland
Google leads U.S. business push to preserve work permits for H-1B spouses
Production of electric cars in Iran needs more motivation - ministry official
Azerbaijan, US exchange views on Armenian-Azerbaijani border situation
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 14
Georgia negotiating with South African, Polish companies to manufacture military UAVs
Second batch of Sputnik V vaccine expected to be delivered to India by end of the week
London May cocoa expiry sees 72,230 tonnes tendered
Azerbaijan confirms 326 more COVID-19 cases, 1,262 recoveries
Azerbaijan names date of issuing tickets for UEFA EURO 2020 matches in Baku
Afghan president calls Azerbaijani president
Wizz Air joins airlines cancelling Tel Aviv flights
Georgia receives financing from WB toward cost of energy supply reliability
More Azerbaijani enterprises to export tomatoes to Russia
'Lancet report on India COVID-19 response another attempt to undermine developing country's ability to challenge big pharma's monopoly'
Kazakh telecommunications company opens tender to buy station for wells management
Russia reports 9,462 daily COVID-19 cases
Azerbaijani MoD names number of commissioned military units in liberated areas (PHOTO)
Total assets of INPEX rise in Q1 2021
INPEX sees decrease in net natural gas sales
INPEX Corporation increases net sales of crude oil
Turkish company Chalik Holding to build new wind farm in Georgia
No oil deliveries planned from Azerbaijan to Belarus in May
Revenues of Azerbaijan State Maritime Agency decrease
Kazakhstan's ERG eyeing more investments into future projects
Kazakhstan sees decrease in trade with Netherlands
Kazakhstan, France discuss fuel energy cooperation prospects
Georgia reports 1,390 new cases of coronavirus for May 14
France's Macron to go down in history as killer of OSCE Minsk Group
Airbnb bookings jump 52% as vaccinations spur vacation rental demand
SOCAR ready to share capacity of Southern Gas Corridor with Turkmenistan
Kazakhstan decreases exports to Hungary
Azerbaijani oil prices decline
Russian IrAero to launch flights to Azerbaijan soon
Zulfiya Khanbabayeva to be the next narrator of Nar's ‘Reading hour’ project (PHOTO)
Apple supplier Foxconn reports Q1 profit T$28.2 bln, beats estimates
Kazakh gas supply company opens tender for pipeline maintenance
Georgia reveals rating of its largest wine and spirits companies
Georgian Geofresh company eyes Europe, Dubai to expand exports
Georgian Adjara creating new platform for tourism development
Turkey discloses number of ships received by Tuzla port
Turkish ministry discloses volume of cargo handled through Bartin port
Sweden, WB supporting Georgia by addressing wastewater treatment challenges
IMF underlines successfully completed four-year extended program in Georgia
Georgia considers opening of land borders
UN Secretary General calls for immediate cessation of hostilities in Gaza Strip and Israel
Kazakhstan requires sustainable management practices for natural resources - UNIDO
Iran’s FM meets with Spanish counterpart
Kazakhstan reports 2,549 more COVID-19 cases, total at 353,140
Turkey reports 11,534 new COVID-19 cases, 5,083,996 in total
6.0-magnitude quake strikes off Japan's Fukushima Prefecture, no tsunami warning issued
Colonial Pipeline restarts entire pipeline system - company statement
Hamas launches 100 more missiles in direction of Ashkelon
More than 745,000 COVID-19 infections detected worldwide over past 24 hours - WHO
UN Security Council to hold open session on Israel and Gaza Strip on May 16
Oil prices drop as U.S. pipeline resumes operations
Latvia eases entry rules for vaccinated travelers
Three rockets launched toward Israel from Lebanon, no damage -Israeli military
Africa's COVID-19 cases surpass 4.66 mln
Over 500 residential buildings razed by Israeli airstrikes in Gaza Strip
Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry issues statement on tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani border
China's Qinghai donates anti-pandemic supplies to Kyrgyzstan
Azerbaijani FM talks tension on Azerbaijani-Armenian border with OSCE Chairman-in-Office
Georgian's commercial banks see increase in number of total loans
Azerbaijani, Russian FMs exchange views on tensions on Azerbaijani-Armenian border
Overseas election headquarters established at Iran’s foreign ministry
Sputnik V approved for use in Republic of Maldives
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 13
Azerbaijan confirms 509 more COVID-19 cases, 1,427 recoveries
COVID-19 cases decrease in 80 Turkish provinces in a week
Tajikistan delegation to visit Uzbekistan on May 14
Gaza death toll jumps to 84 as Israeli air raids intensify
Musk decries bitcoin's 'insane' energy use after Tesla payment U-turn
Azerbaijani president got touched by National leader Heydar Aliyev's words about Shusha (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani president once again says at Jidir Plain in Shusha - Karabakh is Azerbaijan! (VIDEO)
EU countries urged to halt non-essential travel from India
U.S. weekly jobless claims fall
Gaza flare-up further weakens shekel
Georgia increases aviation fuel imports
Iran ready to have closer ties with Saudi Arabia, FM says
Azerbaijan’s import of goods from Italy down
Iran talks insurance data in its mining sector
Turkish ministry discloses volume of cargo handled through Mersin port
Georgia adopts new rule on forest use
Kazakh Senate adopts document on economic relations with Kyrgyzstan, within EAEU
Volume of chemical products exported by Turkey to Azerbaijan disclosed
KazTransOil completes connecting newly constructed sections to Uzen-Atyrau-Samara pipeline
Trade ministry discloses volume of cereals imported by Kazakhstan from Turkey
Russian Bright Way Group to set up pharmaceutical plant in North Kazakhstan
All news