Experts: Neither sanctions nor talks to help Iran out of nuclear impasse

Experts: Neither sanctions nor talks to help Iran out of nuclear impasse

Azerbaijan, Baku, Nov. 3 / Trend T. Konyayeva /

Until the Iranian regime changes its approach to the negotiations about its nuclear program, or the West revises its Iranian strategy, neither new talks nor sanctions will help to resolve the current political crisis over Tehran's nuclear intiativies, experts believe.

Iran is ready to start talks with Europe and the 5+1 group if the talks will help them to have their uranium enrichment program accepted and legitimized. However, the EU is not prepared to accept such a proposal. They know in advance that talks with Iran under normal circumstances will not succeed. Therefore, they are pursuing their so-called "smart diplomacy." With smart diplomacy, they keep the door to negotiations open and also increase pressure on Iran, Professor Reza Taghizadeh, Trend Expert Council member, wrote Trend in an e-mail.

EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Catherine Ashton said last weekend that Iran's chief negotiator Saeed Jalili agreed to begin talks with the six sides (five permanent U.N. Security Council members plus Germany) on the Iranian nuclear program after Nov. 10.

Later, the Iranian Supreme National Security Council confirmed its readiness to negotiate.

Europe thinks that Iran could only comply with its demands under the serious threat of a military attack or an economic breakdown. However, as they are not in a position to attack Iran right now, they have focused on increasing economic and political pressure against Tehran, he said.

In July, EU leaders and foreign ministers proposed additional sanctions against Iran at a meeting in Brussels. The limitations included freezing investments in the country's oil and gas sector, and banning the transfer and provision of industrial technologies and equipment and specialized services. Moreover, the measures include restrictions on trade and banking, and a ban on a number of Iranian officials to enter the EU.

All of the EU's foreign ministers approved imposing additional sanctions against Iran at a meeting in Luxembourg on Oct. 5.

"Pursuing such diplomacy will not encourage Tehran to rush to the negotiation table with the EU, but this approach also has no risks involved and is not costly to Europe," the professor said. "They are well aware that Iran is not going to yield in a foreseeable future anyway, even if they agree go to the negotiation table."

The applied pressures of the United States and the EU have aimed to find a final solution to the Iranian nuclear standoff by breaking down the regime's resistance, and not by giving them gifts or talking nicities with them, he said.

Meanwhile, Professor Meir Litvak at Tel-Aviv University's Dayan Center for Middle Eastern and African Studies said that he does not think that the sanctions will force Iran to completely surrender its nuclear program.

Sanctions have two important goals, he said. The first is to force at least some of the Iranian elite to consider taking a more flexible approach to the negotiations, he said.

Such negotiations, if successful, will delay or slow down the Iranian drive toward nuclear capability, Litvak added. 

Moreover, the sanctions are designed to cause hardships for the regime - again in the hope that it will be forced to divert its attention, efforts and resources to economic instead of nuclear issues, he said.

At the same time, Said Yari, an expert on nuclear issues, Jalili and Ashton will discuss common proposals for both sides, as Iran already answered the IAEA's five questions about the so-called "Modal Program" in 2008-2009.

"If negotiations begin within the proposals put forward by Iran last year, then I believe that they will be encouraging," Yari told Trend over phone from Tehran.

In July 2009, U.S. President Barack Obama urged Iran to respond by September to the proposal of the six countries, which stipulated a refusal from further nuclear research for exchange to trade preferences. Iran responded by submitting a package of proposals relating to world nuclear energy and other global challenges.

Later, Iran's negotiations with the six countries were suspended after the IAEA Board of Governors adopted a resolution condemning Iran for building a second uranium enrichment plant near the Iranian city of Qom and called upon Tehran to reveal any undeclared nuclear facilities.

The West does not hope for any progress within these proposals. It strives for Iran to adopt its concerns about the nuclear program, Yari said.

"The West conducts a paradoxical policy regarding Iran's nuclear program," he added. "They showed an interest in negotiating with Iran, but then they tightened their sanctions against the country. The West must sit at the table to hold negotiations, but not exert pressure. Iran's nuclear program is a strategic project. To stop it by exerting pressure is absurd."

The U.N. Security Council adopted another resolution, which provides for new sanctions against Tehran in connection with its refusal to cease uranium enrichment on June 9. About 12 members of the council voted for Resolution No. 1929, and two non-permanent members - Turkey and Brazil - voted against the initiative. Lebanon abstained. This is the fourth resolution adopted by the council due to Tehran's unwillingness to comply with international requirements concerning the Iranian nuclear program.

Iran's nuclear standoff with the West looks very much like the Arab-Israeli conflict - lots of efforts by all sides and still no quick fix or solution, Taghizadeh said.

The Iranian nuclear issue is multidimensional and looking at it from only one side does not give you a complete picture of the problem, he said.

D. Khatinoglu contributed to this article.

Israel reports 41 new COVID-19 cases, 836,740 in total
Israel reports 41 new COVID-19 cases, 836,740 in total
Frequency of regular flights between Georgia and Israel increases
Frequency of regular flights between Georgia and Israel increases
Tipalti buys in all-Israeli fintech merger
Tipalti buys in all-Israeli fintech merger
Loading Bars
Uzbekistan to open an embassy in Sweden
Global COVID-19 infection rate approaching highest: WHO
Portugal resumes flights to Brazil, Britain
Turkey reports over 63,000 daily COVID-19 cases
EU eyes to provide grants to Georgian non-profit organizations
Israel reports 41 new COVID-19 cases, 836,740 in total
Biden signs order keeping Trump-era refugee cap at 15,000
EU-UK trade plunges after Brexit: Eurostat
UK records another 2,596 coronavirus cases, 34 deaths
UN Security Council approves ceasefire monitors for Libya
North Macedonia vaccinates some 35,000 citizens
Raul Castro resigning from Cuba’s Communist Party
Azerbaijani IT company working on creating new network, server infrastructures
Georgian Economy Ministry to form expert council on Namakhvani HPP
Relations between Russia, Azerbaijan attain degree of strategic alliance - Federation Council Chair of Russian Federal Assembly
Turkish engineers develop fiber that kills coronavirus in minutes
Uzbekistan’s gold and foreign exchange reserves drop to $32.6 billion
Iran’s petrochemical output to reach $40b: Oil Minister
Relations within CIS IA to make comprehensive partnership ties more profound among member states - Chair of Azerbaijani Parliament (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani gymnasts win set of awards at Trampoline Hopes Cup tournament
Russia to permanently ban entry for eight US officials
Liabilities of Azerbaijan's Kapital Bank increase in 1Q2021
Azerbaijan's Kapital Bank completes 1Q2021 with profit
Azerbaijan’s production of oil and gas condensate down
Big share of Azerbaijan's GDP in Q1 2021 accounts for industrial sector
Azerbaijan announces date of next coupon payments on SOCAR bonds
Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan increase trade turnover
Azerbaijani insurance company to increase volume of payouts
Georgia, Turkey have significant prospects for co-op in agriculture, forestry
Georgian 'Mambo Frost' company exports its products to Azerbaijan
Fighter aircraft crashes in Kazakhstan
Russia adds 8,995 COVID-19 cases
Head of EU Delegation to Azerbaijan summoned to Azerbaijani MFA
Georgian budget to save funds thanks to low-interest rate on new Eurobonds
Azerbaijan discloses number of COVID-19 vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijan confirms 2,163 more COVID-19 cases, 2,251 recoveries
Frequency of regular flights between Georgia and Israel increases
Azerbaijani president, first lady sign obituary on famous film director’s death
Georgia not to revise 2021 budget
Volume of cargo exported by Azerbaijan via sea in 2021 disclosed
Raisina dialogue: Indo-Pacific epicentre of strategic competition, says Australia PM
Azerbaijan records sharp increase in cargo movement by air
Remittance inflows from Azerbaijan to Georgia show growth
Decrease in apartment prices in Georgia not expected - analyst
US investors aim to finance Georgian startups
Azerbaijan expanding network of seismic stations (PHOTO)
Turkmenistan prioritizes promotion of domestic goods to world markets
Kazakhstan boosts trade with Tajikistan despite COVID-19
Azerbaijan shows footage from Memer village of Gubadli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Nominal income of Azerbaijani population drops for Q12021
Foreigners show interest in making investments in Georgia
Azerbaijan's Azertutun company to be privatized - decree
Kazakhstan to amend rules for use of unmanned aircraft systems
Dozens of vehicles to be put up for state property auction in Azerbaijan
Next volume of ADA University’s Baku Dialogues Journal published
FAO working on approving Country Program Framing with Turkmenistan
U.S. housing starts increase more than expected in March
Photo capturing reaction to relative's death in Armenian attack on Azerbaijani Ganja named ‘Media Photo of Year’ in Turkey
Nokia expanding its activities in Georgia
SIEMENS AG modernizing thermal power plants in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent
Georgia shares data on dried fruit exports
Uzbekneftegaz JSC implementing modernization of unit at Uzbekistan's Shurtan Headings
Azerbaijan sees increase in inflation rate for Q12021
Turkmenistan leads in aviation oil exports to Georgia
Volume of Azerbaijan's 1Q2021 railway cargo traffic revealed
Russia's Yandex to launch e-grocery delivery in Paris then London
Kansas City revenue falls 3.5% as COVID-19 hits volumes
India To Spend $200 Million In Next 5-7 Years To Promote Hydrogen Use
Georgian Railway plans to issue Eurobonds in June 2021
Turkmenistan sees increase in number of registered business entities
Russian Hevel Energy Group commissions solar plant in Kazakhstan
UK PM Boris Johnson To Finalise "Roadmap 2030" With India: High Commission
India, France sign agreement for cooperation on Gaganyaan mission
Amazon announces $250 million fund for small, medium businesses in India
Sputnik V covid vaccine deliveries to India to begin this month
Anglo Asian Mining lowers gold output in Azerbaijan
International airport being built in Uzbekistan's Samarkand
Iran top OPEC oil producer for March 2021
Total assets of Azerbaijan's Kapital Bank increase
Japan provides loan to Uzbekistan within socio-economic dev't
Iran expects increase in production
Azerbaijan restoring roads in Tartar damaged during Second Karabakh War (PHOTO)
Memorandum of Understanding on co-op between Azerbaijan and OIC in field of statistics approved
COVID-19 affects trade turnover between Switzerland, Azerbaijan - ambassador
President of Afghanistan holds meeting with Nizami Ganjavi International Center (PHOTO)
Volume of natural gas industrial treatment at Turkmenistan’s Galkynysh field revealed
Iran has to take advantage of regional markets - Chamber of Commerce
Russia discloses volume of Sputnik V vaccine to be supplied to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan shares data on cancelled tender, quotation poll results
Iran, Qatar may connect their power networks
Azerbaijan reveals 2M2021 data on cargo movement via TRACECA
Georgia sees increase in production of nuts and grapes
Meetings held in Azerbaijan with representatives of state bodies to switch to G-Cloud
Azerbaijan Airlines’ Supervisory Board holds first meeting (PHOTO)
China to invest in development of Iranian ports
Production of wheat and potato in Georgia increases
Switzerland sees potential in strengthening co-op with Azerbaijan in energy field
Uzbekistan interested in import of livestock from Kyrgyz Republic
Turkmenistan receives new industrial oil inflow
Uzbekistan discloses processing capacity of sunflower seeds by 2022
All news