China trade steps seen as good start but leave core U.S. demands untouched

China trade steps seen as good start but leave core U.S. demands untouched

The United States has welcomed Chinese concessions since the two declared a trade war truce in early December, but trade experts and people familiar with negotiations say Beijing needs to do far more to meet U.S. demands for long-term change in how China does business, Trend reports referring to Reuters.

U.S. President Donald Trump and his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping, agreed on Dec. 1 in Buenos Aires to stop escalating tit-for-tat tariffs that have disrupted the flow of hundreds of billions of dollars of goods between the world’s two biggest economies.

Since then, Beijing has resumed buying U.S. soybeans, the single largest agricultural export between the two countries. China has also cut tariffs on imports of cars from the United States, dialed back on an industrial development plan known as “Made in China 2025,” and told its state refiners to buy more U.S. oil.

Trump took those as signs that “China wants to make a big and very comprehensive deal.”

But they only start to bring Beijing and Washington back to their pre-trade-war status quo, experts said, and do little to resolve core U.S. demands for structural changes in China to end policies that subsidize large state-owned enterprises and effectively force the transfer of American technology to Chinese firms.

“I think these are goodwill gestures, but they don’t go beyond offers that were on the table before Trump launched his trade war,” said Gary Hufbauer, a senior fellow and trade expert at the Peterson Institute for International Economics.

“Much more will have to be offered by China to reach an interim agreement in March 2019,” Hufbauer said, adding that structural changes would be far harder to agree on, much less achieve, by then.

Trump and Xi agreed on Dec. 1 to launch new talks while the United States delayed a planned Jan. 1 tariff increase until March 2.

A spokeswoman for U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, who is leading talks from the American side, did not respond to queries about the significance of China’s trade steps.

No schedule for face-to-face talks between U.S. and Chinese officials has been announced since Trump and Xi met, but a person familiar with the discussions said meetings would likely take place in early January and that the two sides were in frequent contact.

The first signal that China had resumed purchases of U.S. soybeans came in a Reuters interview last week with Trump, who said Beijing was buying “tremendous” amounts of soybeans.. China had stopped importing the oilseed from the United States in July, when the two countries unleashed new tariffs on each other’s goods.

But the initial purchases of 1.5 million tonnes disappointed traders and were only a fraction of the 30 million to 35 million tonnes China buys from U.S. farmers in a typical year, with 2017 purchases of $12 billion.

“We’re glad to have it, and we hope there is more,” a person familiar with the U.S. negotiating strategy said of China’s initial soybean purchases.

“Remember, even with the tariffs, the expectations were still for $7 billion worth of soybeans going to China. And we haven’t seen that.”

The concession that most captivated Trump was China’s suspension of a punitive 25 percent tariff on U.S.-built vehicles, cutting its tariff rate back to the 15 percent global rate it put in place in May..

Derek Scissors, a China scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, a business-oriented think tank in Washington, said the move was a “reasonable trade step,” but taken years too late. He added China would not likely increase imports from the United States because of a slowing market and excess domestic production capacity.

“Trump is right to say it’s a positive move, but in a year he’s going to be angry because auto exports to China aren’t going to have budged,” Scissors added.

China also issued guidance to local governments dropping references to its “Made in China 2025” high-tech industrial development goals amid reports it was looking to replace the program aimed at rivaling U.S. dominance in industries such as aerospace, robotics, semiconductors, new energy vehicles and artificial intelligence.

U.S.-China trade watchers expressed the most skepticism about that move, because state control of China’s economy has increased under Xi and few see China agreeing to abandon its industrial policy goals of developing national champions in future industries.

Signals of further concrete steps could come from Xi on Tuesday in a speech marking the 40th anniversary of China’s 1978 economic opening under late leader Deng Xiaoping and a major Communist Party conclave on economic policy. Some Chinese government advisers have called for accelerated reforms on the anniversary.

Scott Kennedy, director of China studies at the Center for Strategic and Economic studies in Washington, said it was essential that Xi send “unequivocal signals about the broad direction of greater liberalization.”

“The next step would be to see a series of substantial reforms taken on their own, and all of that would lay the groundwork for renewed U.S.-China negotiations early in the new year,” Kennedy added.

One of the people familiar with the talks said Lighthizer would insist on commitments and evidence that China is changing laws on competition policy, joint ventures, intellectual property rights and market access and enforcing the changes.

“It would be great if Xi Jinping, in the name of achieving competitive neutrality, pledges to take very concrete steps that would strip immunity and special treatment from state-owned enterprises in Chinese law,” the person said.

“They’ve got to go considerably past the old status quo on a lot of difficult issues to be able to claim that they’ve done something really significant.”

Total 10M2020 capital of Turkey-registered Azerbaijani companies revealed
Total 10M2020 capital of Turkey-registered Azerbaijani companies revealed
Growth of monetary aggregates observed in 9M2020 - Central Bank of Azerbaijan
Growth of monetary aggregates observed in 9M2020 - Central Bank of Azerbaijan
Main source of self-financing for Tbilisi City Hall to be tax revenues
Main source of self-financing for Tbilisi City Hall to be tax revenues
Loading Bars
Latest
China launches Chang'e-5 to collect, return moon samples
UN working on deploying mine clearance mission to Nagorno-Karabakh
UN says US’ decision to withdraw from Open Skies Treaty is regrettable
Number of COVID-2019 cases across globe up by over 542,000 in past day
Uzbek-Chinese construction enterprise eyes increasing production
Demand for Turkish steel growing on Turkmen construction market
Total 10M2020 capital of Turkey-registered Azerbaijani companies revealed
Azerbaijan’s Baku Metro opens tender to buy equipment
Iran exports to CIS hit $692mn in six months: TPO
Flag of Azerbaijan raised at former secondary school of Gulabli village in Aghdam (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Teimur Radjabov defeats Levon Aronian at Skilling Open tournament
Ukrainian president retests negative for COVID-19
Turkey summons EU, Germany, Italy envoys after interception of Libya-bound commercial vessel
President Ilham Aliyev raises Azerbaijani flag in Aghdam city (PHOTO)
Georgian gov't administration head Natia Mezvrishvili resigns
EU promises 217 mln USD to debt relief for 29 poorest countries
It is time to rebuild, heal and revive Azerbaijani Fuzuli city - Algerian Ambassador (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev and first lady Mehriban Aliyeva visit liberated from occupation Aghdam city (PHOTO)
Meeting with the leadership of the Interstate Television and Radio Company “Mir”
Turkmenistan participates to the 2020 Afghanistan Conference
Mine explosion in Karabakh injures Russian officer on search mission
Azerbaijan's Culture Ministry urges French cultural figures to be honest and impartial
Baku Metro, Almetcon LLC sign contract on installation of aluminum windows
Georgian Poti Free Industrial Zone talks about ongoing projects
Azerbaijan expects growth of pomegranate yield
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale November 24
Azerbaijani First VP Mehriban Aliyeva shares footage from Aghdam (VIDEO)
Growth of monetary aggregates observed in 9M2020 - Central Bank of Azerbaijan
Iran preparing to use water reservoir on Araz River on border with Azerbaijan
Main source of self-financing for Tbilisi City Hall to be tax revenues
Azerbaijan to make amendments to e-mortgage & loan guarantee system
Lufthansa to resume flights to Iran
Azerbaijan investigating criminal case against Armenian ex-minister
CoE approves trilateral declaration to end all hostilities between Armenia and Azerbaijan
Goods stuck in Iran customs exceed 550,000 tons
Iran claims its COVID-19 death toll to decrease next month
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price starts to rise
Uzbek currency rates for November 23
Turkmen Ministry of Construction extends tender for construction of checkpoints
Iran reveals investments for Markazi Province
Azerbaijani consumers prefer to buy car on credit - expert
Kazakhstan to establish facilities around big plants in Kyzylorda region
Azerbaijan to initially organize educational tourism in liberated districts - state agency
Expert explains Iran's current limits with its oil, oil product exports, revenues
Iran-Afghanistan, Khaf-Herat railway to open soon
Kazakhstan decreases exports to Netherlands amid COVID-19
Georgian Tskali Margebeli company may increase prices of products
Uzbek commodity exchange trading floor opened in Ukraine
Innovative Technology Park in Uzbekistan starts developing robots production
Azerbaijani mortgage fund issues regular bond interests
Prices of old apartments decline in Georgia
Azerbaijan confirms 634 more COVID-19 recoveries
Turkmenistan's Turkmentehnogurlusyk opens tender for audit
Turkey announces commissioning date for logistics center in Kars province
Iranian tourists reduce visits to Turkey amid COVID-19 pandemic
Azerbaijani organizations to benefit from Visa's updated Fast Track program
Azerbaijan discloses revenues from passenger, cargo transportations via TRACECA
Toyota leads re-exported vehicle brand from Georgia
Iran to launch Bostanabad-Tabriz railway line
Kazakhstan increases imports from France despite COVID-19
Transportation of Caspian oil via Baku-Supsa pipeline increases
Tbilisi’s residential property sales marginally down in October
Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan holding negotiations on possible gas supplies
Kazakhstan to build desalination plants in Mangystau region
Iran to allocate funds for the rehabilitation of Anzali Wetland
Iran to distribute domestic COVID-19 vaccine by summer of 2021
Netanyahu met Saudi crown prince, Pompeo in Saudi Arabia on Sunday
Citizens of Russia and Ukraine will be able to return from Azerbaijan to their homeland
Lithuanian - Turkmen cooperation not affected by COVID-19
Rompetrol opens its flagship station in Georgian Borjomi
Lithuania interested in developing co-op with Turkmenistan in transport sector
Azerbaijan’s AzerGold to pay investor fee on placement of second tranche of bonds
Iran discloses number of licenses issued in Mazandaran Province
Fitch Ratings forecasts growing share of problem loans in Azerbaijan
Deputy minister talks tree-planting campaigns in liberated lands of Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan boosts import of cars in 10M2020
Azerbaijan strengthens preventive measures related to coronavirus in justice system – Justice Ministry
Death toll from coronavirus pandemic in Iran surpasses 45,000
Gold, copper ores output decreases in volume in Kazakhstan
Iran eyes to link Persian Gulf with Caspian Sea via railway
Kazakhstan's revenue from maritime cargo transport increases
Azerbaijan aims to put Armenian ex-defense minister on int'l wanted list
Azerbaijan establishes Nagorno-Karabakh Regional Department of Justice Ministry
Uzbek-Korean JV announces tender for transport services
Russian shipbuilding corporation plans to start construction of ships in Turkmenistan
Iran reveals forecast on employment for Lorestan province
Ambassador Manig: Germany will strengthen Council of Europe by focusing on initiatives enabling better protection of citizens (INTERVIEW)
Batch of new Hyundai buses delivered to Turkmenistan
Uzbek commodity exchange to buy tires via tender
Azerbaijan ramps up exports to CIS countries
Ceyhan terminal transships 188 million barrels of ACG oil
Iran discloses balance of bank loans
Azerbaijani State Fire Control Service begins work in liberated districts
Uzbekistan boosts grape exports to Russia in September
Uzbek chemical enterprise starts commissioning of new fertilizer plant
Uzbekistan’s Jizzax Organic to import cattle from Europe
Uzbek Jizzax Organic predicts increase of purebred sheep herds in Uzbekistan
Famous UK-based poetess of Azerbaijani origin appeals on Armenian ecological terror (VIDEO)
Volume of gold exports stops growing in Uzbekistan
Iran doing research on several types of COVID-19 vaccines
All news