A divided UN challenged by Myanmar's obstinance

It took a natural disaster the size of Cyclone Nargis for the United Nations to find that it cannot work easily with an authoritarian regime like Myanmar, which has not warmly welcomed international aid despite high civilian deaths and destruction, dpa reported.

The UN had quickly brought assistance to victims of deadly earthquakes in Iran and Pakistan in the past, and after the 2004 tsunami in Indonesia. Governments in those countries welcomed aid and international relief workers with open arms.

It took North Korea, an isolated authoritarian regime, months in the 1990s to decide to call for international aid after severe floodings destroyed crops and spread largescale famine among the population. But the UN did provide food and medicine to help the impoverished country.

Myanmar's military junta, which clashed with the UN on democratic reform, has been extremely reluctant to accept relief workers from the outside as it is facing a major humanitarian disaster brought by Nargis.

The government was scheduled to go ahead with a national referendum this weekend on a new constitution and speculation was that it felt the less international presence the better. The next step would be presidential elections in 2010.

The draft constitution has been criticized as not inclusive because opposition members, including Aung San Suu Kyi, head of the National League for Democracy, may be barred from participating. Despite a humanitarian disaster it cannot handle, the government appears to be intent on proceeding with a questionable referendum.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Thursday called on Myanmar to focus on solving the national tragedy without suggesting outright that the government should call off the referendum.

"Due to the scope of the disaster facing Myanmar, the secretary general believes that it may be prudent to focus instead on mobilizing all available resources and capacity for the emergency response efforts," a spokesperson said.

The UN has not made the leap of linking Myanmar's apparent rejection of foreign relief workers to the holding of the referendum, preferring to focus instead on providing food and medicine to the more than 1 million people affected by the cyclone.

The UN Security Council, which held a hand-wrangling discussion about what to do with an authoritarian government that has failed to meet the responsibility to protect its own people, found itself divided.

Council members clashed between democratic governments that want to provide aid at all costs and those that showed understanding of dictatorship regimes.

"That's the difference between democracy and dictatorship," one exasperated Western ambassador said after confronting council members on the provision of humanitarian aid.

Council members disagreed on the implementation of the UN concept of the responsibility to protect, developed in 2005, which would allow UN intervention in a major civilian humanitarian crisis regardless of national sovereignty.

Western members said that responsibility must be met in conflicts as well as in humanitarian disasters. Asian, Arab, Africa and Latin American council members said the concept applies only in conflict situations, and some of them said the council should not discuss humanitarian disasters. Period.

Western members wanted John Holmes, the UN undersecretary general for humanitarian emergency affairs, to appear before the council. But other council members opposed. Holmes himself preferred not to be caught between the two camps.

US Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad expressed "outrage" that Myanmar had not welcomed international help.

"We are outraged by the slow response by the government of Burma to welcome and accept assistance," Khalilzad said, using the traditional name of the country. "It's clear that the government's capacity to deal with the situation is catastrophic."

Khalilzad suggested that Holmes appeal to UN members for help since he cannot appear before the 15-nation council.

Holmes, a former British ambassador to France, planned to launch an appeal to the international community to provide assistance to Myanmar. But he was criticized for being soft on Myanmar after some governments, including France, suggested providing relief goods at all costs.

"I don't think that invading Myanmar is a sensible option for the people in Myanmar," Holmes said on Wednesday when the amount of aid was just trickling into Myanmar. "If it was a blanket refusal by the government, it would have been a different matter, but it is not the situation we're in."

"The cooperation (from Myanmar) is reasonable and we're moving in the right direction," he said, adding that discussion between the UN and Myanmar had been "useful and constructive."

But Holmes raised the level of frustration after having to deal with a government that showed no inclination to accept the generous outpouring of relief aid.

"I am disappointed by the progress received since yesterday (Wednesday), a little of progress as I said, but nothing like as much as (is) needed given the desperate situation," Holmes told.

Myanmar has not totally waived visa requirements to foreign aid workers ready to bring much needed relief goods to the more than 1 million people severely affected by the cyclone.

It has also not clearly said whether the relief goods will be exempted from customs charges and has demanded that foreign relief workers be escorted in Myanmar.

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Georgia reveals TOP-10  of largest energy consumers in country
Georgia reveals TOP-10 of largest energy consumers in country
Iran's ministry shares financial data on backing its industrial, mining enterprises (Exclusive)
Iran's ministry shares financial data on backing its industrial, mining enterprises (Exclusive)
Iran unveils details of its trade turnover with Oman
Iran unveils details of its trade turnover with Oman
Loading Bars
Latest
Top U.S. envoy to Afghanistan stepping down
Georgia reveals TOP-10 of largest energy consumers in country
Over 70% of Iranians already received first dose of COVID-19 vaccine - Iranian President
Iran's ministry shares financial data on backing its industrial, mining enterprises (Exclusive)
COVID-19: Kazakhstan adds over 1,300 fresh cases in 24h
N.Korea fires ballistic missile as military activity surges
Algeria lifts lockdown nationwide amid drop in COVID-19 cases
Road crash kills 11 in Ecuador
Turkey summons envoys of 10 countries over Kavala statement
Gunmen kill at least 43 in northern Nigeria - state governor
Apple introduces M1 Pro, M1 Max chips
Number of COVID-2019 cases across globe exceeds 240 mln
Morocco police seize over one tonne of cocaine in Tangier port
Latvia announces four weeks of lockdown as COVID-19 cases spike
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by Russian TASS news agency on October 19, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: October 19, 2020
Occupation Museum, Memorial Complex and adjacent Victory Park will be built in Fuzuli
Israel congratulates Azerbaijan on Independence Restoration Day
Turkish President congratulates Azerbaijan on Independence Restoration Day
Tigray forces say air strikes hit Ethiopia's Mekelle, government denies
Czech president too ill to work, politicians discuss relieving him of duties
PMs discuss Belarus-Kazakhstan economic cooperation
Pentagon chief says US values Georgia as strategic partner
Azerbaijan's flag illuminated on TV tower in Georgia due to anniversary of restoration of Azerbaijan's independence (PHOTO)
Iran unveils details of its trade turnover with Oman
Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall in Iran
Iran’s Lavan Oil Refining Company reveals products on sale at IRENEX
Post Bank of Iran sees increase in revenues
Price of Turkmen gas supplied to China grows - Wood Mackenzie
Turkey's Presidential Administration congratulates Azerbaijan on Independence Restoration Day
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijan confirms 1,245 more COVID-19 cases, 409 recoveries
Georgia and US sign Memorandum of Understanding
Uzbekistan Railways expanding transport, logistics co-op with sea and dry ports
Azerbaijan to hold new auction for state property facilities
Saudi fast-food franchise operator Alamar Foods considers IPO
French ambassador makes statement on occasion of Azerbaijan's Independence Restoration Day
German companies interested in expanding economic co-op with Azerbaijan
EU has exported over 1 bln COVID-19 vaccines
U.S. manufacturing output declines in September
Azerbaijan issues startup certificates to more SMEs
Uzbekistan’s private airline launches flights from Tashkent to Moscow
Iran eyes resuming import of Turkmen gas
Azerbaijan's Khudafarin bridge in Jabrayil district - finally liberated (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan’s renewable energy potential exceeds installed capacity fourfold
Kazakhstan to extend food import substitution measures amid COVID-19
Ukraine has every capability to restore infrastructure of Azerbaijan’s liberated territories – MP
Playtech acquired for $3.7b
Total value of Azerbaijan's oil export abroad up in 9M2021
Georgia to further develop relationship with Azerbaijan - Georgian MFA
EU Special Representative for South Caucasus to visit Azerbaijan
Iran records decrease in production of raw steel, steel products
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
Turkish MoD congratulates Azerbaijan with its Independence Restoration Day
Ukrainian companies may partake in construction, restoration of Azerbaijan’s Aghdam – MP
Azerbaijan's announces drastic increase in car imports for 9M2021
Pan-European Executive MBA designed specifically to integrate holistic approach to business (VIDEO)
NATO ready to support ensuring peace in South Cacasus region - special rep
Non-OPEC oil output to more than half from 2020 levels
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for October 18
Israel and Azerbaijan are great allies and partners, who have common interest in region – former Israeli MP
European renewables generation to exceed 6,000 TWh
Over 60% of total investment to be spent on developing new oil & gas fields
Iran’s NICICO boosts extraction and production
Azerbaijan Automobile Federation organizes 'Time Attack' race (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan's foreign trade turnover increases in 9M2021
Year passes since Azerbaijan's liberation of Khudaferin bridge from Armenian occupation (PHOTO/VIDEO)
EU gas production falls by 8%
Share of renewables in EU power generation mix decreased
North Carolina declares Oct. 18 as Day of Restoration of State Independence of Azerbaijan
MUSIAD aims to raise trade turnover between Azerbaijan and Turkey (VIDEO)
EU gas consumption reaches highest level in last seven years
EIB, EU Commission ink deal on financing for alternative fuels infrastructure projects
Armenia’s failure to provide minefield maps to Azerbaijan impedes restoration work in liberated territories - FM
Azerbaijan sees no effective steps from Armenia in opening transport links - minister
Azerbaijan recommends revanchist forces not to go down wrong path - PM
TAP updates on progress in market test
Azerbaijan stands for normalizing relations with Armenia in post-conflict period based on int'l law - FM
Turkey reveals cargo traffic with Netherlands for 8M2021
Master plans for Zangilan, Gubadli, Kalbajar and Lachin being prepared, will be done without taking any loans - Azerbaijani president
Khudaferin Bridge is proof of talent of Azerbaijani people - President Ilham Aliyev (VIDEO)
Physical gas flows, nominations at TAP’s interconnections
Great leader Heydar Aliyev returned to power at request of the people, then threat of losing independence again was prevented - president
Azerbaijan boosts gas exports
People of Azerbaijan tirelessly walked towards this victory - President Aliyev
Turkish FM tweets on marking Day of Restoration of Azerbaijan's Independence
Iranian currency rates for October 18
Kazakhstan sees rise in gold jewelry price
IRICA shares data on Iran’s export to neighboring countries
Azerbaijan gives update on mine clearance work on its liberated lands
Azerbaijan calls for urgent interim measures against Armenia
Bank of Georgia allocates funds to back project at local construction company
In villages of Fuzuli, each house will have at least 12 acres of land - president
Azerbaijani First VP Mehriban Aliyeva shares post related to October 18 - Independence Restoration Day on Instagram (PHOTO)
Banks to start connecting Mir cards to Google Pay from October 26
Kazakhstan reveals main objectives of national agro-industrial complex project until 2025
Qatari companies might participate in restoration of Azerbaijan's liberated territories - FM
Gas price in Europe down to $980 per 1,000 cubic meters as trading opens
President Ilham Aliyev receives Turkish minister of labor and social security
All news