'Cancer-free' baby born in London

The first child in Britain known to have been screened as an embryo to ensure she did not carry a cancer gene was born Friday, a spokesman for University College London told CNN.

Genetic screening allows lab-fertilized embryos to be tested for genes likely to lead to later health problems.

Her embryo was screened in a lab days after conception to check for the BRCA-1 gene, linked to breast and ovarian cancer.

People with the gene are known to have a 50-80 percent chance of developing breast or ovarian cancer in their lifetimes.

British newspapers have dubbed the girl the "cancer-free" baby.

"This little girl will not face the specter of developing this genetic form of breast cancer or ovarian cancer in her adult life," said Paul Serhal, a consultant at University College London Hospital and Medical Director of the Assisted Conception Unit.

"The parents will have been spared the risk of inflicting this disease on their daughter. The lasting legacy is the eradication of the transmission of this form of cancer that has blighted these families for generations."

Yet not everyone is thrilled with the idea of testing embryos for genes that could cause health problems later in life, a process known as preimplanatation genetic diagnosis.

"This is not a cure for breast cancer," said Josephine Quintavalle, co-founder of Comment on Reproductive Ethics, which describes itself as group that focuses on ethical dilemmas related to reproduction.

"This is simply a mechanism for eliminating the birth of anybody (prone to) the disease," she said. "It is basically a search-and-kill mechanism."

She opposes the procedure because embryos found to carry disease-causing genes often are discarded. She says that is essentially murder.

"They will be destroyed," she said. "They will never be allowed to live."

Doctors in Britain and elsewhere increasingly test embryos for genes that are certain to cause illnesses such as cystic fibrosis or Huntington's Disease.

What's different about the girl born Friday is that she is the first infant known to have been tested in Britain as an embryo for a gene that is merely likely -- not certain -- to cause disease.

In the United States, geneticists are free to test for any condition for which they can develop a probe -- and they're free to look for genes that are certain to cause diseases as well as genes that merely may pose problems later in life.

Quintavalle opposes any form of in-vitro fertilization where embryos are "killed," she said. But she is particularly troubled by the idea of screening an embryo for the BRCA-1 gene because carriers of the gene do not always develop the disease, and the disease is not always fatal.

"The message we are sending is: 'Better off dead than carrying (a gene linked to) breast cancer,'" she said. "We have gone very much down the proverbial slippery slope."

Peter Braude, one of the top British experts on the genetic testing of embryos, said he understands the ethical objections but focuses on the benefits.

"There has always been a vociferous group in opposition," he said. But "there are people who can benefit and I think they should be allowed to do so."

In fact, he argues that the procedure actually prevents abortions because it takes place on a three-day old embryo in a lab. Only embryos that lack the defective gene are implanted.

"I don't think you can equate eight cells in a dish to an embryo or a child," said Braude, head of the department of women's health at the King's College London School of Medicine.

For many couples, the alternative to testing an embryo is to conceive a child naturally and test the fetus weeks or months into a pregnancy. Some couples opt for an abortion when such testing reveals a defect.

Diagnosing an embryo genetically typically involves fertilizing an egg with a sperm in a lab, testing the resulting embryo and implanting it in the mother if no defects are found.

Braude agrees that testing for diseases that may not be fatal -- or may not manifest themselves for decades -- raises thorny ethical questions.

"How serious does it have to be before you throw away an embryo?" he asked. "Are you prepared to throw away a 16-week embryo for Huntington's, which will not manifest until age 40?"

In Britain, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority determines the conditions for which geneticists can test. It has approved testing for more than 60 conditions since it was established in 1990.

The authority approved testing for the BRCA-1 gene in 2008.

Dr. Mark Hughes, who founded a genetics clinic in the United States, said he likes the idea of an authority that regulates what tests can be performed -- the system in place in Britain -- but believes that parents who want to test for genetic abnormalities should be allowed to do so.

At his Genesis Genetics Institute in Detroit, Michigan, Hughes carries out about two tests a month for BRCA-1 or BRCA-2, a related gene.

"The couple is the best one to be making these decisions, because they live with these diseases," he said.

"When it hits your family over and over again, many couples are saying: 'Enough of this. Let's prune this out of our family tree forever.'"

He rejects the notion that parents will use genetic testing to remove all imperfections from children.

"You can get up on your high horse and say people are looking for perfect children, but let's give these families more credit," he said. "They just want one that has a fighting chance of not having a disease."

Hughes said he doubts genetic screening will ever be used to test all babies. That's partly because it costs the equivalent of about $11,755 -- 8,000 British pounds -- to screen embryos.

It's also because the process is very complex.

"It's gotten easier to do now than it was 19 years ago," when Hughes did his first test for cystic fibrosis, he said. "But it has not exploded, not burst onto the medical field like some technologies do.

"No one would use these technologies for a trivial reason. It's too much effort," he said. "Not just the money -- it's so many hoops to jump through for a couple that would prefer to make their baby on vacation rather than in a clinic."

Volume of electricity generated by Turkmenistan’s Mary power plant revealed
Volume of electricity generated by Turkmenistan’s Mary power plant revealed
Uzbekistan, St. Korea to expand effective mechanisms for info exchange in tax area
Uzbekistan, St. Korea to expand effective mechanisms for info exchange in tax area
Uzbekistan’s Central Bank keeps refinancing rate unchanged
Uzbekistan’s Central Bank keeps refinancing rate unchanged
Loading Bars
Latest
Volume of electricity generated by Turkmenistan’s Mary power plant revealed
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office gives updates on civil casualties, damages
There is no future for second Armenia within internationally designated borders of Azerbaijan - Azerbaijani FM
Protest rally against Ganja terror was held in Budapest
Prices of Azerbaijani oil continue to grow
The slogan “Karabakh is Azerbaijan” was raised at the rally of the US President
Karabakh conflict will continue until Pashinyan admits reality - Russian general
Uzbekistan, St. Korea to expand effective mechanisms for info exchange in tax area
Georgia reports 1,759 new coronavirus cases, 350 recoveries
Uzbekistan’s Central Bank keeps refinancing rate unchanged
Kazakhstan increases import of cars from Turkey
Armenia must draw conclusions from Moscow's clear position on Karabakh conflict - Turkish government
Co-financed areas to be increased in Georgia
Four more Armenian UAVs neutralized - MoD
Non-resident investors' interest in securities issued by Georgian government grows
Armenian Armed Forces intensively shelling Tartar, Aghdam and Aghjabadi districts - MoD
Azerbaijan discloses information about flora, fauna of occupied territories
Uzbekhydroenergo to directly attract financing in international markets, Fitch Ratings
Why Kashmiris around the world celebrate 27 October as a Black Day?
UK retail sales growth beat expectations in September
Uzbekistan’s 9M2020 volume of financial services revealed
UN Country Office ready to provide humanitarian aid to affected people in Azerbaijan
Emerson gets multi-million dollar contract for Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli
Georgia approves air quality management plan for Rustavi
Turkmenistan names volume of planned rice harvesting in Lebap region
Armenian appeal to NATO is another misleading diplomatic offensive of Yerevan - US expert
A framework agreement of cooperation between IsDB and Standard Chartered Bank
IsDB Group and UAE Ministry of Economy co-organise first digital edition of Annual Investment Meeting on 20-22 October 2020
Oil demand for petrochemicals to decline in advanced world
Famous UK-based poetess of Azerbaijani origin appeals on Armenian aggression against Azerbaijan (VIDEO)
First mobile connection in Karabakh!
Global demand for jet fuel to peak around 2030
Diesel consumption to peak later this decade
Azerbaijani currency rates for October 23
Iran and Russia to lift visa requirements
German Commerzbank ready to expand partnership with Turkmenistan
OSCE Minsk Group's co-chairman from Russia goes to US Washington for meetings on Karabakh
Almost all countries to see lower oil demand in 2021 than in 2019
Iran lifts rice import ban
Timing of US Secretary of State's meeting with Azerbaijani Foreign Minister announced
Members of Nizami Ganjavi International Center send letter President Aliyev
Oil prices to be higher than projected levels in 2020
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 23
Iran reduces cars imports from Turkey
Azerbaijan's 9M2020 exports to Ukraine increases
Cars export to Georgia decreases, Turkish Ministry of Trade
Processes automation and robotization in digitalization of fuel and energy complex carried in Kazakhstan
Cars export from Turkey to Iraq decreases for 9M2020
Ambassador Extraordinary, Plenipotentiary of Japan to Turkmenistan completes diplomatic mission
UN comments on upcoming meeting of Azerbaijan, Armenian Foreign Ministers in Washington
Azerbaijani soldier addresses people in connection with coronavirus (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan - our home, our homeland, says Azerbaijani soldier of Jewish origin (VIDEO)
Latest situation at front line on Oct. 23
Servicemen of Armenia refused to get engaged in battles and left their positions - Azerbaijani MoD
Important territories, high grounds liberated as result of operations by Azerbaijan Army - MoD
Azerbaijan approves procedure for maintaining personal records of insured persons
Amount of value added tax paid by private sector down in Georgia
Georgia reveals number of subscribers of five largest providers
Income of Internet providers operating in Georgia up
Britain signs first major post-Brexit trade deal with Japan
Kazakhstan’s total number of COVID-19 cases surpasses 110,000
Israeli aircraft attack Gaza military sites in response to rockets firing
Chinese mainland reports no new locally transmitted COVID-19 cases
Intel reports 4 pct drop in third quarter revenue
U.S. sanctions three new Iranian organizations for alleged election disinformation
Israel says Gazan militants fire 2 rockets into southern Israel
Turkey confirms 2,102 daily COVID-19 patients, 355,528 in total
Moscow records another 62 coronavirus deaths
Trump tests negative for coronavirus ahead of debate: aide
France extends curfew as COVID second wave surges in Europe
Armenians commit provocation during sanctioned protest action of Azerbaijani youth in Poland (PHOTO)
WHO reports record daily rise in coronavirus cases across the globe
ANAMA disseminates info on missile attack on Azerbaijan’s Kurdamir by Armenia (PHOTO)
Car exports to Israel declines, Turkish Trade Ministry
Situation when significant part of Azerbaijan's territory is lost can't last forever, Vladimir Putin
Armenia discloses number of servicemen killed by Azerbaijani army
We already started to plan our future agricultural development with respect of liberation of territories - President Aliyev
Without normalization of relations with Turkey and with Azerbaijan Armenia has no future - President Aliyev
If Armenia makes constructive steps and liberate territories of course, we will open all communications - President of Azerbaijan
Popular Front Party, and Musavat Party going against national interests of Azerbaijan - President Aliyev
With TAP pipeline everything is on the schedule, says president of Azerbaijan
If any country assumes role of mediator, this country must be neutral, says Azerbaijani president
International monitors, peace-keeping forces one of last issues, which had to be addressed - President Aliyev
All the regions of Azerbaijan must be liberated, says President Ilham Aliyev
Azerbaijan is fighting itself, we don’t need any foreign fighters - President Aliyev
There will be no referendum in Nagorno-Karabakh - President Aliyev
If we are attacked, we must not only defend ourselves, but also launch a counter-attack - President Aliyev
Our refugees and internally displaced persons must return to all the occupied territories - President Aliyev
We must have decisive say about international monitors, says Azerbaijani president
If Minsk Group for 30 years cannot produce results, it speaks for itself - President Aliyev
WHO roots for rapid diagnostic tests to boost COVID-19 war in Africa
Kazakhstan to boost export of agricultural products to SCO markets
Int'l organizations informed about rocket attacks on Azerbaijani regions (PHOTO)
Morale of Azerbaijani army personell at high level - Azerbaijani MoD (VIDEO)
With this Armenian government unfortunately, prospects for peaceful settlement very remote - President Aliyev
More military equipment of Armenian armed forces destroyed (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani flag hoisted in Agbend village of Zangilan district (VIDEO)
Central Bank presents forecasts for Uzbekistan’s macroeconomic dev’t
Kazakhstan, Romania trade turnover increases despite COVID-19
With liberation of Aghband settlement, taking full control over Azerbaijani-Iranian state border ensured - President Ilham Aliyev
All news