Facebook executive jailed in Brazil as court seeks WhatsApp data

Facebook executive jailed in Brazil as court seeks WhatsApp data

Brazilian police arrested a senior Facebook Inc executive on Tuesday as a dispute escalated over a court's demand that the company provide data from its WhatsApp messaging service to help in a secretive drug-trafficking investigation.

Court officials in Sergipe state confirmed that a judge had ordered the jailing of Facebook Vice President for Latin America Diego Dzodan. Federal police in Sao Paulo state said he was being held there for questioning.

Law enforcement officials withheld further information about the nature of their request to the messaging service that Facebook Inc acquired in 2014, saying that doing so could compromise an ongoing criminal investigation.

The arrest, which Facebook called an "extreme and disproportionate measure," came as social media and Internet companies face mounting pressure from governments around the world to help them eavesdrop on users and filter content.

Arrests of officials from social media companies are extremely rare, though not unprecedented, because the companies typically comply with local court orders, especially from countries where they have branch offices.

"Precisely because these large global Internet companies have staff in many countries who are vulnerable to legal action including arrest and criminal charges, they generally do comply with legally binding requests from authorities for user data or to remove or block content in those countries where they have 'boots on the ground,'" said Internet freedom activist Rebecca MacKinnon.

Prior to its acquisition by Facebook, California-based WhatsApp had less skin in the game in disputes with governments outside the United States because, unlike Facebook, it did not have staff scattered around the globe.

"WhatsApp is a company that was started very focused on U.S. laws," said Internet law attorney Marcia Hoffmann. "Now that it's owned by a company with people and resources in other countries, there is more leverage for those governments to put pressure in new and in different ways. Arresting executives is one of them."

While details of the case remain murky, court officials said the judge in Brazil resorted to the arrest after issuing a fine of 1 million reais ($250,000) to compel Facebook to help investigators access WhatsApp messages relevant to their drug-trafficking investigation.

That is likely impossible because WhatsApp began using end-to-end encryption technology in 2014 that prevents the company from monitoring messages that travel across its network, said Christopher Soghoian, principal technologist with the American Civil Liberties Union.

"They are using technology to try to take themselves out of the surveillance business," Soghoian said.

The arrest surfaced as Apple Inc finds itself at odds with the United States government on similar grounds.

U.S. prosecutors want the company to build a software tool to help investigators unlock the iPhone used by one of the shooters in the San Bernardino, California, attacks. Apple has refused, saying it would set a dangerous precedent that would make its customers vulnerable to spying. Privacy concerns have previously put Facebook at odds with Brazilian law enforcement seeking evidence in criminal cases, although the confrontations rarely rise to the prominence of Apple's current standoff with the U.S. authorities. In December, a judge suspended Facebook's popular WhatsApp phone-messaging service in Brazil for about 12 hours after it failed to comply with two court orders to share information in a criminal case.

Brazil passed an Internet law two years ago aimed at streamlining thorny legal issues, but lower courts still have vast discretionary powers according to legal expert Ronaldo Lemos, a chief architect of that 2014 law.

"The court of appeals tends to be more sensitive in these cases, but the lower courts are still tough, as today's decision shows," said Lemos.

Geostat reveals volume of gas imported by Georgia from Azerbaijan
Geostat reveals volume of gas imported by Georgia from Azerbaijan
Georgia sees increase in coronavirus cases
Georgia sees increase in coronavirus cases
Georgia increases imports of tea from Azerbaijan
Georgia increases imports of tea from Azerbaijan
Loading Bars
Latest
Turkmenistan bank opens tender for audit
Azerbaijan to open bus routes to Shusha and other liberated lands
Demand for notes of Azerbaijani Central Bank significantly exceeds supply
Azerbaijan looking to create favorable conditions for Turkish investors
Geostat reveals volume of gas imported by Georgia from Azerbaijan
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for January 21
Kazakhstan’s national atomic company reports COVID-19 cases at its JV with France
Presidents of Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan hold online meeting
Azerbaijan ups trade turnover of food, beverages, tobacco products in 2020
Suicide attack kills three, injures 16 in central Baghdad market
Azerbaijan to be telecommunication hub between Europe, Asia via TASIM implementation
Bank Melli Iran unveils amount of loans issued for coronavirus pandemic
Kazakhstan’s National Bank sets up monetary policy committee
Turkmenistan begins harvesting first tomatoes in new year
Azerbaijani oil prices rising
Kazakhstan multifold decreases imports of Brazil-made goods
Kazakhstan reports decrease in raw sulfur production volume
Azerbaijan discloses volume of oil transportation via BTC pipeline in 2020
Turkish companies to initially invest in textile sector in Azerbaijan's Karabakh
Azerbaijani currency rates for Jan.21
Gold and foreign exchange reserves increases in Uzbekistan in 2021
Iran discloses amount of investments made in petrochemical sector
Azerbaijan's 'Regional Development' Public Association launches new portal (VIDEO)
Trading platform IG to buy U.S. brokerage tastytrade for $1 billion
Turkmenistan among top three countries in terms of potato imports from Russia
Representatives of Turkish companies arrive in Azerbaijan to support restoration of liberated lands (PHOTOS)
Average downloads speed in Azerbaijan reduce
Google and French publishers sign agreement over copyrights
Visit agenda of Iranian Foreign Minister to Azerbaijan revealed
COVID-19 disrupts supplies of essential goods and food to Uzbekistan
Georgia sees increase in coronavirus cases
Azerbaijan's territorial waters serve to increase country's maritime transport potential
Azerbaijan starts preparation for 'Kharybulbul' festival, Days of Vagif's Poetry in Shusha (PHOTO)
Georgia increases imports of tea from Azerbaijan
Geostat reveals volume of gas imported by Georgia from Azerbaijan
Details of Iran's tractor exports announced
Indo-Japan digital partnership: Co-creation, co-production and co-innovation is the future
India produced COVID-19 vaccines reach Bhutan, Maldives; Sri Lanka, Afghanistan next in line
Serbia may get Azerbaijani gas by 2023
The 'superpower' that led this woman to the top of Twitter's Asia-Pacific business
Uzbekistan’s national bank to fund reconstruction of Termez int’l airport
Kamala Harris' ancestral village rejoices with fervour as 'she scripts history'
Ninety-Two countries post request for Made-in-India vaccines
Iran issues several loans to manufacturing enterprises in Semnan province
Turkmenistan, UNDP to launch new joint project
Trend TV prepares video report on water supply to Karabakh
BP to see sharp fall in upstream capex
Canada to implement drip irrigation project in Uzbekistan
Kazakhstan sees multifold decrease in exports to Singapore
Brexit responsible for food supply problems in N.Ireland
Global oil & gas capex to increase by 6% in 2021
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on January 23
Kazakhstan’s Ulba Metallurgical Plant to buy pies via tender
Turkmenistan, IMF review country's economy sectors positively impacting GDP growth
Construction of small solar power plant starts in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent region
Iranian currency rates for January 21
Azerbaijani FM starts visit to Turkmenistan
Italy-based omnichannel content solutions provider extends co-op with Azerbaijani Topaz
Azerbaijani Balakan ferry repaired and put into operation
JOCAP reveals plans for Absheron gas field in 2021
Kazakhstan’s freight transportation operator opens tender to rent vehicles
Absheron EPS progress: pipe laying in Oil Rocks vicinity kicks off – JOCAP
Azerbaijan to get revenues also from third countries’ gas supplies via Southern Gas Corridor
Azerbaijan's CBA signs contract for purchase of banknote-calculating machines
Iran urges US to return JCPOA
Oil slips on surprise rise in U.S. crude stocks
Population of Azerbaijan continues to grow
Kyrgyzstan plans to approve concept of creative economy
EU leaders convene amid vaccine delays, virus variant fears
California first U.S. state to surpass 3 million COVID-19 cases
China sees rise in new COVID-19 cases despite curbs
EBRD, Turkmenistan to implement new joint projects in 2021
Largest gas refinery in Middle East to be unveiled in SW Iran
UN chief welcomes U.S. re-engagement with WHO
Biden reverses U.S. withdrawal from WHO
Kazakhstan unveils 11M2020 trade value with Turkey
France's daily COVID-19 cases hit two-month high
UK records highest daily coronavirus death toll
Israel registers 9,089 new COVID-19 cases, 574,718 in total
Portugal experiences worst day of COVID-19 pandemic
Iran ready to build Herat-Mazar-i-Sharif railway: Roads min.
Tourism becomes key source of foreign-exchange earnings in Georgia
Georgian domestic exports up 3.5%
Amazon sues EU antitrust regulators for letting Italian case go ahead
Korean logistics company ULP invited to invest in Kyrgyzstan
Turkey reports over 6,400 new coronavirus cases
Kyrgyzstan's Central Election Commission approves election results
UAE signs deal with U.S. to buy 50 F-35 jets and up to 18 drones
WHO chief congratulates Joe Biden and Kamala Harris on their inauguration
Qatar reports 271 new COVID-19 cases, 148,000 in total
Over 40 dead after migrant boat capsizes off Libya: UN agencies
Joe Biden sworn in as 46th President of the United States
Kazakhstan to develop strategies to ensure financial stability in banking sector
Iran’s FM to visit Azerbaijan
COVID-19 vaccinations in Turkey exceed 1 million in 1st week
CBI Governor says part of Iranian frozen assets released
Georgian Parliament calls Pension Agency Head for transparency
Kyrgyzstan receives COVID-19 diagnostic reagents from Russia
Trump leaves Washington, skips incoming president Biden's inauguration
Blast rocks building in downtown Madrid
All news