Oligarchies pose obstacles to Iran’s economic growth

Baku, Azerbaijan, Dec. 21

By Mehrdad Emadi for Trend:

While the recent reports by Central Bank of Iran suggest impressive achievements, many believe that the economy still suffers from deep shortcomings.

The economy is still facing deep rooted problems most of which are caused by internal factors driven by the behavior of “economic oligarchies”.

However, the latest report on growth released by the Central Bank of Iran confirms a rise in the growth rate for the economy. The figure of 7.4 percent is an impressive achievement given than three years ago the economy was shrinking at a rate of around 4.6 percent.

This is certainly not a small feat for Iran especially noting the depressed oil market and the current oil prices which have greatly reduced the foreign revenues of the government from the sale of the crude oil.

Gradual Improvement

The emerging data suggest that the economic conditions have been gradually improving in Iran in the last two years.

However, this does not mean that all sectors in the economy have been experiencing growth. There appears to be a clear dichotomy appearing in the economy. On one hand, we have large strategically significant projects which have been identified as driving leaders for industrialization and strategic poles for technology transfer.

These projects have received capital injection through partnership with outside firms, often global leaders in their field.

I identify these activities as technology-driven export-oriented projects which are guided to become competitive at world prices in the near future.

There is, in fact, supporting data that confirms over 15 percent growth and expansion for this part of the economy.

The spin-off from such projects has been improvements in the demand for the smaller and medium size firms that can be considered as service provider for the core projects.

The growth in this area combined with structured support from the government have facilitated a re-orientation toward export markets and can be confirmed is that for the first time in 56 years, the trade performance of the country is improving showing a surplus in the trade balance while at the same time the share of oil in the economy shows a decline.

This is a historical change suggesting that the political leadership has succeeded in weaning off the economy from oil revenues and instead to guide the economy toward the manufacturing and the production of exportable goods.

This will have important ramifications for the strength of the economy and its ability to stand external shocks or any attempt in the future to impose new trade or investment sanctions upon Iran.

IRGC involvement

At the same time, there is a vector of activities where there seem to be persistent recessionary conditions arising from the falling investment and stagnated activities exacerbated by shrinking demand.

Most notable here are projects which used to receive preferential treatment in the allocation of foreign currency by the government as well as unimpeded imports exempted from the existing import duties and taxes.

The main revenue here has been rooted in “economic rent” from imports and “soft loans” to undertake new projects.

Most notable amongst these have been businesses owned or controlled by entities connected to the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps and their parallel organizations.

The emerging opening of the economy to competition from outside and the insistence of the government to reduce the monopoly power of the oligarchies have reduced the ability of this sector to enjoy access to easy money, i.e. soft loans and credit, and foreign currencies at preferential rates.

In this segment of the economy and all the businesses that used to benefit from serving it, data suggests a stagnated growth and even contraction in new investment.

Furthermore, completing the previously awarded contracts has suffered because suddenly this sector of the economy has had to face hard budget constraints and financial discipline similar to those faced by the privately owned business.

Given the size and reach of the owners of the businesses in the sector, it is understandable that there are concerted efforts to resist the plans of the government to make the economy more competitive and open large projects in key sectors such as oil, gas, petrochemicals, automotive and construction to foreign competition.

Translation of this resistance can be measured through daily and weekly media campaigns by some of the religious quarters who also have seen the emergence of a more competitive and transparent economy unfavorable to their current business interests.

Given the substantial share in the economy, it is my view that government should continue on its current path of pro-competition macro policies whilst at the same time enter a period of consultation with the main actors in this sector with a view of offering them a framework of transition during which those firms that can increase their productivity and reduce wasteful practices can continues doing business competitively.

I think there may be merits in helping this sector since there are many resources at the disposal of firms in this sector that can be employed productively resulting in stable employment at competitive salaries and product prices. We should be reminded of the success of Vietnam and China here.

Wait-and-see” segment of the economy

Finally, there are firms and activities which do not fall into either of the aforementioned categories which have been trapped in what I call the wait-and-see segment of the economy.

These are by large, privately owned businesses with no mentionable political connections whom in my view are the most important long-term actors in economy.

This segment has the potential to become the core of the economy.

However, the managers in this segment are wary of the durability of economic reforms and indicated transparency.

The deeply rooted concerns about the return of oligarchs to take back the control of foreign trade and barter-based trade of the last administration make the managers jittery because of the uncertain future.

Should we see good economic practices started in the last two and half years to continue taking roots and become common practice, I view this segment as the true engine of growth for the Iranian economy.

Through re-orienting their investment and expanding their output capacity, the sustainable employment will come from this part of the economy.

And I also suggest the most impressive performance in increasing exports at competitive prices will be reported by firms that are truly independent of government and other political entities.

Still optimistic

I stay cautiously optimistic on the future of the Iranian economy for the following reasons.

The flow of outside firms interesting in investing in the economy of Iran shows a positive rise whilst at the same time the pressure on business entities owned by the quasi-state entities to adopt more transparent measures has been rising. Just recently the largest telecommunication contract awarded to a firm owned by the Revolutionary Guards was reversed because of a non-payment problem.

I view this as a sign that the political leadership at the most senior level has agreed that the economy in the country needs to become more robust by improving its competitiveness and budgetary discipline.

There seem to be more signs of such a dynamics though we also have signs that certain religious organizations have received special dispensation with regards to tax and duties.

Whilst the figure of 7.4 percent growth may not be supported by the looking at the data from an array of economies activities, there are sectors in the economy that have seen 10-16 percent growth in their activities.

Typical of a state-centered economy like Iran at this stage, for the politically unconnected firms, read the true private sector to experience a 5-plus growth rate, we need to see the continuation of the growth in the super-macro projects and the ripple effects of the growth to the small and medium firms.

I expect in another twelve months, barring a negative shock, we hear a widespread rising activity in the economy.

Mehrdad Emadi is an economic expert and consultant at the UK-based Betamatrix International Consultancy.

Iran hopes Kish-Istanbul-Abadan flights to improve its trade
Iran hopes Kish-Istanbul-Abadan flights to improve its trade
Iran becomes self-sufficient in building oil, gas platforms
Iran becomes self-sufficient in building oil, gas platforms
Iran boosts its pistachio exports
Iran boosts its pistachio exports
Loading Bars
Latest
Italy reports 29,003 new coronavirus cases, 822 deaths - health ministry
Russia's Sputnik V developers call on AstraZeneca to try combining vaccines
Paris does not recognize so-called "Nagorno-Karabakh Republic" - Foreign Ministry
Recovery of oil prices has positive impact on Kazakhstan’s external balances - IHS Markit
Group of German medical experts arrives in Kyrgyzstan to fight COVID-19
Georgian NCDC Head urges people over 70 to stay at home except in necessary circumstances
Iran, Russia to cooperate on COVID-19 vaccine development
Bitcoin price down 12.7%
Armenian eco-terror in Karabakh constitute serious threat to peace and security in region - opinion
Hungary, Poland double down to try to eject rule-of-law condition from EU budget
Over 3,500 coronavirus-related deaths recorded in Moscow in October
Belavia resumes regular flights from Baku to Minsk in early December
Iran hopes Kish-Istanbul-Abadan flights to improve its trade
Kazakhstan Railways opens tender to buy welding equipment
Georgia to support businesses amid new coronavirus restrictions
WB extends deadline for implementation of agricultural project in Azerbaijan
Turkey steps up inspections as coronavirus pandemic figures climb
Cavushoglu and Stoltenberg discuss situation in Karabakh
Swedish royals test positive for COVID-19
England reveals new regional COVID tiers in fight against coronavirus
Azerbaijani gymnasts reach finals of 36th European Championship in Ukraine
Georgia continues to support its citizens amid COVID-19 pandemic
News on return of Azerbaijani soldier captured by Armenians false, relative says
Azerbaijan sends note of protest to France
Ample opportunities for investments to be created in Karabakh – minister
Azerbaijani's negotiations with UAE on renewables nearing completion
Kazakhstan, Mongolia eye signing roadmap for trade, economic co-op
Russia bans import of tomatoes from Uzbekistan’s Fergana region
36th COMCEC session opens under chairmanship of Turkish president (PHOTO)
Uzbek Ministry of Finance publishes draft law on increasing taxes on gasoline, diesel
Russian Gazprombank predicts Azerbaijan's economic recovery in 2021
iPhone 12 Pro Max and iPhone 12 Mini now at Azercell Exclusive shops!
Iran becomes self-sufficient in building oil, gas platforms
Cotton growing in Azerbaijan hits record - agriculture ministry
Italian municipalities adopt documents expressing solidarity with Azerbaijani people
Uzbekistan to grow industrial cannabis in Sardoba district
Azerbaijan detects 3,705 new COVID-19 cases, 1,609 recoveries
Turkmen Ministry of Construction opens tender for equestrian sports complex construction
Azerbaijani, Saudi FMs exchange views on current situation in Karabakh
Uzbekistan reveals data on its ICT sphere enterprises and organizations
Azerbaijan to export persimmons to Slovakia and Czech Republic
Level of religious tolerance in Azerbaijan is much higher than in France - ISESCO ex-director
Kazakhstan's exports to Switzerland decrease year-on-year
Azerbaijani medical insurance agency signs contract with tender-winning IT company
Resolution adopted by French Senate must be canceled – Azerbaijani NGO head
Volume of Turkish textile clothing supplies to Kazakh market surges
Latvian AirBaltic cancels Riga-Tbilisi-Riga flights
Reconnaissance work completed within Baiterek space complex creation in Kazakhstan
Thermal power plant modernization, other projects underway in Kazakhstan's Karaganda
Georgia imposes further restrictions to curb spread of coronavirus
Georgian carrier to launch regular cargo flights from China to Europe
Russia's Rostelecom expects to develop transit routes through Turkmenistan
Average monthly salary in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan rises
Azerbaijani, Afghan FMs discuss latest situation in region
WB, AIIB to fund rural infrastructure development in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani, Indonesian FMs stress importance of trilateral ceasefire statement
Austria fully supports Uzbekistan obtaining of EU’s GSP beneficiary status
Turkmenistan's Dashoguz region opens tender for installation work
France not part of Karabakh settlement, but part of problem - Turkish defense minister
Japanese companies to provide technical support for terry production in Uzbekistan
Germany's hotspot district to launch COVID-19 mass tests for children
Yield of citrus fruits in Azerbaijan up
Capital of Kazakh companies operating in Turkey revealed
Iran boosts its pistachio exports
World Economic Forum announces Azerbaijan's road quality score
Share of assets in Azerbaijani banking sector declines
Kazakhstan eyeing amending legislation to support renewable energy dev't
Georgian Hualing Free Industrial Zone plans to finalize deal with 4 new companies
Mortgage lending in Azerbaijan through state line grows manifold
Kazakhstan to launch hundreds of industrial projects before year-end
Azerbaijani ICT company wins tender on purchase of licenses
Central Bank of Azerbaijan discloses data from foreign exchange auction
Employment in Iran's West Azerbaijan Province increases
Buta Airways to Increase the Frequency of Flights Performed to Izmir
Azerbaijan, Hungary discuss possibilities of attracting investors to liberated territories
Georgian Huliang FIZ offering available land plots to potential investors
Azerbaijani NBCO talks about its activities amid coronavirus
Azerbaijan’s carpet producer signs tender contract
Many members of French Senate unaware war in Karabakh ended (VIDEO)
Number of people infected with coronavirus pandemic in Iran exceeds 900,000
Baku Stock Exchange admits local investment company
Uzbekistan eyes to set up local production of various vaccines
France does not deserve Azerbaijan’s confidence – senator
Bahar Azadi gold coin price still falling in Iran
Bank mortgages in Azerbaijan rise
Full text of Azerbaijani parliament’s statement against French Senate’s resolution
Iran's economy remains strong and steady – Iran's president
Turkmenistan to be vital strategic partner, gas supplier to China long-term - Wood Mackenzie
EDB talks Kazakhstan's economy growth forecast, return to pre-COVID levels
Ambassadors of Turkey, Iran to Azerbaijan hold discusses on Karabakh
“I am quite sure that giving a hand to customers in this challenging time will pay off in the future”: interview with Dariusz Kacprzyk, Member of Supervisory Board of AccessBank Azerbaijan
Import of Turkish ready-made clothes by Iran down
Water resources of Azerbaijan’s Kalbajar district to be re-explored
Turkey's export of ready-made clothes to Uzbekistan down
Money supply in Azerbaijan grows - CBA
Lending to banking sector in Azerbaijan up
Turkmenistan raises 10M2020 imports of Turkish ready-made clothes
Uzbek gas chemical company opens tender for insurance services
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan up
Azerbaijan’s natural gas exports to Turkey down by 8%
All news