China has overestimated its nominal and real growth rates by about 2 full percentage points on average between 2008 to 2016, with the miscalculation increasing each year, according to a new study published on Thursday, Trend reports referring to South China Morning Post.
The results indicate that the actual size of China’s economy at the end of 2018 was well below the government’s official estimate.
It also raises questions not only about the quality of economic data from the world’s second largest economy, but also the willingness of the government to take the steps necessary to accurately report information.
Using the study’s findings and applying them to government figures starting with the level of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) at the end of 2007 and the growth rate for 2008, calculations by the South China Morning Post show that the current nominal size of the Chinese economy is about 18 per cent lower than the official level of 90 trillion yuan (US$13.4 trillion) at the end of 2018.
The calculation assumes that the government’s official 2017 and 2018 nominal growth rates are overestimated by 2 percentage points, as suggested by the study.
Overestimates of growth in 2007 and previous years would further reduce the current size of the Chinese economy.
SCMP calculations show the adjusted nominal GDP level in China is about US$11.5 trillion using current exchange rates, still more than twice the size of Japan’s economy at US$5.16 trillion, but well below the economy of the United States at US$20 trillion.
The paper, “A Forensic Examination of China’s National Account”, was submitted to the “Brookings Papers on Economic Activity”, a journal published by the US-based think tank Brookings Institute twice a year on macroeconomic issues that are influencing the public policy debate. It will be formally presented in Washington on Thursday.
“Our estimates suggest that the extent by which local governments exaggerate local GDP accelerated after 2008, but the magnitude of the adjustment by the NBS did not change in tandem,” the authors said.
The study focuses primarily on nominal, non-inflation adjusted growth.
The paper comes at a sensitive time for Chinese policymakers, who are battling a slowing economy due to their campaign to reduce debt and risky lending as well as the effect of the trade war with the United States. The inflation-adjusted growth rate of 6.6 per cent last year was the slowest since 1990.
The paper’s four authors – Chen Wei, Chen Xilu and Michael Song from the Chinese University of Hong Kong and Chang-Tai Hsieh from the University of Chicago – used a mix of economic indicators that are less likely to have been manipulated by authorities to prove that the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) have not done enough to correct the errors in the data collected from provincial governments over the past decade.
It has long been believed that local Chinese officials inflate figures reflecting their economic performance, which is closely tied to their opportunity for promotion. Since 2003, the NBS has produced a national gross domestic product (GDP) figure that is lower than aggregate provincial data after examining other data such as the census and land sales.
Local statistics bureaus generally overstate industrial output as a portion of overall production as well as the size of investment within overall expenditures, the two different approaches to calculating GDP, according to the paper. The methods of data collection are often the cause, for example, calculations of investment spending have been based purely on government reports on specific projects rather than on the financial statements of the investing firms involved.
One method that the authors used to probe the accuracy of the NBS’s adjustments was comparing the growth of official GDP with the growth of revenue from value-added tax (VAT), which taxes the value added to a product at each stage of production.
Local governments have fewer incentives to manipulate VAT revenue, since a large portion of it is eventually transferred to the central government, therefore overstating VAT would only increase fiscal revenue losses.
The authors found that since 2008, the official growth rate for industry and other sectors exceeded their corresponding VAT growth rate, with the gap widening over the past decade, indicating that the government was overstating official GDP.
In other words, the overstatement of official growth has worsened since 2008 and NBS’s corrections have been increasingly inadequate to offset bottom-up data exaggerations.
A similar conclusion was drawn when the authors examined and adjusted the official GDP growth data with a set of alternative indicators, including satellite images showing lights at night, national tax revenue, electricity consumption, railway cargo traffic, as well as imports and exports that are less likely to be over-reported, although these proxies did not fully capture the growing importance of the service sector in the economy in recent years.
Among all 31 Chinese provinces, Guangdong, Zhejiang, Beijing, and Shanghai appeared to have the highest data quality, based on the economists’ own calculations that were privately confirmed by NBS officials. The worst performing provinces included Tianjin, Liaoning and Inner Mongolia, all of which have been exposed as having exaggerated economic data in recent years.
The economists suggested that the problem is that much of the underlying data needed to project GDP is outside the NBS’s control, even though the agency has been trying hard to collect local data itself. At the same time, the NBS is also in a weak political position to confront local political leaders to demand better data collection.
“Although the NBS adjusts downwards local statistics, it does not report the adjusted local statistics, perhaps out of a desire to not confront powerful local leaders,” the authors said.
Since September, the NBS has named and shamed local governments on its website for manipulating data, but it remains to be seen if local governments fall in line.
In a post in January, the NBS said it had passed 14 cases of data falsification on to local governments before February 2018 but that it had not been updated even though local officials are required by law to punish those responsible for manipulating data within six months after receiving a notice of a violation.
The NBS’s ability to fix China’s GDP data problem is bound by its limited political power, the authors indicated.
“There are three problems with China’s GDP. One is that it doesn’t necessarily measure the right thing. Two is statistical bias in the way data is collected. Three is really a macro policy problem by the government which should write down all the bad debt,” said Michael Pettis, professor of finance at Peking University.
“The NBS is only trying to fix the second problem.”
Latest
-
Turkmenistan's Halkbank experiences surge in bank card issuance
-
Kazakhstan keen to export locally produced cars to Afghanistan
-
Strategic initiatives-driven Turkmenistan boosts use of Turkmenbashi seaport
-
More than 15 thousand people registered for Baku Marathon
-
Turkmenistan and Germany forge stronger trade ties over six-year period
-
Middle Corridor development to boost economic growth in Central Asia
-
Kazakhstan boosts rail freight in China-Russia direction
-
President Ilham Aliyev concludes his working visit to Germany (PHOTO)
-
COP29 organizing committee members meet with Chile's Environment Minister (PHOTO)
-
Heydar Aliyev Foundation and Turkish Zero Waste Foundation sign MoU (PHOTO)
-
Azerbaijani-Kazakh military experts share expertise (PHOTO)
-
Kazakhstan ready to provide support to Turkish investors for implementation of projects- PM
-
Bakcell event full of innovations took place on the Boulevard (PHOTO)
-
Azerbaijan's Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of Nakhchivan announces car tender
-
Transport corridor linking Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan to boost CAREC potential - ADB
-
President Ilham Aliyev, President Frank-Walter Steinmeier hold expanded meeting in Berlin (PHOTO)
-
Uzbekistan's investments from own funds of enterprises, organizations grows
-
Kazakh delegation's visit to Azerbaijan continues (PHOTO)
-
Kyrgyzstan's trade turnover with SPECA countries increases
-
President Ilham Aliyev signs Guest Book at German president's residence
-
President Ilham Aliyev, President Frank-Walter Steinmeier hold one-on-one meeting (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Azerbaijani Institute of Catalysis and Inorganic Chemistry announces IT equipment tender
-
Azerbaijani, Kyrgyz customs services forge co-op on information exchange
-
Azerbaijan, Armenia install 28 border pillars
-
Uzbekistan's trade turnover with China grows in 3M2024
-
Azerbaijani SOCAR, Russian Gazprom discuss cooperation
-
Uzbekistan discloses volume of imported industrial goods
-
Kazakhstan's KazMunayGas plans to drill three new exploration wells in 2024
-
Embassy of India, Baku Showcases Indian Textile Excellence at “Weaving Wonders with Threads of Opportunity” Trade Event (PHOTO)
-
President Ilham Aliyev, UAE industry minister hold meeting in Berlin (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Our performance exceeded training – Azerbaijani gymnast
-
Azerbaijan will continue to be an important partner for Europe for many years to come - President Ilham Aliyev
-
President Ilham Aliyev, German FM hold meeting in Berlin (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Azerbaijan's Azercosmos and Türkiye's Turksat sign commercial agreement
-
Batumi Sea Port reveals volume of supplies of Kazakh ammonium nitrate via Middle Corridor
-
AZAL introduces exclusive airfare deals to Bucharest and Sofia
-
Azerbaijanis organize solidarity rally in Berlin (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Uzbekistan shares volume of investments in 1Q2024
-
We plan to compete in World Acrobatic Gymnastics Championships for top spot - Azerbaijani athletes
-
We must protect our media landscape from external negative influences, just like any other country - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Deposit portfolio volume of individuals and legal entities in Azerbaijan disclosed
-
Tajikistan concerns over denial of its citizens' entry into Russia
-
Residents of Azerbaijan's Lachin city, Zabukh village presented with several professional areas
-
Kyrgyzstan's and Russia's defense ministers sign new agreements
-
Kazakhstan intends to boost exports to Türkiye
-
Kazakhstan, Türkiye sign commercial documents worth millions of dollars
-
COP29 will not be an arena of confrontation - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Kazakhstan, Türkiye outline prospects for threefold boost cargo transportation along TITR
-
Kazakhstan's Astana hosts meeting of SCO defense ministers
-
We highly value ongoing peace negotiations between Azerbaijan and Armenia - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Uzbekistan Airways launches regular flights to Russia's Makhachkala
-
6,000 former IDPs have already returned to their ancestral lands - President Ilham Aliyev
-
There are very good opportunities to achieve peace - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Turkmenistan to host CIS Council of Heads of Government Meeting
-
President Ilham Aliyev expresses his gratitude for Germany's support regarding COP29 in Azerbaijan
-
Recently, Germany-Azerbaijan relations have been experiencing period of rapid development - President Ilham Aliyev
-
President of Tajikistan, Pope Francis discuss strengthening cooperation
-
Azerbaijan's Baku port aims to reduce emissions by 2040
-
We welcome initial demarcation agreements between Azerbaijan, Armenia - Olaf Scholz
-
Germany ready to support Azerbaijan and Armenia on way to peace - German Chancellor
-
Gunashli deepwater production platform shuts down for routine maintenance - bp
-
Energy Commission of European Union sees Azerbaijan as pan-European gas supplier - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Chinese CSCEC keen to invest in transport projects in Kazakhstan
-
AFFA refutes Neftchi's appeal in Azerbaijan
-
Good to see traditional fuel-exporting nations to address climate change - Olaf Scholz
-
Uzbekistan to build new cargo terminal at Tashkent Int'l Airport
-
Every person returning to their native land thanks Azerbaijani Army - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Azerbaijan, supplier of natural gas, will also become supplier of green energy to Europe - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Russia's Caspian ports' cargo turnover grows
-
Border delimitation, demarcation begins between Azerbaijan, Armenia - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Azerbaijan to launch nine wind and solar power plants this year - President Ilham Aliyev
-
COP29 in Baku to focus on debates over several vital issues - German Chancellor
-
German companies keen to co-op on renewable energy projects in Azerbaijan - Olaf Scholz
-
Turkmenistan consults with foreign partners to remake Middle Corridor operations
-
Azerbaijani soccer club's manager meets FC Barcelona president (PHOTO)
-
AFFA Disciplinary Committee issues verdict on Qarabag-Neftchi FCs match
-
President Ilham Aliyev, Chancellor Olaf Scholz make press statements (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Kazakhstan, Russia and China create new transport hub
-
Another group of former IDPs return to homelands in Azerbaijan's Fuzuli
-
Turkish-Russian monitoring center in Azerbaijan contributed to regional peace - MoD
-
Middle corridor to become crucial part of global supply chain in foreseeable future - Chinese analyst
-
President Ilham Aliyev, Chancellor Olaf Scholz hold expanded meeting in Berlin
-
ADB appoints new country director for Kazakhstan
-
Wilhelmsen Port Services, AD Ports Group, Inveco to co-op in developing Middle Corridor
-
Turkmenistan and French Thales discuss cybersecurity cooperation prospects
-
Tajikistan allocates funds for Rogun HPP construction
-
CEO of BISTP shares measures to further benefit from port's potential
-
Energy security should definitely be treated as a matter of national security of countries - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Azerbaijan, Tajikistan moot investments in aluminum industry
-
bp, SOCAR, and TAP delegates in Amsterdam outline plans to grow Azerbaijan's gas exports
-
All these green energy projects I mentioned are financed by foreign investors - President Ilham Aliyev
-
President Ilham Aliyev, Chancellor Olaf Scholz hold one-on-one meeting in Berlin (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Mastercard to set up consulting group in Azerbaijan in 2024
-
Our green agenda started to materialize prior to being awarded COP29 - President Ilham Aliyev
-
A country rich in natural resources, particularly oil and gas, should be at forefront of those addressing issues of climate change - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Azerbaijan Championship and Baku Acrobatic Gymnastics Championship to finalize (PHOTO)
-
Uzbekistan notes growth in trade turnover volume with EAEU countries
-
EU Parliament's resolution unjustified - Azerbaijani MFA
-
COP29 will allow us to engage countries of the Global South - President Ilham Aliyev
-
We do not only need to organize COP29 well but also to deliver good results - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Election of Azerbaijan as COP29 host by unanimous decision is a big honor for us - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Uzbekistan releases data on Asia Alliance bank's revenues via payment terminals
-
Our oil and gas will be needed for many more years including European markets - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Turkish-Russian monitoring center in Azerbaijan adequately coped with its tasks - official
-
As host country of COP29, Azerbaijan is in active phase of preparation - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Process of complete withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Azerbaijan begins - MoD
-
Tajikistan’s Khujand holds potential to become transnational transport hub - ADB
-
Azerbaijan's relations with most European countries developing successfully - President Ilham Aliyev
-
Turkmenistan explores space industry partnership with Airbus
-
Gas supply sources for Hungary in 2024 announced (Exclusive)
-
ADB urges Tajikistan to prioritize green urbanization
-
Azerbaijani Ombudsperson's purview includes protecting intellectual property rights - official
-
Türkiye calculates chemical exports to Iran for 1Q2024
-
Turkmenistan approves standards for construction of cottage-type residential buildings
-
Azerbaijan's historical triumph positively impacts intellectual property - official
-
Main problem of intellectual property lies in ecosystem formation - Chairman of Board
-
Kazakh National Bank, Turkish Central Bank sign MoU
-
President Ilham Aliyev participates in High Level Segment of 15th Petersberg Climate Dialogue (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Masterpass to be integrated into mobile application this year - official
-
Joint Turkish-Russian Monitoring Center in Azerbaijan's Aghdam holds closing ceremony (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
Baku hosts roundtable event on "Intellectual property at present stage"
-
Azerbaijan's rate of tech adoption outpaces global average - Mastercard's CEO
-
Kazakhstan continues rehabilitation project of Uzen, Karamandybas oil fields
-
Mastercard sets goal to enhance digitalization of payments in Azerbaijan
-
China's company to establish car assembly plant in Kyrgyzstan
-
Mastercard outlines main priorities of activity in Azerbaijan for upcoming period
-
Western Azerbaijan Community condemns EU parliament resolution urging to impose sanctions against Azerbaijan
-
Azerbaijani Naval Forces, MES wrap up Wave-2024 joint tactical drills (PHOTO/VIDEO)
-
President Ilham Aliyev expected to attend 15th Petersberg Climate Dialogue
-
Turkmenistan and Georgia seek to expand economic cooperation
-
Azerbaijan takes lead in contactless payments in region - Mastercard
-
Details of potential collaboration between Azerbaijan's SOCAR and Hungarian MOL revealed (Exclusive)
-
Azerbaijan's SOCAR clarifies stance on projects with Israel (Exclusive)
-
Armenian-made explosive substances detected in Azerbaijan's Khojavand district
-
Hungary stands ready to support Azerbaijan in organizing COP29
-
Kyrgyzstan's Manas Int'l Airport announces changes in board leadership
-
Uzbekistan cooperates with French company in modernization of Bukhara oil refinery
-
Kazakhstan reveals planned gas production volume for 2024
-
Azerbaijan identifies new national chess champion
-
Turkmengaz opens tender to buy material and technical resources
-
Azerbaijani referee to officiate Panathinaikos team match
-
Azerbaijan, Hungary set future course for energy cooperation
-
Azerbaijan hails Hungary's participation in multilateral cooperation on Middle Corridor
-
Breaking barriers: Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan reach new milestones
-
Houthis attack MSC Darwin in Gulf of Aden
-
AI effects likely to run unequal within nations – IMF’s Giovanni Melina (Interview) (PHOTO)
-
US, Moldova to develop cooperation in field of gas supplies to Europe
-
Number of residents back to their native lands in Azerbaijan’s Fuzuli (PHOTO)
-
Türkiye counts out volume of cargo received from Italy in 1Q2024
-
Kyrgyzstan, AIIB agree to establish working group for Kambarata-1 HPP project
-
Kyrgyzstan's Naryn regional department opens tender for sports complex construction
-
Iran's non-oil exports to Georgia increase
-
Uzbekistan notes growth in beverages, tobacco imports
-
Azerbaijan publishes banks' ranking by authorized capital volume
-
Azerbaijani government affiliate announces tender for procurement of lubricants
-
Canada imposes sanctions on Iran's defense minister
-
Azerbaijan's ministry announces tender for attraction of repair works
-
Azerbaijani boxing team completes European Championship with two bronze medals
-
Industrial production in Tajikistan's Sughd region goes up
-
Turkmenistan's tourism growth sparks investment opportunities in related sectors - UNWTO (Exclusive)