Europe in Depression?

Europe in Depression?

By Federico Fubini, Azernews

Italian award-winning author and financial columnist. He is the author of Noi siamo la rivoluzione (We are the revolution).

Charles P. Kindleberger, the great economic historian, once noted that the Great Depression was so deep and so long because of "British inability and American unwillingness" to stabilize the system. Among the functions that the great powers failed to perform, a few should ring a bell to European leaders today. Kindleberger singled out their failure to "maintain a market for distress goods" - that is, to keep their domestic markets open to imports from crisis-stricken economies.

Surely history is not repeating itself - at least not in the literal sense. European creditor countries today are not tempted by anything like America's Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which crippled world trade in 1930. Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, and Finland remain committed to the European Union's single market for goods and services (though their national regulators hinder intra-European capital flows).

Still, one cannot help but notice similarities with the 1930's. At the time of the Great Crash, the United States and France were piling up gold as fast as the Weimar Republic was piling up unemployment. Today's northern European countries are running up record current-account surpluses, just as some southern European countries are experiencing Weimar-level unemployment. For Italy, Europe's fourth-largest economy, the current slump is proving to be deeper than the one 80 years ago. Meanwhile, huge savings and potential demand for consumer and capital goods remain locked up next door.

How did this happen? As Kemal Derviş has pointed out, the cumulated current-account surplus of the Scandinavian countries, the Netherlands, Austria, Switzerland, and Germany is now around $500 billion. This dwarfs China's surplus at its mercantilist peak of the mid-2000's, when the G-7 (including Germany) regularly scolded the Chinese for fueling global imbalances.

More striking still, in the now-rebalancing eurozone, many countries' current accounts are trending toward balance (and Ireland has recently moved from deficit to a small surplus). One exception is Germany, whose external position strengthened over the last year, with the surplus rising from 6.2% to 7% of GDP - all the more remarkable in the context of a European recession and a slowing domestic economy.

Indeed, Germany's GDP grew by just 0.9% last year, and is forecast to slow further this year, to 0.6%. Slackening growth, declining private and public debt, and super-low interest rates would suggest loosening up a bit and supporting aggregate demand. Instead, a distorted view of what competitiveness really is (mis)leads politicians to consider large external surpluses an unqualified good and a testament to virtue, whatever the consequences abroad.

The second exception is France. Over the last year, France's external deficit deteriorated further, from a 2.4% to 3.5% of GDP. France now faces zero or negative growth in 2013, and seems to have reached the point at which it must reverse course on competitiveness or risk more trouble ahead.

Unfortunately, this, too, is reminiscent of the 1930's. To paraphrase Kindleberger, French inability and German unwillingness to stabilize the system are contributing to an ever more intractable European crisis.

In this respect, the debate in Brussels concerning the "right" amount of austerity misses the mark; in the same vein, southern European leaders' strategy of blaming German Chancellor Angela Merkel for their own tax increases looks increasingly futile. It is not Germany's fault that Italy and Spain had to tighten their budgets last year. As research by Ray Dalio shows, any country with an average cost of debt far above its nominal GDP growth has little choice but to resort to belt-tightening.

For example, in November 2011, interest rates on Italian sovereign bonds were around 8% all along the curve, even as the government faced refinancing needs totaling nearly 30% of GDP over the following year. Because debt monetization was not an option, austerity had to ensue at that point, regardless of what Merkel - or anyone else - had to say.

This suggests a collective failure by European leaders to frame the response to the crisis properly. Southern European leaders have wasted time and energy asking Merkel for weaker fiscal medicine. Merkel and her allies have invested just as much political capital in resisting such pressure. And the European Council has become a theater for tired repetition of the same old show, performed mostly for domestic audiences, with little attention devoted to the opportunity - once Italy's political stalemate has ended and Germany's upcoming election is over - to re-write the script.

Southern countries, still largely in denial, should accept the need for deeper, competiveness-enhancing reforms. Germany and its allies, for their part, should accept that running high external surpluses is damaging the eurozone and themselves, and that it is time for them to put part of their huge excess savings to work to support growth. The failure of leaders in France, Italy, and Spain to raise this issue more effectively has been a clear shortcoming so far.

Without a pro-growth, pro-reform deal, southern Europe's attempts at deleveraging may result in a politically destabilizing depression. As Mark Twain famously observed, "History doesn't repeat itself. At best, it sometimes rhymes." In Europe's case, the poetry could be very dark

Copyrights: Project Syndicate

Belarusian airlines announces another suspension of flights to Turkmenistan
Belarusian airlines announces another suspension of flights to Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan, Tajikistan postpone flights resumption date
Uzbekistan, Tajikistan postpone flights resumption date
Netherlands removes Georgia from list of safe countries
Netherlands removes Georgia from list of safe countries
Loading Bars
Latest
Central Banks of Iran announces volume of foreign currency put up for sale
Assistant to Azerbaijani President arrives in Barda, Tartar together with diplomatic corps
Foreign exchange reserves of Azerbaijan's CB increase
Ambassador of France in Azerbaijan makes statement on Armenian missile attack on Barda
Industrial production increased in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic
Certain facilities launched in Iran’s water and electricity sectors
Belarusian airlines announces another suspension of flights to Turkmenistan
New York Times prepares article covering Armenian missile attack on Azerbaijani Barda
Eni lowers oil&gas output amid COVID-19, OPEC+ commitments
Azerbaijani General Prosecutor's Office assessing damage to liberated territories
Iran to boosts gas production
Armenia grew narcotic plants in occupied Azerbaijani territories - Ecology Ministry
Debris of missiles fired at Azerbaijani Barda (PHOTO)
Targeting innocent civilians shows that Armenia prefers cruel, hideous methods of warfare - Azerbaijani embassy in US
Equinor sees increase in natural gas sales volumes
Turkmenistan organizes charter flight from Russia’s Tatarstan amid COVID-19
TCCI meeting with special emphasis on 'Supporting Azerbaijan' to be held
Equinor’s liquids, gas production up due to new fields
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale October 31
Military equipment left on battlefield by Armenian Armed Forces (VIDEO)
Progress achieved in upgrading energy system - Int'l Energy Charter Secretary General
Solar panels to be installed on school roofs in Georgia
Artillery fire aimed at civilians is crime against Azerbaijani people, against humanity as whole - International Turkic Culture and Heritage Foundation
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 29
Georgia expects increase in bread prices
Azerbaijani-Turkish unity and strategic alliance have today reached highest level - President Ilham Aliyev
Nokia's third-quarter results miss expectations
President Ilham Aliyev sends congratulatory letter to President Erdogan
Equinor reduces output from Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli block
High-ranking Armenian officers annihilated - Azerbaijan Defense Ministry
ICRC gives statement on Azerbaijani volunteer killed as result of Armenian shelling
Armenia's attacks on civilians discussed during Baku-Istanbul teleconference held be Trend News Agency (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani FM holds phone conversation with British minister
Iran must support to Azerbaijan fully - Iranian MP
War call of Armenian catholicos is beyond church canons - Albanian-Udi community's head
Oil inches up after 5% slide overnight as hurricane shuts U.S. output
Iranian currency rates for October 29
Armenian Armed Forces fired on Azerbaijan's Goranboy, Tartar districts - MoD
IFRC volunteer killed in Barda as result of Armenian shelling - top official
Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan to strengthen co-op by increasing volume of export-import operations
Footage of Gubadli region's Giyasli, Saryyatag villages liberated from occupation unveiled (VIDEO)
SOCAR expected to see 25% haircut to cash
Assistant to Azerbaijani President due in Barda, Tartar together with diplomatic corps
Switzerland supports territorial integrity of Azerbaijan - Switzerland's FM
SOCAR's liquidity to remain manageable, if its operations continue uninterrupted
Phone conversation held between Azerbaijani Foreign Minister, EU High Representative
SOCAR’s assets, exports not to be damaged from Karabakh conflict
SOCAR’s EBITDA expected to decline in 2020
Destroyed military equipment of the Armenian army - LIST
Latest situation at front line on Oct. 29
OSCE PA to observe parliamentary elections in Georgia
New COVID-12 cases rise sharply in Kazakhstan, total exceeded 111,000
EU moves to avoid COVID shortages, ease trade
Supply of potential COVID-19 vaccines to start in earnest in April: EU's von der Leyen
Brazil reports 158,456 COVID-19 deaths
Hurricane Zeta makes landfall in Louisiana
Surge in coronavirus cases set to shake Asian markets
Iraq reports 4,043 new COVID-19 cases, 463,951 in total
5.6-magnitude quake hits 56 km WSW of Changuillo, Peru
France and Germany plunge back into lockdown as second COVID-19 wave sweeps Europe
Iran has condemned occupation of Azerbaijani territories from very beginning - Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister
Iranian-Azerbaijani relations have developed rapidly in recent years - Azerbaijani president
If Armenia does not withdraw from rest of occupied territories of its own free will, we will drive them away from there as well - President Ilham Aliyev
UNICEF makes statement on Karabakh conflict calling on to protect children
Iran is next to people and state of Azerbaijan - special representative of Iranian President
Karabakh conflict must be resolved within territorial integrity of Azerbaijan - Special Representative of Iranian President (EXCLUSIVE)
Armenia should know that no provocation can hinder Azerbaijan on its way to victory - MoD
Pakistani ambassador condemns Armenia's attack against civilians in Azerbaijan's Barda
Manpower of Armenian Armed Forces destroyed (VIDEO)
Management of Azerbaijani Emergency Situation Ministry arrive in Barda
Azerbaijani artillerymen destroying Armenian troops' manpower (VIDEO)
Armenian troops firing at Azerbaijani civilian population destroyed with precise fire (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani FM holds telephone conversations with OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva: Such barbaric attacks show that atrocities of Armenians have no limits (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev receives delegation led by Special Envoy of Iranian President (PHOTO)
Azercell stands by people in Barda!
Pakistan’s National Assembly adopts resolution condemning Armenian aggression
Armenian leadership acts as if it lost its mind - Turkish Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijani FM, US deputy secretary of state hold phone talks
Armenia threatens not only Azerbaijan's energy security - energy minister
Freedom of speech suppression by Armenian lobby in France unacceptable - analyst
Azerbaijan provides footage of Armenian troops, military equipment being destroyed (VIDEO)
Ministry of Emergency Situations staff among civilians killed in Azerbaijan’s Barda
Natural gas supplied to village of Khulo of Georgian Adjara
Turkmen FM takes part in second session of India-Central Asia Dialogue
Children among dead, wounded in Azerbaijan’s Barda due to Armenian terror - chief physician
Armenia responsible for death of Azerbaijani civilians - Turkish presidential administration
Armenians think shelling of cities will force Azerbaijan to end war - Russian expert
Iran unveils volume of loans issued to Golestan Province
Azerbaijan destroys Armenian troops (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan expands list of settlements banned with entry-exit due to COVID-19
'Reporters Without Borders' condemns Armenian online attacks against French TV reporter
SOCAR Turkey may evaluate operational partnership for Aliaga port terminal
Shelling of residential areas in Barda once again exposes Armenia's terrorist nature - MFA
Uzbekistan expects GDP to grow in 2021
State budget of Georgian Adjara to up in 2021
Turkey says export of domestic mining products to Georgia down
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price starts to fall
Missile attack on Barda once again proves terrorist essence of Armenia - Turkish MoD
President Ilham Aliyev: Blood of Barda residents will not remain unavenged, aggressors will be given decent rebuff on battlefield
All news