...

Syria after Assad: from ruins to a new era

Politics Materials 12 December 2024 20:06 (UTC +04:00)
Syria after Assad: from ruins to a new era
Elchin Alioghlu
Elchin Alioghlu
Read more

Bashar al-Assad’s regime didn’t just fall—it imploded, shaking the Middle East to its core. What once seemed like an unbreakable fortress, propped up by decades of brute force and alliances of convenience, collapsed under its own dead weight. Assad’s downfall wasn’t just a political earthquake; it was the eruption of decades-long fault lines that left chaos, destruction, and uncertainty in their wake. Syria, once a regional heavyweight, now stands dazed at the crossroads of history, its future written in sand and blown away by the winds of change.

How the Mighty Fell: Why Assad Collapsed So Quickly

The Assad regime’s fall wasn’t just a stumble; it was a freefall. What makes it more shocking is the speed of its unraveling. At first glance, it’s easy to point fingers at external pressures—Iran and Russia pulling back, exhausted by the spiraling costs of propping up their client state. But the rot ran far deeper.

Syria’s army, once the iron fist of the regime, had turned into a brittle shell after years of war and mass defections. Instead of organized resistance, Assad’s defenders became little more than a disorganized mob in retreat. Meanwhile, the opposition forces—fractured and at each other’s throats for years—managed to forge an uneasy alliance, united by one shared goal: toppling the regime. This coalition, however temporary and volatile, was enough to deal the death blow to Assad’s hollowed-out power structure.

Syria’s Future: A Fractured Map and Bleak Prospects

Syria today is less a nation and more a patchwork of warring fiefdoms, each vying for its own slice of the pie. The vacuum left by Assad’s fall has become a battleground for new players, each seeking to turn chaos into opportunity. But this turbulence has birthed new and ominous threats, casting a long shadow over Syria’s future.

Fragmented Power: Rebel factions like Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and the Syrian National Army (SNA) are more rivals than allies. Their fragile unity was built on a shared hatred of Assad, but now that the common enemy is gone, old grudges and conflicting ambitions threaten to tear them apart.

Radicalization: The extremist groups controlling swaths of Syria’s territory are incubating the next wave of terrorism. Radical ideologies are filling the vacuum, and the risk of Syria becoming a launching pad for regional and global instability is real.

Humanitarian Hellscape: Millions of refugees, cities reduced to rubble, and a devastated economy leave Syria teetering on the edge of a full-blown humanitarian crisis. The world watches with bated breath, but will it step in, or will Syria be left to twist in the wind?

The New Power Players: Turkey and Israel

As the old power brokers—Russia and Iran—find themselves sidelined, Turkey and Israel are stepping up to the plate. Both nations see opportunity in Syria’s collapse, but their playbooks couldn’t be more different.

Turkey: Erdoğan’s Big Gamble
Ankara views the fall of Assad as its moment to rewrite the regional script. Turkey’s goals are ambitious: establish a buffer zone along the border, uproot Kurdish forces, and send millions of Syrian refugees back home. President Erdoğan’s proxy forces, like the SNA, are doing the heavy lifting, but the balancing act is precarious. Ankara is navigating a minefield of regional rivalries, all while trying to keep its domestic house in order.

Israel: Silent and Strategic
For Israel, Assad’s fall is both a challenge and an opportunity. By creating a security zone in the Golan Heights, Tel Aviv has ensured a buffer against potential threats. But Israel’s strategy goes beyond just containment. The Druze communities in southern Syria, wary of Sunni extremists, offer Israel a potential ally in stabilizing the region. As always, Israel prefers to pull the strings from behind the scenes, avoiding direct entanglement while ensuring its enemies remain weak and divided.

Scenarios for Syria: Chaos or Redemption?

What’s next for Syria? The crystal ball is foggy, but a few scenarios are emerging, each as unsettling as the last:

A New Civil War
The fragile alliances among opposition groups are already fraying. Without a unifying goal, Syria risks descending into another round of internecine bloodshed.

Rise of a Radical Regime
Should extremist factions consolidate power, Syria could become Ground Zero for global terrorism, exporting chaos far beyond its borders.

Partition and Fragmentation
The Kurds in the north, Sunnis in the center, and Alawites in the west—all carving out their own territories—could turn Syria into a patchwork of rival fiefdoms, each with its own rules and rulers.

International Intervention
If the threat of terrorism or humanitarian collapse becomes too severe, the global powers might step in. But history has shown that such interventions often create as many problems as they solve.

Syria at the Crossroads: What Lies Ahead?

Syria, free from Assad’s grip, now stands on a precipice. Its path forward will be anything but smooth. The choices made by internal players and the international community in the coming months will determine whether Syria rises from the ashes or sinks deeper into chaos.

For Turkey and Israel, this is a moment to reshape the regional order to their advantage. For Iran and Russia, it’s a bitter lesson in overreach. And for the Syrian people, it’s a test of resilience in the face of unimaginable adversity.

Syria’s past is written in blood, its present in turmoil, and its future hangs in the balance. The Middle East’s shifting sands have rarely been so unpredictable, and the stakes have never been higher. Whether Syria finds redemption or descends into permanent fragmentation will define not only the nation’s destiny but also the balance of power in one of the world’s most volatile regions.

The once-potent “Axis of Resistance,” a linchpin of Iran’s regional aspirations, now lies fractured and ineffective. This coalition—which included Palestinian factions like Hamas and Islamic Jihad, Lebanon’s Hezbollah, Bashar al-Assad’s Syrian regime, pro-Iranian militias in Syria, Iraq’s Popular Mobilization Forces, and Yemen’s Houthis—has been reduced to isolated fragments unable to mount a unified strategy.

Syria, the backbone of this alliance, succumbed to the combined pressures of Israel, Turkey, and the Syrian armed opposition. The severing of the land corridor between Iran and Lebanon, famously known as the “Shia Crescent,” has left Tehran strategically adrift. What was once a cohesive mechanism of Iranian influence is now a shadow of its former self.

Turkish Dominance: Redrawing the Map of Syria

Turkey’s rapid 11-day offensive and its strategic alliances have reshaped Syria’s political landscape beyond recognition. The downfall of Assad’s regime has shifted control of much of Syria, including Damascus, to forces aligned with Ankara. Yet, this newfound influence is far from consolidated, reflecting a blend of Turkish ambition, tactical contradictions, and unresolved rivalries.

The two key factions—Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and the Syrian National Army (SNA)—dominate the post-Assad reality. HTS, headquartered in Idlib, boasts a decentralized yet modern army of 20,000 fighters, known for their autonomous operations and advanced use of drone warfare. While Gulf states have supported HTS financially, its operational strength is largely attributed to Turkey’s strategic backing. Despite this, HTS retains a degree of independence, potentially complicating Ankara’s long-term plans.

In contrast, the SNA operates under direct Turkish oversight, its leaders and operations heavily influenced by Ankara’s military officers. Reports indicate Turkey meticulously coordinated the opposition’s actions months in advance, showcasing its calculated approach to regime change.

Turkey’s Strategic Ambitions

Ankara’s goals in Syria are as ambitious as they are multifaceted. These include:

Establishing a Security Buffer
Turkey aims to create a 25–30 km buffer zone along the entire Syrian border, displacing Kurdish forces affiliated with the PKK (Kurdistan Workers’ Party). Kurdish autonomy, currently spanning 40% of Syria’s territory, represents a significant hurdle to this plan.

Expanding Regional Influence
Turkey sees Aleppo and Mosul as critical nodes in its regional strategy. Reconstruction investments and administrative involvement in Aleppo are poised to solidify Turkish influence in northern Syria.

Repatriating Syrian Refugees
With millions of refugees straining Turkey’s social fabric and becoming a political liability, Ankara prioritizes their return. The collapse of Assad’s regime has removed barriers to repatriation, enabling Turkey to address domestic pressure over this issue.

Managing Allied Rivalries
Preventing conflict between HTS and the SNA remains a critical challenge. Turkey’s ability to mediate these tensions will be key to stabilizing the regions under its influence.

U.S. Roadblocks and Other Obstacles

American military bases in Kurdish-controlled areas serve as a bulwark against Turkish military ambitions. However, a potential U.S. withdrawal—aligned with Donald Trump’s foreign policy leanings—could pave the way for Turkey’s expanded operations. Should this scenario materialize, Ankara is likely to strengthen ties with HTS and the SNA to execute a large-scale campaign against Kurdish forces.

The sudden collapse of Assad’s regime has also introduced challenges for Turkey, from rebuilding war-torn infrastructure to navigating the interests of competing international powers like Russia and Iran. The path forward is fraught with complexities that demand careful maneuvering.

A New Chapter in Syrian History

Syria’s civil war has entered a transformative phase, with Turkey emerging as a central figure. The fall of Assad offers Ankara significant opportunities, but the road ahead is laden with obstacles. Turkey’s ability to manage alliances, address internal and external conflicts, and tackle humanitarian crises will determine whether it succeeds in shaping Syria’s post-Assad trajectory.

This pivotal moment in Syria’s history marks the beginning of a new era in the Middle East. Turkey’s capacity to assert leadership, coupled with Israel’s strategic recalibration, will redefine the balance of power in the region. As Iran and Russia retreat to the sidelines, the unfolding dynamics will test the ambitions and resilience of all key players.

Israel’s Strategy: Securing Its Southern Frontiers

Israel is methodically solidifying its position on the Syrian front. The creation of a security zone along the Golan Heights is not merely a defensive measure—it’s a calculated move to maintain strategic control over the region. With the disintegration of the “Axis of Resistance” and the severing of Hezbollah’s arms supply through Syria, Israel has achieved crucial milestones in its long-standing battle against Iranian influence.

But Israel’s ambitions in Syria extend beyond containing Tehran. The Druze communities in southern Syria, caught between their fears of Sunni extremism and the collapse of Assad’s protective grip, offer an opportunity for Israel. By aligning with these communities, Tel Aviv seeks to expand its influence, counter extremist factions, and bolster its regional security framework.

The Geopolitical Fallout: Winners and Losers

The collapse of Bashar al-Assad’s regime has reshaped the Middle East’s power dynamics. For Iran, it represents a devastating blow. The loss of the Syrian corridor for supplying Hezbollah not only weakens its grip on Lebanon but also undermines its broader regional strategy. Stripped of a crucial ally, Tehran finds itself increasingly isolated in a region where its influence was once robust.

Russia, too, emerges as a loser in this recalibrated order. Moscow’s failure to shield Assad reveals the limitations of its power projection in the Middle East, casting doubt on its reliability as a strategic partner. The fall of Syria as a client state has weakened Russia’s standing in the region, leaving a vacuum that other players are eager to fill.

Among the clear winners are Turkey and Israel. Both nations have seized the opportunities presented by Assad’s downfall to advance their strategic interests. Turkey has asserted itself as a dominant force in northern Syria, while Israel has consolidated its southern front, weakening both Hezbollah and Iran in the process.

Syria’s Fragmentation: A Nation on the Brink

Despite Assad’s departure, Syria remains a fractured and volatile battleground. Rebel factions such as Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and the Syrian National Army (SNA) are locked in a tenuous coexistence. Their unity was forged in opposition to Assad, but with that common enemy gone, old rivalries are beginning to resurface. These internal divisions threaten to ignite a new civil war, plunging Syria into even deeper chaos.

Turkey’s role in this fragmented landscape is pivotal. As the most influential external actor, Ankara has the leverage to coordinate among the various factions under its sway. However, the volatile nature of these alliances means that Turkey’s grip is far from guaranteed. Internal power struggles among its proxies could undermine its ability to shape Syria’s political future.

Israel, meanwhile, is charting a different course. Its strategy focuses on containment rather than direct intervention. By fortifying its borders and ensuring that extremist groups do not gain a foothold near its territory, Israel is prioritizing long-term security over short-term political gains.

The Unwritten Future: Chaos or Redemption?

Syria’s post-Assad era marks a defining moment not only for the nation but for the entire Middle East. The power vacuum left by Assad’s fall has created a volatile environment ripe with both opportunities and dangers. Turkey and Israel have emerged as the key players in this new reality, leveraging their influence to reshape the region to their advantage. Meanwhile, Iran and Russia are relegated to the sidelines, their roles diminished by the rapid shift in power dynamics.

But the road ahead for Syria is fraught with uncertainty. Will the country find a path to recovery, or will it succumb to deeper fragmentation and radicalization? The possibilities are stark:

A New Civil War
The fragile alliances among rebel groups could disintegrate, plunging Syria into a renewed cycle of violence.

Rise of Extremism
If extremist factions consolidate power, Syria risks becoming a global epicenter for terrorism, threatening not only its neighbors but international security.

Partitioned Future
Syria could splinter into autonomous regions—Kurdish-controlled areas in the north, Sunni strongholds in the center, and Alawite enclaves in the west—each governed by its own rules and alliances.

International Intervention
The international community may be forced to intervene if the situation spirals out of control, though past interventions have often exacerbated instability rather than resolving it.

A Region in Flux: What’s at Stake?

The Middle East’s balance of power is shifting dramatically. Syria, once a linchpin of regional politics, is now a battleground for competing visions and interests. For Turkey and Israel, this is a moment of opportunity—a chance to solidify their positions as regional powerbrokers. For Iran and Russia, it’s a bitter reminder of the limits of their influence.

Syria’s fate hangs in the balance. The choices made by its internal factions and external stakeholders will determine whether the nation rises from its ashes or becomes a cautionary tale of a state’s irreversible collapse. The world must watch closely, for what happens in Syria will reverberate far beyond its borders, shaping the future of the Middle East for decades to come.

Latest

Latest