U.S view: Moscow-Tehran relations

U.S view: Moscow-Tehran relations

Trend Commentator Polad Hamidov

In his recently published article about the geopolitics of Russia, Herman Pirchner, well-known U.S. political analyst, head of the Washington Council on U.S. foreign policy fervently outlined the pros and cons of relations between Moscow and Tehran. This publication is not surprising, given that Iran is still considered the main threat to U.S. national security.

Pirchner appreciated Russia's decision, taken after several years of delays, which included the final refusal to sell Iran S-300 medium-range anti-aircraft missile systems. He said that the cancellation of the contract for S-300 sale is associated with the Israeli threat to attack Iran in case such defensive systems were installed.

However, the Russian side, guided by specific motives, justified its refusal to the latest UN sanctions adopted towards Iran. Many people consider the military solution to Iranian nuclear program as unreal. Uzi Rubin, the founder of the Israeli department on anti-missile defense system, spoke about a military solution to Iranian nuclear issue. He stressed that in this case, everything depends on the availability of reliable intelligence data and it cannot be known for sure "what they actually have there," the Israeli expert said in an interview with "Vremya Novostey". This means that an attack on Iran will not be effective if we take into account the world intelligence agencies' incomplete information.

Meanwhile, Rubin regarded the Russian S-300 anti-aircraft missile system as dangerous for the Israeli aviation. The means of its overcoming have not been developed yet because of the system's secrecy.

Perhaps, the canceled contract on supplying S-300 anti-aircraft missile systems to Iran allowed Russia and Israel to reach a consensus on the licensed production of the unmanned aircrafts in Russia, which was signed in the autumn of last year.

Consequently, the Russia-Israel relations, in the sphere of military-technical cooperation, reached a qualitatively new level.


Russians have made at least four arguments in favor of cooperation with Iran:

An accommodation with Iran postpones the day the Islamic republic will use its resources to stir up the Muslim populations of Central Asia, or even worse, Russia proper. The West's continuing problems with Iran reduce America's appetite and capability for playing a role in Ukraine, Georgia and other parts of the former USSR.

From the economic point of view, if a serious crisis occurs with the West, oil prices will go up dramatically - an event that will help Russia. Russia profits from reactor and arms sales.

The counter-arguments, which are ascendant, include:

If Iran gets the nuclear bomb, other unstable and unfriendly Muslim states will also get the bomb. This is dangerous for Russia.

A nuclear Iran will not need cooperation with Russia, and Tehran's most extreme elements will help Russian jihadists. Thus, Russia should help the West stop this problem before it grows.

Hoping for a confrontation between the West and Iran is stupid because the consequences cannot be predicted including the effect on the world economy and midterm oil prices.

As mentioned above, Russia decided to stop the delivery of S-300 systems to Iran. It is telling that this decision was made public following Vladimir Putin's Paris meeting with French President Sarkozy.

It is not a coincidence because Russia and France have agreed on joint production of two helicopter carriers Mistral, which was negotiated during 2010. It deals with building of four ships, a phased transfer of technologies with a gradual transfer of production to Russia.

Russia's refusal from selling Iran S-300 most likely contributed to conclude such agreements with the European country.

Mistral, a large landing helicopter carrier and a ship-docking of the French Navy with capacity of 21,300 tons, is capable of placing roughly 900 paratroopers, 13 tanks, 16 heavy and 35 light helicopters and four landing boats.

It is strange that Pirchner's article, dedicated to Iran, does not reflect U.S. interests, which gives the impression that the United States is completely loyal towards the region. This article describes the vicissitudes of the relationship between the three geopolitical players: Russia, Europe and Iran.

Kalbajar returned to its true owners - Turkish government
Kalbajar returned to its true owners - Turkish government
Fitch withdraws ratings of Yerevan due to incorrect information
Fitch withdraws ratings of Yerevan due to incorrect information
Turkey congratulates Azerbaijani people on returning to native Aghdam
Turkey congratulates Azerbaijani people on returning to native Aghdam
Loading Bars
Latest
Kazakhstan's KazMunayGas forecasts annual oil output decrease
More migrants relocated from Malta to EU countries
U.S. grants ByteDance new seven-day extension of TikTok sale order
82 bandits killed in Nigerian airstrikes
China, Kyrgyzstan to boost pragmatic cooperation
AzerGold CJSC talks plans for extraction of precious metals
Kazakhstan’s Almaty Power Stations JSC opens tender to buy compressors
Volume of funds allocated to fixed capital increases in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan
Retail trade turnover of Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic drops
Azerbaijani MoD unveils footage depicting advancement of Azerbaijani armyuits to liberated Kalbajar region (VIDEO/PHOTO)
Resolution of France's Senate nothing more than piece of paper for Azerbaijan - top official
Resolution adopted by France's Senate has no legal force - MFA
IKEA investment arm in talks to buy city-centre retail property in big European cities
Kazinform and IRNA news agencies hold joint online conference
Iran to compensate for Ukraine plane crash according to int'l norms
Oil tanker hit by blast at Saudi terminal, Saudi Arabia confirms
National Bank of Georgia sells funds at foreign exchange auction to stabilize lari
First Turkish Trade House to open in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijani president signs law renaming Tsakuri village in Khojavend district
Azerbaijani president signs law renaming Gushchubaba village of Khojaly district into Baharli village
Azerbaijan to monitor fields in Kalbajar - Head of National Geological Exploration Service (Exclusive)
EU allocates macro-financial assistance to Georgia to tackle COVID-19
Turkmen FM gives speech at 13th Central Asia-Korea Cooperation Forum
Turkmenistan advocates cooperation in resolving regional and global environmental problems
Azerbaijan confirms 1,229 more COVID-19 recoveries
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale November 28
Austria provides Uzbekistan with railway equipment
U.S. weekly jobless claims increase again
Produce in Georgia agency selects business ideas for micro and small entrepreneurship grant program
Kazakhstan eyes to fully put up produced LPG on electronic trading platforms in 2021
Uzbekistan’s food production to grow by end of 2020
Fergana region becomes main textile producer in Uzbekistan
More countries allow import of Uzbek-grown products
Volume of lending in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan in annual circulation greatly increases
Lari depreciation among possible reasons for fuel price increase in Georgia
Azerbaijan prepares projects to restore road infrastructure in liberated territories
Production of Iran’s Sefid Dasht Steel Company increases
Kazakhstan's Kuryk port boosts cargo handling, launches direct link to Iran
Turkmenistan has sufficient reserves to mitigate effects of pandemic - IMF
Volume of cargo transportation of Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic drops
Kazakhstan to localize production of German agricultural machinery's popular models
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall
Georgian-produced ski equipment to be exported to Europe
Kazakhstan decreases exports to Italy year-on-year
Volume of goods released from Iran’s customs checkpoints announced
Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of instrumentation
Investments in Iran’s Kerman Province increase
Azerbaijani refugees from Kalbajar visit Martyrs Alley (PHOTO)
FM talks on possible Azerbaijan-Armenia peace treaty to French Le Point
Azerbaijan shows new footage of Azerbaijani army units entering Kalbajar (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Armenia must answer for war crimes - Azerbaijani FM
Iran’s South Pars Gas Company opens tender to buy equipment
Uzbekistan eyes to maintain macroeconomic stability in 2021
Volume of loans issued by commercial banks down in Georgia
Cable TV operators ready for full deployment in liberated Azerbaijani territories
Activities of private sector in Iran can put end to economic problems - analyst
Georgia increases export of precious metal ores and concentrates
During Karabakh hostilities, Turkey responded to political pressure exerted on Azerbaijan - ambassador
Oil shrugs off U.S. inventory gain helped by vaccine hopes
Total volume of non-bank deposits in Georgian banking sector down
Return of Kalbajar region to Azerbaijan has not only important political but also economic significance - Georgian expert
Number of bank accounts registered in Nakhchivan over 10M2020 unveiled
Azerbaijan's gold company reveals profits
Two facilities in Iran’s oil sector to be put into operation
Baku residents hold rally celebrating Kalbajar's liberation (PHOTOS)
Georgia reveals data on persimmons and caraway seeds exports
Turkmenistan’s growth model relies on large-scale public investments - IMF
Four dead as migrant boat capsizes off Canary Islands, more missing
Kazakhstan’s joining UPOV could help improve lives, provide for economic dev't
SOCAR reveals volume of transshipment through Kulevi terminal
First VP Mehriban Aliyeva congratulates Azerbaijani people on liberation of Kalbajar (PHOTO)
Cargo handling at Kazakhstan's Aktau seaport decreases over 10M2020
Foreign trade turnover of Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic increases
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for November 25
Life insurance in Azerbaijan occupies about half of all insurance fees - association
SOCAR and LUKOIL eye expanding co-op
Baku Stock Exchange hosts auction for CBA's short-term notes
Concerns of some OSCE MG co-chairing countries don't matter - Erdogan
Kazakhstan boosts passenger cars manufacturing within 10M2020
Turkmen IT company to create first online platform of Union of Industrialists, Entrepreneurs
Azerbaijan to export medical masks to Russia and Germany
UNESCO to take part in protection of cultural, religious heritage in Karabakh
Iran says ready to return to Jan 20, 2017
Iran talks banking obstacles
Azerbaijan disclose data on investments in local renewable energy projects
Iran prevented release of German home appliances from customs
Kazakhstan’s oil producing company opens tender to buy spare equipment parts
Turkmen company provides domestic market with products made of polyethylene
Production of agricultural products increases in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic
Azerbaijani soldiers created conditions for Armenian population to leave village in Aghdam - president
Iran reveals data on new enterprises in free trade zones
Pashinyan, where did you sign the act of capitulation? - President Aliyev
When Pashinyan put forward seven conditions to us, I said: I have only one condition: get out of our land - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan reveals data on GDP
Amount of loans issued for agricultural machinery in Iran spikes
Those who want to accuse us of something should first of all look in mirror - President Aliyev
When we drove enemy out of Shusha, it destroyed water line feeding city - President Aliyev
Global LNG prices expected to strengthen in 2021
Armenians had made maps of “Nagorno-Karabakh Republic”, where are those maps? - President Aliyev
Kazakhstan's 10M2020 import of Turkish leather products declines
All news