Official: ECHR decision on Safarov’s case puts no int'l legal obligations on Azerbaijan

Official: ECHR decision on Safarov’s case puts no int'l legal obligations on Azerbaijan

BAKU, Azerbaijan, May 27

By Huseyn Safarov – Trend:

The decision of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) regarding Ramil Safarov's case does not impose any international legal obligations on Azerbaijan, the country’s Plenipotentiary Representative to the ECHR Chingiz Asgarov told Trend.

He made the remark commenting on the ECHR’s decision on the "Makuchyan and Minasyan v. Azerbaijan and Hungary" case.

Asgarov said that relatives of officers who participated in those events in Budapest filed a complaint in ECHR against Azerbaijan and Hungary.

"Azerbaijani and Hungarian governments participated in this process as defendants. This process has been going on for quite some time, and this decision was expected, because earlier the ECHR adopted key decisions on Articles 2 and 14 of the European Convention, which provide for the right to life and the prohibition of discrimination. In essence, the ECHR made a ruling based on its case law," Asgarov said.

"However, I fundamentally disagree with the interpretation of the decision by Armenia. This has to do with violation of the material aspect of the right to life,” he said.

“In order to assess the ECHR’s decision, the attention should be paid to the particular opinion of Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, the judge representing Portugal in the ECHR. If to consider his particular opinion, it can be seen what Armenia wanted from the ECHR’s decision -- they desired to achieve recognition of the international legal responsibility of Azerbaijan on the issue of the material aspect of the right to life,” Asgarov added.

“The second defendant in the case was Hungary, whose authorities extradited Ramil Safarov to Baku, but the ECHR found no violations in actions of Budapest. In other words, Ramil Safarov was legally extradited by the Hungarian government to Azerbaijan, and Azerbaijan actually accepted him in accordance with the provisions of the European Convention. This is the main thing to consider in the ECHR’s decision," he said.

Asgarov went on to say that the most interesting are the closing comments of the Portuguese judge.

"He believes that justice for the victims will be restored and that this case will be referred to the ECHR’s Grand Chamber and the court will find all the "desired" violations of the European Convention. This particular opinion of the judge cannot be called impartial,” he said.

Asgarov believes it is yet early to talk about the steps to be further taken by Azerbaijan's government.

"The decision was only published on May 26 and Azerbaijan has three months to consider transferring the case to the Grand Chamber, and this decision, from the point of view of general measures, does not impose any obligations on Azerbaijan. There are only individual measures, which mean that Azerbaijan's government will pay the legal fees to the applicants, meaning, the work of their lawyers. No compensation, including for pecuniary nor non-pecuniary damage, is noted in the decision. So for now, it is hard to say if there are any further actions on appealing the decision of the ECHR," he said.

As for any possible involvement of Armenian lobbyists in the case, the ECHR is not as politicized as the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), where Armenians can easily lobby their interests, and where the Armenian lobby is very active.

“On the other hand, I have no idea whether it is the work of the Armenian lobby or the Armenian government, but the applicant is defended by the very people who usually stand on the side of Armenia in complaints against Azerbaijan - the British lawyers. In the future, of course, Armenia will lobby for this decision in order to somehow use it against Azerbaijan in different European political structures. But in any case, this decision does not impose any international legal obligations on Azerbaijan,” he added.

International airport construction in full swing in Turkestan
International airport construction in full swing in Turkestan
Uzbekistan launches production of tank wagons for liquefied gas transportation
Uzbekistan launches production of tank wagons for liquefied gas transportation
Fitch affirms long-term issuer default ratings of Ipoteka-Bank of Uzbekistan
Fitch affirms long-term issuer default ratings of Ipoteka-Bank of Uzbekistan
Loading Bars
Many verified Twitter accounts able to post again after hacking
Majority of respodents believes that Georgian government made adequate and timely measures for prevention of COVID-19
International airport construction in full swing in Turkestan
Brazil registers over 75,000 deaths from COVID-19
Iran, Belarus review ways to further develop agro cooperation
Transport company becomes coronavirus hotspot in Lithuania
Tunisian PM submits resignation after majority party's break with gov't
International Olympic Committee yields $100 million for Olympic movement worldwide
Belgium postpones decision on move to Phase 5 easing of COVID-19 restrictions
German gov't supports steel industry in transition to low-carbon production
Sudan discloses lower Nile water levels, hints GERD gates closure
Pompeo says U.S. to impose visa curbs on Huawei over rights
Turkey discloses number of real estate properties purchased by Iranian citizens
SOCAR plans to send another batch of Azerbaijani oil to Belarus
Turkish company invests in production of copper, aluminium wires in Georgia
Georgia may arrange charter flight to Germany - minister
Subsistence minimum for average household down in Georgia
Bank of Georgia implements new project in hotel business
NATO-Georgia Commission praises reforms carried out in Georgia
New hotel to open in Kazbegi with support from Bank of Georgia
Bank of Georgia launches new program with Hazelnut Growers Association
Azerbaijan's SOCAR boosts natural gas export in 2Q2020
Daughter of Azerbaijan’s Aghdam village resident killed by Armenian armed forces discloses details of his death (PHOTO)
Iran reveals value of trade turnover with Thailand
Gold, silver prices show growth in Azerbaijan
MP: All residents of Tovuz district believe in Azerbaijani army and support it (VIDEO)
Assistant to Azerbaijani president exposes Armenian FM’s lies on live TV broadcast
Uzbekistan launches production of tank wagons for liquefied gas transportation
Share of OPEC crude oil in total global production decreased
Fitch affirms long-term issuer default ratings of Ipoteka-Bank of Uzbekistan
Armenian armed forces shell Azerbaijani village visited by Azerbaijani journalists, MPs
Azerbaijan remains main supplier of electricity to Georgia
Israeli expert: Armenia’s provocation aimed at diverting attention from internal problems
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products for sale July 18
Minister: Textile factory in Georgia's Rustavi to export products
Iran's Railway Company signs contract on purchase of railway transport
French ambassador summoned to Azerbaijan's Foreign Ministry
Pakistani journalist: No peace in Nagorno Karabakh without implementing UN resolutions
Latest Armenian aggression on Azerbaijan - big challenge for world powers, says expert
Citizen of Armenia passes to Azerbaijani Nakhchivan's territory (VIDEO)
U.S. import prices beat expectations in June
EBRD, Bank of Georgia take steps to mitigate coronavirus impact on private sector
Criminal case initiated in Azerbaijan on Armenians shelling of settlement in Gazakh
Georgia sees increase in fish production
Azerbaijani currency rates for July 15
Two largest sugar factories of Uzbekistan cease to operate
Iran discloses value of private sector investment in its ports
WHO supports measures taken by Turkmenistan to prevent COVID-19 outbreak
Georgian TBC to offer better conditions to wineries under Preferential Agro Credit project
Russian group of companies to operate e-document circulation in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani oil prices down
Water and electricity facilities to be commissioned in Iran's Hormozgan Province
Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to grow in Iran
International Islamic Trade Finance Corporation Provides COVID-19 Emergency Food Package Relief Program for Republic of Kyrgyzstan (FOTO)
Money transfers to Georgia up in June 2020
Azerbaijan confirms 559 new COVID-19 cases
Volume of gas pumped into Iran's Shourijeh D gas storage facility grows
Mobile operator of Uzbekistan sums up its activity for 1H2020
Turkmenistan receives medicines from WHO/Europe
Field control point of one of Armenian armed forces’ units destroyed (VIDEO)
Global organizations should intervene to stop Armenia's aggressive behavior - expert
Turkmengas extends tender for in-line diagnostics of gas pipelines
EBRD to allocate loan to Turkmen company for PET preforms production
Azerbaijani army’s attack causes panic in Armenian army (VIDEO)
Assistant to Azerbaijan's president: Armenian side planned provocation in advance, on purpose
President Ilham Aliyev chaired Cabinet meeting on results of socio-economic development in first quarter of 2020 and future tasks (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan plants forest on dried part of Aral Sea
Turkmenistan’s Demiryollary opens tender to purchase spare parts
Pakistani expert: Armenian attack on Azerbaijani civilians - potential threat for peace in region
Demand for Iran's products increases in Russia
Ambassador: Georgian-French joint projects reflect countries' close relations
Uzbekistan to expand bilateral relations with India
OSCE chairperson-in-office concerned about escalation of tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani border
Azerbaijani army destroys Armenian military vehicle with pinpoint strike (VIDEO)
MyWay Airlines brings Georgian citizens back from Barcelona
Azerbaijani president expresses condolences to families of Major General Hashimov and Colonel Mirzayev
SOCAR Ukraine bids for shipment services for Odessa Port Plant
Large increase in grain production expected in Iran
Colliers International: Georgia's Tbilisi real estate market plummets
Turkmenistan's Lebap region ready to supply rice for state purchase
Oil gains after big U.S. drawdown, eyes on OPEC committee meeting
Central Bank of Uzbekistan reveals volume of foreign currency sales
Airbnb says one million nights booked in one day
Hotel business, food sector of Uzbekistan suffer most due to COVID–19
MP: Artillery shell fired by Armenians at Azerbaijan's Dondar Gushchu village didn't explode (VIDEO)
Defense Ministry: Azerbaijani army didn't use Grad system
Georgia reveals volume of exported peaches
Apple wins fight against $15 billion EU tax order
Number COVID-19 cases exceed 1K in Georgia
Renewable energy sector is of particular interest both for Romania, Azerbaijan
Romania eyes to assess opportunities for expanding energy cooperation with Azerbaijan
Romania names viable options for Southern Gas Corridor’s expansion
COVID-19 to have very strong, but short-term impact on oil market
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for July 15
Iran discloses value of exports from Ardabil Province
Demand for Turkish cement falling in Uzbekistan's construction market
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for July 15
COVID-19 crisis, low oil prices to affect trade relations between Finland, Kazakhstan
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry: Another military facility of Armenia destroyed (VIDEO)
NATO-Georgia Commission gives high evaluation to reforms carried out in Georgia - Foreign Ministry
All news