Australians shudder at where wonder economy has gone

Lots of Australians are disobeying Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and keeping rather than spending the money he gives them to boost demand in the economy, dpa reported.

Their behaviour is a rational response to warnings given about a nasty end to 17 consecutive years of economic growth.

"The truth is we are going through the worst financial crisis in our lifetime," Rudd told them when announcing spending of 10.4 billion Australian dollars (6.7 billion US dollars) in October on one-off payments to low-income families, first-time house buyers and pensioners.

Finance Minister Lindsay Tanner bemoans the lack of confidence that prompts people to pay off credit card debt rather than rush to the shops and spend.

But when he warned that "if everybody retreats into their shells, that will make the situation much worse," he stoked the very fears that he sought to allay.

The second stimulus package, worth 42 billion Australian dollars, is through Parliament and the cheques will soon be mailed out. Again, many will chose to save rather than spend. And again, it will be a rational response.

Many will want to get ready for tax increases they see as inevitable. Within the space of 12 months, the government accounts are to move from a surplus of 22 billion Australian dollars to a projected deficit of 22 billion Australian dollars - a debt that has to be paid off either through reduced public services or tax increases.

Liberal leader Malcolm Turnbull, who with his party voted against the latest stimulus package, says people are right to worry about government spending.

"I think their package is too big, I think it's twice as big as we ought to be spending at this moment," he said. "This is a panic move. It's too much money, too much debt, at this time."

Turnbull reckons joining a global recession is not inevitable and talks up Australia's strengths.

The economy is still growing, unemployment is below 5 per cent and the financial services sector is strong. The rate of mortgage foreclosures is minuscule and more than 90 per cent of house owners are paying off their borrowings faster than they need to.

The economy is not the wonder it once was but it's better placed to weather the global downturn than most.

The fear among some is that the massive size of the stimulus packages - about 5 per cent of gross domestic product and likely to put the budget in deficit by 200 billion Australian dollars over the next four years - will itself sap confidence.

"When a package is announced that is disproportionate to the known indicators," says Canberra University economist Milind Sathye, "consumers and businesses may conclude that they don't have the complete picture of the economy, which the government has, and this uncertainty may inhibit the investment and consumption that the package is meant to stimulate."

In contrast, senior International Monetary Fund (IMF) official Ray Brooks lauds the Rudd government for acting early and not being frightened of incurring debt.

"What has been done so far by the authorities has been a very timely policy response that helps cushion the blow," he said. "There will be a budget deficit and that will be appropriate."

Brooks, head of the IMF's Asia Pacific department, said that the fiscal measures were working in tandem with the monetary policies set by the independent Reserve Bank of Australia central bank.

Interest rates were cut by 1 per cent to 3.25 per cent in January - the fifth cut in as many months.

A criticism of Rudd's largesse is that it comes without consideration for other shifts in the economy. Lower petrol prices, the lower cost of servicing debts that comes with interest rate cuts and lower inflation, mean it is very hard to predict trends.

For example, analysts who expected a big fall in employment in January were surprised when jobs were created. And retailers, who had predicted a wipe-out at Christmas, were buoyed by an 8-per-cent increase in sales.

"I think there have been too many recessions predicted that never actually happened," said Carl Emmerson, deputy director of London's Institute for Fiscal Studies. "I think it's probably better to wait until you're sure you are in recession, and that recession requires more action than what you can deliver through cuts in interest rates alone."

The most extreme criticism of pump-priming the economy by supplementing private demand with government money comes from University of New South Wales economics lecturer Neal Stoughton.

He said tax cuts would have been better than hand-outs but that governments everywhere had a poor record of getting value when they spent taxpayer's money.

"If the choice is between doing nothing and doing what they've done, I would probably pick nothing," he said.

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Azerbaijani currency rates for December 7
Azerbaijani currency rates for December 7
VISA supports Azerbaijan in digital banks dev’t
VISA supports Azerbaijan in digital banks dev’t
Azerbaijan discloses plan for strategic for dev’t of agrarian sector on liberated lands
Azerbaijan discloses plan for strategic for dev’t of agrarian sector on liberated lands
Loading Bars
Latest
Uzbekneftegaz obtains industrial gas flow from South Kemachi field
Azerbaijani currency rates for December 7
Putin, Biden will particularly discuss operation of diplomatic missions — Kremlin
VISA supports Azerbaijan in digital banks dev’t
Uzbekistan shares domestic COVID-19 data for December 6
Azerbaijan discloses plan for strategic for dev’t of agrarian sector on liberated lands
Oil extends gains on easing Omicron fears, Iran delay
Azerbaijani MoD expresses condolences to Pakistan regarding military crash victims
India's COVID-19 tally rises to 34,648,383
Talks between Putin and Biden scheduled for 18:00 Moscow Time - White House
Kazakhstan’s AIFC aims to promote Green Investment Principle among financial institutions in Central Asia
Israel reports outbreak of bird flu at southern farm
Death toll from Java volcanic eruption rises to 22
IOC respects US’ decision to boycott upcoming Beijing Olympics
Mixing Pfizer, AstraZ COVID-19 shots with Moderna gives better immune response -UK study
France extends mask mandate in schools, orders nightclubs to close
UN chief names US diplomat Stephanie Williams to run Libya mediation
Iran ready for resultative talks on nuclear deal - top diplomat
Israel reports 10 new cases of Omicron variant
New York mayor plans vaccination mandate for private-sector employers
Russia, India to expand energy cooperation, says statement
IRICA reveals data on Iran’s trade turnover with ECO member states
Raisi: Iran welcomes development of ties with UAE
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan identify priority issues for cooperation
Saakashvili: reconciliation is the best option for everyone
Azerbaijan sends 100,000 vaccines to Burkina Faso
US announces diplomatic boycott of 2022 Beijing Olympics
Azerbaijani FM, US Assistant Secretary of State discuss latest situation in region
Armenia seen that, whole world seen that, no-one been able to stop us - President Ilham Aliyev
Israel lifts tariffs on dairy imports to cut prices
Young grew up who did not see Karabakh, they liberated Karabakh at cost of their lives – President Ilham Aliyev (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani Minister of Youth and Sports talks about appointment of new deputy minister
I tell them to give us date of when Zangazur corridor will be opened - President Ilham Aliyev to Armenia (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan discloses volume of oil exported to Turkey in 10M2021
Azerbaijani deputy defense minister leaves for Moscow
Forecast of Azerbaijani State Oil Fund’s total management costs for 2022 revealed
Turkmenistan approves anti-crisis program for 2022
Volume of cargo shipment via Turkish ports from Morocco for 10M2021 revealed
Ministry shares data on volume of cargo shipment via Turkish ports from Belgium for 10M2021
Volume of cargo shipment via Turkish ports from China for 10M2021 unveiled
Turkey discloses volume of cargo shipment via its ports from Germany for 10M2021
Cost of goods transported via sea up in Azerbaijan
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva visit monument to national leader Heydar Aliyev in Guba (PHOTO/VIDEO)
SOFAZ asset management revenue forecast for 2022 unveiled
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on December 7
Azerbaijan is creating social zone in industrial park of liberated Jabrayil district- ministry
Turkmenistan continues oil prospecting work on Cheleken peninsula
Uzbekistan shares data on import of potatoes in 10M2021
Price indexes of construction, trade sectors at Uzbek stock exchange fall
Galt & Taggart shares data on Georgia’s bonds on London Stock Exchange
Uzbekistan unveils volume of exports and imports
Georgia’s persimmon exports continue to increase
Russia remains main importer of Georgia’s tangerines
Uzbekistan reveals volume of tomato exports for 10M2021
Uzbek Statistics Committee shares data on foreign trade turnover
Kazakhstan’s oil and gas company opens tender to supply electric pump
Turkey discloses volume of cargo shipment via its ports from Albania for 10M2021
Eurostat reveals data on Czechia's import of petroleum oils from Azerbaijan
Vegetable pathogen detected in batch of pepper imported to Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan’s National Bank discloses inflation expectations
Turkmenistan talks demand on local aviation, lighting kerosene among foreign clients
Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences talks demographic indicators of Karabakh, East Zangazur
Kazakhstan talks forecasted growth level of GDP for late 2021
All 6 Israel policymakers voted to keep key rate at 0.1%
Iran reaches increase in load/unloaded operations at Amirabad port
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijan confirms 585 more COVID-19 cases, 944 recoveries
Iran's Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to rise full speed
Eni Turkmenistan Ltd to purchase spare parts for pumps via tender
Azerbaijan talks 4G network coverage in liberated territories
Iran’s Nakhlak Lead Mining Complex boosts production
Kazakh-Chinese bitumen plant opens tender for vehicles rent
Act of amnesty covers 16 foreign citizens in Azerbaijan
Tesla did not want to wait on EU aid - German economy minister
Austrian President swears in Karl Nehammer as new Chancellor
Iran’s CBI general director talks foreign currency exchange activity data
Unemployment in Israel fell sharply in November
Oil and gas production dep’t of Turkmenistan’s Turkmennebit SC exceeds production plan
Volume of natural gas transportation via Serbian-Hungarian interconnector revealed
Field rearranging underway on Serbian-Hungarian gas interconnector route
Iran not to follow 'plan B' while in Vienna nuclear talks - FM
Georgian business sector sees increase in turnover
Kazakh National Bank announces its decision for base rate
Kazakhstan reveals GDP growth in 10M2021
Azerbaijan working on flight recorder of crashed helicopter - Prosecutor General's Office
UK to block poor-performing companies from winning public work
Croatia confirms its first two cases of COVID-19 Omicron variant
Balacans Agro Food LLC, Azerbaijan Investment Company sign agreement (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan to consider joining int'l documents on intellectual property protection
Oil majors to mitigate demand fluctuation with digital twins
SOFAZ sees significant increase in Shah Deniz revenues
Azerbaijan shares data on number of freed convicts as part of act of amnesty
Annual inflation rate slightly slows down in Kazakhstan
SOFAZ discloses revenues from Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli
Azerbaijan shares data on number of people covered by Act of Amnesty so far
TBC Capital publishes Georgia’s weekly economic review
Oil rebounds above $71 on Omicron hopes, Iran talks
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva meet with residents of Gonagkand settlement (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Israeli firm to sell HSBC Tower in New York for $855 million
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for December 6
All news