"There is important point often neglected about IAEA's professional role regarding Iran"

"There is important point often neglected about IAEA's professional role regarding Iran"

Baku, Azerbaijan, March 4

By Saeed Isayev - Trend:

There is an important point that is often neglected in discussions over IAEA's professional role, teaching fellow of the Department of Politics and International Studies of SOAS (University of London), Dr. Shirin Shafaie told Trend.

She was commenting on the question of Iran's ballistic missiles having the design that could be adjusted to carry nuclear warheads.

"The International Atomic Energy Agency's inspection mandate is limited to ensuring the peaceful usage of nuclear material only," she said. "IAEA's objectives and functions are clearly stated in its Statute that is available for the public to review online. The Agency does not have a mandate to probe details of any country's defence establishment or activities."

However, Shafaie said that another important point here is that according to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), Article IV, the Agency is also very much responsible for facilitating the fullest possible exchange of equipment, materials and scientific and technological information for the peaceful uses of nuclear energy to all parties to the Treaty without any discrimination, with special consideration for the needs of the developing areas of the world.

"Unfortunately however, in the case of Iran the IAEA has been reduced to a mere "watchdog" and increasingly expected by the US and Israel (the latter is a nuclear-armed, non-NPT state, without a civilian nuclear energy program) to undertake extra-legal investigations of Iran's defence (i.e. non-nuclear) sites and activities," she said.

"Similarly, linkage of Iran's ballistic missile program to its nuclear energy program is unfounded and cannot be justified under any exiting internal law or treaty, least of all under NPT or the IAEA Statute," she added.

Speaking about Iran not having submitted a detailed report about its heavy-water reactor Arak to IAEA, especially regarding the periods of supplying heavy-water to the reactor, Shafaie said that according to Iranian officials the heavy-water facility in Arak is needed for research purposes and production of radioisotopes that are used for diagnosis of cancer in more than 850,000 Iranian patients.

"The problem is that heavy-water (but also light-water) reactors can also be used to produce plutonium which can then be used to make a bomb - also known as the plutonium route, as compared with the highly enriched uranium," she said.

She went on to add that the Arak heavy-water facility is currently incomplete and not operational.

"Iran has accepted to voluntarily halt the installation of nuclear equipment in this facility for a period of time based on the recent nuclear deal," Shafaie said. "Moreover, Iranian officials have announced that they would be willing to modify the design plans of the reactor at this facility to reduce the amount of plutonium produced there."

"According to experts, there are other options that Iran could consider, with IAEA's assistance, to allay concerns over this particular facility, for example guarantees that there will be no reprocessing plant built in Iran that can extract plutonium from spent fuel, or agreements for shipment of the spent fuel out of the country. It is hoped that these options will be explored in future comprehensive negotiations between P5+1 and Iran but also during technical discussions with the IAEA experts given that the essence of the agreement is not violated by any of the parties involved," she said.

Shafaie told Trend that however there still remains a significant risk to the fulfillment of these plans and success of a comprehensive and permanent nuclear deal with Iran.

"Violation of Iran's "inalienable right to develop research, production and use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes without discrimination" would seriously harm if not fully destroy the success of the Interim Deal. This "inalienable right" is granted to Iran as a Party to the NPT (under Article IV) and is not a favour that the US may or may not decide to give to Iran," she said.

She added that currently negotiations have been successful and constructive because the P5+1 group has not demanded the complete dismantling of Iran's national nuclear energy program.

"However, this agreement will unravel if it becomes clear that the US and its European allies have not been sincere in their public statements that acknowledge Iran's nuclear rights," Shafaie said.

"This has been the case with regard to the Sa'dabad Agreement that was singed between Iran and EU3 (Britain, France and Germany) in 2003 (and The Paris Agreement signed between the same parties in 2004) based on which Iran agreed to sign the IAEA Additional Protocol and carry out its provisions on a voluntary basis and suspend its uranium enrichment activities for an agreed period to build trust."

She noted that in return the Europeans pledged to provide "firm guarantees on nuclear, technological, and economic cooperation and firm commitments on security issues" to Iran.

"These agreements failed because in principle "the West did not want Iran to have an enrichment capability". A European diplomat was quoted to have said that the West gave Iran a beautiful box of chocolate that was nevertheless empty," she said.

"Another historic agreement was reached in May 2010 between Iran, Brazil and Turkey based on which Iran would ship most of its low-enriched uranium abroad in return for nuclear fuel rods for Tehran Research Reactor ("Tehran Declaration"). President Obama had initially fully supported this initiative by writing to the Brazilian and Turkish leaders separately to inform them about the US most positive position on this potential deal," Shafaie noted.

"According to Noam Chomsky, President Obama wrote these letters in support of the deal, "apparently on the assumption that it would fail and provide a propaganda weapon against Iran. When it succeeded, the US was furious, and quickly undermined it by ramming through a Security Council resolution with new sanctions against Iran that were so meaningless that China cheerfully joined at once - recognizing that at most the sanctions would impede Western interests in competing with China for Iran's resources," she said. "Once again, Washington acted forthrightly to ensure that others would not interfere with US control of the region."

"We can only hope that this time the US and its European allies are truly honest about their statements and will respect their obligations based on the most recent nuclear deal (2013-2014). Only then this Interim Deal will have a chance of being turned into a permanent and sustainable agreement," Shafaie concluded.

Iran and the P5+1 held meetings in Vienna in February to work on a comprehensive deal. Iran and the P5+1 (Russia, China, France, Germany, UK and the US) signed an interim deal on Iran's nuclear energy program in Geneva on November 24, 2013. The deal took effect on January 20.

Under the agreement, six major powers agreed to give Iran access to its $4.2 billion in revenues blocked overseas, if the country fulfills the deal's terms, which offer sanctions relief in exchange for steps on curbing the Iranian nuclear program.

Iran and P5+1 aim to continue their talks to reach a final agreement to fully resolve the decade-old dispute over the Islamic Republic's nuclear energy program. The next round of negotiations will begin with a meeting between technical experts from the P5+1 and Iran on March 5.

Zarif terms JCPOA as product of negative-sum to positive-sum transmission
Zarif terms JCPOA as product of negative-sum to positive-sum transmission
US State Dept.: Maximum Pressure Campaign stops $65B in potential Iranian oil revenue
US State Dept.: Maximum Pressure Campaign stops $65B in potential Iranian oil revenue
Iran will pursue peaceful nuclear program with IAEA, deputy FM says
Iran will pursue peaceful nuclear program with IAEA, deputy FM says
Loading Bars
Chinese mainland reports 25 new confirmed COVID-19 cases
Trump calls nuclear disarmament with Russia world’s biggest problem
Container cargo transportation between Kazakhstan and Turkey via Azerbaijan ramps up greatly
Info on 1H2020 cargo shipment via Turkish Mersin port disclosed
Kazakhstan's export of locally-made goods to Czech Republic increases
Agriculture Minister: Georgia may become sizable almond exporter
New COVID-19 cases spotted in Kazakhstan in past day
Brazil reports 52,160 more COVID-19 cases, 1,274 new deaths
UK finance minister weighs delaying autumn budget on 2nd COVID-19 wave
Over 40 injured in street clashes in Beirut - Red Cross
Israel reports 1,871 new COVID-19 cases, 86,593 in total
Rocket hits Green Zone in Iraq's capital
Turkey reports 1,183 new COVID-19 cases, 243,180, in total
Trump surprised Biden picked Kamala Harris as running mate
Iran calls for more regional cooperation against COVID-19
Number of COVID-2019 cases across globe up by over 216,000 in past day — WHO
Boeing 737 MAX cancellations rise, deliveries drop as crises drag on
Germany issues travel warning for Madrid due to coronavirus
Biden picks Kamala Harris as running mate
Africa's confirmed COVID-19 tally pass 1.05 mln as death toll surges to 23,582
Quality certificate of oil equipment in Iran to be issued within 90 days
Death toll from Beirut port blast up to 171
Kazakhstan, Romania boost mutual trade
Permanent container shipping line to be established between Iran, Russia
Georgia to receive macro-financial assistance from EU
Turkey unveils six-month cargo shipment through its Gemlik port
Azerbaijani Cabinet of Ministers amends decision on accepting customers in catering facilities during COVID-19
Facebook removes seven million posts for sharing false information on coronavirus
Israel scrutinizes Russian coronavirus vaccine
UK PM confirms 300-mln-pound funding for hospitals in England
U.S. COVID-19 cases surpass 5.1 mln: Johns Hopkins University
Volumes of 1H2020 dolomite transshipment through Turkish ports disclosed
Georgian ministry reveals volume of exported potatoes
Benzol transshipment via Turkey's ports during 1H2020 disclosed
National Bank of Georgia reveals volume of net profit received by banking sector
Germany, UK to persuade US to temporary lift sanctions against Iran
Cargo transshipment via Turkey's Iskenderun port for six months revealed
Georgian Health Ministry purchases rapid COVID-19 tests
Georgian Tskali Margebeli reveals volume of mineral water to be exported to Japan
AzEduNet seeking to attract investments for transferring schools to optic connection
Georgian olive oil replaces over 20% of imports
Iranian fisheries company interested in exporting their products to Turkmenistan
Russia's Ministry of Agriculture: Russia expands range of exports to Uzbekistan
Switzerland finances digital learning project of Uzbekistan
National Bank of Pakistan cease to operate in Uzbekistan
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products for sale on August 12
Thermal power plant to be commissioned in Iran's Shiraz industrial park
Bentonite transshipment via Turkey's ports in 1H2020 unveiled
Turkey reveals cargo shipment from Ukraine via its ports in 1H2020
Volume of wheat purchased in Iran's Kurdistan Province revealed
Coronavirus patients covered by supplementary insurance in Iran
Ukrtransnafta reveals volume of Azerbaijani oil transportation
Iran discloses number of stations being built in Iran's Shiraz county
Vienna University of Technology has announced admission for the first Master's program in Baku
Price for cars may decline in Iran
General Motors' Dhivya Suryadevara steps down as CFO
Kazakhstan increases oil export, petroleum goods production
Volume of wheat purchased in Iran announced
Return of blocked deposits in closed banks in Azerbaijan to begin in few days
Azerbaijan's Constitutional Court decides in favor of citizens on deposits in closed banks
Sale of Iran's oil bonds to bring profit to buyers
Afghanistan’s activity at Turkmen State Commodity Exchange in July 2020
Кazakhstan Electricity Grid Operating Company to buy construction materials via tender
Demand of Azerbaijani banks at Central Bank's currency auction fully met
Iran to review possible withdrawal from nuclear deal before US elections
Kazakhstan’s freight transportation operator opens tender for equipment maintenance
Iran's oil bonds not profitable during foreign currency crisis
Iran uses domestic nanotechnology to paint coating of airplanes
Insurance sector’s premiums up in Georgia
New inflow of natural gas received at Turkmenistan's Tajibay field
Uzbekistan aims to boost production of cement, construction materials
Iranian economist: Selling oil bonds - win-win deal
Turkish president receives Azerbaijani Foreign, Defense Ministers
Azerbaijan confirms 214 more COVID-19 recoveries
Uzbekistan establishes joint Uzbek-German asphalt production enterprise
Turkmenistan exports large volume of vegetables, fruits to EAEU countries
Iran's Shazand Oil Refining Company reveals amount of fuel produced for ships
Kazakhstan's foreign exchange reserves up month-on-month
Georgian Products Renaissance company expands export of its products
Saudi arabian company to build gas turbine power station in Uzbekistan
Prices of precious metals change in Azerbaijan
Turkmenistan increases tomato exports to EAEU
Georgian citizens arriving in Finland not to undergo compulsory quarantine
Uzbek-Korean JV to buy industrial vacuum cleaners via tender
Kazakhstan's import of Austrian-made goods plummets during COVID-19
Turkey unveils 1H2020 volume of gasoil movement through its ports
Mevlut Cavusoglu: Turkey always next to fraternal Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan's PM holds phone talk with CEO of BP Group
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to rise
Iran talks about details of dairy products export
Volume of gas injected into storages in Azerbaijan disclosed
Turkish Anadolu news agency publishes interview with Azerbaijani MP Sevil Mikayilova on Azerbaijani-Turkish relations
Russia is first to register COVID-19 vaccine worldwide
French privacy watchdog opens preliminary investigation into TikTok
Azerbaijani currency rates for August 11
Demand for coal in Uzbekistan increases
Georgian Partnership Fund to sell its shares in Telasi energy distributor company
Design of upper block for Azerbaijan's Karabakh field being developed
Home purchases in Israel at 10-year peak in June
Iran's Tehran Oil Refining Company to boost its production
All news