Delaware judge says Tesla board must face trial over Musk's mega-pay package

Delaware judge says Tesla board must face trial over Musk's mega-pay package

A Delaware judge ruled on Friday that Tesla Inc’s (TSLA.O) board of directors must defend at a trial Chief Executive Elon Musk’s multibillion dollar pay package, which a shareholder lawsuit said unjustly enriched the head of the electric vehicle company, reports Trend referring to Reuters.

Tesla estimated the 2018 compensation package was worth $2.6 billion when it received stockholder approval in March 2018, although stock analysts at the time said it could be worth up to $70 billion if the company - which has yet to post an annual profit - grew quickly.

The compensation award includes no salary or cash bonus for the Silicon Valley billionaire Musk, but sets rewards based on Tesla’s market value rising to as much as $650 billion over the next decade.

On Friday, Vice Chancellor Joseph Slights of the Delaware Court of Chancery ruled against Tesla’s request to dismiss the lawsuit by shareholder Richard Tornetta at an initial phase in the litigation because of the way the board approved the package.

As a result, the board must now defend against allegations that it breached its fiduciary duty in approving the package, and that the package unfairly enriches Tesla’s CEO. The ruling opens the way for additional discovery into the decision-making process.

Tornetta had asked that the pay package be rescinded and the board of Tesla be overhauled to better protect investors.

The ruling turned on Tesla’s compensation committee, which the company conceded was not independent of Musk, according to Slight’s opinion. Had the package been negotiated by truly independent directors and approved by a majority of shareholders who were unaffiliated with Musk, Slights said he would have dismissed the lawsuit.

“Plaintiff has well pled, however, that the board level review was not divorced from Musk’s influence,” Slights wrote.

Musk’s compensation package passed shareholder approval with about 73 percent of votes cast, excluding votes by Musk and his brother Kimbal. The vote result indicated some, but not all, big investors were prepared to support a large payout at the founder-led company, which has struggled to produce its electric vehicles efficiently and profitably.

At the time, proxy advisory firm Institutional Shareholder Services recommended voting against the compensation, noting that if achieved Musk’s award would surpass anything previously granted to top U.S. executives.

Under the award, which involves stock options that vest in 12 tranches, Tesla’s market value must increase to $100 billion for the first tranche to vest and rise in additional $50 billion increments for the remainder. The package does not require Tesla to hit profitability metrics.

Musk does not hold a majority of the Tesla’s stock, but in a separate case, Slights determined that Musk’s sway over Tesla made him in effect a controller from a legal standpoint. As a controller, the board is subject to a higher standard of legal oversight for decisions it makes regarding its relationship with Musk.

The judge did dismiss Tornetta’s claim that the package amounted to a waste of corporate assets.

Azerbaijan increases import of cars from Turkey
Azerbaijan increases import of cars from Turkey
Azerbaijan Micro-finance Association supports female entrepreneurs affected by COVID-19
Azerbaijan Micro-finance Association supports female entrepreneurs affected by COVID-19
Iran's stock market grows with inflation
Iran's stock market grows with inflation
Loading Bars
Latest
COVID-19 cases in Israel surpass 17,000
WHO reports single-day increase in coronavirus cases by over 116,000
Moscow registers 69 coronavirus-related deaths in past 24 hours
Coronavirus cases surpass 6 mln globally
Spain's daily coronavirus death toll drops to a handful
Two gunmen killed in counterterrorism operation in Ingushetia
Azerbaijan increases import of cars from Turkey
Turkey's daily coronavirus cases remain below 1,000 with 26 new deaths
Italy records 111 new coronavirus deaths, 416 new cases
Azerbaijan discloses number of coronavirus tests
EU urges U.S. to reconsider decision to cut ties with WHO
Britain at a very dangerous moment in the pandemic, health official says
COVID-19 deaths in Netherlands rise by 20
Magnitude-5.4 earthquake rattles southern Philippines
Iranian minister announces number of renewable energy power plants under construction
Azerbaijan Micro-finance Association supports female entrepreneurs affected by COVID-19
2,355 new COVID-19 infections detected in Qatar, total 55,262
Iran's Aghajari Oil & Gas Production Company introduces LBV technology
Azerbaijan confirms 257 new COVID-19 cases
Iran eyes to review gas export contracts
Turkmenistan decreases import of ready-made clothing from Turkey
Iran's stock market grows with inflation
Turkey's export of steel to Uzbekistan down by over half
Iran gov't to transfer shares of 20 companies to Social Security Organization
Data on cargo transshipment through Turkish port of Aliaga disclosed
Kazakhstan reduces import of cars from Turkey
Kazakhstan's import of Turkish defense products heavily down
Japan supports sustainable development of Uzbekistan
Russia’s Asian-Pacific Bank to supply its silver bullion to Kazakhstan
Volume of wheat purchased in Iran's Fars province increases
Cargo deliveries from Georgia to Turkey climb
Kazakhstan's oil extracting company opens tender for equipment overhaul
Revenue of Kazakhstan’s largest oil pipeline company plummets in 1Q2020
Turkish ministry discloses number of oil exploration wells drilled in 2019
Uzbek-Korean JV opens tender for procurement of MTR for pumps
Georgia reports 11 new coronavirus cases
Plane of Kazakhstan's private airline bursts into fire
Kazakhstan's KazTransOil to allocate entire income to pay dividends
Iranian Offshore Oil Company repairs floating processing terminal
Iran's export transportation fees tripled
Iran to sell domestically produced cars via profit-sharing scheme, lottery
Yandex registers as taxpayer in Uzbekistan
Largest in CIS solar plant commissioned in Kazakhstan's Akmola
Georgia ranks third in gas prices
Iran investing heavily in expanding national internet network
Kazakhstan adopts law on imported goods traceability mechanism
Kazakhstan’s uranium fields exploring venture to buy filters via tender
Iran cuts import of electrical goods from Turkey
Azerbaijan Mikro-Kredit NBCO's assets marginally up
Iran spends less foreign currency on car manufacturing
Iran discloses COVID-19 statistics for May 30
Azerbaijan's NBCO faces heavy drop in profit in 2019
Governor of Central Bank of Iran promises to gradually get rid of chronic inflation
Azerbaijan may introduce COVID-19 passport after resuming flights
Rouhani: It is not possible to return to pre-coronavirus conditions soon
Value of foreign trade via customs of Iran's Mazandaran Province increases
Leading Azerbaijani bank reduces payment card fees during COVID-19 pandemic
Azerbaijani oil grows in price
Azerbaijan's Azeltech eyes testing new drones
USAID interested in expanding co-op with Uzbekistan
Cargo transportation from Turkmenistan to Turkey slips
FINСA Azerbaijan NBCO's total assets triple
Turkish ministry bans engineering company from participating in ETI MADEN I.G.M.'s tenders
Iran's Esfahan Oil Refining Company announces savings due to import substitution
First Free Economic Zone of Uzbekistan talks its achievements
Georgian National Bank reveals official exchange rate of lari in April
Iran's Khodro cancels prepayment for its lottery sales
Sales value of National Iranian Copper Industry Company increases
Volume of cargo transshipment from Germany via Turkish ports revealed
Uzbekistan reports rise in coronavirus cases
Share of population under absolute poverty line slightly decreases in Georgia
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 29 times
Iran Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale May 30
Georgia's import of electrical goods from Turkey shrinks
Uzbekistan to construct BMX track
Turkey announces volume of cargo transshipped via its ports from Italy
Iranian airlines to receive coronavirus-related relief loan in June
Cargo transshipment volumes from Belgium via Turkish ports disclosed
Iranian currency rates for May 30
Armenian architect admits: Previously, Armenians didn't live in Yerevan (VIDEO)
Uzbek holding to assemble agricultural machinery in Kazakhstan
Gazprom says price of natural gas for Georgia to remain unchanged
FAO designs projects aimed at overcoming COVID-19 consequences in Azerbaijan
Minneapolis imposes mandatory curfew amid unrest
S. Africa reports record daily increase in COVID-19 cases
China reports four new coronavirus cases for May 29
Hundreds in New York protest over George Floyd's death
Brazilian Economy Ministry predicts greater GDP decline in second quarter
5.2-magnitude quake hits Whitianga of New Zealand
Number of COVID-2019 cases across globe up by over 107,000 in past day
Trump says terminating U.S. relationship with World Health Organization over virus
Brazil sets new record for daily COVID-19 infections
Singapore reports 611 COVID-19 cases
Turkey reports 1,182 COVID-19 cases over past 24 hours
Bulgaria to end quarantine on travel from most of EU
Iraq records highest daily new COVID-19 cases
Azerbaijan expected to resume domestic flights in 10 days
Uzbekistan sharply increases air cargo traffic
Iran Mercantile Exchange to run housing market
Azerbaijan confirms 230 new COVID-19 cases
All news