Tehran Risks Serious International Isolation:  Senior Research Fellow of EU Institute for Security Studies

Dr Walter Posch, Senior Research Fellow, EU Institute for Security Studies

Special for Trend

The EU's engagement with Iran, which actually includes issue like Energy Security and Human Rights also, is for some years now dominated by Iran's nuclear issue. The EU does not deny Iran's right for peaceful nuclear energy, and unlike the US it never aimed at a military solution, however it also made it clear to the Islamic Republic that it sees a nuclear weapons capability of the Islamic Republic as inacceptable. As it is now, several offers have been made to the Islamic Republic (in 2005, 2006 and recently 2008) in which Iran's need for peaceful nuclear energy are addressed. The 2005 offer was basically an EU offer the packages of 2006 and 2008 are offers with the explicit support of the US, Russia and China. In order to start negotiations the international community represented by the P5+1 (the five permanent members of the Security Council plus Germany) represented by the EU's Javier Solana offers a "freeeze for freeze" approach to Iran which means the International community "freezes" its sanctions and IRan its nuclear enrichment. Technicalities of the negotiations aside the main question is that of trust, as the EU High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security policy, Javier Solana has said. Iran's insistence on uranium enrichment, which can be the first step for a weapons programme, raises doubt over the Islamic Republic's further intentions. The question is now how does Teheran react. As it is always with Iranian foreign policy an inward looking nationalist and highly ideological political faction opposes a politically realist one, the latter is largely identified with the reformist camp. Until now Tehran could have it both ways which means it negotiated but at the same time proceeded with its programme. This worked fairly well from the viewpoint of Iranian factionalism as in a certain way the suggested policies of both sides were followed. This time however Tehran has a unique opportunity as the current offer is supported by the P5+1 and the US have indicated they are interested in finding a diplomatic solution for the nuclear crisis. If Tehran rejects now even the freeze for freeze approach, then the international community will have no other means but to proceed with sanctions, which most likely will aim at Iran's financial sector and at certain enterprises related to Iran's power holders. These sanctions may not impress the regime in the short run, because Iranians compare economic hardship caused by sanctions to their experience during the war years. The EU and the P5+1 are not keen in imposing sanctions for the sake of sanctions; rather sanctions are imposed in order to underpin the credibility of the International Community. Therefore they can easily be reverted as soon as there are positive signals from Tehran. This approach has been spearheaded by the EU which took a intermediate position between that of the US (aggression) and the one of Russia and China (appeasement) towards Iran. As things stand now, the EU has achieved quite a lot in sofar as it secured diplomacy and the responsability of the international community to be the only way to deal wiht Iran's nuclear crisis. Today there is even a small chance for a US-Iranian rapprochement (otherwise the US would hardly have participated at the last meeting) which would hardly exist without the diplomatic efforts of the EU's indefatigable Solana. Tehran has always played on disunity and on frictions either between the West (US Europe) and the East (Russia, China, Non-Aligned Movement) or within the EU (E3 against the rest), however the offer from July 2008 and the current set of sanctions are the result of long and complicated negotiations within the Security Council and the EU, therefore EU unity and international solidarity in the positive (when Tehran accepts the offer) and in the negative way (when it rejects it) can be taken for granted. However, the circumstances for applying sanctions have changed. Sanctions are no unilateral EU sanctions but they are imposed by the International community via the security council. Politcally too the envirmont has changed as Teheran cannot count any longer on Russian and Chinese understanding, in fact Beijing and Moscow are increasingly frustrated with Tehran. But even traditional friends like India are cooling. Hence Tehran risks serious international isolation.

The opinion of the author may be not coincide with the opinion of the editorial staff of Trend Agency

Turkmenistan increases gas exports to China
Turkmenistan increases gas exports to China
Global oil consumption to recover another 2.5 mbd
Global oil consumption to recover another 2.5 mbd
Gas sales of Georgian Oil and Gas Corporation down
Gas sales of Georgian Oil and Gas Corporation down
Loading Bars
Dollar exchange rate to Uzbek soum revealed
Turkmenistan increases gas exports to China
Azerbaijani State Service: Many volunteers appeal to participate in battles
Iran talks details of exporting mining materials
Armenian Ambassador: Yerevan working out plans to evacuate population from Karabakh
Azerbaijan confirms 70 more COVID-19 recoveries
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry: Armenian army experiencing lack of food, meds
Number of tractors delivered to farmers in Iran announced
Azerbaijani ethnic communities make joint statement
Azerbaijan increases imports of Italian goods
Armenian artillery units in Agdere direction of front line hit (VIDEO)
Georgian expert: Underestimation of Nagorno-Karabakh issue can lead to most dangerous consequences for Armenia
Global oil consumption to recover another 2.5 mbd
Erdogan: Those who did nothing to solve Karabakh conflict for 30 years, making statements now
Azerbaijani president congratulates president of Germany
Turkmenistan increases imports of wheat flour from EAEU countries
Action in support of Azerbaijan in Georgia (PHOTOS)
Ukrainian MP: Imposing sanctions may force Armenia to return Azerbaijan's occupied lands
Turkey unveils data on cargo runs via its ports from Greece
Iran discloses volume of cargo loaded, unloaded at Shahid Rajaee port
Demand for inexpensive roofing building materials up in Uzbekistan
Armenia discloses number of killed servicemen
Azerbaijan declares partial military mobilization
EU calls on all players in region to avoid interfering in situation in Nagorno Karabakh
Azerbaijan's actions on Nagorno-Karabakh conflict comply with int'l law - Kazakh expert
Islamic Corporation for Dev't eyeing deals under PPP mode in CIS
Number of people infected with coronavirus (COVID-19) in Iran reaches 450,000
Turkish defense minister: Armenia must immediately withdraw its armed forces from Azerbaijani lands
Russian Security Council’s deputy chairman calls for political and diplomatic settlement of Karabakh conflict
Data on cargo movement from Ukraine via ports of Turkey revealed
Georgia exports large volume of wine to Turkmenistan
Azerbaijani major general: We'll fight until final victory
Georgia reveals total volume of water exports to Turkmenistan
Bulgaria’s ex-president: Armenia’s attack on Azerbaijan is provocation ignoring law
Azerbaijani defense ministry: Armenian military command staff orders to use weapons against its soldiers
Activities of Iran’s Imam Khomeini ports declared
Azerbaijani schoolchildren killed as a result of Armenia's attack - ministry
Armenia's shelling of Tartar District court in Azerbaijan results in civilian casualties
FM: Azerbaijan informed int'l organizations about another Armenian provocation
Iran reveals volume of cargo loaded, unloaded at Khorramshahr port
Uzbekistan considers reduction of import duties on textile products
ADB funds Uzbek power sector improvement
Net foreign investment in capital decrease in Uzbekistan amid COVID-19
Uzbekistan, Tajikistan to consider resuming flights
Volume of cargo loaded and unloaded via Iran’s Abadan port revealed
Azerbaijani Defense Ministry: Two more tanks of Armenian armed forces destroyed (VIDEO)
Volumes of Russia's cargo transshipment via Turkish ports announced
Volume of cargo loaded and unloaded via Iran's Arak railway increases
ICD exploring opportunities for collaboration in Azerbaijan during pandemic and after (INTERVIEW)
Hikmat Hajiyev: Armenian side spreads misinformation on social networks
Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry discloses number of civilian casualties
Azerbaijan: Bodies of mercs from Middle East among losses of Armenian army
Prosecutor General's Office: Resident of Aghdam killed as result of Armenian shelling
Foreign military attachés, representatives of int'l organizations informed on situation at front line (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan calls on Azerbaijan and Armenia to stop hostilities
Shuttle trade in Uzbekistan suspended due to COVID-19
Georgia's external public debt up
Iran Khodro boosts car manufacturing
Khazar Consortium opens tender for purchase of materials, equipment
Azerbaijan's Defense Ministry: There're mercenaries of Armenian origin from Syria, Middle East among destroyed Armenian armed forces
Assistant to Azerbaijan’s president: Azerbaijan acts within the international law as opposed to Armenia
Gas sales of Georgian Oil and Gas Corporation down
Russian Foreign Ministry calls for utmost restraint over situation in Nagorno Karabakh
Gold, silver prices decline in Azerbaijan
Protest condemning Armenia's provocations against Azerbaijan held in Istanbul
Assistant to Azerbaijani president: Some int'l organizations showing biased position
Generation of Iran's Bandar Abbas TPP disclosed
Assistant to Azerbaijan's President: Police department, town for IDPs in Tartar shelled
US hopes to expand co-op with Turkmenistan through different dialogues
Heydar Aliyev International Airport to temporarily operate in limited mode
Turkey unveils data on cargo shipment via its ports from Saudi Arabia
COVID-19 cases exceed 5000 in Georgia
Jean-Francois Mansel: Clashes between Armenia, Azerbaijan - result of int'l community's passivity
Azerbaijani army continues operations to liberate occupied lands
Value of Iran's exports via Mehran customs announced
Azerbaijan's Agro Service lowers fertilizer prices
Former Czech PM: it is great challenge for int’l community to bring peaceful solution to Karabakh conflict
Cargo handling volumes from Israel through Turkish ports unveiled
Georgia to increase snail exports
Federation Council praises further dev't of Russian-Turkmen inter-parliamentary dialogue
China ready to make efforts to further develop bilateral partnership with Turkmenistan
Russian bank to open representative office in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office taking steps that Armenian servicemen punished within int'l law
French president makes phone call to President Ilham Aliyev
Assistant to President of Azerbaijan gives interview to Al Jazeera Media Network in connection with latest provocations of Armenia (VIDEO)
Weekly review of Azerbaijani oil market
Iran declares volume of sugar beet to be produced
National Iranian Copper Industries Company boosts its sales
Volume of cargo transshipment from Japan through Turkish ports revealed
Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu: Armenian aggression against Azerbaijan is clear violation of int’l law
Former Bosnian foreign minister: Ignoring UN resolutions on Nagorno Karabakh threatening global peace
UN must stop Armenia's military provocations - Lebanese lawyer
Azerbaijani currency rates for Sept. 28
Deputy PM: Heroic Azerbaijani army continues its victorious advance
ARETI inform Turkmenistan about promotion of number of joint projects
Iranian currency rates for September 28
Italian senators condemn Armenia's provocation against Azerbaijan
Russian analyst: Rocket-artillery strike on civilian population of Azerbaijan logically reflects essence of fascist regime in Armenia
High grounds around Azerbaijani Talysh village cleared of Armenian armed forces (VIDEO)
Iran discloses amount of loans issued to tea farmers
All news