UPS liable for shipping contraband cigarettes in New York, damages reduced

UPS liable for shipping contraband cigarettes in New York, damages reduced

A federal appeals court found United Parcel Service Inc liable to New York state and New York City for shipping hundreds of thousands of cartons of untaxed cigarettes, but reduced its payout for damages and unpaid taxes to about $97.6 million from $247 million, Trend with reference to Reuters reports.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan agreed with a trial judge that UPS violated a federal anti-cigarette trafficking law and New York’s public health law by shipping the contraband cigarettes, which often came from Indian reservations.

In a 115-page decision, Circuit Judge Gerard Lynch wrote that UPS also violated its October 2005 Assurance of Discontinuance with the state not to ship cigarettes to consumers and unlicensed dealers, and that shielding it from liability “would thwart the AOD’s purpose.”

But the court also said the trial judge imposed excessive civil penalties, and should not have halved what Atlanta-based UPS owed for unpaid state and local excise taxes.

Civil penalties were lowered to $78.8 million from $237.6 million, while the tax payout doubled to $18.8 million from $9.4 million. New York state would receive about $58.8 million overall, and New York City about $38.8 million.

The vote was 2-1. The dissenting judge, Circuit Judge Dennis Jacobs, would have set aside more of the payout. New York state and New York City originally sought more than $872 million.

UPS said in a statement that it may appeal, but was pleased that the “unwarranted damages” award was reduced significantly.

James Johnson, New York City’s corporation counsel, in a statement said the decision was a “big win” for New Yorkers, and “sent a powerful message to companies: Do not illegally transport untaxed cigarettes; it will cost you.”

The office of New York Attorney General Letitia James did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

State and city officials had accused UPS of having since 2010 shipped more than 683,000 cartons of untaxed “contraband” cigarettes to unlicensed wholesalers, unlicensed retailers and residences, often from smoke shops on Indian reservations.

Both sides had appealed from parts of the May 2017 award by U.S. District Judge Katherine Forrest, which followed a non-jury trial. Forrest is now in private practice.

In January, UPS rival FedEx Corp agreed to pay $35.4 million to settle three lawsuits by New York state and New York City over the shipment of untaxed cigarettes.

The case is State of New York et al v United Parcel Service Inc, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Nos. 17-1993, 17-2107, 17-2111.

Tajikistan official confirms the death of 19  citizens in the recent border clashes
Tajikistan official confirms the death of 19 citizens in the recent border clashes
Kyrgyzstan is interested in establishing joint Kyrgyz-Korean enterprises
Kyrgyzstan is interested in establishing joint Kyrgyz-Korean enterprises
Kazakhstan's president decides to provide humanitarian aid to Kyrgyzstan
Kazakhstan's president decides to provide humanitarian aid to Kyrgyzstan
Loading Bars
Latest
Baku hosts opening ceremony of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup (PHOTO)
Former serviceman accused of treason and espionage in Armenia
Azerbaijan plans to withdraw its peacekeepers from Afghanistan – Defense ministry
India grants permission for 5G trials to telecom service providers
Armenian side does not fulfill obligations upon int’l humanitarian law – MFA
Japan pledges $50.3 million to help India combat COVID-19
Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan developing analogy of Schengen visa for Silk Road countries
Azerbaijan forming perspective industrial complex
Azerbaijan - important int’l transport hub - chairman of Azerbaijan Railways CJSC (PHOTO)
ADB to no longer finance coal mining, oil, and natural gas field exploration
Successful policy on development of sports in Azerbaijan bearing fruit - Deputy Sports Minister
All gymnasts provided with necessary time to train for Rhythmic Gymnastics FIG World Cup in Baku - Greek gymnast
Germany says production capacity, not patents, key to upping vaccine output
Saudi to make COVID-19 vaccinations mandatory for all workers
Georgia shares data on number of citizen registered for temporary employment in Germany and Israel
Uzbekneftegaz increases natural gas output at field of Gazli oil and gas production dep’t
Uzbekistan to increase copper sulfate exports to Poland
Several investment projects to be implemented in Kazakhstan's Zhambyl in 2021
Iran continues to strengthen ties with China, Russia
Winners of ‘Sustainable Development in Chemistry and Chemical Engineering’ conference awarded (PHOTO)
Very exciting to perform in Rhythmic Gymnastics FIG World Cup in Baku - Polish gymnast
Global Affairs Canada welcomes release of Armenian detainees by Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan's SME Dev't Agency holds training for female entrepreneurs (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani PulPal payment system receives purchase offer
Georgia begins renovating buildings and infrastructure in Gardabani
Azerbaijan eyes to launch WeChat payment solution
Azerbaijan's Central Bank unveils results of tender launched to support database platform
SOCAR’s Petkim reveals profit in Q1 2021
S.Korea to set up training center for advanced technologies of fruit, vegetable production in Uzbekistan
Oil prices set for weekly gain despite India virus surge
Azerbaijan boosts steel imports from Turkey
No 'Indian' strain of COVID-19 detected in Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan-China Pipeline LLP opens tender on repairs of pipelines
Uzbekistan, Ireland consider establishing co-op in tourism sector
Egyptian gymnast talks AGF's organization of World Cup in Baku
Nuvei acquires Israeli fintech co Simplex for $250m
SOCAR’s Petkim increases production capacity to 92%
Kazakhstan decreases imports of Belgium-made goods
Thailand expects up to 20 mln doses of Pfizer vaccine from July
Kazakhstan's inflation rate for April 2021 revealed
Shusha declared cultural capital of Azerbaijan - presidential order
Number of ships received at Turkish Gemlik port in 1Q2021 revealed
Putin instructs government to support international Arctic expedition
Kazakhstan’s Nostrum identifies measures to add to PDP reserves
Azerbaijan’s renewable energy path: ongoing and future projects
Georgia reports 1,547 new cases of coronavirus for May 7
Uzbekistan eyes attracting Singaporean companies for co-op in electrical industry
Turkey ratifies agreement on international combined transport of goods with Georgia
Kazakhstan boosts trade with Spain
Latest prices for Azerbaijani oil announced
Wide opportunities opening for TRACECA to implement major projects (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan establishes uninterrupted water supply to liberated Hadrut village
Construction of new main water pipeline to Shusha begins in Azerbaijan
Gold, silver prices increase in Azerbaijan
Size of hydrogen aircraft market by 2040 disclosed
Czech companies interested in implementing green energy projects in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani Ro-Pax type ferry on its first voyage, en route to Kuryk port (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan’s freight transportation operator opens tender to test wheelsets
Countries Need To Assist India In Its Battle Against Second Wave Of Covid: Deloitte CEO
Cement adhesive and dry mortar mixes plant in Georgia expands with state support
WTO Patent Waiver Will Enable Timely Access Of Covid Vaccines: India
Russia promises to show its best at Expo 2020 in Dubai
Friendship between India and UAE increasing as their allies continues in pandemic
UK PM Johnson's party win election for parliament seat
First day of Rhythmic Gymnastics World Cup kicks off in Baku (PHOTO)
India taking steps for economy growth
Multilateral Response Is Critical To Overcome Pandemic In India, Globally: IMF
Indian defence organisations engaged in mitigating people’s sufferings amid Covid surge
India, EU likely to resume FTA talks stalled for 8 years
Bank of Israel bought $5.27b foreign currency in April
EURO 2020 Trophy presented to Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for May 7
Azerbaijan, TRACECA discuss regional opportunities of post-Karabakh conflict period
Azerbaijani currency rates for May 7
Organization of Azerbaijani Veterans appeals to Russian FM
IFC interested in supporting Azerbaijan’s energy transition
IFC supported Azerbaijan’s private sector with around $850 million, says director
IFC to engage in formulating new WB Partnership Framework for Azerbaijan - Director
Tesla tells regulator that full self-driving cars may not be achieved by year-end
India's daily COVID-19 cases rise by record 414,188
Azerbaijani president pays constant attention to work in liberated lands - administration (PHOTO)
Germany's exports up 2.6 pct in april
Brazil's COVID-19 cases surpass 15 million
Turkmenistan offers business opportunities for Swiss private sector in number of areas
Progress has been made in lifting JCPOA related sanctions - Head of Iranian President's office
Turkey, Brazil and US remain main exporters of poultry meat to Georgia
Turkey's central bank leaves key policy rate unchanged at 19%
Tajikistan official confirms the death of 19 citizens in the recent border clashes
GM posts strong performance in Q1
Bundestag approves easing of COVID-19 rules for immunized people
Diamond demand in China directly benefits Botswana: De Beers
U.S. weekly jobless claims drop to 498,000, marking new low during pandemic
WHO says COVID-19 vaccine supply hitches could reignite upticks in Africa
Food prices continue to climb in April - FAO
Turkey reports over 22 388 COVID-19 cases
At least 23 killed in Rio de Janeiro favela gun battle
Kyrgyzstan is interested in establishing joint Kyrgyz-Korean enterprises
Turkey's 1Q2021 revenues from car export to int'l market grow
We reject, don't recognize decision of Latvian gov't on so-called "Armenian genocide" - Turkish Defense Ministry
Georgia launches campaign to popularize state agricultural insurance program
All news