Caspian Energy Grid - Transition through Gas?

Caspian Energy Grid - Transition through Gas?

By Chris Cook

As Sheikh Ahmed Zaki Yamani, perhaps the wisest Saudi oil minister of recent times, memorably put it, the Stone Age did not end because the world ran out of stones, and the Oil Age is not ending because the world is running out of oil.

The US now has the capacity, whenever the oil price rises over (say) $80 per barrel, to rapidly ramp up shale oil production, and this capacity, which has made the US a 'swing producer' of high cost oil has profound geopolitical repercussions.

Former US President Lyndon Johnson brutally said about his long-serving FBI chief J Edgar Hoover (who knew where all Johnson's skeletons were buried) he would rather have Hoover "inside the tent peeing out, than outside the tent peeing in". President Obama's new found energy security frees the US from a historic reliance on Saudi oil which dates back to the Second World War, and means that the Saudis are effectively no longer inside the US tent peeing in, and are now about to be outside the tent pissing out.

The other consequence of oil prices over $80/barrel for five years was the rapid growth of the US renewable energy industry, and of new - 'smart' - technologies aimed at reducing carbon fuel use particularly in road transport. This combination of new high cost production with reduced consumption demonstrates the truth of another astute Yamani observation that "Nothing cures high prices like high prices".

Markets at a Crossroads

International Oil Company market participants like Exxon, BP and Shell now stand at a market crossroads. To the left, as related above, they now see an effective cap on carbon fuel prices: to the right they see the costs of new exploration and development rising inexorably. When I was last in Baku, the head of exploration of a global oil major active in the Caspian Sea made it quite clear that his company regarded the resulting squeeze on profits as unsustainable. Indeed his company has since then taken drastic action, as he predicted it would, to change its business model.

The recently announced merger between the gas-focused Shell and BG aims for survival through achieving economies of scale. But in my view this equates to moving the deckchairs on a 'Titanic' holed below the waterline: oil & gas market trends mean a fundamental and transformational change is inevitable.

So what exactly do these giant companies see when they look forward? The simple answer is Iran and Iraq. The reason why the US and Iran are coming to an accommodation is that the US has finally and belatedly recognised that Iran is no more a fundamentalist seventh century desert theocracy today than China is communist. In other words, US oil corporations can see temptingly before them the low hanging fruits not only of Iran's ageing (but still massive) fields and reserves, but also the enormous reserves of Iraq, where Iran exercises what is essentially a veto over foreign adventurism.

That is to say, that no one will develop Iraqi oil on any scale without Iran's implicit consent. Moreover, the US is in a hurry, because Germany, France & Italy - to name but three - are all over Iran like a rash, and the principal factor holding them back is the difficulty in getting paid via the US dollar clearing system.

Dead Sea Fruit

Unfortunately for the US & EU, this apparently low hanging fruit is in fact Dead Sea Fruit which turns to ashes in the mouth. Iranians are beginning to realise that they do not necessarily need to buy what the US and the EU are selling. Why exactly would they ramp up production and depress $ oil & gas prices further? Why exchange valuable oil for dollars or Euros when so-called risk free dollar assets such as US T-Bills are not risk free if the dollar loses value against other currencies or commodities? And why invest dollar proceeds in T-Bills yielding zero % per annum or Euros in the desperately dysfunctional Euro system: interest rates in Germany are now negative out to 10 years?

There is of course an exchange to be made, but it is not dollars or Euros in exchange for oil and gas. It is the exchange of the value of US & EU technology, knowledge and knowhow for the value of oil and gas production, and particularly for the value of carbon fuel savings.

Indeed, carbon fuel savings are a 'game changer' Why prospect for increasingly costly oil and gas production when you can prospect for oil & gas savings? For every litre of gasoline or diesel saved at the pump, there are probably three to five litres of crude oil to be saved at the well. For every Kilo Watt Hour energy equivalent of heat or cooling delivered in the home, perhaps up to 10 Kilo Watt Hours energy equivalent will be saved of natural gas at the well once the current disastrously inefficient generation and distribution using legacy energy infrastructure is taken into account.

The well travelled conventional oil and gas road is to sell oil and gas as a commodity in order to maximise dollar profits. But of course this road does not lead to carbon fuel savings, because neither oil and gas producers nor middlemen have any interest in reducing demand for their production or sales and therefore their profits.

But there is another oil & gas road: a Road Less Travelled.

Resource Resilience

As reported in Trend, Azizollah Ramazani, the Chairman of Iran's NIGEC and the member of the NIGC board responsible for international affairs, made an important speech in Ashgabat in December at a UN sponsored Energy Charter event on the subject of Reliable and Stable Transit of Energy.

Ramazani had been expected to join Russia's delegate in resisting the Trans Caspian transit of gas for 'environmental' reasons (for which we may perhaps cynically read commercial reasons of competition). However, instead of such a negative position, Ramazani's intervention opened up a very interesting and constructive approach.

Firstly, he suggested that the rational principle to apply in creating the necessary regional Caspian energy transit infrastructure is that of 'least carbon fuel cost', which he explained was simply the principle that for a given use of heat/cooling; electricity and motive power, the use of carbon fuel should be minimised.

While this label of least carbon fuel cost is new, the actual principle has been successfully applied by Denmark for some 40 years. Indeed no-one present in Ashgabat disagreed with the principle, since it is self evident that the more expensive carbon fuel becomes, the more economic sense it makes for a country to save it, and moreover to achieve thereby national energy security, energy independence and resource resilience.

Caspian Energy Grid

Ramazani went on to suggest that the architecture of a least carbon fuel cost Caspian Energy Grid - ie future Caspian energy generation and distribution infrastructure - might be based upon state of the art Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) gas to power hubs operating at more than 60% efficiency, with a similar network of efficient High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) Trans Caspian electricity connections.

So rather than exporting natural gas, and being perceived to be in competition with other gas producers, Turkmenistan might perhaps be better advised to generate electricity from their natural gas and export that regionally?

From the perspective of other Caspian gas producers such as Russia, Iran, Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan the domestic use of such efficiently generated Turkmen power would free more natural gas for export. As I observed at the time, not even the Caspian Sea's economically recoverable gas reserves will last for ever, and such an HVDC Caspian Sea Supergrid will then be available to balance regional flows of renewably generated electricity.

A Road Less Travelled

Of course, such a Caspian Energy Grid - and a new Eurasian Energy Grid to which it would be integral - requires literally $ trillions to finance development and to fund long term operations. This requires new and consensual Caspian legal framework agreements for energy co-operation and energy credit instruments. These must enable conflicting interests to be reconciled not only between Caspian nations with diverging interests, but between competing corporations, and in the conflicted public/private relationship between nations and corporations.

In the course of my research and development work in this field of legal and financial structures and instruments, I have established that not only do such agreements and instruments exist, but that they have always existed and indeed pre-date the financial instruments and public and private institutions with which we are familiar.

The Iranian oil & gas expert, Mr Mahmood Khaghani, who has immense experience of oil & gas generally and Caspian oil and gas in particular, outlined at the recent Athens Energy Forum a crucial element. He pointed out that oil and gas may easily be the subject of energy swaps. These include geographic swaps, such as Caspian crude oil for Persian Gulf crude oil and the gas to power swap - the exchange of a flow of gas for a flow of power generated from that gas. Mr Khaghani was instrumental in just such agreements during his career.

There is also the potential for oil/product swaps, where a flow of crude oil is exchanged for a flow of rights to oil products. I observe that the result is that through the use of swaps, oil and gas need no longer be bought and sold as a commodity: instead oil & gas may effectively be supplied as a service.

Such a switch from the sale of oil and gas as a commodity to supply of oil and gas as a service does not in itself provide a complete financial solution, since an oil producer may have no need for all of the oil products to which he is entitled or a gas producer may find his power entitlements exceed his needs. This is where I observe that the prepay credit instrument now re-emerging in use is crucial in the way that refiners may issue prepay credits returnable in payment for oil products and power generators may issue prepay credits returnable in payment for electricity. This combination of energy swaps and prepay energy credits enables new energy production to be financed and funded in a simple but effective way.

So perhaps new Caspian energy markets with an obvious pricing point at Baku, and operating within a Caspian Energy Clearing Union framework agreement, may be the Road Less Travelled down which the oil & gas industry may now advance?

I look forward to once more making Mr Khaghani and Dr Ramazani's acquaintance and to discussing this question with them and with other eminent experts who will gather at the South Caspian Energy & Petroleum Summit in Vienna on 14th/15th April.

Chris Cook's exclusive article for Trend. Cook is a former director of the International Petroleum Exchange. He is now a strategic market consultant, entrepreneur and commentator.

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
President Erdogan talks bilateral relations with Crown Prince of UAE
President Erdogan talks bilateral relations with Crown Prince of UAE
Qatar Airways to launch flights to Uzbekistan from Jan 17, 2022
Qatar Airways to launch flights to Uzbekistan from Jan 17, 2022
Saudi Arabia reports first Omicron case coming from north Africa
Saudi Arabia reports first Omicron case coming from north Africa
Loading Bars
Moderna exec says company could have Omicron booster ready in March
UN says international migration rose last year despite Covid-19 impact
Kyrgyz border service reports shots from Tajikistan
Bennett declares ‘Yamam’ Israel’s national counterterrorism force
Transport infrastructure in Karabakh to turn Azerbaijan into logistics hub between Central Asia and Europe – CAERC
Four injured after old WWII aircraft bomb explodes in Munich - police
1st US case of COVID-19 omicron variant identified - Fauci
OPEC can elect new secretary general in January 2022 — source
President Erdogan talks bilateral relations with Crown Prince of UAE
Georgia to receive special PCR tests to detect new Omicron variant of coronavirus
Qatar Airways to launch flights to Uzbekistan from Jan 17, 2022
Iran military clashes with armed men on Afghan border
Armenia found itself in complete military-political isolation even within CSTO - Russian military expert
Net foreign assets in Azerbaijan grow for 10M2021
New geopolitical situation in region opens way for Azerbaijan’s further development - ambassador
Ambassador of Kazakhstan expresses condolences to Azerbaijan due to helicopter crash
Azerbaijan working on reconstruction railway line which is part of Zangazur corridor (PHOTO)
SOCAR’s STAR refinery tests numerous types of crude oil
Azerbaijan considering sending medical workers of Baku clinics to district hospitals
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijan confirms 1,795 more COVID-19 cases, 1,967 recoveries
Azerbaijani National Depository Center opens tender to buy new generation security system
Georgia boosts honey exports
Solar PV growth to surpass wind in EU in 2021-2026
Servicemen injured in Azerbaijani helicopter crash talk about incident (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Turkmen company exports paper products to Uzbekistan, Turkey
Iranian companies express readiness to restore factories in Syria - minister
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in Sweden
President Ilham Aliyev receives EU Special Representative for South Caucasus (PHOTO/VIDEO)
US Marshall Legacy Institute sends eight more mine detection dogs to Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds
Azerbaijani agency shares data for mine detection, clearing work in liberated territories
Central Bank of Azerbaijan opens tender to insure fixed assets
Azerbaijan’s 10M2021 oil exports to Spain revealed
Uzbek Statistics Committee shares data on volume of retail trade turnover
Georgian medics advise reconsidering COVID-19 passports issuance
Overview of Uzbekistan's volume of wholesale trade turnover dynamics between 2010-2020
Price indexes of construction, trade sectors at Uzbek stock exchange fall
Georgia, IMF discuss new co-op program
Prices for goods and services in consumer market of Uzbekistan rise
Turkey’s diesel fuel exports to Georgia down
Georgia, NATO discuss further co-op and Black Sea security
Iran bans import of musical instruments due to lack of foreign exchange resources
Turkmen ministry prolongs tender for supply of metal blanks
IRENEX shares data on sales of Tabriz Oil Refining Company
Activities in Iran’s Imam Khomeini port down
Star Refinery satisfies about quarter of Turkey's refined petroleum product needs - CEO
Kazakhstan’s oil and gas company opens tender to supply fittings
Mobile phones rank first in Iran’s total imports - IRICA
Turkmenistan’s education ministry extends tender for setting drip irrigation system
Oil minister tells president, parliament that Iran's oil exports 'significantly grow'
Azerbaijan, Pakistan talk prospects for development of military co-op (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan's SOCAR Polymer exports increase over 10M2021
Iran unveils volume of dates export
Iran’s CBI reveals data on balance of bank loans
EU to exceed current renewable capacity plans for 2030
Azerbaijan reveals oil exports to Italy in 10M2021
Azerbaijan shares data on oil export to Croatia in 10M2021
Baku Metro provides ‘November 8’ station with backup power supply (Exclusive) (PHOTO)
Renewable electricity generation to exceed average annual growth rate of 2015-2020
Expansion of bioenergy for power capacity to slow down
Renewable energy capacity to expand by 2026, says IEA
Azerbaijan talks ongoing work to provide electricity to liberated Lachin district
Special representative of Azerbaijan's President in liberated territories within Karabakh economic region appointed
German Ambassador expresses condolences to Azerbaijan over deadly helicopter crash
Iran, Syria sign four cooperation agreements
Iran to invest in Syrian industrial towns
Austria extends COVID-19 lockdown by 10 days
Branch of Azerbaijan’s Balakhani Operating Company opens tender to buy pipes, pumps
Baku electric company opens tender to buy materials for lamp posts repair
Organization of social zone of Aghdam Industrial Park completes in Azerbaijan – minister
Deputy Prime Ministers of Azerbaijan, Armenia and Russia to meet in Moscow today
Azerbaijan’s Azerishig opens tender for reconstruction of substation in Sumgayit
Kazakhstan increases trade with India over 9M2021
Nar continues to grow IT professionals (PHOTO)
India provides medical, humanitarian aid to over 150 countries to deal with COVID-19: MEA
Georgia receives COVID-19 support grant from German Development Bank
Turkey-Azerbaijan trade turnover grows in October 2021
Kazakhstan reports increase in maritime transport volumes
SOCAR Petroleum to open new petrol station in Azerbaijan’s Gubadli district
SOCAR Georgia Gas increases gas tariffs
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for December 1
Azerbaijan discloses data on oil exports to Israel
Georgian cities receive EU grant for cultural development
Saudi Arabia reports first Omicron case coming from north Africa
Georgian FM expresses condolences for lives lost in crash of military helicopter
PMO records increase in cargo movements in Iranian ports
Turkey’s BOTAS increases gas imports
Hungary launches Stipendium Hungaricum scholarship programm
Russia working out celebration program for 30th anniversary of ties with Azerbaijan - MFA
Burial ceremony of Azerbaijani helicopter crash victims held in second Alley of Martyrs (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgian Embassy expresses condolences to Azerbaijan on helicopter crash
Iran to prepare budget bill with highest economic growth estimates - President Raisi
Construction and installation work under completion at Azerbaijan’s Khojasan metro station (PHOTO)
Dynamics of OPEC+ production in 2021-2023
Share of Iranian government in earnings from crude oil exports to decrease – Official
Some try to use helicopter crash for political purposes - Azerbaijan's prosecutor general (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan lost comrades - head of Azerbaijani State Border Service on helicopter crash
Azerbaijan sees increase in local payments of foreigners via bank cards
Azerishig OJSC reveals work done to supply power to Azerbaijan’ Kalbajar
All news