Experts have different opinions on Turkey's future after referendum

Experts have different opinions on Turkey's future after referendum

Azerbaijan, Baku, September 24 / Trend U. Sadikhova /

The referendum on amending the constitution held two weeks ago in Turkey will play a decisive role in determining the future political course of the country. If a majority of experts estimate the referendum as a positive step, some of them consider this as a threat to Turkey's transformation into a religious state.

"The referendum may be a dress rehearsal for the parliamentary elections next year: It will lend momentum to Erdogan's attempt to entrench his leadership while moving Turkey away from Ataturk's vision of secularism and modernization," the Heritage Foundations leading expert on Eurasia, Russia, Ariel Cohen, wrote in his article.

The referendum was, as Berhan Simsek of the opposition CHP party said, "a poisonous pill coated with chocolate"-a reference to the manner in which the dangerous changes in the judicial system were wrapped with innocuous amendments, he said.

However, the Director of Research and Development at the Institute for Near East and Gulf Military Analysis (INEGMA) Theodore Karasik has another opinion.

"When it comes to the internal political situation, the government stubbornly moves forward in the direction which it thinks useful. That is why the Justice and Development Party is gathering its strength," - said to Trend Karasik, Director of Research and Development of Military Analysis Institute for Near East and Gulf (INEGMA), Karasik said.

A package of amendments, which includes 26 articles of the Turkish Constitution of 1982 and approved by 58 percent of the voters, provides for the reform of the justice system, in particular the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Council of Judges and Prosecutors, as well as institute legal proceedings against the military by civilian courts, the transfer of authority for the dissolution of political parties from the Court of Appeal to the Parliament. Moreover, the country will set up an institute of ombudsman. The possibility of a military elite to intervene in the civil and political matters greatly reduced.

However, these actions were taken to weakene separation of powers and checks and balances, and further defanged the army-the two traditional pillars of secularism ever since Mustafa Kemal Ataturk founded modern Turkey in 1923.

The Turkish army had the right to overthrow the country's government until the referendum, if it assumed that the secular values of Mustafa Kemal were under threat, as a coup in 1980. Afterwards, the current Constitution was adopted.

"For example, four of the amendments increase the number of Supreme Court judges and place their selection in the hands of the parliamentary majority-currently, the AKP. Another article would expand the membership of the Supreme Council of Judges and Prosecutors from 12 to 22, with the government and president playing a greater role in their appointments.

As a result, the Prime Minister brought his long-time foe, the judiciary, under his party's political control," Cohen said.

The courts have repeatedly tried to remove Erdogan's Justice and Development party from the power, suspecting it of the radical religious ideas. The Turkish Constitutional Court almost banned the activity of the party in 2008, which heads the government for eight years.
"By concentrating power in the hands of the AKP's top leadership-Prime Minister Erdogan and President Abdullah Gul-the AKP has damaged the innate balance of Turkish democracy. Turkey is now on a trajectory to become a one-party, Islamist state," Cohen said.

Turkish MP from the opposition Nationalist Movement Party (NMP) Shenol Bal believes that the consequences of the referendum could be even worse than turning into a religious state. "The referendum is a step towards dictatorship. In order to amend the constitution after the elections in 2011, the ruling party resorted to the referendum. The package of constitutional amendments was approved via false propaganda and a long political game," Bal told Trend in a telephone conversation.
She said this referendum is backed by the U.S., which welcomed its outcomes, because in case of change of the constitution, something can happen in Turkey. "

"The government destroys the old values. Through the referendum, they were able to take control over the General Staff and the Constitutional Court," said the MP.

However, member of Trend Expert Council Karasik believes the state is going to use military in what it is intended to do oppose having be a potential force that irrupts and crushes the state.

"They are doing this referendum killing any possibility of the military coup because of the history of coups. There is strategic interest in what the military can be applied," said Karasik.

According to Karasik, the trappings of Islamic appearance are on purpose clearly because that is the part of historical legacy. "The idea that Turkey's destiny to return to the greatness that it was learning from the mistakes from the past, how the economy is preceding, they are able to do more things in much more active way," said the analyst.

Turkish MP from the ruling Justice and Development Party Abdurrahman Kurt believes that the idea of possible Islamisation of Turkey after the referendum is mainly spread by Islamophobia, which is afraid of strengthening of the Muslim states.

"After AKP came to power, the number of believers in the country has grown, and therefore, many believed that Turkey is becoming a religious state. But on the contrary, Turkey got closer to Europe and its democratic values," Kurt told Trend in a telephone conversation.

The process of changing the articles of the Constitution is a requirement for Turkey in accession to the European Union, talks about which have been continuing for several years, said the MP.

"If the society is religious, this does not mean that the country is not democratic. Constitutional referendum is an important step towards the democratization of Turkey for EU accession," said Kurt.
Speaking about the future of the military in Turkey after the referendum, Kurt noted that the Turkish government wants the army to do what it should do, as it happens in European countries and the USA.
"Europe expects from Turkey a lot of progress in democracy, the formation of which is still ongoing. We do not copy the EU and the U.S., but we take the best for the development of freedom of expression and minority rights," he added.

Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall in Iran
Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall in Iran
Azerbaijani business entities modernize digital financial services amid COVID-19 pandemic
Azerbaijani business entities modernize digital financial services amid COVID-19 pandemic
Lending to Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic increases
Lending to Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic increases
Loading Bars
Number of severely ill COVID-19 patients drops in Turkey
Economy Minister of Georgia speaks of need to discuss ways for attracting Covid-vaccinated tourists
Kazakhstan’s coronavirus cases exceed 180,000
Green growth and digital economy - Spain’s two main economic priorities in Georgia
Ireland to extend its highest COVID-19 restrictions until March 5
Kazakhstan's GDP decreases as of 2020 less than global decline - National Bank
UK coronavirus-related deaths top 100,000
Israel reports 7,889 new COVID-19 cases, 613,286 in total
New coronavirus cases rise in France, third national lockdown feared
Anglo Asian Mining plc to pay out dividends for 2020
Uzbekistan cancels number of restrictions introduced to counter spread of COVID-19
Volume of overdue loans up in Georgia
Kazakhstan Development Bank eyes supporting several modernization projects in 2021
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on January 27
Azerbaijan International Telecom company signs contract to buy software
In upward revision, IMF sees Turkey growing at 6% in 2021
Kyrgyzstan's Institute of Business Ombudsman, Economy Ministry sign memorandum of cooperation
Georgian Foreign Minister tests positive for Covid-19
Iran's foreign trade balance hits $59 billion in 10 months
Cities, villages to be established in liberated areas should be based on concept of “smart-city”, “smart-village" - President of Azerbaijan
War has shown many what Azerbaijan's potential is - President Aliyev
Internet in Azerbaijan is free – there is no censorship, no restrictions - President Aliyev
Reforms going on everywhere, reforms are inevitable, country faces new challenges - President of Azerbaijan
Government agencies, ministries and state-owned companies must follow my instructions to end - President Aliyev
We must always build our policy in such way that Azerbaijan's military potential and defense capabilities are always at high level - President Aliyev
We must create conditions for our talented young people to work in Azerbaijan - President Aliyev
When we launched satellites into orbit, some people asked why this was necessary - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan plays central role in region in field of communications and high technologies - President Aliyev
Heydar Aliyev International Airport in Baku is five-star airport - President of Azerbaijan
PACE rejects Armenia’s request on progress of monitoring procedure
We have largest fleet in Caspian Sea - President of Azerbaijan
As result of measures taken, Azerbaijan today is one of world's leading countries in field of transport - President Aliyev
Russia's Charge d'Affaires in Azerbaijan summoned to Azerbaijani MFA
Azerbaijan's Ecology Ministry talks development of entrepreneurship
FAO to start developing agriculture in liberated Azerbaijani lands soon
Demining of Azerbaijan's liberated lands continues (VIDEO)
Russia to directly participate in efforts to unblock economic, transport ties in S. Caucasus - Lavrov
Economy minister discloses share of non-oil sector in Azerbaijan's GDP
Azerbaijan starts preparation work on laying gas lines to liberated lands
Azerbaijan shows footage from Gubadly district's Damirchilar village (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Iran welcomes interaction with Saudi Arabia
Iran can increase oil and gas extraction - National Iranian Oil Company
Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall in Iran
Oxford Institute for Energy Research names ways to improve oil, gas sector in Turkmenistan
Azerbaijani, Turkish FMs discuss regional co-op issues
Bulk of Kazakhstan’s imports of green vegetables falls on Uzbekistan
Georgia sees decline in COVID-19 cases since imposing restrictions
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan plan to start construction of high-speed railroad
Ukrainian air company returns on Georgia's aviation market
Ministry discloses number of mines neutralized by Azerbaijani, Russian sappers in Karabakh (VIDEO)
Uzbekistan’s GDP per capita down in 2020
Oxford Institute for Energy Research talks options for Turkmen gas sector's development
Uzbekneftegaz reveals number of investment projects on increasing production efficiency
Kazakhstan’s QAZAQ AIR airline launching flights on one more route
Georgian aviation plant working on creation of military drone
Uzbek-Korean JV announces tender for installation and assembly services
GGF deepens its engagement with Georgian financial institutions
Number of passengers using railway transport in Azerbaijan increasing after eased quarantine
Kazakhstan to continue decreasing import dependence in food industry
Azerbaijani business entities modernize digital financial services amid COVID-19 pandemic
Lending to Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic increases
Iranian trucks start cargo transportation to Azerbaijan without transshipment
Azerbaijan confirms 551 more COVID-19 recoveries
Kazakhstan taking targeted measures to enhance investment competitiveness
Iran and Russia sign memorandum of cooperation on cybersecurity
Azerbaijan reveals volume of electricity generation from renewable energy sources in 2020
Russia and Iran open to discuss Karabakh issue
Number of bank accounts in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan increased in 2020
Microsoft earnings in spotlight for signs of business recovery, Xbox growth
French engineering company involved in replacing Uzbekistan’s standards in electricity field
UNDP implements new grant program in Georgia
Azerbaijan's former minister of transport appointed to new position - Decree
Company of Turkmenistan’s SC announces volume of oil produced last year
Iran's South Pars gas production increases
Johnson & Johnson promises vaccine data "soon"
Azerbaijan discloses number of servicemen of engineering troops martyred in second Karabakh war
Kazakhstan to continue work on fishing industry development
Iran plans to use domestic ship building capacities
Iranian minister suggests parliament merge Energy and Oil Ministries into one
Azerbaijani delegation to participate in Iran Plast exhibition in Tehran
Clearing of mines, unexploded ordnance continuing in Azerbaijan's liberated Fuzuli district (PHOTO/VİDEO)
Iran's Rouhani opposes any changes to budget bill
"Great Responsibility" At Republic Day Parade: Bangladesh Contingent Chief
Direct air routes between Cambodia, India on the cards
`Vaccine Maitri' helps strengthen bilateral ties with Myanmar, says Indian envoy
COVID-19 vaccine developer CureVac plans five million share sale
EU exec to propose vaccine export registration by end of week
Azerbaijani ministry talks on nanotechnological innovations
Meeting of the Foreign Ministers of Russia and Iran being held
Rates for some excisable goods increasing in Azerbaijan
All tobacco products may be included in list of excisable goods in Azerbaijan
Tax exemptions on wheat imports, sales may be extended in Azerbaijan
Colonel talks restored and built roads in liberated lands of Azerbaijan
FIG cancels holding Artistic Gymnastics World Cup in Azerbaijan’s Baku
Thousands of hectares of cultivatable lands demined in Azerbaijan's liberated districts
Azerbaijani banks buy more foreign currency at CBA's auction
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 26
Sale of gold, silver in Azerbaijan may become tax-free
Azerbaijan Airlines increases flights number on Baku-Nakhchivan route
Access Bank eyes creating bank branches in Azerbaijani lands liberated from occupation
All news