Apple says $14 billion EU tax order 'defies reality and common sense'

Apple says $14 billion EU tax order 'defies reality and common sense'

The European Union’s order to Apple to pay 13 billion euros ($14 billion) in back taxes “defies reality and common sense”, the U.S. firm said as the two sides sparred in a case key to the EU’s crackdown on sweetheart deals to multinationals, Trend with reference to Reuters reports.

The iPhone maker is appealing to Europe’s second highest court to overturn the European Commission’s 2016 ruling that it pay the record sum to Ireland.

Ireland, whose economy has benefited from investment by multinational companies attracted by low tax rates, is also challenging the Commission’s decision.

Apple also accused the Commission of using its powers to combat state aid “to retrofit changes to national law”, in effect trying to change the international tax system and in the process creating legal uncertainty for businesses.

The EU executive dismissed the arguments, saying it was not seeking to police international tax laws and accused Ireland of not having done its homework when assessing Apple’s taxes.

Apple’s arguments at the General Court, Europe’s second-highest, came after the EU executive in 2016 said the tech giant benefited from illegal state aid due to two Irish tax rulings which artificially reduced its tax burden for over two decades.

The case could make or break European Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager’s campaign which has also led to action against Starbucks, Fiat, Engie, Amazon and others.

Apple’s Chief Financial Officer Luca Maestri led a six-strong delegation to the court where a panel of five judges will hear arguments over two days.

“The Commission contends that essentially all of Apple’s profits from all of its sales outside the Americas must be attributed to two branches in Ireland,” Apple’s lawyer Daniel Beard told the court.

He said the fact the iPhone, the iPad, the App Store, other Apple products and services and key intellectual property rights were developed in the United States, and not in Ireland, showed the flaws in the Commission’s case.

“The branches’ activities did not involve creating, developing or managing those rights. Based on the facts of this case, the primary line defies reality and common sense,” Beard said.

“The activities of these two branches in Ireland simply could not be responsible for generating almost all of Apple’s profits outside the Americas.”

Beard dismissed criticism of the 0.005% tax rate paid by Apple’s main Irish unit in 2014, which was cited by the Commission in its decision, saying the regulator was just seeking “headlines by quoting tiny numbers”.

Paying an average global tax rate of 26%, Apple has said it is the largest taxpayer worldwide and is now paying around 20 billion euros in U.S. taxes on the same profits that the Commission said should have been taxed in Ireland.

In its current financial quarter, Apple expects revenue of $61-64 billion and a gross margin of 37.5-38.5%.

Commission lawyer Richard Lyal said Apple’s argument that all its intellectual property-related activities take place in the United States was inconsequential.

“To a large extent that is perfectly correct and perfectly irrelevant,” he said, adding that Ireland was taxing Apple’s Irish subsidiaries, not the group nor Apple Inc.

He said Ireland had failed to examine the functions performed by Apple’s Irish units, the risks assumed and the assets used by the subsidiaries.

“They simply accepted an arbitrary method proposed by the Apple Ireland subsidiaries. That in itself gives rise to a presumption of a special deal, exceptionally advantageous treatment. It is clear that the tax authorities made no assessment in 1991.”

He said the Commission has no hidden agenda.

“What is the case not about? Not about the Commission as policeman of international taxation, not about making sure tax is paid somewhere, though that would be a nice idea, not about resolving tax mismatches,” Lyal said.

Ireland said it had been the subject of entirely unjustified criticism and that the Apple tax case was due to a mismatch between the Irish and U.S. tax systems.

“The Commission’s decision is fundamentally flawed,” its lawyer Paul Gallagher told the court.

Luxembourg, told by the EU to recover millions of euros in back taxes from Amazon, Engie and Fiat, is backing Ireland. Poland and the EFTA (European Free Trade Association) Surveillance Authority support the Commission.

The court is expected to rule in the coming months, with the losing party likely to appeal to the EU Court of Justice and a final judgment could take several years.

The joint Apple cases are T-778/16 Ireland v Commission and T-892/16 Apple Sales International and Apple Operations Europe v Commission.

Azerbaijan extending special quarantine regime (UPDATE)
Azerbaijan extending special quarantine regime (UPDATE)
Azerbaijani president makes phone call to Russian president
Azerbaijani president makes phone call to Russian president
Azerbaijani, Afghan, Turkmen presidents meet through videoconferencing (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani, Afghan, Turkmen presidents meet through videoconferencing (PHOTO)
Loading Bars
Latest
UN chief saddened by enormous loss of life in Myanmar landslide
State Department warns top U.S. firms over supply chain risks linked to China's Xinjiang
Feature: Kenyan cybercafes boom as COVID-19 increases digitization of services
Alibaba Cloud announces business expansion in Southeast Asia
Egypt receives 313 tourists from Switzerland, Belarus amid flight resumption
McDonald's to pause U.S. reopening of dine-in services by 21 days
Iran to inaugurate more dams, water treatment plants
Azerbaijan extending special quarantine regime
Azerbaijan increases import of Indian products
Azerbaijani Agriculture Ministry discloses volume of harvested cereal crops
Bulgaria, Greece to ensure clear distribution of tax profits from IGB
BP, Enagas to promote projects to reduce emissions
Azerbaijan to start exporting hazelnuts to Egypt, Pakistan, Italy
Azerbaijan’s Az-Granata to greatly increase revenues from export of pomegranate juices, wine
Turkmenistan can increase export to Russia’s Astrakhan
Revenues of Southern Gas Corridor CJSC rise
Georgia's Namakhvani HPP receives building permit
Export of Azerbaijani products to Australia edges up
DAIR Hotels & Restaurants Association talks prospects for gastronomic tourism in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan confirms 572 new COVID-19 cases
Georgia's National Bank carries foreign exchange intervention to stabilize lari
Public services digitalization leads to indirect economic effects in Kazakhstan
Southern Gas Corridor CJSC’s assets up
Data on cargo transshipment from Kazakhstan via ports of Turkey announced
Turkmenistan’s Demiryollary to buy materials for track superstructure via tender
Georgia makes changes in preferential agro-credit system for food industry
Azerbaijani gymnasts congratulate policemen on professional holiday (VIDEO)
New opportunities from UNEC for those who want to study Design (PHOTO)
Demand for notes of Azerbaijan's Central Bank surpasses supply
Turkey discloses volume of cargo transshipment through Antalya port
Azerbaijani Agriculture Ministry talks issuing subsidies to farmers
Georgia expands agriculture support programs
Turkmenbashi Complex of Oil Refineries opens tender for feasibility study preparation
Azerbaijani banks' demand at CBA's foreign exchange auction rises
EBRD reveals total investments volume in Turkmenistan
Payment card turnover increases in Azerbaijan
U.S. trade deficit widens as exports fall to lowest level since 2009
Azerbaijan sees growth in volume of deposits
Kazakh president makes amendments to laws on ensuring internet accessibility
Ryanair resumes flights from Greece after four-month grounding
Georgia decreases live chickens export to Azerbaijan
Bank lending on rise in Azerbaijan’s capital and districts
Azerbaijan working on optimizing usage of excess energy
Japan significantly raises import of Kazakh-made goods
Get 4G MiFi device and 3 months of 10 GB internet for just 119 AZN from Azercell!
Kazakhstan, Turkey to cooperate in SMEs development
Turkey's trade turnover with France shrinks
Geological exploration in Kazakhstan to be held over next 4-5 years
Georgian ambassador: Southern Gas Corridor to bring additional investments
Amount of mortgage loans issued by Azerbaijani banks drops
UK says significant differences remain on Brexit free trade deal
Turkey not ruling out leaving Istanbul Convention
Iran reveals housing units built within Mehr Housing Project
Georgia, Azerbaijan to hold another business forum - ambassador
Italy's Prada sales in Asia up double-digit, trend will continue - CEO
Uzbekistan's Uzbekneftegaz overhauls natural gas well in Karakalpakstan
Several airlines to carry out charter flights to bring Georgian citizens home
Uzbekistan may implement joint projects with Spanish Inditex company
Volume of cargo transshipment from Portugal via Turkish ports revealed
Uzbekistan's COVID-19 cases nearing 9,000
Real estate expert talks car prices in Azerbaijan following fuel price rise
Kazakh-Turkish JV opens tender to buy wells piping spare parts
Tesla beats vehicle delivery estimates for second quarter
Singapore's companies mostly operate in Kazakhstan's trade sector
Uzbekistan launches paper production facility
Tender on building overhaul opens in Azerbaijan's Gabala
Entrepreneurs in Azerbaijan to receive loans under state guarantees
EBRD to provide new loan for Turkmenistan's construction sector
Turkey's five-month cargo transportation to Ukraine almost doubles
Azerbaijan's Entrepreneurship Development Fund reveals amount of issued loans
Azerbaijan’s energy minister: It is important to continue expanding OPEC+ format
Ambassador talks cooperation between Azerbaijan, Georgia to increase transit potential
American Airlines warns of 25% drop in international capacity in 2021 summer
Azerbaijan marks growth in number of debit cards
Loan term extended for entrepreneurs in several spheres of Azerbaijani agricultural sector
Geostat: Bulgaria ranks third among largest importers of Georgian products
Chemical fertilizer production plants in Iran's Bushehr province resume operations
Azerbaijan reveals data on lending to economy
Azerbaijani president makes phone call to Russian president
Turkish BOTAS announces volume of oil shipment from Ceyhan terminal
Uzbekistan, US may establish joint investment fund
Liberty Steel Hartlepool updates on work at Umid field
IRENA to partake in Azerbaijan's bioenergy mapping
Banks of Uzbekistan to sell gold bullions
Iran's AEO spokesman talks Natanz nuclear facility damage following accident
Ambassador: SOCAR actively participates in gas supplies for Georgia's new projects
Amount of problem loans down in Azerbaijan
Uzbekneftegaz increases gas production in Uzbekistan's Karakalpakstan
Iran reveals its COVID-19 data for July 2
Turkmenistan working with USAID to find best solutions agricultural pests
Uzbekistan to take measures to further improve agricultural management system
Kazakhstan's renewable energy to benefit from long-term power system dev't scenarios
Uzbekistan intends to issue Eurobonds in national currency
Azerbaijani, Afghan, Turkmen presidents meet through videoconferencing (PHOTO)
USAID intends to strengthen energy co-op with Turkmenistan
Kazakhstan introduces new standards for halal goods production
Bank deposits in Azerbaijani regions mostly made in national currency
Turkmenistan working to obtain status in WTO
Turkmengas strengthens production of enterprises with new equipment, vehicles
Kazakhstan's oil & gas company to buy oils via tender
All news