Lawyers to take Dersim massacres to ICC despite hurdles

Lawyers to take Dersim massacres to ICC despite hurdles
Lawyers are preparing to argue at the International Criminal Court (ICC) that "cultural genocide" continues in the province due to the systematic destruction of traditions, language and values that make the people of Dersim distinct from others. Turkey's prime minister achieved a milestone when he recently apologized on behalf of the state for the Dersim massacre of the 1930s, Today's Zaman reported.

"On behalf of the victims, our petition is ready and all evidence has been collected, including what the prime minister said," stated Erdal Dogan, a human rights lawyer in İstanbul. Together with a colleague, Eren Keskin, they are preparing to submit the petition to the ICC at The Hague in early 2012.

In late November, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan apologized for a 1937 massacre in the predominantly Alevi region of Dersim on behalf of the Turkish state, but said the main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP), which was the only political party at the time, is the actual culprit and called on the party's current leader to apologize for the incident on behalf of the CHP.

It was the first official apology from the Turkish government over the killing of thousands of people in the town of Dersim -- now known as Tunceli as a result of a name change in 1936 -- between 1936 and 1939. The notorious massacre took place in Dersim, which was historically a semi-autonomous region, as a brutal response to an alleged rebellion led by Seyyid Rıza, the chief of a Zaza tribe in the region. The Turkish government at the time, led by former CHP leader İsmet İnönü, used air strikes and other violent methods of suppression, killing thousands of people.

Referring to a document dated 1939, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said 13,806 people were killed in operations carried out against the people of Dersim between 1936 and 1939. He said the document bears the signature of then-Interior Minister Faik Oztrak. Another document Erdoğan revealed related to the Dersim events was a Cabinet decree dated Dec. 23, 1938, which said 11,683 people had been relocated from Dersim and that 2,000 more were to be relocated.

"Erdogan stepped out of the official ideology. His words are positive in regards to changing persisting misperceptions about what happened. By opposing the prime minister's approach, the current CHP representatives continued to deny what happened, showing that their mentality is the same," Dogan said. He added that they will argue in the ICC that as a result of this mentality, "cultural genocide" continues in Dersim, and they have evidence.

Among the evidence he shows is the presence of 11,000 mines in the area making large parts of the land uninhabitable for people. Another is the evacuation of villages and deforestation efforts in the name of fighting against terrorism, especially in the 1980s.

"But deforestation continues even today. On top of that, there are a number of hydroelectric power plant projects on streams that are historically, culturally and religiously important to those people," he said. "Dersim is still under the strict control of the Turkish security forces. It is like an open-air prison. Life has almost been paralyzed."

The lawyers also collected witness accounts from the survivors of the 1936-1939 massacres, and they also have the testimony of people from Dersim in which they claimed that they had been subject to massacres in the 1990s as well.

However, the problem is whether or not the ICC will recognize "cultural genocide" although it was established to punish genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity.

In that regard, Dogan refers to Article 7 of the Rome Statute dealing with crimes against humanity, such as widespread or systematic attacks against any civilian population, which involves deportation, forcible population transfers and similar inhumane acts that intentionally cause great suffering. Therefore, he argues, going to the ICC and claiming that "cultural genocide" continues in the area is possible since the population has been subject to relocation due to some of the state's policies.

"Even though the past perpetrators of the massacres are no longer alive, the system that they established is," he said.

On the other hand, human rights activist and jurist Gunal Kursun said "cultural genocide" or "culturocide" is not recognized in the 1948 Genocide Convention and the Rome Statute, the founding international treaty of the ICC.

"There are four groups recognized as victim groups by means of genocide: national, ethnic, racial and religious groups. Unfortunately, cultural groups are not counted as a victim group in the genocide definition, although it may fit the definition for crimes against humanity," he added.

In addition, the ICC has a mandate that only applies to crimes that were committed after July 2002, when the Rome Statute went into effect.

"The problem here is the time, and we are not able to find any of the perpetrators of the Dersim massacres today. I do not think that ICC will see this issue as a continuous crime," Kursun said but added that going to the ICC would nonetheless have much significance since the issue will be brought to public attention once more.

"With this attempt, I hope we will be able to confront our past this time, but I do not expect any realistic legal consequences," he said.

Kursun also noted that Turkey is not a party to the ICC since it did not sign the Rome Statute, but expects that it will since Prime Minister Erdogan talked about Turkey's intention to become a party in 2004.

"Since that date, we have not seen any positive steps in this direction, and I think this application may trigger a process and discussion in Turkey about confronting its past and becoming a party to the statute. This will be the best outcome," he said.

Agricultural production up in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan
Agricultural production up in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan
Iranian trucks carrying tomatoes stuck at Pakistani border
Iranian trucks carrying tomatoes stuck at Pakistani border
Saudi Arabia explores wind potential in Uzbekistan
Saudi Arabia explores wind potential in Uzbekistan
Loading Bars
Chairman of State Duma of Federal Assembly of Russia talks Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity (PHOTO)
Get rewarded with Azercell!
Chairman of Public Organization of Udi people thanks Azerbaijan
Agricultural production up in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan
Iran's plan to develop paddy fields fails, farmers demand compensation
Iranian trucks carrying tomatoes stuck at Pakistani border
Saudi Arabia explores wind potential in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijan to purchase COVID-19 vaccine
Iran to develop power cooperation with Afghanistan
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale September 26
IranAir to resume flights to Germany after several months
Volume of cargo movement through Azerbaijani ports increases
Iran discloses volume of wheat purchased in Ardabil Province
Energy Community: 2020 - remarkable year in terms of Georgia's ability to continue on its reform path
Iran to announce decisive decisions on combating COVID-19
Kazakhstan taking measures to increase railway border stations capacities
Tesla expects approval for battery cells plant in Berlin
UK Brexit border delays 'likely to worsen' in January
Georgia sees decrease in car re-exports
Import of Turkish clothes by Iran plunges
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to rise
Speaker of Azerbaijani Parliament met with Russian FM (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan confirms 173 more COVID-19 recoveries
Oil accounts for major part of exports from Azerbaijan to Croatia, says ministry
Volume of gas consumption in Iran revealed
Austrian OMV oil company to start gas exploration in Georgia
EAEU countries increase export of dairy products to Turkmenistan
Kazakhstan’s Oil Construction Company to buy pipes via tender
All activities for Ionian Adriatic Pipeline postponed: Croatian Ministry
Turkey's clothes export to Uzbekistan slumps
Russia eyes to build nuclear power plant in Uzbekistan
Vladimir Putin: Increase of excess income tax rates is justified step
Extraction plan for Iran's South Pars gas field determined
Azerbaijan, ADB discuss prospects for expanding cooperation (PHOTO)
Iran to begin studies related to Sanandaj-Bashmakh route
Kazakhstan Railways opens tender to buy electric generators
Review of dairy products exported by Georgia to Azerbaijan
Israel's Mobileye, Dubai's Habtoor partner on self-driving cars
Georgia exports first batch of honey to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan developing vaccination strategy against coronavirus
Auction on placement of Azerbaijani Central Bank's short-term notes held
ADB talks opportunities for financing of projects in Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan's crude oil exports to Netherlands surge in 1H2020
Turkmen company plans to cover domestic demand for viscose thread
Volume of lending in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic increases
Volume of maritime cargo transshipment from S.Korea via Turkey detailed
Ukrainian International Airlines FlyUIA announces flights to Georgia
Kazakhstan's passenger cars export value to Azerbaijan revealed
Turkmen company for polypropylene production thread revealed export volumes
Turkish BOTAS discloses volume of oil shipment from Ceyhan terminal
Iran declares volume of areas put into operation in agricultural parks
Revenues of Azerbaijani Nakhchivan's mobile communication operators up
Speaker of Azerbaijani Parliament: Armenian PM's statements undermine international efforts for peaceful settlement of Karabakh conflict
Georgia's import of tubes, pipes, hollow profiles from Turkey up
Turkmenistan’s Turkmennebit exceeds volume of oil production
Non-cash payments getting increasingly popular in Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan’s QAZAQ AIR resuming flights on more domestic routes
Foreign trade turnover of Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan grows
Iran imports flu vaccine as possible medicine against COVID-19
Paris Eiffel tower evacuated
World GDP spent on energy to be halved by 2050
RAEX: Structural reforms in public sector of Uzbekistan’s economy to support the economic development
AZAL launches special flights to Ankara and Antalya
Turkey remains main importer of flours, meals, pellets from Georgia
Ways for decarbonizing operations of oil & gas companies
China's import of ready-made clothing from Turkey spikes
Geostat reveals volume of ferroalloys exported by Georgia to Turkey
Construction of Ashgabat-Turkmenabat highway continues
Asian Development Bank expanding support program in Azerbaijan
Oil & gas industry to become world’s carbon waste disposal agent
Number of people infected with coronavirus (COVID-19) in Iran exceeds 430,000
Georgians traveling to Estonia to be obliged to go through 14-day self-isolation
Value of exports from Iran’s Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad Province climbs
GDP data of Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan revealed
Georgia reveals volume of fish exported to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan's State Service on Property Issues to put up several enterprises for auction
Iran reveals details of exports from Yazd Province
Georgia reduces import of medicaments from Turkey
Iran threatens to exit from NPT and JCPOA
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan down
Iran's Shazand Oil Refining Company opens tender to buy equipment
Mayor of Israeli city: Azerbaijan no doubt very tolerant country
Russia increases volume of cement imports from Turkey
Iran discloses amount of currency returned to country economy
Bulgarian MEP: Azerbaijani oil, gas pipelines strongly contribute to pan-European energy security
SOCAR Energoresource, Tyumen Oblast ink agreement on socio-economic cooperation
Azerbaijani president, first lady view landscaping work carried out in Balakhani settlement (PHOTO)
Inflation rate grows in Iran
Inflow of labor migrants from Turkey to Turkmenistan decreases
Azerbaijan holds auction on state-owned enterprises
Daily new coronavirus cases reach record in Israel
Several UAVs and military helicopters handed over to Iranian Armed Forces
Bulgarian MEP: Lasting settlement of Karabakh conflict lies in meaningful negotiations
Neste and Shell to increase supply of sustainable aviation fuel
Uzbek-Korean Gas Chemical LLC to build hydrogen and nitrogen storage station
Turkmenistan increases import of Turkish-made electrical goods
Turkmenhimiya opens tender for turnkey construction of production complex
Several more Russian enterprises get right to export fish products to Azerbaijan
Uzbekistan to develop engineering and communication networks in Fergana region
Construction Cost Index increases in Georgia
All news