Russia to benefit Much from Hand Over of Islands to China

Russia to benefit Much from Hand Over of Islands to China

Azerbaijan, Baku, 18 July/ Trend , corr E. Tanriverdiyeva, R. Agayev/ The decision of Russia to give back part of the islands in Amur, which disputed territory, is necessitated by the fact that it is beneficial for Moscow to have good-neighbor relations with Beijing and probably pragmatic reasons and long-term interests of Russia stand behind it.

There are politically powerful interests in Moscow that benefit from large Russian arms sales to China, and those interests are not inclined to jeopardize their profits by antagonizing China over this border issue, John J. Tkacik, Jr, US researcher in Asian Studies, believes.

At the beginning of the next week the Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov will pay an official visit to Beijing where the parties will discuss the hand-over part of the islands in the Amur River to China. The agreement with this regard was signed between Moscow and Beijing in 2004. 

According to experts, by handing over islands to China, Russia first of all thinks of the benefits in its relations with China. "The point is not the benefit from the territorial concessions. It is beneficial for Russia to have good-neighbor relations with China, and well-defined borders approved by both sides. If territorial exchange is required for this purpose, it is considered profitable investment in the future," Nikolai Petrov, expert of Carnegie Center of Moscow said to Trend .

According to expert, the agreement on the Russian-China borders and the fact that the border has been defined on the government level is considered a big achievement of Russia's policy. For many years, this problem remained unsolved and small number of Russian population on one side of border and over 1 billion of Chinese population on the other could not but make Russian military men and politicians worry about it, Petrov said.

Experts disagree on whether hand-over of islands to China was timely and profitable for Russia.

Beijing and Moscow have decided to solve territorial disputes realistically by division of disputed territory, Zhang Jiadong, a Ciense expert said. There are many criticisms both in China and in Russia. Some Chinese think China would lose some part of disputed territories forever and consider Beijing as national betrayer. Some Russians have similar impression toward their government, he said.

"Personally, I think no one lose in this case. China and Russia are doing a win-win model in dealing with disputed territory," Jiadong, Associate Professor of the Center for American Studies, Fudan University based in Shanghai, China, wrote in his comments for Trend via e-mail.

The political experts also point to the important fact of hand over of only small part of territory which historically belongs to China, which is doubtless, beneficial for Russia.

According to Pertov, the point is the very short, local and small territorial exchanges and determining border lines on equal basis and the scale of this territorial exchange is totally incommensurable with the possible claims made by the radical organizations of China.

The US expert Tkacik believes that Russia did not only lost territory, but also it gained.

"Because the 174 square kilometers that Russia is now returning to China still does not give China access to the navigable river Channel, I do not see that it presents a particular "territorial loss" to Russia," Tkacik said. "By returning less than half the area to China, they could claim Russia has actually made a net gain, expert said.

According to experts, the historical aspects also account for the hand-over of lands. The Chinese expert Zhang Jiadong said that these islands in the Amur River are not territory of Russia and China.

"They are "disputed territory" between China and Russia. According to the historical evidences and international law, many islands on the Amur River should belong to China," Jiadong said.

Tkacik also said that this territory historically belongs to China. According to the US expert,perhaps, the Russian Foreign Ministry reviewed its files from 1929 and agreed that Russia had illicitly occupied the islands then.

"My own view is that the Red Army occupied the islands in 1929 in an attempt to ensure the Soviet Union had control of the riverine navigation channel of the Amur and Ussurri rivers, and could defend the major river port of Khabarovsk, in case Manchuria were ever to come under hostile control,"Tkacik said.

The only reason for Moscow's worries can be possible attacks by China to Russia's territories.

"Russia believes that it could fight a military battle on the islands. A Chinese invasion across the land boundary of the Island (Bolshoi Ussuriski) would be easier than an invasion of the island from across the river. The city of Khabarovsk is right across from these islands, and the defense of Khabarovsk from a Chinese land attack would be slightly more complicated with the Chinese also occupying dry land on the Island,"Tkacik said.

The tarabarov island and part of the Bolshoi Ussuriski island were under dispute since 1991 and the borders between Russia and China of 4km were not demarcated for the whole of this period which created tension in relations between the two countries.

"Both Chinese and Russian leaders are wise enough because they have to maintain a fine balance between "actual control" and "historical right" based on international law. They are also courageous enough to face strong criticizes and oppositions at home. In most cases, demand of the public is always beyond government's capability," Zhang Jiadong said.

The correspondent can be contacted at: [email protected]   

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Spain's COVID-19 cases top 5 mln
Spain's COVID-19 cases top 5 mln
British PM tells Putin Russia-UK relationship "is not the one" London wants
British PM tells Putin Russia-UK relationship "is not the one" London wants
Airbus rejects pressure to curb record jet output goal
Airbus rejects pressure to curb record jet output goal
Loading Bars
Chinese Xi congratulates Mirziyoyev on election as Uzbek president
Man shot inside Union Square subway station in New York
Facebook invests billions in metaverse efforts as ad business slows
Egypt not to extend years-long state of emergency: president
Spain's COVID-19 cases top 5 mln
Seven killed, 140 hurt in protests against Sudan military coup
Western ambassadors took a step back, will be more careful: Erdogan
Tesla’s market value tops $1T after Hertz orders 100K cars
6 injured, including officer, in Idaho mall shooting
Saudi Arabia outlines plans under Mideast Green Initiative
British PM tells Putin Russia-UK relationship "is not the one" London wants
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by Italian Rai 1 TV channel on October 26, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev addresses the nation on October 26, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: October 26, 2020
Development of financial technologies in Kyrgyzstan discussed in Bishkek
Georgian PM holds videoconference with Ukrainian, Moldovan counterparts
Modernization of our country, fight against unpleasant situations must reach a completely new level - President Ilham Aliyev
We are a creator nation, and we will rebuild Gubadli - Azerbaijani president
Africa's COVID-19 cases near 8.5 mln: Africa CDC
For me, biggest reward is joy and pride in the eyes of former IDPs - Azerbaijani president
Second Karabakh war showed our strength and our national spirit - President Ilham Aliyev
After 27 years, we ended the occupation and expelled the enemy from our land - Azerbaijani president
Zangilan airport will be commissioned next year - President Aliyev
We will restore all settlements of Gubadli district, including Gubadli city - Azerbaijani president
After restoration work is completed, streets will be named after martyrs - President Aliyev
Uzbekistan’s 9M2021 imports of Turkish leather goods increase
Azerbaijan defense minister meets leadership of Turkish National Defense University (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan, NATO talk prospects for co-op in various spheres (PHOTO)
Ernst & Young reveals total revenues of Uzbekneftegaz during 1H2021
Turkey shares data on cargo shipments via its Aliaga port
Iran talks exports of its nano products to Iraq, Turkey, Afghanistan
Azerbaijan’s State Tax Service expanding use of electronic signature
Turkey discloses volume of cargo shipment via Ambarli port in 9M2021
Iran sees increase in manufacturing of several industrial, mining products
Iran's trade turnover with Azerbaijan booming - IRICA
Azerbaijan’s timber imports from Russian region revealed
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on October 26
Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan sign number of bilateral co-op documents
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price slightly rising
Kazakhstan ready to significantly increase imports of Turkmen gas - President Tokayev
Azerbaijan publishes latest data on mine clearance work carried out in liberated lands
Georgia records highest budget deficit in ten years
Azeronline providing companies in Azerbaijan's liberated lands with Wi-Fi
Kazakhstan ready to increase trade with Turkmenistan
Azerbaijan to open embassy in Vatican
Program of Turkish president's visit to Azerbaijan announced
Airbus rejects pressure to curb record jet output goal
Azerbaijan to export Karabakh honey to France
Azerbaijan reveals funds allocated for drawing up master plan for Gubadli city
Galt & Taggart shares data on Georgia's tourism revenues growth
US data cloud giant Snowflake opens Israel office
Chinese oil company sells stake in Azerbaijan
Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan to dock telecommunication networks at border
It'll take time for Kazakhstan to accelerate its energy transition - Rystad Energy
Iran increases export by aid of private sector
Iran to reform budget plan structure
Azerbaijan discloses timing of booster vaccination for COVID-19 infected persons
Participants of online Global Poster and Painting Competition 2021 felicitated (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani defense minister meets NATO official (PHOTO)
Output volume at Azerbaijan’s Kursangi, Garabagli fields revealed
Fitch places credit ratings of 4 Qatari banks on negative watch
Kazakhstan to raise solid waste disposal share
Uzbekistan eyes implementation of joint projects with Russia
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Hertz orders 100,000 Tesla cars for end of 2022
Azerbaijan confirms 1,477 more COVID-19 cases, 628 recoveries
Kazakh National Bank positively assesses development dynamics in domestic real sector
Azerbaijan exceeds honey production plan
National Iranian Drilling Company unveils number of drilled oil-gas wells in country
Turkey to invest in construction of laboratory for veterinary vaccines production in Azerbaijan
Afghanistan still owes Uzbekistan for electricity, debt continues to grow
VTB Bank Azerbaijan sees drastic increase in net profit
Azerbaijani Ombudsman briefs Bulgarian delegation about crimes committed by Armenia
Azerbaijani president congratulates president of Uzbekistan
After Gubadli, we continued our victory march with dignity and raised our national flag in Shusha - President Aliyev
Georgia's import prices dropping – TBC Capital
Azercell offers a new Wi-Fi campaign!
After many years, we all experienced joy of this victory - Azerbaijani president
Present and future generations of our people will always be proud of our martyrs - President Aliyev
Kazakhstan reports increase in annual coal production volumes
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for October 25
Azerbaijan shares latest data on lending to mining industry
Galt & Taggart reveals Georgia's trade turnover statistics
It is significant and historic day in history of Gubadli district today - President Ilham Aliyev
Kazakhstan eyes completing main reconstruction work of Kostanay airport by end of 2021
SOFAZ reveals revenues from Shah Deniz, ACG
Kazakhstan, Mongolia agree to continue co-op in agro-industrial complex
Iran's East Azerbaijan province continues investments in construction projects
Iran invites investors to develop energy sector
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva shares photos from Gubadli district on her Instagram page (PHOTO)
Iran seeks to curb inflation by aid of private sector
Kyrgyzstan plans to receive USD 80 mln from ADB for budget support
Kazakhstan’s National Bank changes base rate
Weekly review of trading at Turkmenistan's commodity exchange
Azerbaijan sees increase in turnover of payment cards
Kazakhstan’s National Bank reveals inflation rate for September 2021
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva meet with general public of Gubadli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva inaugurate 'Gubadli' substation (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Turkey notes decrease in number of used vehicles
Prices on some food items soar in Iran
All news