You are holding back life-saving research, scientists tell ministers

( Times ) - Life-saving medical research will be held back by draconian new consent laws planned for embryonic stem-cell experiments, a group of leading scientists tell the Government in a letter to The Times today.

The Government's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill will delay vital research by requiring all tissue used to create cloned embryonic stem cells to have the explicit consent of its donor, the experts say.

The 29 biomedical researchers and administrators, including three Nobel prizewinners, warn ministers that the measure will deny stem-cell scientists the use of valuable tissue banks for studying diseases such as muscular dystrophy, Parkinson's and diabetes.

As this tissue was collected before it became possible to clone embryos, the patients who donated it have not given permission for their DNA to be used in embryonic stem-cell models of their diseases. Scientists in this field will thus be forbidden access to most of the tissue banks that act as vast libraries of the genes that contribute to serious disorders. They cannot seek consent retrospectively as most cells were donated anonymously.

The Government's justification for the measure is that some patients who agreed to donate cells in the past might not have realised that their tissue could later be used for cloning.

A second provision in the Bill, which is currently passing through Parliament, will further limit stem-cell research by blocking the use of any tissue from children, even if their parents give consent.

Amendments to overturn both measures have been tabled by Lord Patel of Dunkeld, the chairman of the UK Stem Cell Network Steering Committee, and will be debated in the House of Lords today. The Government is opposed to any change.

"We urge the Government to accept this important improvement to the Bill, which will help to maintain the UK's reputation as the place of choice for this exciting and world-leading medical research," the letter says.

Its signatories include the Nobel medicine laureates Sir Martin Evans, Sir Paul Nurse and Sir John Sulston, as well as leading stem-cell experts such as Sir Ian Wilmut, Dame Julia Polak, Professor Stephen Minger and Professor Robin Lovell-Badge.

The amendments are backed by the Medical Research Council, the Royal Society, the Wellcome Trust and the Academy of Medical Sciences.

Evan Harris, the Liberal Democrat MP who organised the letter, said: "When the science world unites behind an important and reasonable request, that should be taken very seriously by Parliament and ministers."

The new rules will affect the creation of cloned embryos by transferring a cell nucleus from a person with disease into a human or animal egg from which the DNA has been removed. This produces embryonic stem cells with the same genetic defects as the patient, which are powerful laboratory models for studying disease progression and for developing and testing new therapies.

The scientists do not dispute that explicit consent is needed from egg donors and from patients who donate their tissue in the future.

They argue, however, that new rules should not be applied retrospectively, so that they can use cells donated in the past by patients who gave general consent for unspecified medical research.

If stem-cell scientists cannot use existing cell libraries as raw material for cloning, they will in effect have to duplicate these banks. This will cost hundreds of thousands of pounds and significantly delay research.

Lord Patel said yesterday: "If these banks cannot be used, it will take a considerable amount of time and resources to build up another collection. Scientists in other countries will not have to work under the same constraints."

The new provisions have already held up a project led by Lyle Armstrong, of the University of Newcastle upon Tyne, who is a signatory to the letter.

Although he was awarded a licence to make cloned interspecies embryos last week, it was delayed as the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority rejected his plan to use banked cells that did not have explicit consent for this purpose.

The clause that bans cell donation by children also promises to block another experiment planned by Professor Minger, of King's College, London. An American colleague has offered him cells collected from children with spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), a rare genetic wasting condition, but he will not be allowed to use them if the Bill remains unaltered.

"We want to use these to produce stem cells to study SMA, and we cannot get this genetic material any other way," Professor Minger said. "Children with the worst form of this condition do not live to adulthood. It is impossible to wait until they are old enough to give their own consent."

Iran to carry out vaccination against COVID-19 in Jan.-Feb. 2020
Iran to carry out vaccination against COVID-19 in Jan.-Feb. 2020
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 25
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 25
Iranian ship seized in Indonesian waters
Iranian ship seized in Indonesian waters
Loading Bars
Latest
Kazakhstan restoring crude petroleum exports to Czech Republic
Volume of loans issued by Georgia commercial banks up
Kazakhstan’s largest gas supplying company opens tender for road repairs
Kazakhstan taking measures to develop container transportation by railway and sea
Kazakhstan continues to implement transport projects despite COVID-19 pandemic
Azerbaijan’s Baku Taxi Service opens tender for maintenance and repair of London Taxi
Investments in Azerbaijan's economy to increase - Standard & Poor's
Kazakhstan working on launching ferry service with Turkmenbashi, Makhachkala ports
Uzbekistan to use South Korea’s experience in digital economy dev’t
Azerbaijan planning to export domestic oil for diesel engines to Ukraine
Google workers to form global union alliance
S&P forecasts decrease in unemployment rate in Azerbaijan
Azercell expanded the coverage of the LTE network to more than 85% of the country's territory last year
Iran's exports through Astara customs grow
Relations on two sides of Araz are relations of kinship and friendship - Iranian FM
Azerbaijan shows footage from Kurdler village of Fuzuli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to rise
Contract to be signed on eleventh phase of Iran's South Pars gas field
Liabilities of Azerbaijani private sector to banks to decrease over next 3 years
Foreign trade turnover of Uzbekistan’s Samarkand region reduced in 2020
Turkish Yilmaden Holding eyeing chromite enrichment launch in East Kazakhstan
Georgia sees decrease in wine export
Production of vehicles in Azerbaijan increases
Hogan Lovells continues to advise Shah Deniz consortium after launch of SGC
Azerbaijan's Unicapital OJSC predicts notable rise in operations with securities for 2021
South Korea allocates additional grant for Uzbekistan to counter spread of COVID-19
Kazakhstan to auction several land plots for hydrocarbons exploration, dev't
Iran’s IOOC continues operations in Sivand and Esfand oil fields
Azerbaijan's AzerGold CJSC reveals 2020 revenues from export of gold, silver
S&P Global Ratings discloses forecast average inflation rate in Azerbaijan until 2024
Visit of Iran's Zarif to Baku - historic, says MFA spokesman
Russian MP included in "blacklist" - Azerbaijan Foreign Ministry
New opportunities with respect to new situation in region open wide doors to cooperation - President Aliyev
Cooperation on Khudafarin water reservoir, future plans with respect to construction of power station already in very active phase - President of Azerbaijan
Russia’s Tatneft in Turkmenistan opens tender for provision of truck crane services
We will be very happy to see companies from Iran among companies who participate in reconstruction of liberated areas - President Aliyev
Iran to carry out vaccination against COVID-19 in Jan.-Feb. 2020
Non-OPEC oil supply to rise in 2021, says JP Morgan
Iran and Tajikistan agree to complete Istiqlol tunnel
Iran boosts value of exports from Gilan Province
Uzbekistan manages to maintain active foreign trade balance with number of countries
Volume of goods available in Iranian ports revealed
Italy consumer association sues Apple for planned iPhone obsolescence
Iran asks EU to comply with its commitments within JCPOA
IKEA lowers climate footprint helped by pandemic and energy-efficient light bulbs
Iran says it will comply with its commitments if US returns to nuclear deal
Georgian Innovation and Technology Agency implements new project with WB support
Iran discloses data of exports via Astara port
Remittance inflows to Georgia increasing
Uzbek agro-industrial agency announces tender for well construction
Turkey testing domestic missile from submarine (VIDEO)
Kazakhstan's Ministry of Agriculture preparing for sowing campaign
ECB can price climate risk better than the market
Azerbaijan's First VP Mehriban Aliyeva re-elected as President of Azerbaijan Gymnastics Federation
Azerbaijani Economic Zones Dev't Agency to stimulate investment inflow in industrial parks
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 25
Agricultural lands in Iran to be equipped with modern irrigation systems
Azerbaijan's current account balance to return to surplus in 2021 - Standard & Poor's
Azerbaijan sends letters on Armenia's crimes to several countries (PHOTOS)
USAID launches new regional projects with participation of Turkmenistan
Iran’s Petropars Operation and Management Company signed contract on Forouzan field
Trade facilities, hairdressers, and beauty salons resume activity in Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
Spain interested in financing infrastructure projects in Georgia - Spanish Foreign Ministry
Uzbek-Korean JV announces tender for transport services
Iran could rely on oil and gas export for generating revenues - former minister
Azerbaijani investor talks automation of derivative transactions in capital market
Operation in Dashalti in 1992 went down in history as Azerbaijan's most unsuccessful military operation
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office puts several Armenian mercenaries on wanted list
Industrial gas inflow obtained from exploration well managed by Uzbekneftegaz
Nike urges court to throw out EU probe into Dutch tax deal
Uzbekistan to mark lands with organic agricultural seeds with special signs
German business morale drops to six-month low on virus woes
Uzbekistan achieves positive economic growth despite global pandemic
Iran's export via Bazargan border booming
Iranian ship seized in Indonesian waters
Several contracts signed on oil fields of Iran’s NISOC
SOFAZ reveals income generated from sale of condensate from Shah Deniz field
Azerbaijan's SOFAZ discloses volume of revenues from ACG fields for 2020
Georgia reports 298 new COVID-19 cases
Turkmenistan working on registration of second Russian coronavirus vaccine
Dostlug field's development to potentially connect Turkmenistan to Azerbaijan-Europe gas pipelines
Azerbaijan records growth in volume of deposited securities
Textile production in Kazakhstan shows stable growth
Volume of cargo loaded, unloaded in Iran’s Amirabad port announced
Azerbaijani FM receives Iranian counterpart (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Construction of new railway terminal between Iran and Azerbaijan to be launched
Economy Minister talks Karabakh's role in development of Azerbaijan's non-oil sector
Uzbekistan boosts Chinese apple import despite COVID-19
Kazakhstan reports slight decrease in imports from Egypt
Israelis express readiness to travel to Georgia
Turkmenistan plans to commission number of new facilities this year
Uzbek currency rates for January 25
Negotiations to be held on issue of tomato supply from Azerbaijan to Russia
Azerbaijan eyes to integrate state entities to government-cloud system
Belarus names volume of money transfers from Turkmenistan
Roadmaps for further reforming Uzbekistan’s electricity, oil and gas industries discussed
Russian Embassy in Turkmenistan organizes six charter flight
Iranian FM discusses obstacles for Iranian economy
President Ilham Aliyev receives Iranian Foreign Minister
Thailand to sell $2 billion savings bonds to finance stimulus measures
All news