Zarif Reveals Iran’s Proposal for Ensuring Against “Breakout”

Zarif Reveals Iran’s Proposal for Ensuring Against “Breakout”

Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif has revealed that Iran has made a detailed proposal to the P5+1 group of states aimed at ensuring that no stockpile of low-enriched uranium would be available for "breakout" through enrichment to weapons grade levels, Inter Press Service(IPS) news agency reported on June 13.

In an exclusive interview with IPS, Zarif described an Iranian plan, presented at the meetings with the P5+1 last month in Vienna, that would exclude weapons grade enrichment. "The parameters of the proposal would be set to continue Iran's enrichment but to provide the necessary guarantees that it would not enrich to anything over five percent," said Zarif.

The plan would involve the immediate conversion of each batch of low-enriched uranium to an oxide powder that would then be used to make fuel assemblies for Iran's Bushehr reactor, according to Zarif.

Because Iran does not have the capability to manufacture fuel assemblies for Bushehr, the proposal implies that the oxide power would be sent to Russia, at least for several years, rather than remaining in Iran.

The previously undisclosed Iranian plan is part of a broader negotiating stance that insists on the need for a large increase in the number of centrifuges it would have in the future - a demand that the United States and its negotiating partners have rejected.

Obama administration officials have made it clear that they are insisting on very steep reductions in the number of centrifuges, based on the argument that Iran cannot be allowed to have the capability to enrich enough uranium to weapons grade for a single nuclear bomb in less than six to 12 months.

Zarif said he could not discuss the details of the Iranian proposal, because it is "still being negotiated".

But he described it as involving a complete cycle "from conversion to yellowcake, to UF6, to enriched uranium, back to oxide powder, and back to fuel rods," all of which would be "designed specifically to meet the requirements of the Bushehr reactor."

Zarif revealed that the Iranian plan for guaranteeing that Iran could not have a nuclear weapons capability is very similar to the proposal that Iran made to a meeting with the European three (U.K., France and Germany) in Paris in March 2005.

The proposal, which was later published by the Iranian government, included a series of "technical guarantees" against nuclear weapons proliferation. It describes one of those guarantees as "immediate conversion of all enriched uranium to fuel rods to preclude even the technical possibility of further enrichment."

The U.S.-educated Zarif said he had developed that 2005 proposal himself when he was Iranian Ambassador to the United Nations, after he had consulted with a number of American nuclear scientists on ways to reassure the Europeans and the U.S. that Iran could not enrich enough uranium to weapons grade for a nuclear bomb.

"I asked them what would provide the necessary confidence," said Zarif. "They gave me a number of elements, which I put in a package and sent to Tehran, and they took it to Paris."

Frank N. Von Hippel, former assistant director for national security in the White House Office of Science and Technology and now a professor at Princeton University, confirmed in an e-mail that he had been part of a small group of American scientists and others who had met with Zarif to discuss the problem of how to provide assurances that Iran's civil nuclear program would not be used to support a nuclear weapons programme.

Von Hippel said his recollection was that the group had suggested "not building up a stockpile but rather shipping [the low-enriched uranium] to Russia to make fuel for the Bushehr reactor."

Peter Jenkins, then the U.K. permanent representative to the International Atomic Energy Agency, participated in the Mar. 23, 2005 meeting at which the Iranian plan was presented.

"All of us were impressed by the proposal," he recalled in a 2012 interview. The Europeans did not accept it as the basis for negotiation, however, because the George W. Bush administration had insisted that Iran not be allowed to have any enrichment whatsoever, according to European diplomats involved in that earlier phase of negotiations.

Zarif rejected the Obama administration's position that Iran should obtain whatever reactor fuel it needs for Bushehr or any future reactors from Russia or other foreign sources rather than relying on its own enrichment capabilities. "People should not tell us you have to rely on us," he said. "It is 30 years too late."

He was referring to Iran's experience with its reliance during the early 1980s on a French-based uranium enrichment consortium called Eurodif in which it had a financial stake acquired during the Shah's regime that entitled Iran to 10 percent of the enriched uranium produced by the consortium.

After the Islamic Republic resumed the nuclear program begun by the Shah, however, the French government prevented Eurodif from supplying any enriched uranium for nuclear fuel for the nuclear reactor at Bushehr in the early 1980s.

The U.S. State Department acknowledged in 1984 that it had not only ended its own nuclear cooperation with Iran but had "asked other nuclear suppliers not to engage in nuclear cooperation with Iran, especially while the Iran-Iraq war continues."

The foreign minister ruled out the acceptance of the P5+1 proposal in the last round of negotiations, which reportedly would limit the number of Iranian centrifuges to a fraction of its present total of 19,000.

"We're not going to redefine our practical needs," he said, referring to the language in the Joint Plan of Action agreed to last November calling for agreement on an Iranian enrichment programme whose "parameters" would reflect Iran's "practical needs".

But the foreign minister indicated that Iran was "prepared within the scope of those practical needs to work on timing, to work on various technical details...."

Zarif criticised statements by former and present U.S. officials to the news media as well in the negotiations referring to demands that the number of Iranian centrifuges must be geared to the need to extend the time required for "breakout" to 6 to 12 months.

Some of the statements made to the press, including those by former State Department proliferation official Robert Einhorn, as well as some of those made in the negotiations "amount to posturing", Zarif said, adding that they "amount to creating expectations that can never be met."

"It will be much more productive if everyone involved refrains from shaping the debate in a way that [it] will be out of control," said Zarif.

Zarif said the U.S. insistence on Iran's ending of all enrichment at its Fordow facility, which is located in a tunnel under a mountain, is based on "the argument that you can't have this facility, because otherwise we can't bomb it."

The implied assertion of the right to bomb Iranian facilities "strikes the wrong chord in the Iranian psyche and produces exactly the opposite reaction," he said.

Zarif challenged the view reflected in Western news coverage that the Rouhani government is under strong political pressure to produce results in the talks that would remove the worst sanctions.

The last round of talks in Vienna, which were unsuccessful "has been the easiest time at home," he said, and "the toughest time" for him as he had to explain "each positive result to a population that is extremely skeptical of the West's intentions." If he rejected a deal, Zarif said, he would receive a "hero's welcome."

Smerch missile launcher of Armenian Armed Forces used to shell Barda destroyed - MoD (VIDEO)
Smerch missile launcher of Armenian Armed Forces used to shell Barda destroyed - MoD (VIDEO)
Human Rights Watch confirms use of cluster munitions by Armenia to attack Barda
Human Rights Watch confirms use of cluster munitions by Armenia to attack Barda
Numerous sites hit by missiles attack on Azerbaijani Barda were in civilian areas - VICE News reporter (VIDEO)
Numerous sites hit by missiles attack on Azerbaijani Barda were in civilian areas - VICE News reporter (VIDEO)
Loading Bars
Latest
Albania, Azerbaijan has other investment opportunities apart from TAP
Azerbaijan hands over bodies of combatants to Armenia through ICRC
Smerch missile launcher of Armenian Armed Forces used to shell Barda destroyed - MoD (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani FM leaves for working trip to Geneva
Turkmenistan, South Korea aim to intensify co-op within intergovernmental commission
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 30
New fruit processing plant built in Georgia
Human Rights Watch confirms use of cluster munitions by Armenia to attack Barda
Several Azerbaijani districts under fire of Armenian Armed Forces
Latest situation on battlefront on October 30
Azerbaijan expands persimmon export geography
Denmark repeatedly increases import of Azerbaijani products
Azerbaijan's State Service to hold auction for five vehicles
Combat operations continued in direction of Aghdara, Khojavend and Gubadli - MoD
Several items of military equipment of Armenian Armed Forces destroyed - LIST
Every second operation in Azerbaijan carried out contactless - Visa
FM: Boosting cooperation with Iran priority of Afghan foreign policy
President Tokayev addresses International Forum on Northern Economic Cooperation
Turkey reports over 2,300 new COVID-19 patients
S. Korea reports 114 more COVID-19 cases, 26,385 in total
US to sell F-35 fighter jets to UAE, White House tells Congress
In Germany, car rams into group of passersby with one person killed, three injured
Moscow records another 69 coronavirus deaths
WHO registers over 479,000 COVID-19 cases in 24 hours worldwide
Facebook quarterly revenue beats estimates
Numerous sites hit by missiles attack on Azerbaijani Barda were in civilian areas - VICE News reporter (VIDEO)
Innovation Financing component of Georgian GITA supports provision of grants
VICE News highlights use of banned cluster munitions by Armenia to attack Azerbaijani Barda
Forces and equipment Armed Forces of Armenia destroyed (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan to establish embassy in Cuba
Strike on Azerbaijani is tragedy - Chairperson of Migration, Refugees, Displaced Persons Council of PACE
ICRC facilitates handover of combatants bodies killed in action during escalation of Karabakh conflict
Amnesty International verifies use of banned cluster bombs by Armenia to attack Azerbaijani Barda (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan avenges attack on Barda: Armenian units that subjected to fire civilian infrastructure, civilian population destroyed (VIDEO)
GUAM strongly condemns missile attacks on Azerbaijani cities by Armenia
French COJEP issues report on civilian casualties as result of Armenian attacks on densely populated Azerbaijani areas
Nizami Ganjavi International Center discusses renewed fighting between Armenia, Azerbaijan
Georgian Meskhetian Brand Winemaking Company enters new markets
Armenian Armed Forces' attempts to attack prevented in several directions - MoD
Azerbaijan issues statement on handing over bodies of killed servicemen to Armenia
Azerbaijan's MoD notes chaos, mass desertion in Armenian army
Azerbaijan eyes to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in upcoming years
Azerbaijan ratifies agreement on interaction of CIS member states' customs authorities
Azerbaijan reveals volume of tobacco production in Shaki district
UK increases import of Azerbaijani-made products
Georgia to cover utility fees of certain citizens starting from November
Canadian company to be engaged in gold mining in Georgia
Azerbaijani AFB Bank's net profit decreases
EBRD supports Georgian transport sector
No simple solution for Karabakh conflict, says Russian president
Azerbaijan approves law to rename 'Veng' village in Khojavand district into 'Chinarli'
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office updates on woman killed following Armenia's missile fire
Azerbaijan to establish embassy in Cuba
Chairman of Azerbaijani community of Nagorno Karabakh calls on Canadian MP to apologize
Ombudsman of Azerbaijan sends protest letter to UNICEF regarding Armenian provocations
KAZ Minerals metals output on track to exceed full year production guidance
Reports about shelling of Russian border outpost false, says Azerbaijan's MoD
Servicemen of Armenian regiment refuse to take part in Karabakh hostilities
Russia making vigorous efforts to de-escalate Karabakh conflict as soon as possible - MFA
German allocates additional funds to Georgia for fighting COVID-19
Armenian Armed Forces shelling Azerbaijan’s Goranboy, Tartar, Barda
National Bank of Georgia sells funds at foreign exchange auction
World will lose heavily from enmity with Turkey and Azerbaijan, Turkish top official on Trend's 'Baku-Istanbul' teleconference (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Discussions related to durable resolution of Karabakh conflict ongoing constantly - OSCE (Exclusive)
CNPC Drilling Company in Turkmenistan opens tender to buy electric batteries
Number of high-ranking Armenian officials dismissed from their posts within month
One more Azerbaijani civilian killed by Armenian Armed Forces - top official
Azerbaijan sharply increases import of eggs from Georgia
Lebanese human rights defenders condemn Armenian vandalism in Beirut
Armenia once again violates ceasefire agreements - FACTS
Azerbaijan increases tea imports from Georgia
VTB Bank Kazakhstan's parent bank expected to facilitate bank's growth plans for 2020-2021
Azerbaijan appeals to UNICEF regarding Armenia's terror against Barda's civilians
Facebook gains court backing in document row with EU regulators
Commissioning of desalination plant in Kazakhstan's semi-desert zone postponed
Number of debit cards in Azerbaijan continues to grow
Georgia reduces imports of construction materials from Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan reduces import of cigarettes from Georgia
Residents of Barda fully confident in Azerbaijani army - Executive authority
Georgia increases oil import from Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan reveals details of casualties, injuries in Tartar inflicted by Armenian troops
Electricity production using renewable energy sources increases in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan increases import of passenger cars from Georgia
Kazakhstan decreases imports from Austria
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan down
Austria interested in further promoting economic co-op with Turkmenistan
People like Vladimir Yevseev call on Armenia to commit war crimes - Israeli expert
Ronaldinho films video message in support of Azerbaijan
Missile-hit area of Azerbaijan's Barda city targeted purposefully - Executive Office
Armenian military-political leadership to be punished soon – Azerbaijani prosecutor general
Kazakhstan, Spain trade down nearly threefold amid COVID-19
Bashkortostan boosts fuel export to Uzbekistan
President Ilham Aliyev calls President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
Azerbaijan confirms 483 more COVID-19 recoveries
Small industrial zone to be created in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva congratulates brotherly people of Turkey on 29 October-Republic Day
Kazakhstan, Austria agree on Action Plan of Kazakhstan-Austrian Business Council for 2021
Armenian leadership shelled Tartar ignoring visit of diplomats - President's aide
Azerbaijani currency rates for Oct. 29
China's premium car buyers drive VW back to profit
All news