UK experts: Armenia’s Metsamor power plant - historical anomaly

UK experts: Armenia’s Metsamor power plant - historical anomaly

Baku, Azerbaijan, May 16

By Elena Kosolapova - Trend:

Armenia's Metsamor power plant is an historical anomaly, and arguably should never have been placed on a seismic fault line, William Arthurs, member of the British Institute of Energy Economics and Ziba Norman, director of the UK Transatlantic & Caucasus Studies Institute, told Trend May 16.

Armenia has a nuclear power plant, Metsamor, built in 1970. The power plant was closed after a devastating earthquake in Spitak in 1988. But despite the international protests, the power plant's operation was resumed in 1995. Moreover, a second reactor was launched there.

"Its placement is more to do with Soviet concepts of progress than a careful and considered approach to Armenia's energy needs," the UK experts added. "If such a plant were being designed today, in accordance with safety regulations, it would never be placed in such a location."

The accidents at Fukushima and Chernobyl, in different ways, mirror the possible risks borne by those living in the vicinity of Metsamor, according to the experts.

Arthurs and Norman noted that both Metsamor and Fukushima nuclear power plants are located on an area of intense seismic activity - 1988 being the most recent example, a 6.8 magnitude earthquake, the epicentre of which was only 100 kilometers from Metsamor.

"Thus, even if Metsamor were to be upgraded with an additional containment structure, of the type in operation at Fukushima, Metsamor would remain vulnerable to a Fukushima level 7 nuclear accident," said the experts.

The risks posed by the Metsamor power plant are not therefore theoretical and, like Chernobyl, the spread of radioactive materials in the event of an accident would cross national borders, they added.

Arthurs and Norman pointed out that Yerevan itself is a capital city only 20 kilometers from the aged plant, while Turkey is a mere 15 kilometers away from that power plant and there are fertile agricultural lands in this region.

"It is almost inconceivable that a plant as aged as Metsamor (commissioned in 1976) is still being used to provide a major source of energy for Armenia," said the experts. "To continue attempted upgrades, whilst fully aware of the unacceptable risks it poses to Armenia itself and the region is beyond shortsighted and could be considered negligent."

They noted that the international community do have important interests at stake, as the fallout (as in the case of Chernobyl) does not respect national borders.

Arthurs and Norman pointed out that the main question the decision takers should be asking themselves is: would such a plant be commissioned in this location today?

"If the answer is "no", then a continued attempt to keep Metsamor in use is a dangerously poor decision," they added.

The experts said that Armenia is a small area geographically, which could be rendered uninhabitable if an accident at the power plant were to occur.

In a region as energy-rich as the Caucasus it seems a cruel irony that Armenia might stake its very existence, simply for a failure to acknowledge the need for alternative energy supplies, they added.

Furthermore, a sustainable approach to Armenia's energy needs would enhance cooperation in the region, and is therefore win-win; keep Armenia and her people safe, and aid long-term economic prosperity in the region, according to Arthurs and Norman.

"None of this will be possible without an acknowledgement that energy self-sufficiency based on nuclear power may simply not be a realistic option in this region," the experts added.


Follow the author on Twitter: @E_Kosolapova

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh begins 3-day visit to Dushanbe to attend SCO meet
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh begins 3-day visit to Dushanbe to attend SCO meet
Turkmenistan, Tajikistan sign protocol of tenth meeting of the intergovernmental commission
Turkmenistan, Tajikistan sign protocol of tenth meeting of the intergovernmental commission
Central Asian countries discuss  implementation of climate policy in region
Central Asian countries discuss implementation of climate policy in region
Loading Bars
Azerbaijan’s representative offices in Israel - important platforms for expanding business contacts, minister says
Foreign currency demand of Azerbaijani banks declines
Azerbaijani historical, architectural monuments destroyed during Armenian occupation - Academy of Sciences
Weapons, ammunition found in Azerbaijan’s Khojaly district
New prospects for economic cooperation opened between S.Korea, Azerbaijan - ambassador
Meet Alumni of British School in Baku
Database and co-op expanding to intensify work of Azerbaijani-Israeli commission - minister (PHOTO)
Baku court announces verdict to members of Armenian sabotage group
Turkmen Energy Ministry extends tender for power plant construction
Iran launches its Yazd-Eqlid railway line
Another working visit organized to Azerbaijan's liberated Aghdam (PHOTO)
Turkey reveals 1H2021 cargo movement figures via local ports from Belgium
Total assets of Int'l Bank of Azerbaijan grow in 2Q2021
Azerbaijan working to approve boundaries of Bershbarmag mountain security zone
Armenia creating incidents on border with Azerbaijan to evade obligations under trilateral statement - analyst
Newly-created Azerbaijani insurance company becomes member of AIA
Signify focusing on cybersecurity of products, systems, services - Eric Benedetti
Destroyed houses in Azerbaijan's Fuzuli - very depressing sight - Moscow Bar Association member
Trade-economic contacts between Baku, Minsk maintained despite COVID-19 - Belarusian speaker
Azerbaijan provides necessary equipment for work with livestock on liberated lands
Turkey discloses 1H2021 volume of cargo shipment through Ambarli port
Oman extends nightly COVID-19 lockdown
With strong sales, Tesla defines Israel as priority market
International Bank of Azerbaijan sees growth of 2Q2021 liabilities
Kazakhstan twofold increases exports to Poland
Uzbekistan eyes building copper-processing plant at mining and metallurgical complex
Ford raises 2021 profit outlook, eyes shift to build-to-order
Iran shares data on its package for support of non-oil exports
Opening of Azerbaijan's trade mission in Israel - historic event - ambassador
Kyrgyzstan, Japan discuss cooperation in IT sphere
TotalEnergies sees decrease in hydrocarbon output for LNG
Turkmenistan's Dashoguz region preparing for wheat crop sowing
France decreases import of Kazakh-made goods amid COVID-19
Japanese corporation interested in production of ‘green hydrogen’ in Georgia
Azerbaijan inaugurates trade representative office in Israel's Tel Aviv
TotalEnergies to spend 50% of growth investments on renewables, electricity
Turkmenistan boosts import of chemicals from Turkey
Terrorism is the most serious threat to international peace: Rajnath Singh at SCO meet
Indian Navy's new submarines will cost $1 bn each
Antony Blinken, PM Modi Discuss Efforts To Deepen US-India Global Partnership
Few relationships globally more vital than US partnership with India, says Blinken
US Secretary of State expresses gratitude towards India for providing assistance in COVID pandemic
Lending activity in Azerbaijan gradually recovering - Russian expert
Oil prices to retreat to $65-$70/b range in 2022
Turkey sees increase in clothes export to Uzbekistan
Apple's net profit almost doubles in 3Q2021
Global oil demand to surpass 2019 levels in Q4 2022
Turkish Yenisafak online newspaper starts publishing articles of Trend News Agency in English (PHOTO)
Oil market to face deficit in 2021, shift to surplus in 2022
Turkish company to build gas piston power plant in Uzbekistan’s Khorezm region
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for turnkey construction of gas chemical plant
Russia organizes another charter flight from Turkmenistan
Winner of tender announced by Azerbaijan's Treasury Agency for repair services disclosed
Cargo movements in Iranian ports up
Azerbaijani oil prices increase
Baku Metro opens tender to purchase aluminum tires, cable lugs
Azerbaijan Army complying with ceasefire in Kalbajar direction - MoD
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale July 31
Azerbaijan notes growth in precious metals prices
Shell may need to curtail oil & gas production in Q3
Azerbaijani currency rates for July 29
Co-op of Azerbaijan's Accounts Chamber with WB yields good results
Azerbaijan reveals total volume of mortgage loans issued since 2006
Turnover on payment cards grows in Azerbaijan
Number of payment cards in Azerbaijan continues to grow - Central Bank
ECO Park in Tehran - symbol of common cultural traditions of member states - ambassador
Austria to organize trade mission to Azerbaijan
Israeli remote IT management co Atera raises $77m
Airbus raises forecasts after strong first half
US condemns recent escalation of violence along border between Armenia, Azerbaijan
Georgia reveals compensations provided to citizens unemployed due to COVID-19
Six BHOS graduates receive scholarships from German government
Turkey announces company eligible to reserve spot Caspian gas
Non-energy goods - main trade products of Azerbaijan and Russia - ministry
Russian Defense Ministry signs contract on first 10 S-500 air defense systems
Uzbekistan publicizes COVID-19 data for July 29
Kazakhstan’s KazTransOil opens tender for electrical distribution equipment repair
Azerbaijan identifies measures to create green energy zone
Azerbaijan’s Baku Telephone Communications, AZinvest Telecom Technology sign contract
Oil edges higher on inventory drawdowns, Brent tops $75 a barrel
Facebook reports Q2 results with doubled net income
Croatia, Azerbaijan have great potential for co-operation in renewable energy sphere – minister (Interview)
Boeing reports Q2 results with 44 pct revenue increase
Samsung expects strong chip demand to continue in H2 after robust Q2 results
Armenia again violates ceasefire by shelling positions of Azerbaijani army - MoD
Portuguese gov't releases 320 mln euros to help companies recover
Hanwha Life Insurance net more than doubles in Q2
All EU member states committed to building quantum communication infrastructure
WHO reports "sharp" increase in COVID-19 deaths
Canada's building construction prices rise in second quarter
WHO chief says to enhance cooperation with Kuwait
France's new health pass rules to enter into force on Aug. 9
India sends another Oxygen Express to Bangladesh
India To Have Submersibles That Can Carry Scientists To Depth Of 6,000 Metres Into Sea - Minister
Dr Reddy's Says Made-In-India Sputnik V Doses To Be Available From September-October
Indian Astronomers On Team Which Spotted Shortest Gamma-Ray Bursts From Dying Star
Iran, Austria stress judicial, human rights cooperation
Need effective mechanism to address global vaccine inequity - India in UNSC
Harappan city of Dholavira in Kutch among UNESCO’s world heritage sites
Bipartisan group of U.S. senators reportedly agree on infrastructure package
All news