Google criticizes EU over 'eye-catching' $2.6 billion antitrust fine

Google criticizes EU over 'eye-catching' $2.6 billion antitrust fine

Google on Friday called on Europe’s second-top court to throw out what it called an eye-catching 2.4 billion euros ($2.6 billion) EU antitrust fine, saying there was no factual or legal basis to the inflated amount, Trend with reference to Reuters reports.

The Alphabet unit argued that additional amounts tacked on to the fine imposed by the European Commission in 2017 to deter anti-competitive behavior known as a deterrent multiplier and another multiplier factor was excessive and unwarranted.

Google’s challenge came on the final day of a three-day hearing at the General Court, Europe’s second-highest, as it attempts to overturn the first of a trio of EU antitrust penalties totaling

“2.4 billion euros is an eye-catching amount, it might attract the headlines but it is not justified by the actual facts of this case,” Christopher Thomas, Google’s lawyer, told judges.

He said there should not have been a fine in the first place as existing case law showed that Google’s behavior was not anti-competitive while its market shares and the 13 countries where the infringement was committed did not justify the size of the multiplier.

The Commission used a gravity multiplier between 5 to 20% to Google’s 2016 turnover in the 13 EU countries, higher than the 5% levied on Intel in 2009. EU laws allow for regulators to apply a multiplier up to 30%.

EU antitrust regulators should also have taken into account the company’s efforts to settle the case with concessions before they changed tack in 2015 and sanctioned Google, Thomas said.

“Credit should be given for Google’s good faith attempts to find a solution to the Commission’s concerns with its three commitments offers and the almost 9 months engineering effort spent building that solution provisionally agreed with the Commission,” he said.

EU enforcers merely stuck to the rules when calculating the fine, Commission lawyer Anthony Dawes said.

“The Commission scrupulously followed the methodology set out in the guidelines. Google’s conduct constituted a well established form of abuse,” he said.

Irish judge Colm Mac Eochaidh, one of the panel of five judges hearing the case, asked whether the size of the fine was as eye-catching as Google claimed.

“You are one of the richest companies in the world,” he said. “Would you miss the 2.4 billion euros?”

A ruling is expected next year and can be appealed to the Court of Justice, Europe’s highest.

Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly actual topics in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Weekly tenders in the region (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Last week’s laws, orders and decrees in Azerbaijan (April 16-20)
Loading Bars
Latest
134 more die in Iran from COVID-19
OPEC will invite US oil regulator to online meeting on April 6
Azerbaijan’s Baku City Circuit among best F1 circuits of 21st century
Georgia takes measures to lead economy out of crisis
Australia does not recognize so-called “elections” in Nagorno-Karabakh
Rouhani: Iran to facilitate release of necessary goods from customs
Volumes of benzoyl transshipment through Turkish ports disclosed
US helps Uzbekistan to fight coronavirus
Uzbekistan in talks with US to remove country from Jackson-Vanik amendment
Kazakhstan announces wheat, flour volume allowed for export
EBRD pledges urgent financing for Azerbaijani companies
Volumes of diesel transshipment through Turkish ports revealed
Azerbaijani center talks about new exclusive opportunities
AsiaMoney magazine names best digital bank in Uzbekistan
Russia transfers more test systems to Azerbaijan to carry out research on COVID-19
More than 15 million masks produced in Iran
Iranian Red Crescent Society to help the unemployed
Volumes of hexane transshipment through Turkish ports disclosed
Prices for gasoline, diesel fuel decrease in Georgia
Volume of LPG transshipment via Turkish ports revealed
SMS permission to go out does not apply to individuals over 65 in Azerbaijan
Geostat: Consumer Price Index increases in Georgia
Compulsory insurance payments in Azerbaijan up in February 2020
Kazakhstan’s Pavlodar refinery opens tender to attract repair services
Top five countries importing Azerbaijan's non-oil products disclosed
Azerbaijani president attends inauguration of pedestrian crossing at intersection of Moscow Avenue and 20 January Street (PHOTO)
TAP continues all engineering, procurement and construction activities amid COVID-19
Presentation of system related to special quarantine regime held in Azerbaijan
Uzbekistan's Asaka Bank gets recognition from popular European publication
NATO deepens partnership with Georgia
Kazakhstan to construct prefabricated hospitals to battle coronavirus spread
TAP plans to introduce first gas in Albania and then in Italy in coming weeks, months: Murad Heydarov
Azerbaijan's State Border Service: Armenian provocation in direction of Gazakh suppressed
Azerbaijan to ban taxi services via private cars during coronavirus quarantine period
SOCAR discloses volume of investments in Southern Gas Corridor
Kazakhstan's GDP growth may slow down given oil & gas production reduction
Uzbekneftegaz continues to increase gas production of Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani currency rates for April 3
Gold price up in Azerbaijan on April 3
43 more test positive for COVID-19 in Azerbaijan, 6 recover
TOP-10 state non-oil exporting companies in Azerbaijan
Britain's coronavirus peak will be in next few weeks
Kazakhstan's defense industry ventures start medical equipment manufacturing
ADB makes forecast on economic indicators of Georgia
TOP-3 products of Azerbaijan's non-oil export revealed
OPEC+ ministers to hold videoconference
China advises foreign diplomats to stop coming to Beijing
Uzbekistan reports more new COVID-19 cases
Turkmenistan, Ukraine decide to hold regular consultations between MFAs
Number of COVID-19 cases reaches 148 in Georgia
Use of SMS mechanism for elderly for permission to leave home in Azerbaijan explained
Saudi Arabia may seek US, Canada to be part of oil output cut
Third major Kazakh city to be quarantined, to stop coronavirus spread
Fitch Solutions: Dual demand & supply shock puts oil industry in severe stress
Most popular mobile device in Azerbaijan named
Coronavirus to hamper oil and gas projects in emerging economies
Android retains leadership in Azerbaijan's operating systems market
Iran's startup giant Digikala faces rise of online demands amid coronavirus spread
Google releases location data to show if coronavirus lockdowns working in 131 countries
How coronavirus-ready is Iran's telecommunication infrastructure?
SMS messages required to leave home in Azerbaijan during coronavirus to be paid for by state
Azerbaijan's export of goods via “single window” significantly up in March 2020
Payments by foreign bank cards drops in Azerbaijan
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 25 times
Export of Turkey's defense products to world markets down
New Zealand confirms 49 new cases of COVID-19
9 more coronavirus cases detected in Kazakhstan
COVID-19 death toll hits 299 in Brazil, infections reach 7,910
Mexican official says no plans for border closures, as death toll rises
First coronavirus death in Kyrgyzstan
Chinese mainland reports 31 new confirmed COVID-19 cases
S. Korea reports 86 new virus cases, total tops 10,000
UAE reports 210 new COVID-19 cases, 1,024 in total
China to mourn COVID-19 victims on April 4
White House likely to advise people in coronavirus hot spots to wear masks
Global COVID-19 infections exceed 900,000: WHO
Peru, Panama limit men and women to alternate days out to stall virus
First patient under 40 years of age dies from COVID-19 in Moscow
Syria reports 6 new COVID-19 cases
U.S. Navy relieves commander of coronavirus-stricken aircraft carrier
Trump tested again for coronavirus, result was negative -White House
Spain's coronavirus deaths rise above 10,000, yet there is 'glimpse of hope'
Confirmed coronavirus cases top 1 million globally
France's coronavirus death toll jumps as nursing homes included
Georgia reports 134 confirmed cases of coronavirus
Italy reports 760 coronavirus fatalities, 1,431 recoveries in a day
COVID-19 deaths in Turkey rise to 356
Number of global coronavirus fatalities achieves 50,000
Saudi Arabia calls to urgently discuss oil market situation
Iran’s parliament speaker Larijani tests positive for coronavirus
Operational Headquarters of Azerbaijani parliament holds another meeting
Export of cars from Turkey down from January through March
Operational Headquarters under Azerbaijani Cabinet of Ministers decides on movement restriction
IFC takes measures to support business amid coronavirus outbreak
Azerbaijan's Azerenergy reconstructing major strategically important substation
Reserves of Kazakhstan's National Fund decrease
Ambassador: Azerbaijan greatly supported China in most difficult period
Iran mulls over resuming activities in various sectors
Turkmenistan improves national insurance system
Azerbaijan’s large industrial corporation temporarily suspends its activity
All news