Brazilian says he shot U.S. nun out of fear, rage

Other News Materials 23 October 2007 04:07 (UTC +04:00)

(MSNBC) - The gunman convicted of killing American nun and rain forest defender Dorothy Stang told the jury at his retrial Monday that he shot her out of fear and rage, court officials said.

Rayfran das Neves Sales was sentenced in 2005 to 27 years in prison for shooting Stang six times with a .38-caliber revolver on a muddy road deep in the heart of the Amazon rain forest that same year. Brazil grants an automatic retrial for any sentence longer than 20 years in prison.

Stang, a 73-year-old from Dayton, Ohio, spent the last 30 years of her life defending poor settlers in the violence-plagued rain forest region and prosecutors say two ranchers hired Sales to kill her because of a dispute over a piece of forest they wanted to clear for pasture.

Many see the trial as a test of Brazil's commitment to prosecuting the sort of land-related killings that have taken more than 800 lives in Para state alone. Only a handful of killers have ever have been convicted.

Sales "admitted firing the shots, but denied he was contracted by anyone to do it and said he killed her because she had threatened him," court spokesman Gloria Lima said in a telephone interview from Belem, the capital of Para.

"His argument is basically an attempt to get a lighter sentence," Lima added.

Prosecutor Edson Cardoso de Souza told the official government news agency that "nobody with even average intelligence" would believe Sales felt threatened by the elderly woman.

Sales' lawyer Cesar Ramos told Agenica Brasil that his client was never paid for the killing and said, "When she threatened him ... he lost his emotional balance."

Sales' testimony also seeks to clear rancher Vitalmiro Bastos de Moura, who was convicted in May of ordering Stang's killing and sentenced to 30 years in prison. Moura's automatic retrial is set for Thursday.

Two accomplices convicted in the killing received sentences of less than 20 years and do not get retrials.

Another rancher, Regivaldo Galvao has also been accused of ordering Stang's killing but remains free on bail with no trial date set.

In various depositions, Sales has sometimes implicated the ranchers and sometimes denied they had anything to do with the killings.

At the first trial, Sales said he shot Stang after he mistook the Bible she was taking out of her bag for a gun.

Prosecutors allege Moura and Galvao offered Sales and his accomplice Clodoaldo Carlos Batista $25,000 for the killing.

A Brazilian Senate commission found it was part of a wider conspiracy involving a number of ranchers, but only Moura and Galvao have been charged with orchestrating the shooting.

Only two witnesses for the defense are expected to testify at the trial which is expected to end Tuesday.

Prosecutors have called no witnesses and expected to rely on earlier testimony and a videotaped reenactment of the crime which shows Sales firing an empty revolver at a woman standing in for Stang at the murder site.

David Stang, the victim's 70-year-old brother, flew in from Colorado to attend the trial. "This case today is about ending impunity," he said in telephone interview from Belem. "I'll keep coming until justice is done."