U.N. Human Rights chief to leave post

(The Washington Post) - Louise Arbour, the top U.N. human rights official, will step down on June 30, according to sources close to her, ending a four-year term that has been highlighted by confrontation with the Bush administration over the Iraq war, the death penalty and U.S. efforts against terrorism.

Arbour, 61, declined to confirm whether she will leave the post of U.N. high commissioner for human rights. But in an interview Friday, she said the U.S.-led counterterrorism struggle has set back the cause of human rights by "decades" and has exacerbated a "profound divide" between the United States, its Western allies and the developing world. "The war on terror has inflicted a very serious setback for the international human rights agenda," she said.

Kristen Silverberg, the U.S. assistant secretary of state for international organization affairs, said it is "wrongheaded to suggest" the war on terrorism is the critical human rights issue of the times. "We would like to see the high commissioner focus more of her attention and criticism on totalitarian and abusive governments," she said.

Arbour, a former U.N. prosecutor of war crimes who secured the indictment of the late Serbian leader Slobodan Milosevic, said bedrock principles once taken for granted - including the prohibition against torture - have been eroded, and that what she considers as Washington's excesses have undercut her efforts to crusade for human rights, particularly in places where political repression is greatest.

Human rights advocates largely praised Arbour, a former Canadian Supreme Court justice, as a tough, principled lawyer who has offered the United Nations' most forceful critique of the United States' use of harsh interrogation techniques and the transfer of suspects to countries where they stand a chance of being tortured. They note that she has done more to expand the presence of U.N. rights monitors around the world, making reports on abuses from Baghdad to Katmandu routine.

But she has also been a lightning rod for American conservatives, including the former U.S. envoy to the United Nations, John R. Bolton, who scolded her in 2005 for using Human Rights Day to criticize U.S. anti-terrorism tactics instead of highlighting rights abuses by countries such as Burma, Cuba and Zimbabwe. Even supporters say she has trod lightly over abuses by some of the most powerful U.N. members, including China and Russia, leaving the United Nations increasingly silent on one of the world's most pressing human rights issues.

Silverberg said the Bush administration was disappointed that Arbour had not spoken more critically of human rights abuses in Iran during a recent trip there, and accused her of making a "modestly approving statement about progress in human rights in Cuba, which is ludicrous." She also faulted Arbour for speaking "favorably" about an Arab declaration on human rights that was biased against Israel. "We would like to see a much stronger approach," she said.

Arbour acknowledged that she has taken a more diplomatic approach to promoting human rights in places such as China and Russia, saying that she has chosen a strategy of private engagement "that is likely to yield some positive results" over one that "would make me and a lot of others feel good." She said that as a U.N. official she is constrained by the reality of the organization's power centers, including China, Russia and the Group of 77, a bloc of more than 130 developing countries. In that context, she said, "naming and shaming is a losers game."

Arbour's departure, first reported Wednesday by Reuters, comes at a time when critics are questioning the United Nations' reputation as a moral authority. A new U.N. Human Rights Council, established by member governments two years ago to reinvigorate the organization's human rights efforts, has ended up undermining them. The council, which includes some of the world's worst human rights abusers, has scaled back scrutiny of abuses in countries such as Belarus and Cuba. It has devoted most of its energy to castigating Israel. The United States has declined to join the council, although it provides it with financial support.

But Arbour took issue with congressional critics, particularly Ileana Ros-Lehtinen (Fla.), the ranking Republican on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, who implied that Arbour was responsible for the council's failing and in a statement Thursday said Arbour had a record of "condemning democracies and defending tyrants."

Arbour said the statement revealed "ignorance" of the United Nations' inner workings. "There is nothing I could have done," to ensure continued scrutiny over Cuba and Belarus, she said. "The Human Rights Council speaks for itself."

Arbour has told friends that she is leaving to spend more time with her family, and also to avoid a bitter political battle over a major anti-racism summit next year in Durban, South Africa. The United States, along with Israel and Canada, has already announced it will boycott the event, saying it believes it will be a forum for unwarranted criticism of Israel.

Arbour's influence in the United Nations has diminished since the departure of U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan, who made human rights a major priority of his tenure and frequently relied on her counsel on a range of issues. She has often seemed out of step with his successor, Ban Ki-moon, who views public diplomacy on human rights as grandstanding.

Ban has also been more sympathetic of U.S. counterterrorism policies, and has faced resistance from Arbour over his plans to expand the United Nations' role in Iraq and his efforts to avoid the debate on the death penalty.

"She is not his style," said Kenneth Roth, executive director of Human Rights Watch. "Now, does he recognize that the post needs someone who is not his style? Big question. I think it will be essential that the next high commissioner be someone who insists on his or her independence and on his or her public voice."

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Oil rebounds above $71 on Omicron hopes, Iran talks
Oil rebounds above $71 on Omicron hopes, Iran talks
Bob Dole, longtime U.S. senator, presidential candidate, dies at 98
Bob Dole, longtime U.S. senator, presidential candidate, dies at 98
Iran abandoned any compromises in latest nuclear talks - U.S.
Iran abandoned any compromises in latest nuclear talks - U.S.
Loading Bars
Latest
Balacans Agro Food LLC, Azerbaijan Investment Company sign agreement (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan to consider joining int'l documents on intellectual property protection
Oil majors to mitigate demand fluctuation with digital twins
SOFAZ sees significant increase in Shah Deniz revenues
Azerbaijan shares data on number of freed convicts as part of act of amnesty
Annual inflation rate slightly slows down in Kazakhstan
SOFAZ discloses revenues from Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli
Azerbaijan shares data on number of people covered by Act of Amnesty so far
TBC Capital publishes Georgia’s weekly economic review
Oil rebounds above $71 on Omicron hopes, Iran talks
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva meet with residents of Gonagkand settlement
Israeli firm to sell HSBC Tower in New York for $855 million
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for December 6
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva view conditions created at newly built Culture House in Gonagkand
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva view conditions created at secondary school № 1 in Guba
President Ilham Aliyev, First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva attend opening of Guba Abad Factory enterprise (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev inaugurates Guba-Gonagkand highway
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva view conditions created at Guba Olympic Sports Complex
Crisis center discloses 32,136 new coronavirus cases in Russia over past 24 hours
Chevron to expand investments in Kazakhstan’s Tengiz field dev't
Famous scientist talks about significance of victory in Azerbaijan’s Karabakh (PHOTO)
Iran shares data on cargo transportation
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva arrive in Guba district for visit (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan prepares bill on repatriation of people to Karabakh – state committee
Azerbaijani State Oil Fund’s estimates on oil, gas transportation revenues for 2022 unveiled
Azerbaijan gives update on mine clearance work in liberated lands
Azerbaijan’s 10M2021 volume of goods exports via stationary vehicles increases
State Oil Fund of Azerbaijan forecasts revenues and expenditures for 2022
Azerbaijan’s forecast for oil production from Bahar field in 2022 revealed
Cargo movements in Iran’s Noshahr Port down
India, Russia to ink number of pacts during Modi-Putin summit on Dec 6
India clears plan to make AK-203 assault rifles with Russia
Georgia to reduce external debt and budget deficit in 2022 – PM
From buyer of military goods, India wants to become Russia’s ‘development & production’ partner
Georgia, US discuss wine exports potential
EU, UNDP to implement project for green economy transition in Uzbekistan
Imperial Springs Forum 2021 concluded (PHOTO)
Private investment to pick up: CEA Krishnamurthy V Subramanian
Bangladesh, India: Celebrating 50 years of friendship
Georgia's coal production up
Uzbekistan shares data on sales of oil and gas products in 11M2021
Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan sign trade contracts and bilateral agreements
Azerbaijan shares forecast on volume of oil production from ACG field for 2022
Iran records increase in cargo transportation via Bushehr International Airport
bp presented laboratory to be named after Nobel Prize winner
Azerbaijan provides with insurance payments heirs of martyrs, soldiers wounded due to Armenian provocation on Nov. 16
Azerbaijan projects growth in gas production from Shah Deniz field in 2022
Iran sees decrease in number of new mines
Volume of loaded/unloaded cargo in Iran’s Anzali port climbs
EIA names factors triggering wider spread between sweet and sour crude oils
Azerbaijan to install seismic stations in liberated lands until 2025
VISA talks investments in dev’t of its own IT-technologies (Exclusive)
‘Tripartite contract’ could turn Iran into regional transit center - Iranian president
Iranian President talks about nuclear discussions
Financial market of Azerbaijan – review of week’s main events
Equinor to acquire 45% stake in Noriker Power Limited
Iran's SATBA reveals details of country's renewable energy generation
Iran's NIORDC to sign contract for producing dual-fuel taxis with local manufacturer
Private investors in Iran apply to boost renewable energy development countrywide
New economy building must be ensured in Azerbaijan's Karabakh - president's special representative
Azerbaijan reveals insurance payments to heirs of servicemen who died in helicopter crash
Azerbaijan pays great attention to dev’t of innovations, technologies - executive power
Iran to unveil plan for development of rail fleet for its mines
TAP’s technical forward capacity by Dec.12
Only innovative technology-based enterprises to function in Azerbaijan's liberated lands - deputy minister
Physical gas flows, nominations at TAP’s interconnections
Azerbaijan creating innovative financial, banking services in Karabakh
Participants of Second Karabakh war, families of martyrs living, working in Azerbaijan’s liberated territories to be provided with benefits
Negotiations with several enterprises to attract investors to Aghdam industrial park nearing completion – deputy minister (PHOTO)
Iran eyes increase in activities in Chabahar port
Iran records increase in exports from Gilan Province
Turkey discloses cargo shipments via its ports from Bulgaria in 10M2021
Azerbaijan eyes several directions for innovative development of liberated areas - deputy minister
UK to require travelers from Azerbaijan to submit negative PCR test
Iran sets increase of monthly salary in budget bill for next year
Decision makers in Iran realize going forward without JCPOA is wrong - analyst
Iran negotiating with Russia to lift bell pepper export restrictions
Pace of LNG supply growth in Asia forecast to slow down
Mariana Vasileva expresses gratitude to President Ilham Aliyev, First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva
Iran set to reform its insurance sector
Iran relying on domestic car manufacturers to increase production by 2025
Global LNG sector poised to post healthy export growth this year
Georgia releases COVID-19 data for December 6
Iran planning to increase steel production for domestic needs and export
Iran to reform rules for startup companies to participate in stock market deals
Azerbaijani currency rates for December 6
Iran hopes to raise local car manufacturing
Iranian currency rates for December 6
CAMEX International launches cargo airline in Georgia
Overall index of the Tehran Stock Exchange drops on December 5
Turkey reveals cargo traffic via its ports from US for 10M2021
Azerbaijan shows footage from Kalbajar's liberated Kechiligaya village (VIDEO)
Uzbekistan shares domestic COVID-19 data for December 5
Turkey discloses number of docking ships at Bandirma port for 10M2021
Azerbaijan discloses turnover of investment companies for 11M2021
Uzbek Direct Investment Fund and South Korean company co-op to attract investments
Cargo movements in Iran’s Bushehr port up
Iran shares data on exports via customs of Semnan Province
Azerbaijan interested in Turkish "Hürkuş" trainer aircraft - Turkish Defense Industry
Cargo transportation via Iran's Kerman International Airport soars
All news