Bipolar gene test causes stir

( AP )- Dr. John Kelsoe has spent his career trying to identify the biological roots of bipolar disorder. In December, he announced he had discovered several gene mutations closely tied to the disease, also known as manic depression.

Then Kelsoe, a prominent psychiatric geneticist at the University of California, San Diego, did something provocative for the buttoned-down world of academic medical research: He began selling bipolar genetic tests straight to the public over the Internet last month for $399.

His company, La Jolla-based Psynomics, joins a legion of startups racing to exploit the boom in research connecting genetic variations to a host of health conditions. More than 1,000 at-home gene tests have burst onto the market in the past few years.

The proliferation of these tests troubles many public health officials, medical ethicists and doctors. The tests receive almost no government oversight, even though many of them are being sold as tools for making serious medical decisions.

Health experts worry that many of these products are built on thin data and are preying on individuals' deepest anxieties.

"People are always rushing to the market on the basis of one or two studies," said Dr. Muin Khoury, director of the National Office of Public Health Genomics at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "We have very little evidence that telling people their genetic information is going to make any difference."

Tests have become available claiming to help predict and diagnose everything from serious illnesses like cancer and Alzheimer's to athletic ability and a person's ideal diet. Psynomics' offering is one of the first psychiatric gene tests on the market.

Kelsoe, 52, acknowledges that bipolar disorder probably results from a combination of genetic factors and life experiences, and that the presence of these gene variations does not at all mean that someone will, in fact, develop the disease. He admits, too, that his findings about the genetic basis of the illness are far from complete.

But he said his test is a vital starting point toward moving away from the notoriously tricky practice of diagnosing bipolar disorder based purely on a person's behavior.

"The goal of this is to try and help doctors make an accurate diagnosis more quickly so the patient can be treated appropriately," Kelsoe said. "Anything is going to help, even if it just helps a little bit."

Bipolar sufferers experience intense mood swings as they cycle between manic, sometimes delusional highs and depressive lows that can lead to suicide if untreated. The disease is often misdiagnosed as other forms of depression, which delays treatment and can result in the prescribing of antidepressants that make some patients' symptoms worse.

To take the test, patients receive by mail a plastic cup that they spit into, seal and send back to Psynomics. The company analyzes DNA in the saliva.

Psynomics will send patients' test results only to their doctors to avoid the risk of self-diagnosis.

The report that accompanies those results instructs doctors that a positive test means patients are two to three times more likely to have bipolar disorder. But the studies from which those figures come also show the gene variations themselves are rare even among those with bipolar.

The report also points out that for now, the test is valid only for whites of Northern European ancestry who show some behavioral symptoms and have at least one other bipolar family member.

Patients taking Psynomics' bipolar test may feel branded by a positive result, even if they are not ultimately diagnosed with the disorder, said Hank Greely, a professor of law and genetics with the Stanford Center for Biomedical Ethics. Or they may feel false hope from a negative result, despite the company's disclaimers.

Likewise, doctors have little training beyond what companies tell them when it comes to applying the test results. "They may make a foolish decision that backfires to put you on meds," Greely said. "Or they may make a decision that backfires not to put you on meds."

Unlike many tests for other conditions on the market, Psynomics does not claim its bipolar test can predict a person's risk of developing the disorder later in life. It is meant to be used as a purely diagnostic tool for patients already showing symptoms.

That is an important distinction that makes the Psynomics test more responsible than others that promise a glimpse into the genetic crystal ball, according to Dr. Greg Feero, head of genomic health care at the National Human Genome Research Institute.

"Now you're talking about an individual who has symptoms or signs that already put them in a very different risk category than someone who has no symptoms or signs," Feero said.

Among hundreds of families Kelsoe has studied, one of the gene variations in the Psynomics test showed up in 1 percent of those unaffected by the disorder versus 3 percent who are affected. The other variation appeared in 7 percent of those without bipolar compared to 15 percent who have the disease.

Many other genes interacting with a patient's environment contribute to the development of bipolar disorder, Kelsoe and other researchers believe, meaning no single genetic variation ultimately causes the disease. Researchers in Kelsoe's lab are working to track down more genes.

"Why are we starting before it's finished? You've got to start somewhere," Kelsoe said. "Even if we knew everything about the genes, which we certainly don't, it's never going to be 100 percent predictive."

Psynomics has sold only a few tests so far but is projecting sales of 1,800 tests in 2008 and 30,000 in the next five years.

In coming months, at least two other startups led by genetic researchers are set to release their own psychiatric genetic tests. One test claims to predict the risk of developing schizophrenia. The other is designed to forecast the likelihood that some medications for major depression could heighten suicidal thoughts in patients.

The American Psychiatric Association has yet to create an official policy on genetic testing. A fact sheet issued by the Federal Trade Commission advises consumers to be wary of assertions made by at-home genetic testing companies.

The Food and Drug Administration does not evaluate the tests for accuracy, though a panel is working on a set of standards for the growing industry.

For now, worry persists that with the proliferation of tests, there is too little understanding of what to do with the results, or what they mean.

"We just don't know how people will use the information," said Dr. Jinger Hoop, a professor of psychiatric genetics and medical ethics at the Medical College of Wisconsin in Milwaukee. "We don't know whether it will be helpful to them in the long run."

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Kazakhstan decreases petroleum gas export to Hungary amid global pandemic
Kazakhstan decreases petroleum gas export to Hungary amid global pandemic
Militants kill 7 soldiers in Nigeria's northeastern Borno state
Militants kill 7 soldiers in Nigeria's northeastern Borno state
South Africa hit by fourth COVID wave driven by Omicron
South Africa hit by fourth COVID wave driven by Omicron
Loading Bars
Latest
Kazakhstan decreases petroleum gas export to Hungary amid global pandemic
Militants kill 7 soldiers in Nigeria's northeastern Borno state
Iran nuclear talks adjourn, resume next week
South Africa hit by fourth COVID wave driven by Omicron
Budget for social rehabilitation and childcare to reach 52 mln GEL next year, Georgian PM says
Putin informs Erdogan on main results of Sochi trilateral meeting
Turkey introduces action plan to improve lives of the disabled
Construction of 50MW solar power plant underway in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijani FM, OSCE rep exchange views on OSCE Charter (PHOTO)
Human remains discovered in Caspian Sea and recovered - SOCAR
Iran highlights need for more customs cooperation with Pakistan
bp discloses investments in construction of power plant in liberated Azerbaijani lands
Turkmen gas may be supplied to Europe via Caspian Connector project - ambassador
Turkish, Russian Presidents hold phone talks
Azerbaijan’s Pasha Holding talks about development strategy
Azerbaijan's Heydar Aliyev Foundation, UNICEF sign another memorandum of understanding (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijani, Turkish military pilots conduct joint training flights in Baku (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Azerbaijan confirms 1,703 more COVID-19 cases, 2,180 recoveries
Turkmenistan can supply natural gas to European market until 2050 - ambassador
Azerbaijan discloses export volume of petroleum coke
Azerbaijan's Finance Ministry to auction gov't bonds via Baku Stock Exchange
SOCAR begins testing of new mobile diving complex
Israeli co Fireblocks raising $400m at $8b valuation
Croatia remains one of Russia’s key partners in EU
Value of goods transported via road increases in Azerbaijan
U.S. job growth misses expectations in Nov.
Policy and Management Consulting Group shares data on Georgia’s economic outlook
Georgia, Qatar discuss favorable investment climate
Price indexes of financial, trade sectors at Uzbek stock exchange fall
Uzbekneftegaz obtains new industrial gas flow from Kulbeshkak field
Uzbek Statistics Committee shares data on imports of meat for 10M2021
Georgia’s economic climate remains stable – PMC
Uzbekistan reveals volume of bank loans allocated to various sectors of economy
Iran, Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan gas swap - win-win deal, says Iranian analyst
FMs of Azerbaijan, Poland hold meeting within OSCE Ministerial Council
Co-op between Turkmenistan, EU to focus on improving business climate till 2027
Azerbaijan's food import volume down for 10M2021
Zones free from animal diseases being created in Azerbaijan’s Karabakh, East Zangazur
Azerbaijan considers opening Indonesian Chamber of Commerce
Azerbaijan increases chemical production volume for 10M2021
Azerbaijan, Turkey begin work on establishing joint university - minister
Azerbaijan’s liberated territories have several types of renewable energy sources– RES agency
Azerbaijani parliament adopts amendment to servicemen insurance law
Azerbaijan may exempt sale of electric cars from VAT
Azerbaijan introduces excise taxes on electronic cigarettes, shisha
Concept for creation of "green energy" zone in Azerbaijan’s liberated territories prepared
Transaction to sell Chinese oil company’s stake in Azerbaijan closed
Output volume at Azerbaijan’s Kursangi, Garabagli fields revealed
Austrian interior minister becomes candidate for country’s next chancellor
Azerbaijan begins geological exploration at Tutkhun gold deposit in Kalbajar
Iran to import hay from Russia
Uzbek home appliance manufacturer Artel joins United Nations Global Compact
Economic stability - framework of Iran`s next year budget
BioNTech CEO confident of quickly adapting vaccine for Omicron
Situation is still fragile in South Caucasus - OSCE Chairperson-in-Office
Azerbaijan to strengthen social protection of population in 2022 – PM
Azerbaijan may exempt import of books and paper from VAT
Iran reveals its non-oil trade in 7 months
Iran aims to build new oil, gas refineries amid growing consumption
Uzbek Central Bank shares data on leading banks in terms of loans
Azerbaijani PM talks on measures to curb price increase
Iran seeks to establish joint banking network with Syria
Azerbaijan to expand agriculture dev’t in Karabakh in 2020 – minister
Demining of water basins in Azerbaijan's liberated Fuzuli, Aghdam underway - ministry
Azerbaijan removes electronic bracelets from 134 convicts within amnesty act
India seeks strong ties with EU, cooperation in transition to clean energy
Dubai's DP World pulls out of Haifa port privatisation bid
Azerbaijani Artillery Units hold live-fire exercises (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Azerbaijan to change state duties on issuing registration plates of road vehicles
Georgian business sector sees average monthly salary increase
Cementing ties with France, UAE places $19 bln order for warplanes, helicopters
Azerbaijan preparing development strategy for Karabakh - Karabakh Revival Fund (PHOTO)
Man of Armenian origin who attacked Azerbaijani soldier neutralized – MoD
Azerbaijan releases 14 prisoners from correctional institution № 16 as part of amnesty act (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan releases 122 prisoners from correctional institution within amnesty act (PHOTO)
Australia calls on Azerbaijan, Armenia to delimit and demarcate state borders
Azerbaijan sees growth of trading via Baku Stock Exchange
Azerbaijan to release 65 female prisoners within act of amnesty
Georgia’s domestic supply of natural gas slightly decreases
Azerbaijan clears almost half of "Araz Valley Economic Zone" Industrial Park of mines - minister
Azerbaijan releases seven prisoners within act of amnesty (PHOTO)
Azernews newspaper selected as media partner of ECO from Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
bp is first company to use flexible approach in management of energy resources during pandemic
Turkey’s fuel exports to Georgia plummet
EU firms in infrastructure sector spent higher share of their investment on energy efficiency
Azerbaijan to strengthen control over allocation of subsidies
Share of EU firms investing in improving energy efficiency falls
Partnered with Azerbaijani banks, VISA actively developing technologies for issuing digital cards
Azerbaijan expands list of goods not covered by VAT refund
Georgia’s electricity exports triple
Azerbaijan’s justice ministry talks number of people released under amnesty act (PHOTO)
Further strengthening of Azerbaijan's army is one of important tasks – PM
Azerbaijan discloses expenses on COVID-19 vaccination
Opening of Zangazur corridor is one of most important issues – PM
Azerbaijani Parliament adopts amendments to Tax Code
Over half of EU firms affected by physical climate change risks
Russia records over 32,900 COVID-19 cases in last 24 hours
Head of Azerbaijan’s State Border Service visits servicemen injured in recent helicopter crash
Average salary in Israel rises 2.9%
All news