Does a new treaty on European security have a future?

Does a new treaty on European security have a future?

Vladimir Ryzhkov for RIA Novosti

At a recent UN General Assembly in New York, President Dmitry Medvedev reiterated last year's proposal to draft and sign a comprehensive treaty on European security.

In the last few years, Russia has been frustrated by the international organizations in which it holds membership. They have been near idle, as with the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), or have reduced their activities to what Moscow considers interference in the internal affairs of Russia and other countries. The Council of Europe and, again, the OSCE have been monitoring elections, human rights, freedom of speech, etc.

These actions have been accompanied by NATO's eastward expansion, deployment of new weapons and renunciation of commitments under the Treaty on Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE) (for instance, the recently abandoned U.S. plan to deploy missile defense in Poland and the Czech Republic). In Moscow's opinion, these are attempts to guarantee one's own security at the expense of Russia and other countries.

Russia cannot accept NATO's claims to play the role of all but the only guarantor of security in Europe, the OSCE's reluctance to do anything regarding the first and second "baskets", or the unilateral policy of the United States, which has ignored not only the UN Security Council, but often even its own allies in Europe in the last few years.

Medvedev urged all concerned parties to draft and sign a legally binding treaty based on the principle of indivisibility of security, which would secure, in part, a commitment "not to guarantee one's own security at the expense of others." At a forum on international security in Evian, France, he suggested that the parties of the proposed treaty should assume the following commitments:

- reaffirm basic principles of security and interstate relations in the Euro-Atlantic space;

- consider the use of force or its threat in international relations unacceptable;

- provide guarantees of equal security for all;

- not to allow any state or international organization to have an exclusive right to the maintenance of peace and security in Europe;

- establish basic parameters for arms control and reasonable sufficiency in the military strength.

These general principles suggest that Moscow wants the United States and the West in general to give it legal guarantees on the following:

- cessation of NATO's expansion towards Russia's borders, primarily, Ukraine and Georgia's non-admission;

- renunciation of the deployment of new military hardware and facilities in Europe, imposition of ceilings on armaments, which can be changed only by agreement between the parties;

- legal and practical delimitation of the zones of responsibility (or spheres of influence) between major security organizations in Greater Europe - NATO, the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), OSCE and probably the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO);

- limitation of U.S. unilateral activity in the region, including in those countries which Moscow considers its "sphere of vital interests."

Speaking about the format of the new treaty, Medvedev suggested OSCE modernization, vesting it with new authority. He believes it should concentrate on the first "basket". In this case, as a pan-European organization, which includes Russia, OSCE could break NATO's emerging monopoly, and pursue a uniform security policy in the entire region. In other words, Medvedev suggested a Helsinki-plus agreement.

However, there are doubts that this most meaningful Russian initiative in the last few years will find enough supporters and be carried out, for a variety of reasons.

First, many countries do not share Moscow's opinion on the inadequacies of the existing security system. To the contrary, it fully suits the majority (not only the United States, but most of the European countries). Statements to this effect have already been made by the U.S., EU High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security Policy Javier Solana, and by other high-ranking officials. They suggest more active use of existing mechanisms, such as the NATO-Russia Council, OSCE, and a permanent dialogue between Russia and the European Union.

Second, it does not seem worthwhile to establish a new organization, when members of the existing ones violate their commitments (recognition of Kosovo, Abkhazia and South Ossetia, Russia's failure to comply with its commitments in the Council of Europe, NATO's unilateral actions, etc.)

The main problem is not the structure of these organizations but the lack of trust and mutual understanding between their participants. This often blocks decision-making in the UN Security Council, paralyzes the OSCE, and the NATO-Russia Council, and obstructs dialogue between Russia and the EU and in the Council of Europe. Any new organization could also be paralyzed in much the same manner.

Conclusion of a new treaty requires a consensus between all states of the Euro-Atlantic region. Would it be signed by Serbia, Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan without revising the decisions to recognize Kosovo, Abkhazia, and South Ossetia, or without settling the Nagorno-Karabakh issue? Are such a revision and such settlement possible? Without these countries, and another dozen states with unsettled grievances, how would a proposed new treaty be comprehensive?

The new security treaty is unlikely to materialize. At the same time, the discussion of its proposed provisions may be useful in specifying the positions of the parties, in their consideration in practical policy, in enhancing the effectiveness of the existing organizations and formats of cooperation, and in establishing cooperation between international organizations that never cooperated before (for example, NATO, the CSTO, and the SCO). Such debates could facilitate an elaboration of a much needed spirit of trust and mutual understanding. Dialogue between Russia and the EU can play a key role in this process. In 2003, they agreed to build a common security space. It is essential to seal this agreement in the new Russia-EU Treaty, which is now being drafted by Moscow and Brussels.

Vladimir Ryzhkov is a member of the presidium of the Council for Foreign and Defense Policy, professor of the Higher School of Economics.

The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of Trend .

Azerbaijan eyes to launch WeChat payment solution
Azerbaijan eyes to launch WeChat payment solution
Uzbekistan, Ireland consider establishing co-op in tourism sector
Uzbekistan, Ireland consider establishing co-op in tourism sector
Iran hopes Gorgan-Aktau flight to boost its tourism industry
Iran hopes Gorgan-Aktau flight to boost its tourism industry
Loading Bars
Brazil sees nearly 2,500 more COVID-19 deaths
UN Secretary General calls for de-escalation in Israeli-Palestinian conflict
Australia installs record number of solar panels
Bitcoin down more than 15% to $46,800
EU launches zero pollution action plan
Norway removes AstraZeneca from COVID-19 vaccination program
NCOC looking to commence Marine Access Channels Project implementation
Israel reports 30 new COVID-19 cases, 839,030 in total
Germany lifts quarantine requirement for COVID-vaccinated travelers
UK records another 2,284 coronavirus cases, 11 deaths
Gaza Strip death toll from Israeli strikes rises to 65 - Health Ministry
Lavrov, Blinken discuss Russia-US summit, agree to meet in Reykjavik
Airbus to supply Uzbekistan with four H125 and H130 helicopters
Iran’s non-oil exports up 80% in current year: Industry min.
Sinovac allows its COVID-19 vaccine to be made in Turkey
FM Zalkaliani confirms one Georgian injured in Israel
Azerbaijani President made post on Ramadan Holiday (PHOTO)
WHO records over 643,000 new daily cases of COVID-19 worldwide
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva shared footages of fireworks organized in Shusha on her Instagram page (VIDEO)
President Ilham Aliyev lays foundation stone for school No1 in Shusha
President Ilham Aliyev views work done at Shusha Art Gallery
Azerbaijani president, first lady view administrative building for Special representation in Shusha
Azerbaijani president, first lady view building for Shusha Creative Center
President Ilham Aliyev inspects Khan gizi Natavan’s palace
President Aliyev views conditions created at block and cottages under “Khari Bulbul” hotel
Azerbaijani president, first lady inaugurate “Khari Bulbul” hotel after renovation (PHOTO)
Holiday prayers will be held in Yukhari Govharagha mosque tomorrow - President of Azerbaijan
I never seen city like Shusha elsewhere in world. There probably isn’t one - President of Azerbaijan
For all these years, we lived with one goal – to liberate our lands, says Azerbaijani president
Azerbaijani culture, prominent representatives of Azerbaijani culture returned to Shusha today - President Aliyev
Next year we will celebrate 270th anniversary of Shusha - President Aliyev
44-day war is our glorious history - Azerbaijani president
“Kharibulbul” festival will now be held in Shusha every year - President Aliyev
After long break, “Kharibulbul” festival being held in Jidir Duzu, we have been looking forward to this day for 30 years - President Aliyev
Montenegro eases COVID-19 restrictive measures
Senior Hamas commander killed as Israel strikes Gaza, Palestinians fire rockets
Anti-Trump Cheney removed from House Republican leadership
Transport Ministry shares data on ships received in southern Turkish port in 1Q2021
Ministry discloses volume of cargo from Israel handled by Turkish ports
Volume of cargo from Greece handled by Turkish ports revealed
Wix reports higher Q1 revenue, lower profit
BMW plans limited series hydrogen fuel cell SUV in 2022
Georgian economy expected to grow
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to increase
More data needed before COVID-19 vaccine booster decisions - EU regulators
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for May 12
European Court of Human Rights to examine Convention violations by Armenia against Azerbaijan
Oil production volumes down in Kazakhstan
Bayati Shiraz mugham performed on Jidir Plain in Azerbaijan’s Shusha (VIDEO)
Deputy Governor of Iran’s Ilam Province talks about energy sector
Construction of Georgian Namakhvani HPP to be suspended
WB supports Georgian MSMEs and promotes digitalization of country’s economy
Azerbaijan confirms 558 more COVID-19 cases, 1,454 recoveries
Collection of notes of works by Azerbaijani composers prepared by Heydar Aliyev Foundation presented at Shusha Music Festival (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Iran discloses volume of bony fish caught in Caspian Sea
Kazakhstan's oil output below plan for 4M2021
Need to restore transport route to Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic - obvious - Russian expert
Activities in Iran’s Bushehr Province increase
Turkey’s export of clothes to Azerbaijan up from January through April 2021
Turkmenistan, China to consider opportunities for developing co-o in number of areas
Iran to manufacture local equipment in drilling sector
Fuel costs in Georgia increase
I was thinking about architecture of new mosque in Shusha for almost few months - President Aliyev
There used to be 17 mosques in Shusha, hated enemy destroyed all of them - President Aliyev
Georgia reports 1,409 new cases of coronavirus for May 12
We returned to Shusha and we returned forever - President Aliyev
Business activity index slows down in Kazakhstan
Geostat reveals TOP-5 suppliers of oil in Georgia
Iran’s PMO declares data of cargo transportation in Bandar Lengeh Port
Turkey’s export of steel to Kazakhstan decreases
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for May 12
Azerbaijani president, first lady attend opening of “Kharibulbul” festival in Shusha (PHOTO)
Trade ministry discloses volume of electrical goods exported by Turkey to Iran
Turkey’s export of cement to Turkmenistan down
President Ilham Aliyev visits restored “Khan gizi” spring in Shusha (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev lays foundation stone for new mosque in Shusha (PHOTO)
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva attend inauguration of 110/35/10 kV Shusha substation (PHOTO)
French Development Agency to support economic dev't of Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan holds Kharibulbul music festival (VIDEO)
UAE to help Sudan secure all petroleum needs through flexible agreement
Similarweb completes NYSE IPO, at $1.6b valuation
Kazakhstan observes slowing down of food inflation
Azerbaijan’s export of plastics doubles
Turkey sees increase in export of cement to Iran
Russia reports over 8,200 daily COVID-19 cases
Norway will not use AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine
Turnaround timeframe at Kazakhstan's Kashagan field unveiled
Turkish airline companies to launch direct flights to Kazakhstan
Dostlug field to allow Turkmenistan to export natural gas to Western countries
Kazakhstan-Latvia trade plummets y-o-y
Refining volume remains practically unchanged in Kazakhstan
Gazelli Group standing beside Azerbaijani nation both in hard and good times (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan’s largest logistics terminal operator to buy fuel via tender
Iran plans to increase exports of non-oil products – Deputy Minister
Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan's SOCAR have huge potential for developing co-op
Kazakhstan boosts goods import from Afghanistan
Azerbaijani PM expresses condolences to Russian counterpart
Volume of loaded, unloaded cargo in Iran’s Shahid Bahonar port up
EIA increases forecast for oil extraction in Kazakhstan
Iran's trade turnover with EAEU member states announced
All news