TRANSFER PRICING: General overview, global trends and perspectives in Azerbaijan

TRANSFER PRICING: General overview, global trends and perspectives in Azerbaijan

Baku, Azerbaijan, Dec. 23


By Rashad Abbasov

Most recently the draft law introducing significant amendments to the Tax Code which also includes TP, has passed from first reading of Azerbaijani Parliament and presumably will be sent (or may be already sent) to the President to sign into law.

Although there have been some media reports on certain aspects, no exact scope of expected TP changes in the law at this stage is identified nor it is known whether these TP changes would be substitute for or complement to current market price rules. Below is a brief summary on the essence of TP, common practice and the most recent international trends in TP and also a comparison of OECD recognized TP principles with Azerbaijani market price rules. We will also address a rationale for adopting detailed TP rules in the Azerbaijan tax system.

General understanding of transfer pricing

With a rise of multinational enterprises (MNEs), a significant part of today’s global trade consists of transfer of goods and services, capital (money) and intangibles within a MNE group or controlled parties affecting several tax jurisdictions. Such transactions between controlled parties are called controlled transactions. As a general rule, whether or not parties are controlled, are analyzed based on a substance over form principle. Thus, the existence of formal ownership structure is not a prerequisite - parties are treated controlled if they are effectively controlled directly or indirectly by the same interest.

Since parties to the controlled transactions share the same economic interests as a group, there is concern that these transactions between them may not always be governed by market driven forces only. Rather, such a transaction may be structured in the best possible ways to meet specific needs of the group, for example, to minimize “tax cost” by reducing worldwide effective tax rate (“ETR”) of the group.

In order to illustrate this concern, let us consider following simple example. Suppose Company A is a tax resident of country A while Company B is a resident of country B. They both are wholly owned subsidiaries of Company C, a tax resident of country C. Corporate income tax rate in country A is 20% while the same tax rate in country B is 35%. Company B produces certain widgets and it finds a would-be buyer, Company D located in Country D. Assuming that production cost of these widgets are USD 10, Company B may make a profit of 40 should it sell these widgets directly to Company D for USD 50. Then, tax payable in Country B would be USD 14 (40 X 35%). In such a case, ETR of the group would be 28% (USD 14/USD 50). Since Company A and B are controlled by the same interest- Company C, in order to reduce the group’s ETR Company C may instruct Company B to sell widgets to Company A for USD 20 and then Company A to sell directly to the buyer for USD 50. In this scenario, profit of a Company B would be USD 10 (20-10) and Company A 30 (50-20). Converting it to a payable tax amount, it would be USD 3.5 for Company B (10 X 35%) and USD 6 (30 X 20%). Total taxes payable by the group will be USD 9.5 while it would have been USD 10 had Company B sold directly to the buyer. In terms of ETR, the group might be able to reduce its ETR down to 19% from 28%.

In the light of the above said, it is not difficult to see why it is a key priority of the governments to make sure that the right price or “transfer price” is charged in the controlled transactions between controlled parties. The “arm’s length” is widely used principle to ensure that the right price is charged in these controlled transactions. The authoritative statement of this principle is determined in paragraph 1 of Article 9 of the OECD Model Tax Convention based on which vast majority of the bilateral tax treaties signed worldwide. This principle follows the approach of treating the members of an MNE group as operating as separate entities rather than as inseparable parts of a single unified business. [1]

The cornerstone of the arm’s length principle lies in comparability analysis which focuses on the nature of the transactions between the controlled parties and compares whether conditions of these transactions differ from those that would be obtained in comparable uncontrolled transactions. In this regard, several transactional and profit TP methods are used to establish whether the conditions imposed in controlled transactions are consistent with the arm’s length principle. It has been observed that transactional methods, especially CUP (“Comparable Uncontrolled Price”), are preferred over profit methods in tax jurisdictions with relatively younger TP regimes and vice versa in the jurisdictions with mature TP regimes. Nevertheless, the best practice suggests that choice of methods should be based on a “best method” rule and no strict priority of methods shall be prescribed, and no method shall invariably be considered to be more reliable than others. That is to say, arm’s length result of a controlled transaction must be determined under the method that provides the most reliable measure of an arm’s length result given the particulars of each case.[2]

Most recent trends in international tax arena-TP documentation

Given its importance, it is not a surprise to see transfer pricing as one of the hot topics in international tax arena. In 2013, OECD and G20 countries adopted 15-point Action Plan to address base erosion and profit shifting (“BEPS”). The aim of the Action Plan is to ensure that profits are taxed in those tax jurisdictions where economic activities generating these profits are performed and where the value is created. One of the actions (Action 13) is dedicated to TP, namely Guidance on Transfer Pricing Documentation and Country-by-Country Reporting.

Action 13 replaces Chapter V (Documentation) of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations. Previous Chapter V was adopted in 1995 and imposed certain compliance requirements to the MNEs in that some documents must be reasonable used or relied upon by the taxpayer to make sure that arm’s length price is charged in controlled transactions. Since it did not provide a clear guidance on a number of issues (such as the list of documents to be included in TP documentation, TP documentation process), many countries adopted their own TP documentation rules in order to address these shortcomings in the OECD TP Guidelines. This, in turn, made the TP compliance for MNEs more costly since MNEs were obliged to prepare a separate set of documentation in each tax jurisdictions.

Action 13 aims to address these shortcomings and to provide tax administration with sufficient information to perform a TP risk assessment, as well as to unify TP documentation rules over several tax jurisdictions. It identifies three objectives of TP documentation-(i) to ensure that taxpayers follows TP rules in establishing prices in controlled transactions, as well as they report income derived from such transactions; (ii) to provide the tax authorities with sufficient information so that they are able to conduct adequate TP risk assessment and (iii) to provide tax administration a starting point in performing TP audits.

In order to achieve these objectives, Action 13 adopts a unified approach to TP documentation and instructs MNEs to have the following documents in place:

Master file-provides information on legal and ownership structure and geographical location of operating entities, description of MNE’s business(es), MNE’s intangibles, MNE’s financial and tax positions. It should be reviewed annually and updated, if necessary, by the tax return due date for the ultimate parent of MNE group;

Local file-provides information of each specific controlled transaction. It is to be prepared no later than due date for the filing of the tax return for the fiscal year

Country-by-country report (“CbCR”)- provides information on global allocation of income, paid taxes and certain indicators of the location of economic activity among tax jurisdictions. The date for completion be extended to one year following the last day of the fiscal year of the ultimate parent of the MNE group.

Master file is aimed to assist tax administrations in evaluating the presence of significant TP risk while local file serves to assure that the taxpayers has complied with the arm’s length principle in their TP positions. As per CbCR, it is designed for high-level TP risk assessment purposes.

Action 13 goes on suggesting full TP documentation requirement in the local file to be applicable only those transactions meeting specific materiality thresholds, establishment of which are up to individual countries.

Action 13 includes a number of other provisions concerning penalties, language of the documentation, confidentiality and retention of the documents by the taxpayer.

Status of TP in Azerbaijan

Although Azerbaijan does not have TP rules, it does have market price rules, which may be taken as a similar concept to TP to certain extent. However, there are some fundamental differences.

The major deviation of market price rules from the TP is that while TP only targets controlled transactions between the controlled parties. Because in the controlled transactions there is a high possibility that structure of such transactions may be determined by a combination of market and group driven forces. However, the market price rules have much more extensive implications. Thus, the existence of controlled transactions is one of the conditions that may trigger market price rules along with the other four. It is very important to understand that in open market transactions, parties come up with adverse economic interests. Therefore, it is less likely that a price charged in these transactions will not be governed by market forces. Because current market price rules ignore this fact, even non-controlled transactions are exposed to the risk of being scrutinized by the tax office. In addition to compliance costs, this creates uncertainty for the businesses.

Furthermore, current market price rules specify only transactional methods and ignore the best method rule. Thus, they require comparable uncontrolled price to be applied first before utilizing other transactional methods.

The Azerbaijani market price rules also fail to address the TP compliance requirements and does not set a list of documents that the taxpayers must retain to justify that the prices charged in the controlled transactions are arm’s length. Therefore, it raises the concern whether a specific TP study produced by the taxpayer will be acceptable for the tax office.

As another shortcoming, the market price rules refer to official data sources, as well as databases of state and local executive authorities in order establish market prices of goods and services. Since these databases are not specifically tailored for TP purposes, as well as reliability and accuracy of this data may be questioned, there is a great concern that whether a produced result will always reflect “true arm’s length”.

Most recent global TP trends require Azerbaijan to have sophisticated TP rules in conformity with the internationally recognized standards for the country to become more investment friendly for MNEs. There is a number of other important reasons why Azerbaijan should have detailed TP rules. These may be summarized as follows:

  • It will preclude artificially shifting profits overseas;
  • It will eliminate double taxation of cross-border transactions and will ensure that Azerbaijani domestic tax rules are in compliance with the double tax agreements Azerbaijan is a party, which involves a provision similar to Article 9 (Associated Enterprises) in the OECD Model Tax Convention;
  • It will result in enhancement of transparency and certainty, since there will be clear “playing rules” both for the taxpayers and the tax office;
  • It will create the same playground for both MNEs and local companies running businesses in Azerbaijan.

Establishment of a TP legislative framework will have a significant impact to business environment. Given that, TP rules should be drafted based on the best practice, as well as TP experience of the countries with relatively similar (such as Russia, Kazakhstan, Ukraine, etc.) economic indicators to Azerbaijan should be taken into account.

Last but not least, great consideration must be given to the implementation of these rules. Smooth implementation of the TP rules requires tax administration to have adequate resources, in particular, existence of competent staff with specific TP knowledge. It also requires raising taxpayer's awareness of the TP rules.

[1] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administration, Chapter 1 the Arm’s Length Principle, B. Statement of the arm’s length principle.

[2] U.S. Treasury Regulations §1.482-2(c)

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Agreement with Azerbaijan on additional gas supplies aimed at ensuring Turkey's gas reserves – Erdogan
Agreement with Azerbaijan on additional gas supplies aimed at ensuring Turkey's gas reserves – Erdogan
Azerbaijan, Turkey ink deal for additional gas supply
Azerbaijan, Turkey ink deal for additional gas supply
Turkey confirms 31,248 daily COVID-19 cases
Turkey confirms 31,248 daily COVID-19 cases
Loading Bars
Israel's annual inflation up 2.5 pct, highest in nearly decade
Africa's COVID-19 cases surpass 8.41 mln: Africa CDC
US shares specific data on cybercrime with Russia, awaits its actions, White House says
Saudi Arabia appoints Al-Rabiah as new Hajj minister
Chronicles of Victory: President Ilham Aliyev interviewed by Turkish A Haber TV channel on October 16, 2020 (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Chronicles of Victory: October 16, 2020
Czech PM Babis pledges smooth power handover to opposition
UK MP dies after being stabbed at constituency meeting
China’s Shenzhou-13 manned spacecraft successfully reach orbit
Four migrants dead, 21 missing off Spanish coast
FIA approves schedule for Azerbaijan Grand Prix in 2022
COVID-19 kills 197 more Iranians over past 24 hours
Georgian FM meets Slovenian counterpart
Armenia trying to prepare ground for new provocations against Azerbaijan by spreading fake information - MoD
Azerbaijani FM discusses mine threat in liberated territories with French CNEMA delegates (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan lifts flight restrictions for number of countries
Azerbaijani President signs law "On Independence Day"
EBRD to allocate loan to Turkmen beverage company
Azerbaijan records decline in fixed capital revenues for 9M2021
Turkmenistan, WB talk new areas of co-op
Uzbek-Korean JV announces tender to buy clarifier
Gasoline prices in Georgia increase
Money transfers to Azerbaijan via Golden Crown service grow for 9M2021
Iran looking to develop renewable energy - SATBA
Azerbaijani MoD discusses mine clearing in liberated territories with French delegation (PHOTO)
Iran eyeing increase in trade with Spain
Export-oriented local Georgian company to get benefits within USAID program
Saudi Arabia to ease coronavirus curbs from Oct. 17
Russia, Venezuela developing secured messenger — Rostec
Kazatomprom to look for new ways to bolster nuclear energy for peaceful purposes
Turkmenistan discloses area allotted for sowing winter barley in Dashoguz region
Agreement with Azerbaijan on additional gas supplies aimed at ensuring Turkey's gas reserves – Erdogan
First container train on its way to Azerbaijan's Karabakh (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Uzbekneftegaz receives gas flow from well at Khojikazgan field
Kazakhstan to exempt Caspian oil exports from customs duties
Kazakhstan unveils data on trade with other EAEU states
Volume of financial assets of non-financial corporations in Georgia increases
LUKOIL Uzbekistan to buy ceramic balls for catalysts via tender
Azerbaijan, as victorious country, is ready to normalize relations. We hope that Armenian leadership will not pass up on this historic opportunity - President Aliyev
U.S. administers 405.4 mln doses of COVID-19 vaccines
Кazakh national telecommunications operator opens tender to buy spares
Geostat shares data on revenues of Georgian enterprises for 2020
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Netherlands’ FMO is open to new investments in Uzbek financial sector (Exclusive)
Azerbaijan confirms 1,850 more COVID-19 cases, 735 recoveries
Student of Baku Higher Oil School: ‘I am proud to bear the name of such a historical figure!’
French Renault begins production and commercial activities in Uzbekistan
NEQSOL Holding supports ADA University’s project to restore Gazakh Seminary (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan's agrarian agency discloses volume of issued subsidies in 9M2021
Money transfers to Georgia exceed investments
Russian peacekeepers - guarantors of peace in Karabakh - President Putin
Georgian air cargo transportation decreases
Azerbaijan ready to start talks with Armenia on delimitation of borders - President Ilham Aliyev
TAP helped in reducing European gas market volatility
Armenia has destroyed 16 of the 17 mosques in Shusha - President Aliyev
President Ilham Aliyev: Armenia refuses to provide us with full maps of mined areas
For about 30 years, Armenia, together with Iran, used former occupied territories of Azerbaijan for drug trafficking to Europe - President Aliyev
Illegal Armenian armed forces attempt new provocation against Azerbaijani units
Azerbaijan's State Employment Agency to launch project on financial support of entrepreneurs
President Ilham Aliyev hailed special role of President Vladimir Putin in cessation of hostilities in Karabakh
City of Aghdam was called “Hiroshima of the Caucasus” - Azerbaijani president
Karabakh conflict has been consigned to history - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan takes part in meeting of heads of security and intelligence agencies of CIS
Brent oil price on the ICE exchange up over $ 85/barrel
Iran seeks to transform its ports to transshipment hubs
Microfinance sector in Georgia hopes to rebound from COVID-19, shares forecast
President Ilham Aliyev attends CIS Heads of State Council's session in video conference format (PHOTO)
France's intention to take part in de-mining of Azerbaijan's lands - important, MP says
Death toll climbs to seven following fatal gun battles in Beirut
Azerbaijani ombudsman issues statement on anniversary of shelling of funeral procession in Tartar by Armenian troops
EBRD talks on financing of construction of high-voltage transmission line in Uzbekistan
Israeli companies getting increasingly interested in Russian market — Lavrov
TAP compensated decreasing share of imports from Norway and other LNG to Europe
Azerbaijan’s Parliament adopts bill ‘On Independence Day’
Agriculture goods production increases in Kazakhstan
Turkmenistan’s cotton mill shares export data for 9M2021
Kazakhstan unveils data on local car insurance
Turkmen enterprise reveals volume of oil products shipped to consumers
Uzbekistan approves funding for dozen of scientific projects
Azerbaijan’s Parliament to send congratulatory letter to President Ilham Aliyev, First Vice President Mehriban Aliyeva
Azerbaijani agrarian agency talks female entrepreneurs provided with preferential loans
Uzbekistan reveals number of vaccinated citizens as of October 15
Kazakhstan boosts cargo transportation by road
USAID ready to continue investing in agriculture dev’t in Azerbaijan
JOCAP updates on offshore installation campaign for Absheron field
JOCAP details ongoing works at Azerbaijan’s Absheron gas field
Georgia shares data on COVID-19 cases for October 15
IEA lowers forecasts for Azerbaijan’s 2022 oil output
Georgian honey exports skyrocket, following COVID-ravaged year
Azersu OJSC eyes attracting investments for implementation of its projects
Oil prices climb on power boost, set for multi-week gains
Brand new iPhone 13 smartphones with 50GB free internet now available at Azercell Exclusive shops!
Georgia and International Labor Organization to launch new co-op programs
Kazakhstan eyes expanding share of exports of Russian trading house
Uzbekistan shares COVID-19 data for October 15
Turkmenistan, UN discuss strategic cooperation
Kazakhstan's Aktau port opens tender to buy electric valve actuator
Azerbaijan, Turkey ink deal for additional gas supply
SOCAR-STP certified by American Petroleum Institute for manufacturing products
Russia, Israel to coordinate efforts at UN to counter history revision
All news