Expert: Amended constitution of Kyrgyzstan may be excellent example for many countries

Expert: Amended constitution of Kyrgyzstan may be excellent example for many countries

Azerbaijan, Baku, June 1 / Trend V.Zhavoronkova /

If Kyrgyzstan's new constitution is accepted and starts to work, it can be a wonderful example for many countries, Freedom Radio expert on Central Asia Bruce Pannier said.

"I hope it all works out, because if it does, it will provide a splendid example for many countries, starting with Kyrgyzstan's neighbors in Central Asia, Pannier wrote Trend in an e-mail.

Kyrgyzstan is expected to hold a referendum on amendments to the constitution in late June. The amendments affect several areas, the main of which is the change of government in the country to the parliamentary system.

The new draft constitution has been developed by the interim government after the overthrow of Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev in April. Now Roza Otunbayeva is the head of the state.

Pannier believes the new draft of constitution is an interesting document and a bold experiment by Kyrgyzstan, moving to a parliamentary system of government.

Pannier thinks that Kyrgyzstan is the only one of the Central Asian countries that actually has the political maturity to make such a system work at this time.

The strong point in this is the change to a system where the prime minister, selected by parliament, has the real power, he added.

"The draft has provisions that ensure no one party can have more than 65 seats in the 120-seat parliament the draft constitution creates," Pannier said.

He said unlike the other Central Asian states, Kyrgyzstan does have experience with parliaments that included a good number of opposition representatives. Prior to the 2005 parliamentary elections the opposition always had somewhere around 20 to 30 percent of seats in the parliament.

The new arrangement called for in the draft constitution creates a system that makes debate on issues obligatory and helps prevent the appearance of an authoritarian government, he added.

However, in his opinion, the president's role in this system is not yet entirely clear.

The last-minute inclusion of the "transition period" that keeps Otunbayeva as president until January 1, 2012 was a bit troubling just because it seemed to be thrown in at the very end when it was too late for anyone to object, Pannier said.

"However, Otunbayeva's pledge not to run in presidential elections in December 2011 and her quitting the Social Democratic Party to avoid claims of partisanship are hopeful signs that she can be an honest broker in the formation of this new government," Pannier said.

Pannier regards as downside the fact that Kyrgyzstan has many (more than 100) registered political parties and movements. How many will cross the five-percent barrier and get seats in parliament remains to be seen, he said.

But how easy it will be for some of these various parties to reach agreement in this new parliament is the big question, Pannier said.  First Kyrgyz President Askar Akayev dissolved parliament in September 1994 because of the nearly incessant arguments among deputies that delayed passing legislation.

Pannier said one must add to this that Kyrgyzstan has a culture of personal power.

"People there identify more with an individual - Omurbek Tekebaev,  Roza Otunbayeva or  Feliks Kulov - more than with political parties," Pannier said.

The Kyrgyz people will accept the new system if they can see it is doing something that will lead to an improvement in the lives of the country's people, Pannier believes.

If the parliament does turn into a forum of endless debate, accusations and insults the people will turn against the system, he added.

"One must remember that Kyrgyzstan's people have twice in just over five years brought down the government," Pannier said. "The people may not have much patience, meaning this new government needs to act maximum efficiently."

Do you have any feedback? Contact our journalist at [email protected]

Kazakhstan's exports volume to Georgia increases multifold
Kazakhstan's exports volume to Georgia increases multifold
Kazakhstan’s daily COVID-19 case count stands at 1,584
Kazakhstan’s daily COVID-19 case count stands at 1,584
Belarus, Kazakhstan seek closer cooperation in exchange trade
Belarus, Kazakhstan seek closer cooperation in exchange trade
Loading Bars
Iran's NIDC declares number of drilled oil & gas wells
Iran unveils details of exports via Bilasuvar border checkpoint
Uzbekistan to launch charter flights from Russia to Tashkent
Chinese smartphone maker discloses amount invested in opening factories in Turkey
Buy/sell operations at Iran Mercantile Exchange revealed
Georgia's import of tubes, pipes, hollow profiles from Turkey increases
Body of Azerbaijani citizen killed on Turkish ship to be sent to his homeland soon - Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry
Israel to start COVID-19 vaccination for high school students
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 24
Azerbaijan confirms 568 more COVID-19 recoveries
Portugal votes for new president at height of pandemic
Expert talks promoting import of electric and hybrid vehicles to Azerbaijan
Turkmennebit opens tender for purchase of various equipment
Azerbaijan shows footage from Jomerd village of Kalbajar district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Sales of goods at Iran Mercantile Exchange spike
Iran reveals amount of loans issued to manufacturing companies
Georgia increases export of marine mammals, fish fats, oils and their fractions to Turkey
S&P talks about Azerbaijan's GDP growth in 2022-2024
Turkey set to receive second vaccine shipment from China soon
Russia records over 21,100 daily coronavirus cases
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
Kazakhstan's exports volume to Georgia increases multifold
Azerbaijan's strategic foreign exchange reserves increase year on year
Iran announces volume of sprat caught in Caspian Sea
Azerbaijan shares footage from Ashaghi Veysalli village of Fuzuli district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Consumption of steel products in Iran increases
3 injured as blast hits vehicle in Kabul
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
Georgia reveals data on exports of semi-finished products of iron or non-alloy steel to Turkey
Iranian companies join UN CTCN
Kazakhstan’s daily COVID-19 case count stands at 1,584
Weekly review of main events in Azerbaijan's transport sector
UK to quarantine visitors from nations with high COVID-19 risk
China rescues first person from Shandong gold mine: state media
Over 2 mln coronavirus cases registered in Colombia
Israel reports 4,550 new COVID-19 cases, 593,578 in total
Iran's Marun Oil & Gas Production Company manufactures certain equipment
Iran to begin COVID-19 vaccinations in coming weeks: President Rouhani
France registers 23,924 new COVID-19 cases, 230 deaths in one day
Turkmenenergo to sign new contracts with foreign companies
7.0-magnitude quake hits South Shetland Islands: CENC
Turkey reports 5,856 new COVID-19 cases, 2,424,328 in total
After first phone call, UK PM Johnson looks forward to working with Biden
UK records another 33,552 coronavirus cases, 1,348 deaths
WHO reports over 600,000 new daily cases of COVID-19
Azerbaijani, Turkish FMs discuss pirate attack on ship
Top Spanish general resigns over allegations of vaccination queue-jumping
Pirates hijack Turkish ship off coast of Guinea, one person killed
BMB Trade Group and Uzbek Saffron Research Center discuss saffron cultivation and processing
Trend TV shares video report from plundered during Armenian occupation Azerbaijani Zangilan
Belarus, Kazakhstan seek closer cooperation in exchange trade
Management of Azerbaijan's State Oil Company being improved - Decree
New staff of Azerbaijani SOCAR's Supervisory Board approved
Georgia's external merchandise trade down 14.8% in 2020
Turkey halts flights from Brazil due to new COVID-19 variant
Gas pressure in Iran's South Pars gas field projected to decrease
Iran's gas processing potential to increase
Portugal holds presidential election as COVID-19 cases spiral
Italy reports 488 coronavirus deaths and 13,331 new cases
Italy to rethink vaccine roll out if supply problems persist
US broadcaster, journalist Larry King dies aged 87
Russia signs deal with Turkey on vaccine production
Azerbaijani MoD issues footage from Kalbajar district's Gamishli village (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Manat exchange rate against dollar to remain unchanged - Standard & Poor's
Bahar Azadi gold coin price again falling in Iran
Azerbaijan considering issues of regional schools damaged during Karabakh War
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on January 24
State subsidy to increase from 10 to 15 GEL per 50 kg of wheat flour in Georgia
Goods transit via Iran's Bileh Savar on rise
Tax authorities of Kyrgyzstan, Russia discuss launch of joint project
Japan's COVID-19 death toll exceeds 5,000 as total cases surpass 360,000
Indian gov't confirms outbreak of bird flu
Azerbaijani president expresses condolences to Ukranian counterpart
Bulgaria to ease some COVID-19 rules, restaurants closed for now
COVID-19 vaccine delays may slow wider Irish roll-out, says PM
Azerbaijan confirms 705 more COVID-19 recoveries
WHO office in Azerbaijan discusses project on preventing deaths from COVID-19 pandemic
Uzbek-Korean Uz-Kor Gas Chemical to buy spare parts for water purifier via tender
Georgia increases import of vehicles from Turkey
Geostat reveals volume of ferroalloys exported from Georgia to Turkey
Iran oil export never reached zero - Iran's Oil Minister
Azerbaijani expert talks impact of recycling old cars on traffic jams
Weekly review of highlights in Azerbaijani ICT sector
Uzbekistan’s Uzpromstroybank reveals plans for strategic dev’t in 2021
WHO chief thanks India, PM Modi for 'support to global Covid-19 response'
Yukselish competition organizes webinar presented by Azerbaijani president's assistant (PHOTO)
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 23
Azerbaijan shares footage from Ashaghy Maralyan village of Jabrayil district (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Turkmenistan taking measures to further increase volume of cotton production
Iran to increase Shiraz municipality budget
Azerbaijani oil prices fall
Georgia sees decrease in COVID-19 cases
Russia reports 20,921 coronavirus cases over day, record low since November 11
Iran-Iraq-Syria transit route would improve economy - Iran's Minister of Road
Azerbaijan and Turkey ink MoU to support SMEs (PHOTO)
Karabakh's geography allows developing various tourism products - Azerbaijan Tourism Board
Standard & Poor's upgrades Azerbaijan's credit rating outlook
Georgian import of medical products from Turkey down
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for January 23
Brazil President Bolsonaro thanks PM Modi for 'sanjeevni booti' against Covid with Hanuman pic
All news