McConaughey, McG draw fouls in "Marshall" mishap

McConaughey, McG draw fouls in "Marshall" mishap

( - What should have been an inspirational story about fortitude and courage in the face of mind-numbing tragedy becomes a compendium of sports cliches in "We Are Marshall."

Although based on a true story, the studio development process has produced a film in which real-life characters feel thinly motivated and insubstantial and "composite" characters -- meaning fictional ones -- are nothing more than ill-conceived dramatic devices. Young men and sports fans represent the film's major audience, which is a shame because the story, properly told, should not be a sports movie at all. Yet line by line, scene by scene, the emphasis falls on the wrong things.

On Saturday evening, November 14, 1970, a charter jet carrying Marshall University's football team, its coaches, staff and boosters, returning from a game in North Carolina, crashed in the Appalachian Mountains minutes before its schedule landing in Huntington, W.Va. In a moment, an entire football program and the heart and soul of the small town vanished. No one survived.

The next year, a new football team took the field lead by head coach Jack Lengyel, an outsider hired by university president Dr. Donald Dedmon to rebuild the program. He used a mix of junior varsity and injured players who didn't make the North Carolina trip, walk-ons, basketball players and true freshmen, who in those days were only able to play because of an NCAA waiver. This is the story that screenwriter Jamie Linden (from a story by Cory Helms and Linden) and director McG (the "Charlie's Angels" films) fumble away with blatant sentimentality, poorly sketched characters and forced dialogue.

The first thing that puts you off is Matthew McConaughey's odd take on playing coach Lengyel. Outfitted in some of the worst examples of that era's clothing styles and sideburns that threaten to never quit, McConaughey ambles into the movie as if it were an off-kilter comedy. His reasons for eagerly pursuing for the job -- in reality he was the university's third choice -- are never explored. Instead, the movie accents his breezy self-confidence and quirky manners in his approach to people still in shock over the tragedy. This makes the coach come off as an opportunist or at least someone insensitive to the situation.

His assistant coach, Red Dawson (Matthew Fox), who missed the flight for a recruitment visit, is a real character with a real problem about stepping back onto the gridiron. The same goes for Nate Ruffin (Anthony Mackie), an injured linebacker who lost all his teammates but fights to continue the program. He is easily the movie's most vividly drawn character.

But the other characters dreamed up by the filmmakers -- Paul Griffen (Ian McShane), a father who lost his son in the crash; Annie (Kate Mara), a cheerleader engaged to his son; and Tom Bogdan (Brian Geraghty), wallowing in guilt that he missed the flight by oversleeping -- feel fraudulent from the get-go. Indeed, the cheerleader is completely extraneous.

Where the focus should be on how people find a way to go on with life, this film dwells excessively on Paul's bitterness over the university's failure to suspend the football program. While some town folks did feel that way, this was not the major issue the film would have you believe. Most people wanted a football team. Even President Nixon sent an encouraging telegram.

Instead of showing how the community sought to heal itself by re-investing emotionally in its team, the movie returns time and again to the football field to demonstrate how the new coach tinkers with the offense and gives pep talks. In other words, it turns into a movie about football.

Technical credits are adequate, but the football action falls short of the standards established by such films as "Any Given Sunday" and "Friday Night Lights." Runs, tackles and fumbles look staged. The editing further confuses things during plays with annoying cut-aways to shots of fans in the stands or coaches screaming on the sidelines. This is a movie destined to look at the wrong things.

2021 begins with victories, says President of Azerbaijan
2021 begins with victories, says President of Azerbaijan
Let no-one think that they may have special privileges - President of Azerbaijan
Let no-one think that they may have special privileges - President of Azerbaijan
War is over, Nagorno-Karabakh conflict consigned to history - President of Azerbaijan
War is over, Nagorno-Karabakh conflict consigned to history - President of Azerbaijan
Loading Bars
Significant number of currency exchange offices closes in Georgia
2021 begins with victories, says President of Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan's export of beverages nearly halves
CISCO eyes to apply smart lighting model in Baku
Let no-one think that they may have special privileges - President of Azerbaijan
War is over, Nagorno-Karabakh conflict consigned to history - President of Azerbaijan
Everything in liberated lands must be done in planned manner - President Aliyev
Main export-import data between Turkmenistan, Spain published
Amount of money saved in biotech field in Iran revealed
Air Arabia airline company returning to Georgian market
Restoration of the Karabakh region is high on my agenda - President of Azerbaijan
Industry, agriculture, non-oil sector, export opportunities, reduction of dependence on imports – all these factors created new reality today - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan's state agency talks current status of road construction to post-war Shusha (PHOTO)
Number of insignia awarded to Azerbaijan's transport workers in 2020 revealed
Kazakhstan decreases export of crude petroleum oils to Romania
Total speeds up renewables push with $2.5 billion investment in Indian solar power
Revenues of Georgian air navigation service provider down
Sale transactions in Georgia's real-estate sector may drop in Jan.-Feb. 2021
President Aliyev attends groundbreaking ceremony for two plants in Sumgayit Chemical Industry Park, inaugurates sheet glass factory (PHOTO)
Bombardier to overhaul Israel Railways carriages
Georgia may receive Pfizer vaccine in 1Q2021
Uzbekistan to receive Pfizer/Biotech vaccine against COVID-19
Iran’s Maskan Bank increases amount of loans issued in Zanjan Province
Analysts raise EU carbon price forecasts after bull run
COVID-19 vaccination may stabilize Azerbaijan's economy
Azerbaijan realizes most import operations via free convertible currency in 2020
Iran to fulfill commitments if JCPOA signatories return to negotiations - Atomic Energy Organization of Iran
USB cable manufacturing launched in Georgia
Azerbaijan records slight growth in 2020 export cargo railway freight
Iran expands manufacturing of equipment in oil sector
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for January 18
Georgia reveals volume of exported tangerines
Iran expects increase of trade with Syria
Vaccination from COVID-19 in Azerbaijan being carried out voluntarily
Turkmengas opens again tender for gas turbine compressor maintenance
German economy at risk of 'sizeable setback' if curbs extended - Bundesbank
Total passenger traffic by buses in Azerbaijan for 2020 disclosed
Kazakhstan boosts production of main precious metals year-on-year
Turkmen garment factory releases annual production data
Volume of foreign investments made in Iran's free trade zones announced
Iranian parliament's investigation of stock exchange, energy exchange dragging on
Kazakhstan reports drastic annual surge in international reserves
Azerbaijan's communication operator expands its coverage area (PHOTO)
Turkmen cotton-spinning factory names volume of output for 2020
Amazon to open two new hubs in Italy this year
Uzbekistan to introduce voluntary accreditation for medical organizations
Crypto currency mining in Iran requires transparency - local blockchain community
Kazakhstan sees increase in transporting cargo via internal waters
Companies based in Iran's Ardabil province ready to participate in restoration of Karabakh
Weekly review of main events of Azerbaijani transport sector
Uzbek currency rates for January 18
Devalued lari reduces microfinance market in Georgia
Meeting of Azerbaijan-Iran Joint Economic Commission underway in Tehran
Weekly review of highlights in Azerbaijan's ICT sector
New building of fire safety put into operation in Turkmenistan
Prices of precious metals in Azerbaijan decrease
Kazakhstan may launch gas stove production in co-op with Uzbek manufacturer
Transactions on Uzbek stock exchange increase despite COVID-19
Kazakhstan sees decrease in mutual trade with Kyrgyzstan over 11M2020
Import of products by air to Azerbaijan plunges in 2020
Azerbaijani Ministry of Economy talks tax revenues to state budget for 2020
Steel production in Iran rising up
Azerbaijan reveals last year's export, import volumes
Saudi Arabia will be able to reverse its1 mbd cut in April
Global diesel demand to break above 2019 levels in September 2021
Vaccine from COVID-19 used in Azerbaijan - most safe and effective - health minister (PHOTO)
Iran unveils data on its gas extraction
JP Morgan forecasts oil surplus in 1Q21, rapidly tightening markets thereafter
Azerbaijan shows footage from Merdinli village of Fuzuli district (VIDEO)
Iran's rising inflation affects foreign currency rate - analyst
EU gas storage up due to lower demand
Remittances from Azerbaijan to Georgia up
Georgian Nikora supermarket chain aims to increase its turnover
Uzbekneftegaz detects previously unknown layers of natural gas at Lower Surgil field
Airport in Uzbekistan extends tender for purchase of batteries
Airport in Uzbekistan extends tender for purchase of building materials
Georgia sees significant decrease in COVID-19 cases
UK teachers, police, shop workers could get vaccine in phase 2
President Aliyev sends letter to Kazakhstan's First President Nazarbayev
Azerbaijan unveils data on total exports for 2020
Weekly review of Azerbaijani oil prices
CNPC ready to expand mutually beneficial co-op with Turkmenistan
Kazakhstan’s oil-producing company opens tender to buy pipes
India gives Nepal 'iron clad' commitment on Covid-19 vaccine, supply schedule coming week
UK invites PM Modi to attend G7 summit in June; Boris Johnson likely to visit India ahead of summit
Israel can contribute to reconstruction process in Azerbaijan's Karabakh - Azerbaijani MP
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan consider opening new transport corridors
Prospects of Nakhchivan corridor - new dev't stage in post-blockade period -Azerbaijani MP
Indian government offers Nepal HADR training, capacity building
Uzbekistan to provide discounts for foreign airlines carrying pilgrims
Saudi Arabia interested in expanding investment co-op with Uzbekistan
Tourism not to reach pre-pandemic levels until 2023 in Georgia
Turkmenistan - supplier of polymer products for Russian plant
Azerbaijani MoD shares footage from Aghdam district's Khydyrly village (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Azerbaijan's Health Minister, Head of TABIB vaccinated from COVID-19 (PHOTOS)
Vietnam gives Foxconn unit licence for $270 million plant to produce laptops, tablets
Azerbaijani medical workers undergoing vaccination from COVID-19 (PHOTOS)
Coronavirus vaccination in Azerbaijan to kick off on Jan. 18
Azerbaijan leads in South Caucasus in terms of military power
Kazakhstan approves rules for categorization of hydrocarbon deposits
All news