Fund Investors Still Owe Spitzer a Big Debt Of Gratitude

( FOX BUSINESS )- New York Gov. Eliot Spitzer's fall from grace brought with it a chance for critics to kick him in the butt on the way out the door.

As pundits debated his legacy, the consensus seemed to be that he'll be more remembered as "Client No. 9" -- his purported designation with the Emperor's Club escort service that was exposed last week and led to his resignation, effective Monday -- than as the "sheriff of Wall Street," the guy who as New York attorney general took on the big investment houses and beat them into submission.

What you're hearing about Spitzer -- aside from the tawdry details of his costly trysts -- is that he was a bully who stopped at nothing to make his point, but often got nothing out of his most famous cases.

As attorney general, an office he was elected to in 1998 and 2002, Spitzer was able to reach multiple settlements with big investment firms, but he almost never got to the individuals behind the tainted research, bid-rigging and other bad actions that he was desperate to quash. Most of his individual prosecutions have either languished in court, or his targets have fended off the charges.

He was largely responsible for shining a light on the mutual fund rapid-trading scandals in 2003, which critics now say were a lot of noise about almost nothing, since few investors were directly hurt by the actions of the bad guys. Industry insiders cast him as a bully and the Securities and Exchange Commission said he overstepped his jurisdiction and actually hurt their actions, and those critics are now crowing about his downfall.

The truth, however, is that Spitzer's biggest, most lasting impact came in the fund industry, and in a lot of ways that ordinary investors don't think about and fail to appreciate. Moreover, by uncovering the fund scandals when he did, he saved Wall Street from a much larger problem that, in hindsight, would appear to have been an inevitable consequence of the bad behavior that was happening in the fund world.

To see why, let's revisit some Spitzer history and the lasting outcomes.

Early signs of scandal

In 2003, Spitzer started pursuing a case in which some mutual fund management companies were allowing hedge funds to rapidly trade in and out. The idea was "stale-price arbitrage," where an investor took advantage of the way mutual funds are priced to bet on the way an international fund would pop, based on the actions of the domestic market. In other words, if a big day in the U.S. appeared ready to give foreign markets a power boost, the rapid traders would jump into an international fund moments before the domestic market closed; they would capture the one-day pop and be out again.

The problem is that the funds had rules against quick turnarounds, and that ordinary investors were paying the freight -- the trading costs -- for every load-in and load-out.

Spitzer incorrectly characterized the bad acts as market timing -- there is nothing illegal about market timing; the problem was in giving some investors special trading privileges -- but correctly moved to root it out and to get any executive who had a hand in bestowing favors on certain customers.

The Spitzer-inspired actions, and subsequent step-up by an embarrassed SEC, stopped the covert trading cold. That's crucial because 2003 was the last year of a protracted bear market and near the beginning of a huge run in international and emerging-markets stocks.

Investment firms are notorious copycats; if they see one firm making money on a certain strategy, they want to follow suit. With the Street reeling from the bear market, firms would have been anxious to line up the deals, and the impact would have mushroomed. Billions would have been lost as the bad practices continued for several more years.

Lighting the way

Spitzer had some wild ideas too, at one point he suggested that fund boards should have to put management contracts out for bids every year -- a patently silly notion, because no firm would ever start a new fund again -- but the biggest changes stemmed from issues he brought to light and that other regulators and politicians then pushed along.

Most notably, today's shareholders benefit from stepped up compliance requirements and disclosure rules. Investors may not recognize that fund directors must now justify why they renewed a manager's contract, but directors realize that the decisions they make and the reasons for those choices will be scrutinized by shareholders and, more importantly, the plaintiffs bar, looking to make a case.

Requiring a majority of a fund's trustees to be independent also came from the fallout of the scandals.

"It's not the numbers in the settlement that matters," says Geoff Bobroff, a consultant, fund director and industry observer whose firm is based in East Greenwich, R.I. "Just look at the compliance function inside the world of mutual funds."

"The most significant lasting contribution is elevating compliance to a core fundamental priority. ... Don't look at the shops that had great compliance to begin with -- firms like Vanguard or T. Rowe Price -- but look at the small firms that didn't care much. ... Investors are safer in funds today, and there's no denying that Spitzer had a hand in that."

Kazakhstan boosts trade with Turkmenistan despite COVID-19
Kazakhstan boosts trade with Turkmenistan despite COVID-19
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of chemical products
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of chemical products
Turkmenistan’s Railways open tender for construction of railway station
Turkmenistan’s Railways open tender for construction of railway station
Loading Bars
Latest
Azerbaijan sends numerous appeals to int’l organizations about Armenia's war crimes
Bronze monument to world-famous Azerbaijani singer to be ready in a month - Trend TV
Command-staff exercises start in Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan garrison (PHOTO/VIDEO)
EBRD loan portfolio in Azerbaijan shrinks
Iran reveals volume of crude oil to be transported via Goureh-Jask pipeline
Iran, Italy to expand economic ties – FM
Saudia Airlines eyes return to profitability by 2024
Azerbaijan Innovations Export Consortium eyes to expand co-op with Turkic-speaking countries
EBRD's net profit declines in 2020
Activity of Heydar Aliyev Foundation today covers all important spheres of life in Azerbaijan - Russian MP
Novatek to complete Arctic LNG-2 construction one year earlier
Kazakhstan boosts trade with Turkmenistan despite COVID-19
Turkish ŞINLAK HOLDING eyes building solar power plant in Kazakhstan
Uzbek-Chinese JV opens tender for welding electrodes
Turkmenistan's Turkmengas opens tender for purchase of chemical products
Iran's FM discussing international issues with Pope (PHOTO)
Turkmenistan’s Railways open tender for construction of railway station
Azerbaijan's oil exports decline in 4M2021
Uzbek-Chinese JV opens tender for electrical spares parts
France, Germany and Spain strike deal over joint combat jet
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price again falling
Azerbaijan reports sharp increase in 4M2021 gas exports
Uzbek currency rates for May 18
Uzbekistan Railways notes decrease in net loss
Azerbaijan Economy Ministry cancels requirement of several taxpayers for non-cash payments
EBRD approves working capital loan to Kazakhstan companies operating chromium mine
WTL talks construction of DC, SDA units at Turkmenbashi Complex of Oil Refineries
Uzbekistan, S. Korea eye enhancing bilateral co-op in public security
Kyrgyz Republic’s SMEs Sector to Benefit from ITFC’s US $4 Million Line of Trade Financing Facility
Iran unveils production data of steel products
Germany implementing pilot agricultural project in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan announces number of citizens vaccinated on May 17
Azerbaijan's 4M2021 revenues from gasoline, diesel retails disclosed
Azerbaijan confirms 426 more COVID-19 cases, 515 recoveries
Iran has potential to become hub for home appliances export
Railway freight traffic between Kazakhstan, Lithuania grows despite COVID-19
Russia ready to assist Armenia, Azerbaijan in border delimitation issue - FM
Volume of Georgian wine exports and its value up
Iran continues to import COVID-19 vaccines
Majority of mobile communication operators in world to support eSIM by 2025 - GSMA Association
Several types of COVID-19 vaccines delivered in Turkmenistan
Active work underway on construction of Pskem HPP in Uzbekistan
Uzbekneftegaz repairs unit for gas purification from sulfur at Mubarek Oil & Gas Production dep’t
Money transfers to Georgia up in April 2021
Lithuania looks to resume regular flights to Kazakhstan - ministry
Kazakhstan boosts mining of iron ores
Unemployment rate down in Azerbaijan
Turkish ambassador meets with head of Turkey-Azerbaijan Interparliamentary Friendship Group (PHOTO)
Baku Boulevard to remain open during 2021 F1 Azerbaijan Grand Prix competition - Baku City Circuit
‘Nar’ team progresses to semifinal in ‘Brain Ring’
Value of chargeable services rendered to Nakhchivan's population in 4M2021 drops
Turkmenistan‘s Turkmenbashi oil refinery develops its industrial potential
Value of Azerbaijan's 4M2021 industrial production down
Kazakhstan’s Pavlodar Oil Chemistry Refinery to buy valves via tender
Indian Shilpa Medicare signs deal to produce Sputnik V
Petrochemical plants to be put into operation in Iran
Kazakhstan boosts imports of Belgium-made goods
EU agrees partial truce with U.S. over Trump tariffs
Dubai eases COVID-19 restrictions, allows full hotel capacity
Azerbaijan announces 4M2021 investments in fixed assets
Azerbaijan to hold auction for shares of joint stocks companies
Azerbaijan announces tasks for using renewable energies in electricity production
Georgia's electronics market shrinking
Cargo transportation volumes surge in Kazakhstan
GPON-based technology being introduced in villages of Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
Iran anticipates another JCPOA Joint Commission Meeting - MFA
No alternative to implementation of trilateral statement on Karabakh - Russian president
Azerbaijan preparing to vaccinate citizens with Russian 'Sputnik V' COVID-19 vaccine
Convention on simplification of customs procedures enters into force for Uzbekistan
Iranian Oil Minister talks about exports, contracts in oil sector
GSMA predicts growth in number of mobile service users in Azerbaijan by 2025
Polish company eyes producing packaging materials for automotive industry in Uzbekistan
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for May 17
Weekly review of Georgian's capital markets (May 10 through May 14)
Azerbaijan continues military exercises, with extensive use of maps (VIDEO)
Iran’s trade turnover with UK announced
Kyoto Convention enters into force in Turkmenistan
Investment in Iran's industrial sector increases
Georgian microfinance organizations reveal data on their profits
SOCAR Ukraine resumes premium fuel sales
Turkmenistan introduces changes to customs system
Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic sees annual increase in GDP
Train in Iowa hauling hazardous materials derails, catches fire
BTA announces extension of bicycle roads in Baku
Iran to determine condition of its joint oil fields with other countries
Armenian side reacting inadequately to process of clarifying border - President Aliyev
Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan reveals 4M2021 cargo transportation data
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
Azerbaijan continues mine clearance in liberated lands
Saudi Arabia lifts quarantine requirement for COVID vaccinated foreign visitors
Three people killed after knife attack in Urals
FGP-WPMP implementation progresses at Kazakhstan’s Tengiz field
India's Cumulative Vaccination Coverage Crosses 18 Crore Mark: Centre
Azerbaijani Nakhchivan's 4M2021 manufacturing value of agricultural products grows
Crude production at Kazakhstan’s Tengiz revealed for 1Q2021
Investment proposal submitted for White Dragon project involving TAP
Georgia reports 504 new cases of coronavirus for May 17
Uzbekneftegaz updates electricity supply systems at Shurtan oil and gas production dep’t
Kazakhstan-Romania trade down amid COVID-19
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
All news