Boeing-Northrop tanker war rages in media and Congress

( AP )- Northrop Grumman Corp and Boeing Co escalated their war of words on Wednesday over a $35 billion contract for 179 U.S. Air Force refueling aircraft that Boeing argues it should have won -- not Northrop and Europe's EADS.

The two sides have been fighting for the contract for years, but last month's decision by the Air Force to award the deal to Northrop and EADS, the parent of Europe's Airbus, did anything but end the debate. Airbus is Boeing's chief rival in the commercial sector.

Instead, it has sparked a whole new battle that is being waged in the hallways of Congress and the media.

Northrop issued a press release on Wednesday accusing Mark McGraw, head of tanker programs for Boeing, of making "a number of false assertions" in a letter to the editor of the New York Times and said it wanted to set the record straight.

It said the Air Force preferred the size and capability of the A330-based tanker it offered and stressed that its plane had been built, flown and tested. In contrast, Northrop said, the 767 variant offered by Boeing involved parts of various other 767 models and has not yet been built.

McGraw's letter accused the Air Force of changing the terms of the process in midstream to favor Northrop and its Airbus A330-based tanker, and not informing Boeing.

A day earlier, the Wall Street Journal published an editorial citing what it called "misguided calls on Capitol Hill for 'patriotism' in defense procurement."

Rep. Todd Tiahrt, a Kansas Republican, has proposed banning manufacturers from countries whose governments fail to spend at least two percent of gross domestic product on their own defense, from U.S. military contracts.

Tiahrt represents Wichita, where Boeing has a large plants that would have done work on the Air force tanker.

The Journal said any such legislation would bar companies from most of Europe and was certain to invite retaliation that could harm Boeing and other defense contractors, who have huge overseas sales. Other lawmakers have threatened to block funding for the Northrop contract.

"What's really going on is a familiar scrum for federal cash, with politicians from Washington and Kansas using nationalism as cover for their pork-barreling," the Journal wrote in its editorial.

Air Force acquisition chief Sue Payton said the process was "incredibly open and transparent and rigorous" and that both bidders had "a lot of opportunity to communicate with us."

For now, the Air Force has stepped back from the limelight to allow the Government Accountability Office, the arm of Congress that hears contract disputes, to review whether the service followed the rules when it made its tanker decision.

The GAO has until June 19 to announce a ruling.

Lawmakers are arguing over which of the two bids would have created more jobs, but the Pentagon says employment is simply not part of the acquisition decision under current laws.

Employment levels could be considered in defense acquisitions, but first Congress would have to change the law, Pentagon chief weapons buyer John Young said this month.

Both sides are briefing congressional aides on their respective proposals -- and how the Air Force evaluated them.

Air Force documents viewed by Reuters show that both companies received similar ratings in five evaluation areas, but Northrop's tanker was judged to be "advantageous" in four of the five.

Its scores were bolstered by superior aerial refueling capability, better marks for management of other programs, and studies which showed the Northrop tanker could accomplish a designated war scenario with 22 fewer tankers.

The documents revealed some weaknesses in the Northrop proposal, including concerns about adequate lighting for nighttime refueling operations, software integration and the defensive capabilities of the tanker, but evaluators said these issues could be resolved during the development phase.

Boeing's bid got lower marks due to concerns about its performance on other programs and the likely cost of developing the new 767 variant. Specific figures were redacted from the documents, but they indicated it would cost over $1 billion more to develop the Boeing tanker and Northrop's first four aircraft would be ready much earlier in the development phase.

Northrop is staffing a "war room" at its Washington office where its officials keep in close touch with suppliers and track every editorial and article written about the deal.

After an initial lower-key approach, Northrop officials are now challenging any "misstatements" they come across. Last week Northrop Chief Executive Ron Sugar went public to defuse what he called the "jingoistic" reaction to the contract.

An earlier sole-source deal for 100 Boeing 767 tankers collapsed in 2004 amid a procurement scandal that sent two former Boeing executives to jail.

John Hamre, deputy defense secretary under President Bill Clinton who now heads the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies, said the politicians should step back and let the GAO make a dispassionate decision.

"In this instance we should rely on experts -- held to a rigorous standard of objectivity and discipline -- to decide what we need," Hamre wrote in a memo dated March 17.

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
New World Order and India
New World Order and India
Turkey reveals volume of vehicles shipments between its Yalova, Italian Bari ports
Turkey reveals volume of vehicles shipments between its Yalova, Italian Bari ports
Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna expect data on shot's protection against new COVID-19 variant soon
Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna expect data on shot's protection against new COVID-19 variant soon
Loading Bars
Latest
Iran eyes developing national space industry
Azerbaijan once again achieves its goals at meeting in Russia’s Sochi - experts
Uzbekistan shares updated COVID-19 data
New World Order and India
Iranian currency rates for November 27
Azerbaijani oil prices decrease
Azerbaijan sees decrease in number of users per payment terminal in 10M2021
Iran, France to improve economic ties
Turkey reveals volume of vehicles shipments between its Yalova, Italian Bari ports
Georgia-China trade turnover up
Kazakhstan’s Ekibastuz GRES-2 power station opens tender to buy spares for engine
Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna expect data on shot's protection against new COVID-19 variant soon
“Armenian clan” guides European institutions (PHOTO)
Iran, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan sign tripartite MoU on railway cooperation
Turkey bans travel from 5 African countries over new COVID-19 variant
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan sign an agreement worth about $612 million
Kazakhstan has great potential to use high environmental standards in practice - AIFC
South Africa says travel bans over new variant unjustified
US announces travel restrictions over new COVID-19 variant
At least 19 dead, 32 injured after bus crash in Mexico
US company Moderna begins work on vaccine against new SARS-CoV-2 variant ‘Omicron’
Dozens of COVID-19 cases on flight from South Africa, Dutch authorities say
Top Iran diplomat calls for lifting of sanctions, days before Vienna nuclear talks
U.S. President Biden calls for intellectual property protection waivers on COVID-19 vaccines
WTO postpones major meeting over COVID-19 concerns - sources
Trilateral meeting in Sochi can be called historic - Chairman of State Duma Committee
487 illegal immigrants rescued off Tunisian coast: ministry
WHO names new COVID variant Omicron
Sochi meeting is tremendous step in right direction; Armenia must act quickly in order to intercept its abandoned priorities - experts
Turkey to support Qatar's regional and international goals: Shentop
Kazakh President holds talks with President of European Commission
Statement by President of Azerbaijan, PM of Armenia and President of Russia published
Georgia carries out judicial reform with support of U.S., MP Okhanashvili says
Iranian, Malaysian FMs discuss bilateral ties
Foreign Ministry comments on trilateral meeting of leaders of Azerbaijan, Russia and Armenia
Putin discusses results of meeting with President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev and Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan with Security Council
Vladimir Putin announces agreement on unblocking transport corridors between Azerbaijan and Armenia
Commission for delimitation of border between Azerbaijan and Armenia to be created
We numerously publicly stated that we are ready to start delimitation process - President Ilham Aliyev
After military hostilities ended, over 100 Armenian servicemen were returned to Armenian side - President Ilham Aliyev
Trilateral working group of Azerbaijan, Russia and Armenia to hold meeting next week in Moscow - Putin
President Ilham Aliyev ends his working visit to Sochi
Agreement reached on creation of mechanisms for demarcation and delimitation of border between Azerbaijan and Armenia before year end - Putin
Decisions taken at trilateral meeting in Sochi to contribute to safer and more predictable situation in South Caucasus - President Aliyev
Baku holds award ceremony of winners of second day of 28th FIG Trampoline Gymnastics World Age Group Competitions (PHOTO)
Kazakhstan records growth in remittances to Azerbaijan since early 2021
Russian gymnasts grab gold in synchronized trampoline at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Russian President, Azerbaijani President and Armenian Prime Minister make press statements (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Price indexes of financial, trade sectors at Uzbek stock exchange rise
US gymnasts rank first in synchronized trampoline among men at 28th FIG Trampoline Gymnastics World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Azerbaijan approves boundaries of protected zone of State Reserve of Shusha city
Russian gymnasts grab gold, silver, bronze in double mini-trampoline among men at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Russian-Turkish ceasefire monitoring center working hard - President Putin
French gymnast grabs gold in tumbling among women at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Best moments of second day of 28th FIG Trampoline Gymnastics World Age Group Competitions in Baku (PHOTO)
Uzbekistan building power unit complex for nuclear plant in Jizzakh region
Body of another Armenian serviceman found on Azerbaijan's liberated lands
Russian gymnast grabs gold in tumbling among men at 28th FIG Trampoline Gymnastics World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Footage of warm meeting between Azerbaijani, Russian presidents in Sochi (VIDEO)
Portuguese gymnast ranks first in individual trampoline at 28th FIG Trampoline Gymnastics World Age Group Competitions in Baku (PHOTO)
Russian gymnast ranks first in double mini-trampoline at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Georgia, Serbia working to strike a free trade agreement
Excellent conditions created for Azerbaijani students in Russia - President Ilham Aliyev
Cargo transportation volume between Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan revealed
Volume of freight traffic between Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan for 10M2021 revealed
Russian gymnast grabs gold in individual trampoline at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Turkey reveals volume of vehicle shipments between its Mersin, Italian Trieste ports
We characterize our relations with Russia as those of strategic partners - President Ilham Aliyev
Conditions being created for future normal life in region – Russian president
Finalists in synchronized trampoline jumping among women announced at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Azerbaijan was maximally constructive on eliminating consequences of Karabakh war, unblocking communications - President Aliyev
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan sign investment and commercial contracts
Georgia shares its top wine export destinations
Turkey reveals volume of cargo shipment via its ports from Ukraine for 9M2021
Nar upholds positive dynamics in telecom market
Finalists in double mini-trampoline among men unveiled at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Russian president to hold operational meeting with permanent members of Russia's Security Council
Azerbaijan's non-oil export reached highest level since early 2021 - deputy minister
Finalists in tumbling among women unveiled at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Kadimastem seeks Nasdaq listing, raises $3.2m from ILEX
Trilateral meeting between Azerbaijani, Russian presidents, Armenian PM held in Sochi (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Azerbaijan increases its revenues from gas supplies via pipelines in 9M2021
Azerbaijani gymnasts reach finals of 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in synchronized trampoline
Georgia’s exports of copper ores decrease
Putin, Indian PM to discuss privileged strategic partnership on Dec 6 — Kremlin
Azerbaijan reveals current state of road projects implemented in Karabakh, East Zangazur (VIDEO)
Georgia shares data on import, export price indices
Turkey's cargo, passenger traffic at Ankara Esenboga Airport grows in 10M2021
Volume of trade between Azerbaijan and Russia increased - Russian president
Turkey's cargo traffic via Karasu port for 9M2021 disclosed
Finalists in individual trampoline among men and women unveiled at 28th FIG World Age Group Competitions in Baku
Leading Uzbek banks in terms of volume of assets unveiled
Since beginning of operation of Russian peacekeeping forces on 10 November last year, there have been no major incidents in area of responsibility of Russian peacekeepers - President Ilham Aliyev
SOCAR Petroleum commissions gas station in Azerbaijan's Gubadli district
Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan reveals loans issued to individuals, legal entities for 10M2021
Russia hopes to outline promising directions to normalize relations between Baku and Yerevan in Sochi - MFA
Passenger cars manufacturing on rise in Kazakhstan
US embassy in Azerbaijan donates trees in honor of local staff
Georgia, Qatar plan to expand economic ties
Plastic cards usage increases in Kazakhstan
All news