Expert proposes resolution for Central Asia’s enduring water problems

Expert proposes resolution for Central Asia’s enduring water problems

Baku, Azerbaijan, June 3
Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, donors have spent millions trying to solve Central Asia's chronic water and energy problems, but Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan have wasted this opportunity, director of International Crisis Group's Central Asia project, which recently published "Water Pressures in Central Asia" report, told Trend.

"A new strategy is called for, both in the region and by those who would help it, including Western states and Russia," Deirdre Tynan said.

After more than two decades of political independence, millions of people still have inadequate access to clean water in the Central Asia, according to the expert on the region.

Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan could again face energy shortages this year, despite huge potential as producers of hydroelectric power, Tynan believes. She noted that water supplies have even triggered cross-border skirmishes in the Ferghana Valley. These have been limited so far. But they have the potential to trigger a chain reaction that brittle Central Asian governments would struggle to contain without significant loss of life.

According to the expert, Kyrgyzstan, with low water levels in the Toktogul reservoir, faces a real dilemma. The country's meager budget struggles to buy power elsewhere. Last winter, people were told to buy coal for heating their homes. But 37 percent of the population already lives in poverty and many are live in apartment blocks with no chance of an open fire. In impoverished Batken province, people collected firewood and animal dung to burn. The lights stayed on in Bishkek, but only just. Plans to perhaps raise the cost of electricity this year will cause further discontent and anxiety.

In Tajikistan, ordinary people often live with three hours of power a day or less while the lights in the Italianate palazzos of the political and economic elite glitter all year round, Tynan said. Such failure of basic services and falling living standards are fomenting anger. This adds up to a new threat to state stability at a time when popular disillusionment growing.

Despite such looming dangers, regional states are not changing course, the expert noted. Previous water-sharing agreements, largely modeled on the Soviet-era arrangements, are ineffective today.

"Upstream Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan and downstream Uzbekistan see each other not as partners managing a shared resource, but as opponents battling to secure mutually exclusive gains at the expense of their neighbors. There may be regular meetings and a slew of post-Soviet water-sharing agreements, none of which are legally binding, but Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan are drifting ever further apart," she said.

The expert noted that irrigation-intensive cotton remains the Uzbek government's main source of foreign currency. If water is withheld in the Toktogul reservoir this summer, thousands of Uzbek farmers will be hard hit.

She reminded that the Uzbek government has a history of using economic blockades to pressure its neighbors. Tashkent reckons that Bishkek and Dushanbe might be planning to do the same with water, and could take military action against new hydropower plants and reservoirs currently planned in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan.

"Uzbek President Islam Karimov has warned of war, and Russian, Western, and local officials do not think he is bluffing," Tynan said.

The problem is not so much that there is not enough water, but how it is used, Tynan stressed.

"The outlines for an eventual deal that donors and the international community should press for are clear. Uzbekistan should convincingly promise to end the massive wastage and loss of water due to outdated irrigation methods and bad farming practices. At the same time, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan must commit to manage the proposed reservoirs of water in a responsible manner. Rooting out mismanagement and corruption would be a start," she said.

For their part, international donors - of which Russia is a part, as a member of the World Bank and the Organisation of Security and Cooperation in Europe -- must act to insist on prosecutions for the embezzlement of millions of dollars in aid money for water projects, the expert noted. New projects should aim to work through the smallest, most local units of government possible. Continued funding of urban and rural water-supply projects should be contingent on the successful application of anti-corruption measures.

"The funders of large scale hydropower plants should insist on rigorous financial oversight and overall reform of the energy sector. Russia, as the leading investor in large scale hydropower plants in Kyrgyzstan, should insist on rigorous financial oversight and overall reform of the energy sector," Tynan said.

The Kambarata-1 and the Upper Naryn Cascades have the potential to transform energy production in Kyrgyzstan, but with estimated costs in excess of $3 billion it is vital that these projects do not become a vehicle for graft or derailed by bureaucracy, the expert noted.

A new regional agreement on water will likely take a long time, however, Tynan believes.

"As a start, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan should focus on more modest bilateral agreements on shared water. They should accelerate the long-running process of border delimitation and back away from confrontation in disputed areas. Cross-border infrastructure and water-management projects would also go some way to alleviating tensions in the Ferghana Valley. If better bilateral agreements can be brokered, they could eventually form a platform for a regional one," she said.

Russia, and other members of the international community and donors should use all the leverage they have to persuade them to take this path, reverse the dynamics that might lead to armed conflict and lay the foundations of shared prosperity and equitable water supplies instead, according to Tynan.

Demand for Azerbaijani AzerGold company’s bonds exceeds supply
Demand for Azerbaijani AzerGold company’s bonds exceeds supply
Net profits of Georgian commercial banks increase
Net profits of Georgian commercial banks increase
Azerbaijani Ministry of Finance to place state short-term bonds
Azerbaijani Ministry of Finance to place state short-term bonds
Loading Bars
Global coronavirus cases pass 32 mln
President Ilham Aliyev made a speech at general debates of 75th session of United Nations General Assembly in a video format (PHOTO)
16 injured after tanker explosion in Nigeria's economic hub
Kazakhstan's export to China surge despite COVID-19
Presidents of Kyrgyzstan, Turkey discuss topical co-op issues in call
President of Georgia receives Azerbaijani Foreign Minister (PHOTO)
Iran reveals share of free, special economic zones in country's export
Georgia's export of vegetables down year-on-year
Magnitude 4.2 earthquake shakes Istanbul
Azerbaijan’s Agroleasing opens tender to buy services
Kyrgyzstan Foreign Minister takes part in meeting of foreign ministers of landlocked countries
Deputy Minister: Iran's petrochemical production potential spikes
Lavrov: Russia hopes for some new measures to preserve JCPOA
Demand for Azerbaijani AzerGold company’s bonds exceeds supply
Azerbaijan, Georgia interested in peaceful settlement of conflicts in region
Net profits of Georgian commercial banks increase
Azerbaijani FM meets with deputy chairman of Georgian parliament (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani Air Forces conduct combat-training flights (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Timeframe for iron ore exploration in Azerbaijan's Dashkasan revealed
Azerbaijani Ministry of Finance to place state short-term bonds
Georgian Kula company doubles production of dried fruits
Georgia's exports of fruits, nuts soar
Georgia reveals volume of fertilizers exported to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijani minister: Dashkesan iron ore deposit promises great prospects
Azerbaijan plans to export agricultural products to Arab countries soon
Asian Development Bank discloses amount of funds allocated to Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan continues importing more grain, legumes from Turkey
Azerbaijan's State Customs Committee to launch new services for foreign trade participants
Uzbekistan expanding geography of natural uranium exports
Number of migrant workers from Turkey in Georgia edges up
Kazakh political analyst: Azerbaijan - plays important role in Turkic-speaking world
Russia reports over 6,500 new coronavirus cases
Azerbaijan increases import of cars from Georgia
Kazakh import of steel from Turkey down amid COVID-19 global pandemic
Azerbaijani State Customs Committee presents new e-commerce project
Iran provides funding for industrial, mineral projects
Georgia sees increase in export of blueberries
Georgia reveals volume of hazelnuts exported to Azerbaijan
Fitch forecasts moderate dividends from Kazakhstan's KazMunayGas' equity affiliates
Turkmenistan’s Turkmennebit to buy electrical equipment via tender
Diesel imports increases in Georgia
Financing for Uzbek solar power plant construction approved
Azerbaijan's MFA comments on provocative activities of Pashinyan
External debt up in Uzbekistan
Turkmenistan receives Russia's test system for revealing COVID-19
Azerbaijan's Bank BTB kicks off cooperation with Universal Payment Transfer system
The 7th International womEncourage virtual meeting launched with Gold Sponsorship and Digital Partnership of Azercell
Kazakhstan's oil extracting company opens tender to buy accumulators
Cotton harvesting starts in Azerbaijan's Beylagan district
Most popular goods imported to Uzbekistan revealed
Cargo traffic via Turkish Erzurum Airport decreases
Iran to tackle tax evasion
France reports over 1,000 people in ICU due to coronavirus
Azerbaijan, Turkey, Kazakhstan - key players in Turkic-speaking alliance
Iran looks to launch new freeway from Tehran to Karaj
CNG based vehicles could reduce fuel prices in Iran
United to provide COVID-19 tests to customers on San Francisco-Hawaii flights
CSTO resources cannot be used in territorial conflicts - Kazakh expert
Kazakhstan. Spain trade down twofold amid COVID-19
Shekel loses sharply on new lockdown restrictions
Iran hotel construction surges by 70 percent over 7 years
Signs COVID cases rising in Sweden again 'worrying' says PM Lofven
Iran`s Rouhani attends inauguration of several projects via video conference
Azerbaijani minister: Issuance of AzerGold's bonds - one of crucial events in 2020 for capital market (PHOTO)
Foreign Ministry discloses details of meeting of Azerbaijani, Georgian FMs (PHOTO)
Number of Kazakh cizitens sent back from Baku port during COVID-19 revealed
Azerbaijan reveals 133 more COVID-19 recoveries
Azerbaijan expands trade relations with Turkey, Russia during quarantine
Russia increases volume of livestock exports to Turkmenistan
Contract on methanol production in Iran signed
PM: Georgia still remains green state status and safe destination for tourists
LUKOIL-Azerbaijan opens tender on repair work
Bahar Azadi gold coin price still rising in Iran
Death toll from coronavirus pandemic exceeds 25,000 in Iran
Central Bank of Azerbaijan discloses amount of foreign currency bought by local banks
Construction of new oil refinery in Iran starts
Major repairs of Dovletabat-Deryalyk gas pipeline underway in Turkmenistan
Harley books $75 million in fresh restructuring costs, discontinues India operations
President Ilham Aliyev: There is a very high-level partnership between the European Union and Azerbaijan
Baku Stock Exchange holds meeting on issuance of AzerGold's bonds (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan’s Baku International Sea Trade Port discloses total cargo turnover this year
Iran discloses its exports via Jolfa customs
Azerbaijani expert in tourism sector talks about discounts on air tickets
Iran, Malaysia hold talks on preferential trade
FM: Azerbaijan's support for Georgia's position at UN General Assembly essential for us
Mikhail Barkan: Azerbaijan - one of most tolerant countries in world
LafargeHolcim Signs Net Zero Pledge with Science-Based Targets
Turkmen Akymly-Ugur service company announces production volumes
Turkmen service company plans to expand its export geography
Geostat reveals volume of vegetables exported by Georgia to Azerbaijan
SOFAZ expects no changes in its foreign currency portfolio
Azerbaijan unveils amount of loans issued to farmers
Range of products made in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan expanding
Uzbekistan eyes to integrate into global economic, transport and transit corridors
Azerbaijani FM meets with Georgian counterpart (PHOTO)
Construction of large grain warehouse in Iran to be completed soon
Precious metal prices in Azerbaijan drop
Georgia reduces imports of electricity from Azerbaijan
Iran-Najaf flights resume for special passengers
Armenian intelligence network exposed - SOCIAL NETWORKS - PHOTO FACTS
All news