North Korea deal shows times have changed for bush

(Trend.

In his first term, President Bush rejected Clinton administration attempts to win North Korean cooperation with aid and declared that only after ``complete, verified, irreversible dismantlement'' of its nuclear program could the autocratic regime receive U.S. help.

But as the White House held fast to its hard-line approach, Kim Jong Il's rickety government built an estimated eight to 10 bombs, experimented with missile launches, conducted a nuclear test and seemed poised to continue the buildup with impunity.

The agreement reached Tuesday would bring Pyongyang back to the bargaining table, with pledges to freeze its primary nuclear reactor and to discuss dismantling its entire nuclear infrastructure. It was hailed by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice as a ``breakthrough.''

But the deal also gives the impoverished regime an immediate 50,000 tons of energy assistance and other aid upfront and commits the United States to the kind of direct talks with the North Koreans that the White House had long ruled out.

The deal provoked outrage from conservative allies of the administration who said it flatly contradicted Bush's previous policy. At the same time, some former Clinton administration officials termed it a step in the right direction but questioned why it took Bush so long.

Many observers acknowledged that the White House had few choices.

``They recognized that they had to adopt a practical approach,'' said Gary Samore, a National Security Council official during the Clinton administration who is at the Council on Foreign Relations. ``They had to do something to stabilize the situation, or they would face a full-blown crisis on the Korean peninsula.''

The pending accord reached Tuesday is only a first step toward a negotiated end to North Korea's nuclear program, U.S. officials acknowledged. It calls for the regime to shut down and seal its primary nuclear facilities, at Yongbyon, and to allow the return of U.N. nuclear inspectors to verify the process. Then the North Koreans will begin a complex series of talks with the United States, South Korea, Japan, China and Russia.

If North Korea discloses all its nuclear programs, and disables all facilities, it would be entitled to additional aid including 950,000 tons of heavy fuel oil. The process also promises North Korea a chance to reach two other goals: normalized relations with the United States and removal from the U.S. list of government sponsors of terrorism.

Yet, U.S. officials acknowledge that there are numerous issues that could derail a process that has faltered again and again since 1993. ``This is the first quarter, not the fourth,'' Rice cautioned.

Some critics of the administration were quick to charge that the deal had gotten the White House back to where it was at the beginning of Bush's first term.

``This deal takes us back to the future,'' said Sen. Joseph R. Biden Jr., D-Del., chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. ``The good news is that it freezes in place North Korea's nuclear program. The bad news is that North Korea's program is much more dangerous to us now than it was in 2002, when President Bush rejected virtually the same deal he is now embracing.''

From a conservative perspective, Bruce Klingner of Heritage Foundation said the deal ``sends a dangerously accommodating signal not only to North Korea but also to Iran and any other aspiring nuclear-weapons state.''

Rice, defending the deal, said the United States was entering the talks in a much better position than it had during the days of the so-called ``Agreed Framework'' negotiations initiated in 1994 by the Clinton administration. Bush abandoned those talks in November 2002, amid signs that Pyongyang was carrying on a secret uranium-based bomb program.

Rice said the difference now is that the United States has greater leverage over North Korea because of the influence of the four other countries coming to the negotiating table. China, the North's primary energy source and chief trading partner, has brought pressure on Pyongyang since its nuclear test in October, U.S. officials said.

Rice also asserted that the upfront aid Pyongyang would receive for coming back to the table was ``modest'' -- only a fraction of the 2 million tons of heavy fuel oil it was demanding.

Some experts who analyzed the deal agreed.

``Fifty thousand tons is a small amount,'' said L. Gordon Flake, a longtime Korea watcher at the Mansfield Foundation in Washington. ``It's basically a face-saving gesture for the North Koreans.''

Although the deal dramatically illustrates how far the administration has come, there have been signs for some time that the United States has been open to a more flexible approach.

One such sign was in early 2005, when Rice named Christopher Hill, a veteran dealmaker who helped negotiate the Bosnia peace settlement, to be assistant secretary of State for East Asia, making him the State Department's top negotiator on North Korea.

Hill has worked with Rice and Bush on Korea, even as hard-liners, including former U.N. Ambassador John R. Bolton and Robert G. Joseph, the State Department's top proliferation official, were leaving the administration. Bolton branded the agreement Tuesday a charade and said it ``contradicts fundamental premises of the president's policy.''

Last month, Hill met with North Korean officials in Berlin and began talking about a new ``bilateral'' approach, despite the administration's formal insistence that its negotiations must be through meetings of all six countries involved in the discussions.

Another sign of possible change was Bush's State of the Union address last month. Unlike previous years, in which the president berated North Korea, Bush mentioned North Korea only once, doing so to point out that his team was ``pursuing intensive diplomacy'' to eliminate nuclear weapons from the Korean peninsula.

One factor in the change of the administration's approach was its desire to show Iran, another country believed to have nuclear-weapons ambitions, that there could be benefits in giving up a program, U.S. officials said.

Some analysts see the deal as the latest sign that the Bush administration has been forced to turn to compromise solutions that would have had far less appeal in its early days when it appeared it had more choices.

``This demonstrates something that we've seen overall, that, in its waning days, with its options and resources limited by Iraq, more and more it is turning to these practical policy options,'' said Samore, who is director of research for the Council on Foreign Relations. ``You see it in the Middle East, you see it in East Asia. This is a trend that will continue.''

Permissions granted for building construction down in Georgia
Permissions granted for building construction down in Georgia
New fruit processing plant built in Georgia
New fruit processing plant built in Georgia
Small industrial zone to be created in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent
Small industrial zone to be created in Uzbekistan’s Tashkent
Loading Bars
Latest
Military tribunal must be organized to assess Armenia’s crimes – Assistant to Azerbaijani president
SOS Children’s Villages International to do everything to support children during Karabakh conflict
7 families killed as result of Armenian terror against Azerbaijan – Azerbaijani prosecutor general
Armenia commits environmental terror against Azerbaijan - Ministry of Ecology (PHOTOS)
Macroeconomic stability remains steady in Azerbaijan - Central Bank chairman
Azerbaijan raises import of cars in 9M2020
Azerbaijan confirms 480 more COVID-19 recoveries
President Aliyev: Azerbaijani troops liberate several villages of Jabrayil, Zangilan and Gubadli districts
Passenger transportation decreases in Azerbaijan due to COVID-19 pandemic
STAR Refinery’s investment value to near $7B
Azerbaijani prosecutor general reveals civil casualties, injuries inflicted by Armenia
Kazakhstan's KazMunayGas reports decrease of oil transportation volumes
General Prosecutor's Office discloses crimes committed by Armenian Armed Forces against Azerbaijan
Temporary special administrations to be established in Azerbaijan`s territories liberated from occupation
Azerbaijani army destroys missile-artillery warehouse of Armenian Armed Forces - MoD (VIDEO)
Iran talks agricultural exports to Iraq despite restrictions
Kazakhstan's national oil company faces output decrease at country's major oilfields
Euro zone GDP jumps more than expected in third quarter q/q, prices fall
OSCE MG meeting on Karabakh conflict in Geneva to be closed for media
Permissions granted for building construction down in Georgia
Uzbek Ministry of Finance projects revenues, expenditure of consolidated state budget
Turkmenistan privatizing number of facilities to increase private sector's share in economy
Iran to allocate funds for projects in Malayer city
Khaf-Herat railway between Iran, Afganistan to commence by mid-November
Azerbaijan doesn’t succumb to provocations, responding to aggressor on battlefield - Israeli expert
Azerbaijani Prosecutor General's Office assesses damage done from Armenian vandalism
Iran's IRGC provides support to COVID-affected families
Fish production in Iran's Amlash city increases on annual basis
UK condemns continued shelling of civilian areas following attack on Azerbaijani Barda
Russian Export Center talks about exports to Azerbaijan
Glencore reports copper extraction volume decrease in Kazakhstan
Azerbaijan may expand business loan programs - Central Bank
MoD says Armenia's info on shooting down Azerbaijan's UAV - lie
Azerbaijan to develop its lands liberates from occupation via its own sources
World Bank to fund modernization of national innovation system in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijani oil prices decline
Azerbaijani currency rates for Oct. 30
Azerbaijani parliament grateful to Pakistan’s National Assembly for condemning Armenia's aggression
Some int'l organizations remain silent on Armenia shelling Azerbaijani civilians - expert
Gas exports from Azerbaijan to Turkey down month-on-month
New hotel opened within state program 'Produce in Georgia'.
MP Nagif Hamzayev: Azerbaijan will not give up fight for justice
Armenia subjecting Azerbaijani Gubadli district to artillery fire - MoD
Kazakhstan, Bulgaria trade turnover down twofold amid COVID-19
Turkmenistan to increase volumes of deciduous, coniferous, fruit trees and grapes
Armenian troops must leave Azerbaijani occupied lands today - Diaspora Committee
Kazakhstan's coal extracting venture to buy spares via tender
Kazakhstan’s Ulba Metallurgical Plant to buy diesel fuel via tender
Around 177 mb of ACG oil shipped from Ceyhan terminal
The Arab press writes about Azerbaijan's just struggle
Turkmenistan to extend suspension of train operation amid COVID-19
Azerbaijani Community in Geneva organizes protests against terrorist acts of Armenia (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan’s superior military wrests control of several districts abutting Karabakh - Washington Post
EU to send over 70 teams to visit polling stations in Georgia on election day
SCO member states in talks over trade, economic co-op in transport and logistics fields
Total sees decline in hydrocarbon production
Azerbaijan names number of schools heavily damaged by Armenian shellings
Azerbaijani House in Austria condemns terrorist attacks on Barda and Ganja
Malaysia eyes importing high-quality Uzbek textile
Georgia reports 1,696 new coronavirus cases
Azerbaijani MoD denies accusations of carrying out offensive attack
Armenia bombards forests, continuing environmental terror against Azerbaijan - Ministry of Emergencies
Total expects increase in LNG selling with higher oil prices
Azerbaijan using taken as booty military equipment against Armenian Armed Forces (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani social media users uncover another Armenian disinformation - PHOTOFACT
Shell’s Upstream production down due to OPEC+ restrictions
Footage of destroyed house due to Armenia's missile strike on Goranboy (PHOTO)
Turkmenistan to build new greenhouses for growing bananas, citrus fruits
Doubleu merges with Georgian digital marketing agency
Industrial gas flow received at Kashkadarya well in Uzbekistan
Another high-ranking Armenian serviceman who committed war crime eliminated
Azerbaijan Red Crescent Society volunteer died when rocket hit his car in Barda – IFRC (EXCLUSIVE)
Georgian TBC Capital publishes macroeconomic sector overview of country
Azerbaijani, Turkish FMs exchange views on current situation within Karabakh conflict
Oil edges up, but set to post second monthly fall on virus spread
Special temporary administration to be applied in liberated Azerbaijani territories
Uzbekistan’s 9M2020 volume of agricultural production revealed
Albania, Azerbaijan has other investment opportunities apart from TAP
Azerbaijan hands over bodies of combatants to Armenia through ICRC
Azerbaijan destroys Smerch missile launcher of Armenian troops used to shell Barda - MoD (VIDEO)
Azerbaijani FM leaves for Geneva to hold Karabakh talks
Turkmenistan, South Korea aim to intensify co-op within intergovernmental commission
Uzbekistan reveals its COVID-19 data for October 30
New fruit processing plant built in Georgia
Human Rights Watch confirms use of cluster munitions by Armenia to attack Barda
Several Azerbaijani districts under fire of Armenian Armed Forces
Latest situation on battlefield on October 30
Azerbaijan expands persimmon export geography
Denmark repeatedly increases import of Azerbaijani products
Azerbaijan's State Service to hold auction for five vehicles
Combat operations continued in direction of Aghdara, Khojavend and Gubadli - MoD
Several items of military equipment of Armenian Armed Forces destroyed - LIST
Every second operation in Azerbaijan carried out contactless - Visa
FM: Boosting cooperation with Iran priority of Afghan foreign policy
President Tokayev addresses International Forum on Northern Economic Cooperation
Turkey reports over 2,300 new COVID-19 patients
S. Korea reports 114 more COVID-19 cases, 26,385 in total
US to sell F-35 fighter jets to UAE, White House tells Congress
In Germany, car rams into group of passersby with one person killed, three injured
Moscow records another 69 coronavirus deaths
All news