EU unable to unblock peace process in Middle East: experts

EU unable to unblock peace process in Middle East: experts

Azerbaijan, Baku, November 14 / Trend , U.Sadikhova /

Despite that the EU and the U.S. differently view the problem of Jewish settlements, experts do not believe that Brussels will unlock the peace process and will play the role of leading mediator in the Palestinian-Israeli negotiations.

After a statement by French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner that Israel less seems to be a partner in the peace process, during a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, President Nicolas Sarkozy called upon the Palestinians and Israelis to return to the negotiating table.

However, Sarkozy added that the construction of Jewish settlements in the West Bank, the termination of which is the main requirement of the League of Arab States and the Palestinian Authority to resume the peace process, should be immediately frozen in order to achieve comprehensive peace, Al Jazeera Net website reported.

Words by Sarkozy, who also strives for diplomatic mediation between Syria and Israel, differ from the position of the U.S. Administration, which believes that the issue of Jewish settlements should not be an obstacle to the resumption of the peace process, but rather must be addressed within the dialogue of the Palestinians and Israel.

Some European analysts believe that the position of the EU and the U.S. on the issue of settlements is the same - they recognize them illegal, but there is a discrepancy between them on how to solve this problem.

"The EU has often taken a stricter attitude than the US towards Israel in the past and, on that basis, Israel has rejected the EU's role as a potential mediator. However, in the post-9/11 period, there has been more convergence between the EU and the US with regards to their attitudes towards Hamas, which they both view as a terrorist group and an illegitimate partner in peace talks," Nicola Pratt, Associate Professor of the International Politics of the Middle East at the University of Warwick, said.  

"Therefore, it is not unusual for the US and EU to differ over the details of peace negotiations however, given that both support a 2-state solution and both view Hamas as a terrorist organization, I do not think that the difference between the US and EU over settlements will have an impact on the EU's approach to the peace process," Pratt wrote to Trend in an e-mail.  

Arab media reported that missing the chance to take advantage of U.S. pressure on Israel, Arab countries gained a new opportunity to achieve this with the help of EU demands to stop settlement activities.

The EU can play a significant role in the Middle East with the third players which are for example Syria or Lebanon, said Clara Marina O'Donnell, analyst at the Centre for European Reform (CER) in London.

"To have this peace process solved we need a regional solution with all the different players on board. And some member-states of the EU have historically very close relations with Lebanon and with Syria - important players that we need to be on board," O'Donnell, research fellow on EU foreign policy and defence, military capabilities & missions, European neighbourhood policy and the Middle East, told Trend in an e-mail.

Paris was the first in the EU that has established relations with Syria, and also was involved in the construction of the first nuclear power plant in the United Arab Emirates and is an ally of the Government of Saad al-Hariri in Lebanon.

Unlike the U.S. Administration, which is under the pressure of the Jewish lobby, the EU, which has historically close political ties with the Middle East, better understands the policy in the region and the views of Arab countries, and therefore, requires to stop settlement construction, said Awad Chamas, head of the European Research Center for the Mediterranean Basin.

Joint military exercises conducted between Israel and the U.S. in October indicate that Barack Obama's administration is more inclined towards Israel than the Palestinians, Awad told Trend by telephone.

But the European experts believe that the EU and the U.S. seem to converge in opinion regarding the settlements than exacerbating the differences between them in the Middle East. Therefore, despite the dissatisfaction of most Arab countries, the United States still retain mediator in the peace process between Palestinians and Israelis. Experts point out different reasons.

According to Pratt, the EU's current position on settlements will not translate into any meaningful pressure on Israel unless the EU suspends its preferential trade agreement with Israel.

"The EU has always tried to support the peace process through trade (with Israel) and aid (to the Palestinian Authority)," British analyst said.

Trade turnover between the European Union and Israel over the past two years has exceeded $25 billion, while Israel is the largest trade partner of EU in the Mediterranean Sea. Within the Neighborhood Policy, in the period from 2007 to 2010, the European Union provided 14 million euros assistance to Israel.

Brussels analyst Chamas said the EU would be able to use economic pressure on Israel to soften the position on settlement activities, if it would not be under pressure of the U.S. in the Middle East reconciliation.

"In addition, Israel will agree upon mediation of only U.S., so without actions of Washington, neither the EU nor Turkey, nor the Arab countries are able to change the situation in the negotiations," said Chamas.

Chief analyst on Israeli policy at the Chatham House Royal Institute of International Affairs Orit Gal believes that even if the U.S. would retain the role of chief mediator, in the future it is possible to see an increase in the EU's role in the peace process that will largely depend on changes in the structure of the EU.

Here the charge will be institutional and we have to see what the new EU presidency will be and what kind of structure and institutionally framework it will carry out, Gal told Trend in a telephone conversation. 

On Nov. 19, the extraordinary summit of EU member states will determine who will take the post of first president and foreign minister of the EU under the Lisbon treaty, which may come into force in December.

According to British expert O'Donnell, the EU suffers from several shortcomings which limited its ability in playing the important diplomatic role in the Middle East region

"Structural ones are the fact that 27 countries are speaking together, and it is taking a very long time to say anything, to agree a point of view. The EU is weakening its own message by saying at the same time all the different things," O'Donnell said.

Second and the main thing is the fact that the Israeli government and a lot of Israeli public opinion still believe that Europeans do not have Israeli security interest, said British analyst.

Europe well understands this, she added.

Differences between the EU and Israel in the peace process deepened after in summer the EU High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security Policy Javier Solana called to set a definite time frame for the establishment of an independent Palestinian state and recognize the Palestinian Authority as a full-right member of the UN.

However, Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, well-known with rigid position in the peace settlement, rejected Solana's proposal, saying dialogue should be conducted without preconditions.

E.Ostapenko contributed to the article.

Do you have feedback? Contact our journalist at: [email protected]

Georgia and Israel agree on legal employment
Georgia and Israel agree on legal employment
Israel Canada to build 450 prestige homes in Hod Hasharon
Israel Canada to build 450 prestige homes in Hod Hasharon
Delegation of Israeli doctors in Azerbaijan to continue providing support to Azerbaijani soldiers (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Delegation of Israeli doctors in Azerbaijan to continue providing support to Azerbaijani soldiers (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Loading Bars
Turkey to emerge from auto chip crisis through local production
Heads of Trend, Kabar news agencies talk implementation of joint projects
Iran's Saipa Group declares its manufacturing data
Uzbekistan to commission its first solar power plant in September
Exports from Iran's Isfahan Province decreases
Iran - among major countries in terms of diversity in nuclear industry
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price still falling
Cargo transportation via Baku-Tbilisi-Kars railway in Q1 2021 increases
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on April 12
Pakistan extends full support for reconstruction of Azerbaijani liberated lands - expert
Northeastern Iranian Prov exports $3b non-oil products
Kazakhstan reveals plans on rising petrochemicals production
Int'l community should be involved in restoration of Azerbaijani liberated lands - expert
Azerbaijani FM takes part in round table organized by ADA University (PHOTO)
Europe needs a more ambitious COVID recovery plan, says France's Beaune
Azerbaijan publishes latest data on vaccinated citizens
Local elections and referendum in Kyrgyzstan: Voting ends
NCDC Head: Georgia's epidemiological situation deteriorates
Turkey successfully tests hybrid rocket engine for moon mission
Azerbaijan confirms 2,414 more COVID-19 cases, 1,695 recoveries
Africa's COVID-19 cases pass 4.34 mln: Africa CDC
Those who ordered missile strikes on Ganja are responsible for war crimes - top official
Glad to see that Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is over - Hungarian official
Khazar Consortium in Turkmenistan opens tender for plumbing materials purchase
Azerbaijan showed great heroism during Karabakh war - Turkish Presidential Administration rep (Exclusive) (VIDEO)
Iran - one of radioactive drugs exporters
Turkey names 2M2021 volume of cargo shipment via local ports from Ukraine
Visit of Turkic Council’s delegation to Azerbaijan’s Ganja city starts (PHOTO)
Goal of Turkic Council’s delegation's visit to Aghdam was to see Armenian savagery - Assistant to president
Azerbaijan's Aghdam - clear example of urbicide, says top official (PHOTO)
UAE selects first Arab woman for astronaut training
Azerbaijan moving to new stage of its development – Uzbek Information and Mass Communications Agency rep
Turkmenistan Railways opens tender for purchase of material, technical resources
Cargo movements in Iran’s Bushehr port grow
Kazakhstan’s Vagonservice company opens tender to buy oil filters
Situation in Azerbaijan’s Aghdam district - unprecedented barbarism - Turkish Presidential Administration rep (VIDEO)
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for April 11
Indonesia's 6.1-magnitude quake leaves 8 deaths
Delegation of Turkic Council reviews building of Aghdam Drama Theater destroyed by Armenians (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani Finance Ministry to auction mid-term government bonds
Russia reports over 8,700 daily COVID-19 cases
Turkmen company exports batch of formwork sheets to Turkey
Delegation of Turkic Council visits Azerbaijan’s Aghdam Juma Mosque (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Delegation of Turkic Council visits Imarat cemetery destroyed by Armenians (PHOTO/VIDEO)
President Ilham Aliyev plays very important consolidating role in Turkic Council - SecGen (EXCLUSIVE)
Buy/sell operations at Iran Mercantile Exchange disclosed
Georgia reports 707 coronavirus cases, 592 recoveries, 8 deaths
Uzbekistan, Turkey strengthen trade, economic co-op
Visit of Turkic Council's delegation to liberated Aghdam starts (PHOTO)
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
8 rescued, 21 trapped in coal mine accident in Xinjiang
Iran discloses details of exports from industrial parks of Semnan Province
Accident reported at Iran's nuclear facility
Copper ores and concentrates rank first in list of Georgian export
Azerbaijani MoD shows footage from Fuzuli's Ashaghi Rafadinli village (VIDEO)
President of Kyrgyzstan casts vote in local council elections, referendum
India records over 150,000 daily COVID-19 cases, tally at 13,358,805
Saudi-led coalition intercepts Houthi drone
Turkmenistan signs decree on rice production
Number of enterprises put into operation in Iran's Gilan Province revealed
Azerbaijani Gadabay's Executive Office to engage landscaping services via tender
Turkish Airlines to put its 737 Max jets back in the air next week
Kazakh COVID-19 vaccine to be bottled in Turkey
Submarine cable to connect electrical networks of Georgia, Europe to be additional direct channel for telecommunication traffic
IMF, World Bank urged to contain pandemic with fair, efficient distribution of vaccines
South Korean battery makers agree last-minute deal in boost to Biden's EV policy
Egypt, Sudan reject Ethiopian proposal for data sharing on Renaissance dam
Bezos, Musk top Forbes' record-setting billionaire list
Turkey registers more than 52 600 new coronavirus cases
China-Brunei trade grows by over 70 pct in 2020
Argentina's economy minister heads to Europe to woo finance officials over debts
US boosts imports of Turkish-made clothes
Turkey sends off 2nd boron export train to China
First kidney transplant performed in Turkmenistan
Bahar Azadi gold coin price continues to fall in Iran
Iran unveils data of gasoline and petrochemicals exports
New transmission line to provide opportunities for both Georgia’s and EU energy network - expert
Weekly review of key events in Azerbaijan's transport sector
China fines Alibaba record $2.75 billion for anti-monopoly violations
Italy reports 344 coronavirus deaths on Saturday, 17,567 new cases
Azercell’s “Kabinetim” mobile app exceeded 1 million downloads
Pakistani FM to visit Tehran
Funeral for UK's Prince Philip to be held on April 17
Pinterest becomes latest platform to appoint Turkey representative
Italy's economy seen growing 4.1% this year
Volume of cargo loaded, unloaded in Iran’s Bandar Lengeh port announced
Turkmenistan’s growth of trade turnover in 1Q2021 announced
Turkish electrical goods' 1Q2021 export to Uzbekistan spikes
Azerbaijani president's assistant talks Turkic Council media co-op's systematization
Hungary considers Turkic Council member states important partners
Iran's Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on April 11
Uzbekistan ready to actively partake in restoring Azerbaijan's liberated territories
Azerbaijan confirms 2,192 more COVID-19 cases, 1,554 recoveries
Turkey did its best in media coverage of Azerbaijan's Patriotic war - presidential administration
Azerbaijani president's assistant meets with Turkic Council's secretary-general
Briefing of Turkic Council's high-ranking media officials held in Baku (VIDEO)
Anti-Turkic campaigns periodically carried out - Azerbaijani president's assistant
Azerbaijan's victory in Second Karabakh War is victory for entire Turkic world - top official
Azerbaijan working to develop ties between Turkic states - president's assistant
Turkic Council developing roadmap for better co-op with Turkic-speaking countries
All news