Israel passport case sparks debate in top US court

Israel passport case sparks debate in top US court

It may seem like a case on dull passport rules, but lawyers told the US Supreme Court Monday the question of whether Israel is listed on a passport of a person born in Jerusalem raises key issues on foreign policy and separation of powers AFP reported

The top US court heard impassioned arguments on the implications for US foreign policy, the Israeli-Palestinian peace effort and fundamental issues of the authority of the president and Congress in carrying out diplomatic affairs.

The case involves Menachem Zivotofsky, a nine-year-old boy born in 2002 whose US parents sought to list Jerusalem, Israel, as his birthplace, and became entangled in a political struggle on authority over such matters.

The case is complicated because Congress passed a measure as part of a foreign relations law which specifically stated that the State Department shall upon request allow US citizens born in Jerusalem to list their birth county as Israel.

But then-president George W. Bush said in signing the law that he would ignore that provision as unconstitutional interference with the executive authority to conduct foreign policy.

The government, including the succeeding administration of President Barack Obama, has argued that listing Jerusalem as part of Israel on US passports would imply US recognition of the disputed capital, and endanger delicate diplomatic efforts to reach a Middle East peace deal with the Palestinians.

Ari and Naomi Zivotofsky filed a lawsuit in 2004 after State Department officials refused to list Israel as their son Menachem's birthplace. Instead, the birth certificate indicates the boy was born in Jerusalem in 2002.

If Menachem had been born in Tel Aviv or other Israeli cities, his passport would indicate Israel as his place of birth. Under usual practices, US authorities list a country, not a city, as a place of birth.

Nathan Lewin, attorney for the boy's parents, said in oral arguments before the nine justices that the case should not be construed as political, but simply a question of allowing American citizens born in Jerusalem to have the identification they choose.

"This is not a recognition case, this is a passport case," he said.

"We live in a system in which Congress passes the laws and the president is the instrument of foreign policy."

But the comments provoked pointed exchanges with the justices, including Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who told the lawyer: "You say foreign relations is a shared power. So if it is a shared power, why does Congress trump the executive?"

Lewin responded that such a narrow law on passports would not hobble US policy efforts and that Congress still has a role in foreign affairs.

"It is Congress which makes laws, even with regard to foreign policy issues," he said, and noted precedents which would allow passports to contain information on areas in dispute, including Taiwan.

The law, he said, "gives the individual passport holder a choice."

But Chief Justice John Roberts countered that a US citizen born in Northern Ireland "doesn't have that choice even if he thinks that is part of Ireland."

US Solicitor General Donald Verrilli, arguing for the administration, said the constitution gives the executive branch "exclusive recognition power" and added that "the content of the passport is an expression of recognition."

Verrilli said this authority dates back to the early days of the nation when then president George Washington chose to recognize the revolutionary government of France and "concluded it was not necessary to even notify Congress."

He added that because of the sensitivity of the issue, "it is imperative that we speak with one voice" on foreign policy,

But some justices questioned this view as well. Justice Sonia Sotomayor said that if the court agrees with the government view, "we say a president is entitled to ignore Congress. That's a little unsettling."

Justice Stephen Breyer echoed those comments, saying: "There are very few cases when a president can act contrary to Congress."

While Israel has declared Jerusalem its capital, the United States has joined a majority of nations in refraining from recognizing that status for the holy city that Palestinians regard as the capital of their future state.

A decision in the case is due before the end of the Supreme Court's current term in June.

Natanz incident not to hamper Iran's efforts to revive JCPOA - former MP
Natanz incident not to hamper Iran's efforts to revive JCPOA - former MP
All sanctions against Iran should be lifted unconditionally, Russia says
All sanctions against Iran should be lifted unconditionally, Russia says
Moscow, Tehran attach great importance to North-South Corridor – Russian FM
Moscow, Tehran attach great importance to North-South Corridor – Russian FM
Loading Bars
Latest
Uzbekistan to invest in viticulture dev't
Kazakhstan’s national postal service operator to buy consumables via tender
Uzbekistan continues ramping up flour, cereal exports
Mine explosion in Azerbaijan takes life of one more serviceman
Uzbekistan, Russia implementing numerous joint projects
Georgia reports 1,077 new cases of coronavirus for April 16
New Delhi a natural partner in shaping Indo-Pacific region: Australian PM Scott Morrison
Economist Intelligence Unit calculates 13 per cent growth for India, more than IMF prediction
Kazakhstan boosts exports to Russia over 2M2021
French Bouygues carries out construction of two new facilities in Turkmenistan
Azerbaijan's ADIF shares data on compensations paid to depositors of closed banks'
No point in discussing Nagorno-Karabakh problem in previous context - Russian expert
2021 to see over 3% increase in global gas demand
Georgia sees increase in hotel price index for March 2021
Kazakhstan unveils timeframe for large-scale crops sowing
Kazakhstan shares vehicle production data
Prices for precious metals up in Azerbaijan
Turkmenistan signs number of documents with international organizations
EBRD to invest in another project in Azerbaijan
National Bank of Georgia sells funds to stabilize lari exchange rate
Azerbaijan sees growth in retail turnover of ICT products from early 2021
IMF eyeing support to Kazakhstan's cybersecurity and risk management sectors
Iran - P5+1 on right track in Vienna talks - Deputy FM
Italian Senate delegation visits Azerbaijan's liberated Aghdam (PHOTO)
Islamic Solidarity Games-2021 may be postponed - Federation's Executive Committee
Azerbaijan’s pipeline gas deliveries set to increase by over 15%
1Q2021 volume of sold food products in Azerbaijan's trade network up
Denmark speeds up reopening as epidemic stabilises
Azerbaijan IT company monitoring performance of financial structures
Kazakhstan carrying out several projects to boost local cars manufacturing
Turkmen-Chinese partnership has potential in number of areas
European new car sales jump 87% year-on-year in March
Kazakh-German oil extracting JV opens tender for design documentation dev't
Azerbaijani oil prices disclosed
Azerbaijani gas among drivers of Eurasian output growth in Q1 2021
None of Armenian PM's statements worth meaningful comment - Azerbaijani MFA
Axpo plans to produce green hydrogen
Oil climbs to four-week high on strong China data, demand revival
Azerbaijani insurer reports profit growth year-on-year
Kazakhstan's trade structure with EAEU countries for 2M2021 unveiled
Azerbaijani currency rates for Apr.16
Azerbaijan shares footage from Aghdam's Baghbanlar village (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan records high demand for underwriting services in local capital market
Coca-Cola Amatil votes in favour of European bottler's $7.68 bln takeover deal
Share of Azerbaijani gas in Greece’s imports reach 18%
Armenia violating int'l legal principles by refusing to give up minefield maps - Chair of Azerbaijani Parliament
SOCAR announces time of starting gas injection into storages
Rostselmash talks plans on supply of agricultural machinery to Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan enhancing support to SMEs (PHOTO)
Co-op between Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan progresses in all areas - Chair of Azerbaijani Parliament (PHOTO)
Thailand reports record daily number of 1,582 coronavirus cases
Mine clearing operations continue in Azerbaijan's liberated Aghdam
COVID-19 negatively affects mobile segment in Georgia
Georgian mobile operator Silknet’s revenue to increase in 2021 - Galt & Taggart
Major Bulgarian imports from Georgia include copper ores and crude petroleum oils
Azerbaijan developing plan for sustainable business
Georgia implements significant reforms within IMF's Extended Fund Facility program
Japan's March exports grew at fastest pace in more than 3 years
Amazon needs to do better for employees - Bezos
Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan have potential for co-op in maritime transportation
Turkey's central bank holds key policy rate steady at 19%
2,656 new daily COVID-19 cases reported in Kazakhstan
Iran buys 60 million doses Sputnik V COVID-19 vaccine
Eurowings kicks off Dusseldorf-Tbilisi-Dusseldorf flights
Apple announces 200 mln USD fund in forestry projects to reduce carbon from atmosphere
U.S. replaces Britain to be largest source of Ireland's imported goods
Azerbaijan's AzerGold to fund creating test laboratory in Dashkasan
Daimler AG unveiled the electric Mercedes-Benz S-Class luxury sedan (PHOTO)
Canadian lawmakers call for action from U.S., Canadian leaders in pipeline dispute
Economic outlook is brightening - Fed's Mester
Antibiotics in development not enough to tackle 'superbugs' - WHO
China’s Geely targets slice of premium electric car market with ‘startup’ brand Zeekr
Kazakhstan to create concept for development of creative industries
Italy hikes 2021 budget deficit to 11.8% of GDP: source
Turkey registers more than 61 000 new coronavirus cases
IMF corrects estimate on Iran's foreign exchange bank reserves
Kazakhs Association founded in Japan
Turkey provided invaluable support to Azerbaijan in information war with Armenia - MP
Georgian Co-Investment Fund eyes to implements another energy project
Baku Metro opens tender to buy metal structures
Volume of lending to construction sector greatly increases in Azerbaijan
Net profit of Azerbaijani ASB Bank in 1Q2021 decreases
Azerbaijan eyes starting fish caviar export to Hong Kong in 2021
Aggregate capital of Azerbaijani ASB Bank grows
Georgia's Silknet maintains strong cash balance in 2020
Armenia confuses history with mythology again - Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry
Azerbaijani president congratulates president of Djibouti
Turkey leads among countries investing in Azerbaijan's non-oil sector (PHOTO)
Museums like War Trophy Park in Baku, open in many countries - Russian historian
Russia ready to assist in normalization of relations between Azerbaijan, Armenia
Azerbaijan has great opportunities for wind energy dev't - expert
Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry responds to statement of OSCE MG co-chairs
National Bank of Georgia sees decrease in international reserves
Various types of fabrics exported to Turkmenistan from EAEU countries
Kazakhstan's KMG Engineering to buy pump-compressors via tender
1Q2021 assets of Azerbaijan Industry Bank slightly down
Turkmenistan Railways opens tender for installation of surveillance cameras
Kazakhstan’s telecommunications operator to pay dividends for 2020
Kazakhstan’s Kazatomprom sells its solar energy subsidiary
Azerbaijan, Belarus discuss military-technical cooperation prospects
All news