MPs back artificial sperm for childless

MPs are planning a change in the law to allow babies to be conceived from artificial sperm, a move described by opponents as playing God with human DNA. ( Guardian )

A furious debate is building ahead of a vote in the Commons on the government's Human Fertilisation and Embryology bill, which is designed to overhaul legislation covering fertility treatment and embryo research. The bill allows the use of artificial eggs and sperm in experiments, but bans their use to create a human pregnancy, a move opposed by a cross-party group of MPs led by the Liberal Democrat Evan Harris, who will table an amendment.

'There is no good explanation for not allowing this option for people who have survived cancer and cannot have children,' Harris told The Observer. 'This is a good bill, but the government needs to recognise that there are a few improvements still needed - such as allowing the use of stem cell-derived gametes [male or female germ cells that produce an embryo when they fuse] - before we can say that the UK has rational and progressive regulation.'

'Artificial' sperm has been created in experiments on mice. DNA was extracted from a mouse and used to make a line of stem cells. These were then allowed to differentiate into the specialist cells that make sperm.

But Josephine Quintavalle of the campaign group Comment on Reproductive Ethics said it could lead to 'the ultimate incest' of an individual trying to create both sperm and eggs from their own tissue, making them both mother and father of a child. It could also lead to men being redundant in the conception process.

Dawn Primarolo, the public health minister, confirmed last night she was considering pleas from MPs and scientists to relax the ban. There was a 'powerful argument' that the new technique could help solve donor shortages, she said, but she was sympathetic to arguments that a decision should not be rushed.

So far a team from Newcastle University has managed to grow human sperm from stem cells - immature building blocks containing all the necessary genetic information to develop into specific human tissues - taken from bone marrow. It has also created live births in mice using artificial mouse sperm - although the baby mice died after five months. Experts believe it could be five to 10 years before scientists could attempt a human pregnancy.

Dr Allan Pacey, chairman of the British Fertility Society, insisted, however, that the technique did not raise new ethical questions and that a ban was unnecessary. 'The government didn't really explain why they were so keen to ban it,' he said. 'I think if you talk to people - take the example of a cancer victim who hasn't got any sperm or eggs because they have had chemotherapy - if you get to the step where we could make it for them, most people will say they can see the benefits.'

However Quintavalle said ministers were right to move cautiously and it was 'quite ridiculous' to rely on the potential of a technique still in its infancy. 'If you turn the focus around from infertile adults and think about what you are creating, you always get the perspective you should adopt,' she said. 'I think we are becoming extremely selfish in our attitude to the children we produce.'

Harris's amendment would add a so-called regulation-making power to the bill - a device ensuring that if the new technique were proven safe for humans, MPs could nod through a decision allowing it to be used in IVF without a full parliamentary debate and vote.

It would also stipulate that the gametes should come from two halves of a couple, ensuring that in the UK at least the technique could not be used for a single parent to become both mother and father to the same child.

The approach is expected to be backed by the British Medical Association, the Medical Research Council and the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.

Primarolo said she was still consulting on the issue, but added: 'The research can be done, and the issue is whether we legislate to say if it were successful it could proceed. There are some who are saying - and I think these are strong arguments - that it does raise some profound ethical questions.'

Ministers are conscious that the legislation is already controversial, with anti-abortion MPs demanding a free vote on issues such as stem-cell therapy research. Primarolo indicated yesterday that there would be no free vote, arguing that the bill was government business and that stem-cell therapies offered hope of cures for serious diseases.

Subscribe to Trend in Google News! Subscribe
Iranian companies express readiness to restore factories in Syria - minister
Iranian companies express readiness to restore factories in Syria - minister
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds
Iran bans import of musical instruments due to lack of foreign exchange resources
Iran bans import of musical instruments due to lack of foreign exchange resources
Loading Bars
SOCAR’s STAR refinery tests numerous types of crude oil
Azerbaijan considering sending medical workers of Baku clinics to district hospitals
Azerbaijan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens
Azerbaijan confirms 1,795 more COVID-19 cases, 1,967 recoveries
Azerbaijani National Depository Center opens tender to buy new generation security system
Georgia boosts honey exports
Solar PV growth to surpass wind in EU in 2021-2026
Servicemen injured in Azerbaijani helicopter crash talk about incident (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Turkmen company exports paper products to Uzbekistan, Turkey
Iranian companies express readiness to restore factories in Syria - minister
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in Sweden
President Ilham Aliyev receives EU Special Representative for South Caucasus (PHOTO)
US Marshall Legacy Institute sends eight more mine detection dogs to Azerbaijan (PHOTO)
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds
Azerbaijani agency shares data for mine detection, clearing work in liberated territories
Central Bank of Azerbaijan opens tender to insure fixed assets
Azerbaijan’s 10M2021 oil exports to Spain revealed
Uzbek Statistics Committee shares data on volume of retail trade turnover
Georgian medics advise reconsidering COVID-19 passports issuance
Overview of Uzbekistan's volume of wholesale trade turnover dynamics between 2010-2020
Price indexes of construction, trade sectors at Uzbek stock exchange fall
Georgia, IMF discuss new co-op program
Prices for goods and services in consumer market of Uzbekistan rise
Turkey’s diesel fuel exports to Georgia down
Georgia, NATO discuss further co-op and Black Sea security
Iran bans import of musical instruments due to lack of foreign exchange resources
Turkmen ministry prolongs tender for supply of metal blanks
IRENEX shares data on sales of Tabriz Oil Refining Company
Activities in Iran’s Imam Khomeini port down
Star Refinery satisfies about quarter of Turkey's refined petroleum product needs - CEO
Kazakhstan’s oil and gas company opens tender to supply fittings
Mobile phones rank first in Iran’s total imports - IRICA
Turkmenistan’s education ministry extends tender for setting drip irrigation system
Oil minister tells president, parliament that Iran's oil exports 'significantly grow'
Azerbaijan, Pakistan talk prospects for development of military co-op (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan's SOCAR Polymer exports increase over 10M2021
Iran unveils volume of dates export
Iran’s CBI reveals data on balance of bank loans
EU to exceed current renewable capacity plans for 2030
Azerbaijan reveals oil exports to Italy in 10M2021
Azerbaijan shares data on oil export to Croatia in 10M2021
Baku Metro provides ‘November 8’ station with backup power supply (Exclusive) (PHOTO)
Renewable electricity generation to exceed average annual growth rate of 2015-2020
Expansion of bioenergy for power capacity to slow down
Renewable energy capacity to expand by 2026, says IEA
Azerbaijan talks ongoing work to provide electricity to liberated Lachin district
Special representative of Azerbaijan's President in liberated territories within Karabakh economic region appointed
German Ambassador expresses condolences to Azerbaijan over deadly helicopter crash
Iran, Syria sign four cooperation agreements
Iran to invest in Syrian industrial towns
Austria extends COVID-19 lockdown by 10 days
Branch of Azerbaijan’s Balakhani Operating Company opens tender to buy pipes, pumps
Baku electric company opens tender to buy materials for lamp posts repair
Organization of social zone of Aghdam Industrial Park completes in Azerbaijan – minister
Deputy Prime Ministers of Azerbaijan, Armenia and Russia to meet in Moscow today
Azerbaijan’s Azerishig opens tender for reconstruction of substation in Sumgayit
Kazakhstan increases trade with India over 9M2021
Nar continues to grow IT professionals (PHOTO)
India provides medical, humanitarian aid to over 150 countries to deal with COVID-19: MEA
Georgia receives COVID-19 support grant from German Development Bank
Turkey-Azerbaijan trade turnover grows in October 2021
Kazakhstan reports increase in maritime transport volumes
SOCAR Petroleum to open new petrol station in Azerbaijan’s Gubadli district
SOCAR Georgia Gas increases gas tariffs
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for December 1
Azerbaijan discloses data on oil exports to Israel
Georgian cities receive EU grant for cultural development
Saudi Arabia reports first Omicron case coming from north Africa
Georgian FM expresses condolences for lives lost in crash of military helicopter
PMO records increase in cargo movements in Iranian ports
Turkey’s BOTAS increases gas imports
Hungary launches Stipendium Hungaricum scholarship programm
Russia working out celebration program for 30th anniversary of ties with Azerbaijan - MFA
Burial ceremony of Azerbaijani helicopter crash victims held in second Alley of Martyrs (PHOTO/VIDEO)
Georgian Embassy expresses condolences to Azerbaijan on helicopter crash
Iran to prepare budget bill with highest economic growth estimates - President Raisi
Construction and installation work under completion at Azerbaijan’s Khojasan metro station (PHOTO)
Dynamics of OPEC+ production in 2021-2023
Share of Iranian government in earnings from crude oil exports to decrease – Official
Some try to use helicopter crash for political purposes - Azerbaijan's prosecutor general (PHOTO)
Azerbaijan lost comrades - head of Azerbaijani State Border Service on helicopter crash
Azerbaijan sees increase in local payments of foreigners via bank cards
Azerishig OJSC reveals work done to supply power to Azerbaijan’ Kalbajar
Russian Moscow Exchange and Uzbek Toshkent Stock Exchange sign co-op agreement
Turkey increases volume of crude oil import for 10M2021
Turkey shares data on marine fuel exports to Georgia
Volume of industrial production in Uzbekistan increases - Bluestone Investment Bank
Uzbekistan eyes to construct new hydroelectric power plants
Azerbaijan increases cars import over 10M2021
Turkmenistan discloses amount of products sold via local commodity exchange
Iran sees increase in value of trade turnover via Mazandaran Province customs
Turkmenistan’s State Concern open tender for fertilizer plant construction
Azerbaijan doubles export of non-food products
Azerbaijan, Nepal consider signing agreement in IT sector - AIDIA CEO
Azerbaijan may help Nepal to solve cybersecurity issues - CEO of AIDIA
Azerbaijan compiles rating of state, non-state exporters
Azerbaijan reveals sales volume via Azexport website for 10M2021
Implementation of North-South Int’l transport Corridor intensifies Azerbaijan-Iran relations - analysis
JP Morgan forecasts increase in regional oil demand
Closest place for buying a Bakcell number
All news