Lung Association dispute heads to court in Seattle

The American Lung Association on Friday asked a judge to put its Northwest chapter out of business, in a dispute that began when the chapter gave its Seattle headquarters and $600,000 to a different, newly created charity, AP reported.

At a hearing in King County Superior Court, Judge Regina Cahan made clear she didn't understand the chapter's rationale for giving away the building or the money. But she also called the national organization's attempt to deal with the matter "heavy-handed" and questioned whether it was entitled to the legal relief it sought.

"Aren't there other ways besides a preliminary injunction that would serve your means?" she asked the American Lung Association's lawyer.

The national organization asked Cahan for an injunction barring the American Lung Association of the Northwest from continuing to use the ALA name or logo. The national charity also seeks control of the chapter's headquarters and financial assets in order to establish a new Northwest affiliate.

The Northwest chapter runs the charity's efforts in Idaho, Alaska and Washington, including teen anti-smoking efforts, support of indoor smoking bans, and fundraising bike rides and climbs of Mount Rainier.

The spat has been a black eye for the lung association, with some donors saying they would direct their money elsewhere. The judge is expected to rule next week.

The dispute began in late summer, after the Northwest chapter's new chief executive, Mike Alderson, joined two other people in creating a new charitable organization, the Pacific Northwest Lung Cancer Foundation. Alderson persuaded the chapter's board to give his new foundation its one-story, brick headquarters building - assessed at $3.2 million - for just $10.

He also persuaded the board to give the new foundation $1.2 million - $600,000 immediately and $600,000 later - to help get it off the ground. The new foundation's goal was to do high-caliber fundraising that would benefit not only the Northwest chapter, but other organizations devoted to lung health.

The national charity's lawyer, Jed Powell, told Cahan that Alderson had a clear conflict of interest in using his new foundation to "loot Northwest's assets and resources."

In court declarations, Alderson and chapter directors insisted that giving away those assets was a creative way of dealing with financial difficulties.

And, they said, the national organization was threatening to merge the regional affiliate with other chapters unless it boosted its fundraising substantially. The new foundation started by Alderson was to have a full-time development staff, which would be costly for the chapter to hire on its own, they said.

The judge repeatedly questioned that rationale, noting that the $1.2 million promised to the new foundation represented a large chunk of the chapter's $2.6 million cash assets.

"Why do you need this other foundation to do that?" she asked. "Wouldn't it be better for the American Lung Association of the Northwest to have that in their own shop?"

Terence J. Lynum, a lawyer for the chapter, acknowledged its approach was "a little out of the box," but said nothing it did violated the agreement between the chapter and the national organization. The court should not be second-guessing the doctors and other well-intentioned citizens who serve on the chapter's board, he argued.

The national charity's lawyer disagreed. Powell said there were clear violations of the agreement, including one provision prohibiting affiliates from forming new, competing charitable foundations.

While the chapter is allowed to make charitable donations that would further the lung association's mission, he said, Alderson's foundation was so new it had not even adopted a mission.

"Giving away that much money on faith is a breach of their fiduciary duty," Powell told the judge.

The national charity several weeks ago ordered the Northwest chapter to stop using the American Lung Association name and logo, but it continued, and the only way to remedy that is with a preliminary injunction from the court, Powell said. The judge suggested that other measures, such as putting a legal hold on the headquarters building, might suffice.

The Northwest chapter argues that an injunction would put it out of business immediately - before a trial can be held to determine whether the national organization has the right to dissolve it under the contract agreement that governs their relationship.

Commander of Azerbaijani Naval Forces comments on information in social networks about Turkish coordinating officer
Commander of Azerbaijani Naval Forces comments on information in social networks about Turkish coordinating officer
President: If Azerbaijan had been an independent country then, we could have become the richest country in the world
President: If Azerbaijan had been an independent country then, we could have become the richest country in the world
President Ilham Aliyev: The activities of our oil workers serve the interests of the Azerbaijani people
President Ilham Aliyev: The activities of our oil workers serve the interests of the Azerbaijani people
Loading Bars
Latest
Trump Says He’s Approved Oracle Deal For U.S. Tiktok
Iran's Zarif says world should oppose U.S. sanctions or expect same
Rolls-Royce plans to raise up to £2.5 billion as COVID-19 bites
Moscow's death toll from confirmed coronavirus cases rises by 13 - crisis center
Turkey reports 1,538 new COVID-19 cases, 68 deaths
Tajikistan decreases export volumes to Kazakhstan
Police clash with protesters at anti-lockdown demonstration in London
Georgian PM: Our victory must be an economically strong, educated, fair and European state
Iran's Persian Gulf Bid Boland Gas Refining Company declares amount of revenues to be received
Uzbekistan’s car manufacturing company to issue shares for public offering
Trump says he will name Supreme Court successor to liberal Ginsburg 'without delay'
Commander of Azerbaijani Naval Forces comments on information in social networks about Turkish coordinating officer
Gas transportation in Iran expands
Two dead as destructive storm Ianos hits central Greece
Kazakhstan decreases goods export to Ukraine amid COVID-19
Iran and Turkey's gas trade depends on future exploration in the Black Sea
President: If Azerbaijan had been an independent country then, we could have become the richest country in the world
Poland reports over 1,000 new COVID-19 infections, record high since outbreak
CEC sets coronavirus-related safety guidelines for Election Day
China's economy remains resilient despite external risks, says Xi
Iran's Bahar Azadi gold coin price falling
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale September 20
Azerbaijani energy minister stresses importance of co-op within OPEC + format
Ukraine becomes popular destination for Turkish citizens looking for job
General Inspection Organization of Iran strengthen monitoring of banks
Uzbek-Chinese Asia Trans Gas to buy coolant and lubricants via tender
President Ilham Aliyev: The activities of our oil workers serve the interests of the Azerbaijani people
Madrid residents facing localised lockdown doubt curbs will work
TikTok files complaint against Trump administration to try to block U.S. ban
Geostat: Milk, meat production up in Georgia
Germany plans reform to avoid bankruptcy wave due to corona
Turkey decreases value of trade with Turkmenistan
Iran`s Rana Plus car to be launched in October
Uzbek-Chinese Asia Trans Gas to buy air filters via tender
President Aliyev: Key part of Azerbaijan's economy associated with oil and gas sector, and this to be case for many years to come
Azerbaijani president: New phase beginning for Absheron gas condensate field
Azerbaijan confirms 177 more COVID-19 recoveries
EU's share in total import of Azerbaijan up
Azerbaijan's eight-month export of gourds shows uptick
Azerbaijani startup launches new project for automating calculations of repair services
Iranian official: neither side fulfills their obligations in nuclear deal
Iran reveals amount of loans issued to manufacturing enterprises
Update on ski resort construction in Uzbekistan
Azerbaijan expecting inflation decrease by end of 2020
Bank of Georgia raises funds from Citibank to finance trade
Azerbaijani community: Armenia to be held responsible for massacre in Khankendi (PHOTO)
Iranian President expresses concern over people ignoring health protocols
Deaths from coronavirus exceed 24,000 in Iran
Turkmenistan increases imports of steel from Turkey
Iran Export Guarantee Fund`s support for exporters doubles
Kazakhstan's cargo transportation volumes decrease
Trial of social distancing rules on 2 Iranian airlines
Turkmenistan’s Exchange to be transformed into joint-stock company
Buy/sell operation at Iran Mercantile Exchange disclosed
Capital of banks in Iran announced
President Ilham Aliyev attends groundbreaking ceremony of Absheron field offshore operations (PHOTO)
Prices of Azerbaijani oil fluctuate
IMF talks Georgia's investment potential
Defense Minister: Azerbaijan Army ready to suppress any provocations of Armenia, undertake strong retaliatory actions
SOCAR applying digital road map for using high technologies
Uzbek Agroindustry and Food Security Agency to buy laboratory equipment via tender
Production of several products in Iran climbs
Weekly review of Azerbaijan's precious metals market
SOCAR gives sneak peek of its new dev’t strategy
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
Georgian Tbilisi to be host city for 2021 ADB’s 54th Annual Meeting
Azerbaijani FM receives head of International Committee of Red Cross Delegation (PHOTO)
IMF, Turkmenistan review indicators for country's state budget
Minister: Georgia shows signs of economic recovery
Active supply of Turkish cement to Italy amid pandemic recorded
Uzbekistan to include goods and services in Unified Electronic Catalog
Kazakhstan's oil & gas company opens tender to buy filter blocks
Azerbaijani Central Bank unveils number of borrowers with restructured loans
Georgia sees increase in COVID-19 cases
Production started at Uzbek gas condensate field
Japan, Uzbekistan to increase tourist flow between countries
Turkmen Ministry of Construction to purchase equipment from Italian company
Kazakhstan, Russia agree to resume mutual flights
Turkmenistan, Ukraine discuss trade, economic cooperation
Iranian currency rates for September 19
Number of coronavirus cases in Uzbekistan pass 50,000
Armenia violates ceasefire with Azerbaijan 36 times
Australia COVID-19 hotspot records fewest cases since June
Turkey summons Greek envoy over expletive headline against Erdoğan
E3 says Iran sanctions relief to continue beyond Sep. 20
Georgia sends armored medical evacuation vehicles to Indonesia
65 new COVID-19 infections reported in Kazakhstan over past day
UN, Kazakhstan intend substantially contribute to environmental resilience (INTERVIEW)
Japan's new PM Suga to meet with Pompeo in October
Chinese mainland reports 14 new imported COVID-19 cases
Brazil's COVID-19 death toll tops 135,000
French finance minister tests positive for COVID-19
Trump says he sees no reason to delay TikTok decision
Eleven more coronavirus patients die in Moscow in past day
Qatar reports 224 new COVID-19 cases, 122,917 in total
Kazakhstan's crude oil exports to India surge in 1H2020
Georgia to acquire 135 000 doses of flu vaccines in October
Istanbul introduces alternate working hours for public servants amid COVID-19 pandemic
Kazakhstan launches programming learning platform
UK PM Johnson says second wave of virus inevitable, new restrictions possible
All news