Brazilians blame those in power for air failures

( LatWp ) - For months, Brazilians have been using the phrase ``air blackout'' to describe the crisis in the country's aviation system that reached epic proportions this week with the worst crash in the nation's history.

The use of this phrase is no accident. It evokes Brazil's energy ``blackout'' of 2001, when the government imposed emergency restrictions in Sao Paulo, Rio de Janeiro and other large cities in an attempt to curb energy use at a time when long droughts had drained hydroelectric power-plant reserves.

As with the energy crisis, the aviation crisis appears to have raised doubts among many Brazilians about their government's ability to deal rapidly and effectively with an ongoing problem, hold officials accountable for their decisions and punish those responsible.

While much of this week's indignation has been directed at the government of President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, some say the problem goes beyond his administration and reflects more fundamental flaws in Brazilian society.

Lula and other prominent officials this week have avoided making public pronouncements about the crash at Sao Paulo's central city Congonhas airport that killed at least 190 people.

However, they have been advancing theories that it might have been caused by mechanical failures with the plane rather than more systemic failures, and some here perceive what they say is an age-old tendency by Brazil's ruling classes to shirk blame.

``The Brazilian state does not acknowledge to any extent the notion of accountability,'' said Roberto Romano, a professor at the Institute of Philosophy and Human Science at the State University of Campinas in Sao Paulo state. ``This happens again and again, and it has been worsened by two dictatorships of absolute power.''

But in the crash's aftermath, Brazilians this week have been witnessing an unusual spectacle. Ordinary citizens have voiced anger and frustration in a very public way that recalls how Americans responded to the Hurricane Katrina debacle. Several exchanges between the media and government aviation officials have been sharp, even antagonistic. Many commentators have been unsparing in their criticism.

``Brazil has been going through an authority blackout,'' political commentator Lucia Hippolito said on a national radio talk show, referring to Lula and Defense Minister Waldir Pires.

She and other pundits have been especially critical of Lula for failing to make a major public statement about the crash. He was scheduled to address the nation on television Friday night.

Opposition politicians, meanwhile, have been calling for the resignation of key officials, notably Pires. As head of the military that helps run Brazil's aviation systems, Pires was at pains this week to argue that he bears no blame for Tuesday's crash.

Brazil's aviation infrastructure has been plagued with chronic flight delays and cancellations, disgruntled air-traffic controllers and a series of accidents and close calls -- including the collision in September of a private jet and a Brazilian Boeing 737 over the Amazon jungle in which 154 people died.

``Please read the law,'' Pires said to reporters at a Friday news conference. ``I'm not responsible for air-traffic management.''

The belief of some Brazilians that their government is more concerned with polishing its image than solving the aviation chaos was underscored by a Thursday incident in which Lula's personal adviser and minister-without-portfolio, Marco Aurelio Garcia, was shown on national television seemingly making an obscene, triumphant gesture in reaction to news that a flawed brake system had caused the crash.

Garcia has since apologized for the gesture, which the opposition Brazilian Social Democracy Party labeled ``an offense to the Brazilian people.''

Robert Ditchey, a Los Angeles aviation consultant and former airline executive, said that the way that Brazilian officials handled the September crash was ``inept.''

Despite apparent evidence that Brazil's air-traffic control system had been at least partially responsible for miscommunication between the two planes, charges recently were filed against the two U.S. pilots of the private jet.

``I was embarrassed for Brazilians in how they handled this,'' Ditchey said of last fall's accident, which until Tuesday had been the country's deadliest airplane crash. ``People in aviation felt this whole thing was an embarrassment and absurd.''

In addition to its long dictatorships, Romano said, Brazil's culture of non-accountability has been partially engendered by the country's highly centralized government structure, in which the federal government receives about 70 percent of all taxes and presidential power has fewer checks and balances than in the United States or Western European systems.

``There is no direct relationship between municipalities and states and the federal government. And this makes anyone who has any kind of position on a federal level unquestionable and unaccountable,'' he said.

What's more, Brazilian politicians can't be sued or prosecuted while in office, even when potential criminal offenses are involved.

``There is this constant taking the blame off the authorities and laying it on the population,'' Romano said.

It remains to be seen whether this week's backlash will alter that equation. But while Brazilians aren't averse to making their dissatisfactions known, converting those feelings into social change is likely to be a much greater challenge.

``I am 62 years old, I have been involved with politics since the 1960s and I see no possibility for this anger to be translated into action,'' Romano said.

WHO appoints new representative to Tajikistan
WHO appoints new representative to Tajikistan
5.2-magnitude quake hits Tajikistan
5.2-magnitude quake hits Tajikistan
Afghanistan asks Tajikistan to increase power supply
Afghanistan asks Tajikistan to increase power supply
Loading Bars
Latest
Negotiations to be held on issue of tomato supply from Azerbaijan to Russia
Azerbaijan eyes to integrate state entities to government-cloud system
Belarus names volume of money transfers from Turkmenistan
Roadmaps for further reforming Uzbekistan’s electricity, oil and gas industries discussed
Russian Embassy in Turkmenistan organizes six charter flight
Iranian FM discusses obstacles for Iranian economy
President Ilham Aliyev receives Iranian Foreign Minister
Thailand to sell $2 billion savings bonds to finance stimulus measures
Zimbabwe COVID-19 deaths pass 1,000 as infections surge
Russian companies to invite Uzbek labor migrants by applying to construction ministry
Azerbaijani ministry talks up-to-date cloud technologies countrywide
Kazakhstan’s freight transportation operator opens tender to repair equipment
Weekly review of Azerbaijani oil prices
Kazakhstan's Kazpost opens tender on services to purchase accumulators
Uzbekistan, Saudi Arabia sign memorandum on tourism development
India's Ambassadors of Culture and Arts
Kazakhstan boosts imports from Pakistan year-on-year despite global pandemic
India's traditional calling card
SOCAR outlines digitalization plans for 2021
Iran’s NIDC reveals amount of expenses
Azerbaijani HRC shares report on inhuman treatment of Azerbaijani prisoners by Armenia
Number of Azerbaijan Credit Bureau's partners up by early 2021
Price for gold in Azerbaijan continues to drop
Several Turkmen state objects to be sold to members of Union of Industrialists, Entrepreneurs
Logistics companies of Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan sign memorandum of co-op
ACWA Power, Uzbekistan’s National Electric Grids sign agreement on electricity purchase
Azerbaijani currency rates for Jan. 25
Iranian currency rates for January 25
UNEC hosts international conference on "Azerbaijan's Albanian Christian heritage - Khudaveng monastery” (PHOTO)
UAE, Afghanistan purchase products from Turkmenistan’s oil refineries on exchange
Uzbekistan reveals COVID-19 data for January 25
Saudi Arabia And India: The Upward Trajectory
Bangladesh tri-service contingent to lead first 10 rows of R-Day parade in Delhi
OPEC+ to largely abandon its production cuts by 2022
Global oil demand won’t recover to pre-virus levels until at least 2022
Iran applies significant discounts on transportation of Uzbek goods
Brazilian Ambassador calls for ‘strengthening Indo-Brazilian partnership’
US applauds 'true friend' India for gifting Covid vaccine to several countries
Higher oil prices to be dampened by huge amount of oil output capacity
Iranian FM's visit to Azerbaijan focuses on Karabakh reconstruction and multilateral ties - former Iranian ambassador
Iran's Bushehr nuclear power plant construction in progress
Iran identifies illegal cryptocurrency mining farms
Biden unlikely to achieve meaningful changes in US energy mix
Biden’s restrictive oil policy unlikely to continue
Iran extends ban on UK flights due to mutant coronavirus
Iran shares investment data on Goreh-Jask oil transfer project
ACG oil transshipment from Ceyhan terminal exceeds 15 million tons YTD
Iran's economic ties entering new phase - President Rouhani
Talks being held on possibly supplying trains of Spanish production to Uzbekistan
Oil prices fall for second session as COVID-19 lockdown concerns cast pall over demand prospects
Cargo movement in Iran’s Shahid Rajaee port disclosed
Financial capital for creation of airline in Iran to be calculated with national currency
All products of Iran's Shazand Oil Refining Company to meet Euro 5 standards
Iran unveils details of exports and imports via Imam Khomeini port
Work underway in Iran to provide ship supplying for Iranian Ports & Maritime Organization
Azerbaijan developing new bills
Volume of cargo loaded and unloaded in Iranian ports announced
Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy to implement sociological research project
Another success of Azerbaijani president's economic strategy: Dostlug agreement - event of week
When MV Mozart vessel enters Gabonese port, body of Azerbaijani engineer to be sent to homeland - Turkish FM
Iran produces equipment for NIDC domestically
Azerbaijan discloses number of active users of educational programs
Azerbaijani MoD commission continues consideration of appeals of Karabakh War participants
Central Bank of Azerbaijan discloses amount of foreign exchange reserves for coming years
Azerbaijani people's artist, ambassador to Russia arrive in Shusha city as victors
Production of gypsum plaster increases in Azerbaijan in 2020
Oil extraction from Iran's Surush oil field to grow
Apple supplier Luxshare shares fall after U.S. patent infringement notice
China's Kuaishou aims to raise up to $5.42 billion in Hong Kong IPO
Thailand to sell $2 billion of savings bonds to finance stimulus measures
Turkey sold buses to 99 countries in 2020
Iranian COVID-19 vaccine proves safe
Georgian Parliamentary Delegation to attend PACE winter session
WHO appoints new representative to Tajikistan
Makers of Sophia the robot plan mass rollout amid pandemic
Iran's North Azadegan field to be handed over to Arvandan Oil & Gas Company
Mexican president Lopez Obrador tests positive for COVID-19
Sweden bans entry from Norway over new coronavirus variant
Kazakhstan boosts imports from Israel amid COVID-19
34 Houthi rebels killed in Saudi-led airstrikes in central Yemen
5.2-magnitude quake hits Tajikistan
Deutsche Bank starts probe in relation to engagement with some clients
5 terrorists killed in NW Pakistan
Saudi sovereign fund to double assets in next five years to $1.07 trillion - Crown Prince
Azerbaijan completes repair and construction work on roads of Samukh district
Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds in Iran
Iranian Energy Exchange announces products to be on sale on January 25
Weekly review of events in agricultural sector of Azerbaijan
Khazar Consortium opens tender for purchase of cartridges, toners
Georgian exports of knitwear to Turkey decreases
Turkmenistan’s State Concern to sign contract with Chinese company for drilling pipes purchase
Israeli embassy welcomes scheduled resumption of flights to Georgia
Bazargan border reopened after unprecedented snow
Cobalt becomes most produced car in Uzbekistan last year
Turkey registers more than 5 200 new coronavirus cases
Mexican authorities recover 19 bodies, some shot and burned, in remote area
Israel bans international flights to curb coronavirus spread
Bulk of construction work completed in Uzbekistan falls on private sector
FM Zarif arrives in Baku
Turkey to receive 6.5 million doses of China's vaccine next week
All news