YouTube wins user copyright fight in top EU court ruling

YouTube wins user copyright fight in top EU court ruling

Google’s YouTube has scored a win in its latest copyright-infringement challenge after Europe’s top court said online platforms are not liable for users uploading unauthorised works unless the platforms failed to take quick action to remove or block access to the content, Trend reports with reference to Reuters.

The case marks the latest development in a long-running battle between Europe's $1 trillion creative industry and online platforms, with the former seeking redress for unauthorised works that are uploaded.

It is also part of the wider debate on how much online platforms and social media should do to police the posting of unauthorised, illegal or hateful content, an issue that European Union regulators are targeting with tough new rules that could come into force next year.

"As currently stands, operators of online platforms do not, in principle, themselves make a communication to the public of copyright-protected content illegally posted online by users of those platforms," the EU Court of Justice said.

"However, those operators do make such a communication in breach of copyright where they contribute, beyond merely making those platforms available, to giving access to such content to the public," judges said.

The EU court said platforms could also be liable if they do not put in place the appropriate technological tools to tackle copyright breaches by their users or where they provide tools on their platforms for illegal sharing of content.

In response to the court ruling a YouTube spokesperson said: “YouTube is a leader in copyright and supports rights holders being paid their fair share."

"That's why we’ve invested in state of the art copyright tools which have created an entirely new revenue stream for the industry. In the past 12 months alone we have paid $4 billion to the music industry, over 30% of which comes from monetised user generated content.”

YouTube found itself in the dock after Frank Peterson, a music producer, sued the company and Google in Germany over the uploading to YouTube by users in 2008 of several phonograms to which he holds the rights.

In a second case, publishing group Elsevier took legal action against file-hosting service Cyando in Germany after its users uploaded several Elsevier works on its platform Uploaded in 2013 without its approval.

A German court subsequently sought advice from the EU Court of Justice, which ruled on both cases on Tuesday.

Existing EU rules exempt YouTube and its peers from such liability regarding copyright when they are told of violations and remove them.

The EU last year overhauled its copyright rules for the first time in two decades to help its creative industries by adopting a key provision known as Article 17. This requires YouTube, Facebook's (FB.O) Instagram and other sharing platforms to install filters to prevent users from uploading copyrighted materials.

But this has drawn criticism from civil rights groups worried about potential censorship by authoritarian governments and risks to freedom of expression.

Several EU countries have yet to transpose the EU law into national legislation, due in part to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The European Commission has also proposed much a more wide-ranging Digital Services Act, which sets stringent obligations on very large online companies, online platforms and hosting services, backed by fines up to 6% of a company's revenue for non-compliance.

This would apply to websites, internet infrastructure services and online platforms such as online marketplaces, social networks, content-sharing platforms, app stores, and online travel and accommodation platforms.

The draft rules need to be thrashed out with EU countries and EU lawmakers before they can become law, likely to be next year.

The cases are C-682/18 YouTube and C-683/18 Cyando.

Kazakhstan and Brazil Agree to Boost Trade and Economic Cooperation
Kazakhstan and Brazil Agree to Boost Trade and Economic Cooperation
Turkmenistan to hold conference on co-op for Caspian Sea protection
Turkmenistan to hold conference on co-op for Caspian Sea protection
Uzbekistan, Global Green Growth Institute consider introduction of ‘green’ economy technologies
Uzbekistan, Global Green Growth Institute consider introduction of ‘green’ economy technologies
Loading Bars
Latest
South Korea's july exports set fresh high on chips, autos
Turkey reveals number of ships received at local Bartin port in 1H2021
World Heritage Committee closes Fuzhou session, adding 34 new sites to heritage list
Africa's COVID-19 cases surpass 6.67 mln - Africa CDC
Samsung Heavy Industries reduces net loss in Q2
UK reports another 26,144 coronavirus cases
Domestic RMB financial assets held by overseas entities at 582 billion U.S. dollars
Turkey reports 22,332 daily COVID-19 cases
Iran's South Zagros Oil & Gas Production Company boosts gas transportation capacity
China's central bank pledges prudent monetary policy in H2
Facilities of Ministry of Petroleum of Iran to be launched
Kazakhstan and Brazil Agree to Boost Trade and Economic Cooperation
Additional Pfizer jabs to be sent to Georgia
Turkmenistan to hold conference on co-op for Caspian Sea protection
Azerbaijan announces number of citizens vaccinated on July 31
Another group of Azerbaijani firefighters leaves for Turkey to extinguish forest fires (PHOTO)
Azerbaijani First VP congratulates winners of "Rise" competition
Azerbaijan confirms 633 more COVID-19 cases, 174 recoveries
Uzbekistan, Global Green Growth Institute consider introduction of ‘green’ economy technologies
Georgia to start olive soap production
Pakistani Cultural Center opens at Azerbaijan University of Languages (PHOTO)
Cargo transportation in Iran's Sistan and Baluchestan Province grows
Iran’s Bahar Azadi gold coin price rebounds
Russia reports 23,807 daily COVID-19 cases
Azerbaijan conducting large-scale restoration work in Karabakh - former Israeli MP
Amazon-backed Rivian in talks with ministers over UK factory
Iran creates new opportunities at Lamerd Special Economic Zone
Weekly review of highlights in Azerbaijan's transport sector
Azerbaijani president congratulates Swiss counterpart
Data on 1H2021 cargo shipment via Turkish Botas port revealed
Uzbekistan shares data on number of vaccinated citizens for July 30
Info about Azerbaijani Armed Forces opening fire, disseminated by Armenia, unbased - MoD
Georgia shares data on number of active economic agents engaged in market organization
Iran reveals COVID-19 data for July 31
Turkmenistan expects growth of retail trade turnover
Georgia shares data on COVID-19 cases for July 31
Amazon faces more than slowing sales growth
Azerbaijan organizes trip to liberated Aghdam for graduates of foreign universities (PHOTO)
Uzbekneftegaz completes construction of number of wells
Turkey discloses 1H2021 volume of cargo shipment through Istanbul port
Iran could face more dangerous wave of coronavirus, official warns
Residential Property Price Index in Georgia down
Azerbaijan's firefighters helping battle wildfires in Turkey (VIDEO)
Azerbaijan boosts non-oil export
Volume of 6M2021 cargo shipment via Turkish ports from Russia disclosed
Buy & sell operations at Iran Mercantile Exchange soar
Azerbaijani Working Group on Economic Issues holds meeting
Data on environmental damage to Azerbaijan's Zangilan, Jabrayil districts transferred to Prosecutor General's Office
Prices of apartments in Iran’s Tehran city continue to rise
Iran plans to increase insurance premiums
Pakistan always supports Azerbaijan - ambassador
Turkmenistan's oil refinery establishes production of new brand aviation fuel
Azerbaijani Parliament to hold extraordinary session
Kazakhstan's export to Georgia significantly down
Turkish reveals data on 1H2021 data on cargo shipment via local ports from Malta
Armenia still making territorial claims to Azerbaijan - MFA
Uzbekistan’s business activity index for June 2021 revealed
Weekly review of Azerbaijani precious metals market
Turkey reveals 1H2021 data on cargo movement via domestic ports from Italy
Iran may hit record for gold prices soon - Gold and Jewelry Union's VP
Uzbekistan, Japan consider promotion of political peace process in Afghanistan
High economic growth recorded in Georgia - minister
Azerbaijan hosts regular meeting of working group on environmental issues
Weekly review of key events in Azerbaijan's ICT sector
Fake information of Armenia aims to hide army losses - Azerbaijani military expert
Iran assigns more credit for home construction
Georgia’s largest animal feed producer launches construction of new plant
Turkey reveals 1H2021 data on cargo movement via domestic ports from Albania
Iranian currency rates for July 31
Iran's government supplies gas to industrial units of West Azerbaijan Province
SOCAR Petroleum explains reason of Premium gasoline price hike
Weekly review of Azerbaijani currency market
Iran's foreign trade increases
Iran receives shipment of COVID-19 vaccine from Japan
Is there a future for Maglev trains?
Disney makes vaccination mandatory for on-site U.S. employees
Lebanese air carrier starts flights to Tbilisi
Cargo traffic at Turkish Adnan Menderes airport notably grows in 6M2021
Azerbaijani oil prices rise
Construction permits in Georgia increase in January through June 2021
Iran's private sector eyes to use economic opportunities in Syria
Entire ideology of Armenians rests on hatred, false history - Azerbaijani official
Iran's apparel export increases
Uzbekistan publicizes COVID-19 data for July 31
Iranian company excluded from project in Afghanistan
Iran distributes solar panels among nomads in Fars Province
Khazar Consortium opens tender for purchase of equipment
Caspian countries to be united by "green diplomacy"
Paris Agreement to render conventional oil & gas activity less and less viable
2 Green Line trains in Boston crash, injuring more than 20
Turkmenistan makes significant contribution to increasing volume of transit cargo transportation - TRACECA
Triathlon-Britain win first-ever mixed-relay gold
21 new coronavirus cases detected at Tokyo Olympics - organizing committee
US seizes tanker used to evade North Korea sanctions
U.S. resumes fast-track deportation flights of Central American migrant families
Palestinian protesters injured in clashes with Israeli soldiers in West Bank
Study in Argentina shows safety of combining Sputnik V with other vaccines
Biden says he is hopeful about talks with Russia on strategic stability
Israel reports 2,280 new COVID-19 cases
Up to 13 killed in IS attack on funeral in north of Baghdad
All news